Non-epileptic attack disorder: a clinical audit

SeizurePublished 1 June 1994

Bruce Scheepers, Sue Budd, Sue Curry, Sheila Gregory, Sue Elson

DOI10.1016/s1059-1311(05)80203-1

Source URL

Citations26

SJR quartileQ2

SJR score0.79

SNIP1.00

Abstract

The results of an audit of all patients with non-epileptic attack disorder admitted over a 1-year period to a neuropsychiatry tertiary referral centre are presented. The high incidence of: sexual abuse, previous psychiatric history and previous brain injury is noted. Reference is made to the reaction of patients and relatives to disclosure of the diagnosis and the management difficulties which this group of patients pose. The different underlying psychopathological processes are discussed and it is suggested that the diagnosis of NEAD, purely by the exclusion of epilepsy, might carry the risk of treating these patients as a homogenous group. An eclectic approach by an experienced, multi-disciplinary team is probably the most appropriate way of successfully managing the condition. The results of an audit of all patients with non-epileptic attack disorder admitted over a 1-year period to a neuropsychiatry tertiary referral centre are presented. The high incidence of: sexual abuse, previous psychiatric history and previous brain injury is noted. Reference is made to the reaction of patients and relatives to disclosure of the diagnosis and the management difficulties which this group of patients pose. The different underlying psychopathological processes are discussed and it is suggested that the diagnosis of NEAD, purely by the exclusion of epilepsy, might carry the risk of treating these patients as a homogenous group. An eclectic approach by an experienced, multi-disciplinary team is probably the most appropriate way of successfully managing the condition.

Keywords

PsychologyMedicineNeuroscience

BMJDiagnosis of "Hysteria"

378 Citations1965E. Slater

It is a unique honour to have been asked to give the first Shorvon Memorial Lecture; and the author should like to give thanks to the Hospital and the School who have awarded the privilege to him, and to the family whose generous endowment has established it.

View PDF

NeurologyThe clinical features and prognosis of pseudoseizures diagnosed using video‐EEG telemetry

306 Citations1991H. Meierkord, Bamberger Dm +2 more

It was shown that 40% of these patients stopped having pseudoseizures, and this favorable outcome was associated with being female, leading an independent life, a formal psychological approach to therapy and counseling, and the absence of coexisting epilepsy, but not with the duration of pseudoepilepsy, prior episodes of pseudostatus, the coexistence of overt psychiatric disease, or the clinical features of the attacks.

NeurologyPseudoseizures

206 Citations1982Don W. King, Brian B. Gallagher +5 more

It is suggested that pseudoseizures occur frequently in patients being evaluated for epilepsy or suspected epilepsy, and the clinical differentiation between epileptic seizures and pseudoseIZures is often inaccurate.

NeurologyPsychogenic seizures

189 Citations1992A. Arturo Leis, Mark A. Ross +1 more

Slow, subtle writhing or in-phase limb movements were most likely to be mistaken for status epilepticus, and most patients (74%) received anticonvulsants, and six were treated as status epileptus.

SeizureDiagnosis, management and prognosis of a group of 128 patients with non-epileptic attack disorder. Part I

163 Citations1992Tim Betts, Sarah Boden

Three hundred and forty three patients with attack disorder labelled as epilepsy were admitted for assessment to a Neuropsychiatry ward in a small English mental hospital over a 5 year period and at discharge from hospital the majority of patients had practically lost their non-epileptic seizures.

NeurologyPseudoseizures

150 Citations1982Thomas A. Gulick, Ira P. Spinks +1 more

Individual phenomena often simulated epileptic activity; rarely did complete episodes closely resemble epileptic seizures.

NeurologyEvidence for epilepsy is rare in patients with psychogenic seizures

145 Citations1983Ronald P. Lesser, Hans Lueders +1 more

In patients with documented psychogenic seizures, a second diagnosis of epilepsy should not be made without definite EEG support, and patients referred for differentiation between psychogenic and epileptic seizures should be considered.

Annals of NeurologyHysterical seizures: Suggestion as a provocative EEG test

138 Citations1982Robert J. Cohen, Cary Suter

The provocative EEG test employing saline and suggestion is a useful tool in the diagnosis of hysterical “seizures” and described the two types of attacks as different stereotyped behaviors.

SeizurePseudoseizures (non epileptic attack disorder)—clinical management and outcome in 50 patients

111 Citations1993N. Buchanan, Jeff Snars

Early diagnosis and management are important in dealing with the problem of pseudoseizures and appear to produce a good outcome, associated with a less satisfactory outcome in those in whom the problem is chronic.

SeizureNon-epileptic seizures: management and predictive factors of outcome

100 Citations1992Gerard McDade, Stephen W. Brown

At 1-year follow-up the situation remained similar regarding seizures, with responders demonstrating an improvement in social functioning and a marked reduction in demands on health service resources.