The MacArthur Treatment Competence Study. I: Mental illness and competence to consent to treatment.
Law and Human BehaviorPublished 1 April 1995
Paul S. Appelbaum, Thomas Grisso
Citations427
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.14
SNIP1.75
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
This is the first of three papers reporting the results of the MacArthur Treatment Competence Study, a project designed to develop reliable and valid information with which to address clinical and policy questions regarding the abilities of persons with mental illness to make decisions about psychiatric treatment.
Abstract
This is the first of three papers reporting the results of the MacArthur Treatment CompetenceStudy, a project designed to develop reliable and valid information with which to address clinical and policy questions regarding the abilities of persons with mental illness to make decisions about psychiatric treatment. Four commonly applied legal standards for determining decision-making competence are described: abilities to communicate a choice, understand relevant information, appreciate the nature of the situation and its likely consequences, and rationally manipulate information. Previous research related to the capacities of persons with mental illness in relation to these standards is reviewed and critiqued. The principles underlying the design of the MacArthur Treatment Competence Study are described.
Keywords
PsychologyArts and Humanities
Journal of Legal MedicineA history and theory of informed consent
2,348 Citations1986Marshall B. Kapp
Community Mental Health JournalFrom hospital to community psychiatry
2,056 Citations1970Maxwell Jones
It would seem probable that the social worker rather than the psychiatrist should be the leader of a multidisciplinary team in the community, as the goals of prevention, treatment, education, and change are not explicit.
New England Journal of MedicineAssessing Patients' Capacities to Consent to Treatment
1,393 Citations1988Paul S. Appelbaum, Thomas Grisso
The right of patients to accept or refuse recommended treatment requires careful reassessment when their decision-making capacities are called into question, and the clinical examiner's proper role is to gather relevant information and decide whether an adjudication of incompetence is required.
American Journal of PsychiatryAssessment of insight in psychosis
1,078 Citations1993Xavier Amador, David H. Strauss +4 more
The Scale to Assess Unawareness of Mental Disorder has good reliability and validity and has certain advantages over previous measures of insight, suggesting the usefulness of a multidimensional view of this complex concept.
Choice Reviews OnlinePositive illusions: creative self-deception and the healthy mind
799 Citations1990
The Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) Network (American Medical Association)Informed Consent: Legal Theory and Clinical Practice
737 Citations1987Paul S. Appelbaum, Charles W. Lidz +1 more
This chapter discusses the concept and Ethical Justification of Informed Consent, and the role of informed Consent in Medical Decision-making and the Independent Evolution of Ininformed Consent to Research.
Child DevelopmentThe Competency of Children and Adolescents to Make Informed Treatment Decisions
674 Citations1982Lois A. Weithorn, Susan B. Campbell
American Journal of PsychiatryTests of competency to consent to treatment
663 Citations1977Loren H. Roth, Alan Meisel +1 more
The authors describe the various tests of competency to consent to treatment used today and analyze the applicability of these tests to patients' decisions to accept or refuse psychiatric treatment.
Law and Human BehaviorThe MacArthur Treatment Competence Study. III: Abilities of patients to consent to psychiatric and medical treatments.
599 Citations1995Thomas Grisso, Paul S. Appelbaum
Three instruments assessing abilities related to legal standards for competence to consent to treatment were administered to patients recently hospitalized for schizophrenia, major depression, and ischemic heart disease, as well as three groups of non-ill persons in the community who were matched with the hospitalized patients on age, gender, race, and socioeconomic status.
The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology Section AProbabilistic Judgements in Deluded and Non-Deluded Subjects
595 Citations1988Shafik Huq, Philippa Garety +1 more
An experiment is described in which deluded subjects were compared with a non-deluded psychiatric control group and a normal control group on a probabilistic inference task and found to request less information before reaching a decision and to express higher certainty levels.
JAMAPositive Illusions: Creative Self-Deception and the Healthy Mind
560 Citations1990Natalie Shainess
Schizophrenia BulletinAwareness of Illness in Schizophrenia
541 Citations1991Xavier Amador, David H. Strauss +2 more
The argument is made here that many of the self-awareness deficits observed in schizophrenia are of diagnostic significance, are neurally based, and are indispensable in guiding treatment decisions.
The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (1973-)Evaluating Competencies: Forensic Assessments and Instruments
529 Citations1988William Michalek, Thomas Grisso
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseInsight in Schizophrenia. Its Relationship to Acute Psychopathology
528 Citations1989Joseph P. McEvoy, L. Joy Apperson +6 more
It is suggested that very little of the deficiency in insight seen in schizophrenic patients is explainable on the basis of acute psychopathological features, and the mechanism that accounts for impairment in insight in schizophrenia may be relatively resistant to treatment with neuroleptic medication.
Journal of Legal MedicineInformed consent: Legal theory and clinical practice
367 Citations1988Richard G. Lonsdorf
Appelbaum, P. S., Lidz, C.W., and Meisel, A. (Oxford University Press, New York, 1987), 286 pages, $27.95.
Psychiatric Clinics of North AmericaCognitive Deficits in Schizophrenia
364 Citations1993James M. Gold, Philip D. Harvey
There is accumulating evidence that impairment of neuropsychological and basic information processing abilities is an important feature of schizophrenia and that cognitive impairment is a symptom domain in its own right, with as much importance for understanding and treating the disorder as positive or negative behavioral symptoms.
Clinical HAndbook of Psychiatry and the Law
319 Citations2000Thomas G. Gutheil, Paul S. Appelbaum
The Clinician in Court Index contains links to articles on confidentiality and Privilege, legal issues in Emergency Psychiatry, and other forms of Liability Competence and Substitute Decision Making Forensic Evaluations.
Archives of General PsychiatryCompetency to Consent to Research
284 Citations1982Paul S. Appelbaum
The requirement that a subject be competent as a condition of valid consent to participate in research has been accepted by most students of legal and ethical problems of human experimentation but has lacked a clear and generally agreed on standard.
JAMACompetency to Give an Informed Consent
279 Citations1984James F. Drane
A sliding scale is suggested that requires an increasingly more stringent standard as the consequences of the patient's decision embody more risk.
Clinical Psychology ReviewIs depressive realism real?
276 Citations1991Ruby Ackermann, Robert J. DeRubeis
Archives of General PsychiatryDrug Refusal in Schizophrenia and the Wish to Be Crazy
264 Citations1976Theodore Van Putten
It is interpreted to mean that some schizophrenics may prefer an ego-syntonic grandiose psychosis to a relative drug-induced normality.
Law and Human BehaviorThe MacArthur Treatment Competence Study. II: Measures of abilities related to competence to consent to treatment.
253 Citations1995Thomas Grisso, Paul S. Appelbaum +2 more
The development and psychometric properties of three standardized and objectively scored measures, the MacArthur Treatment Competence Research Instruments, are reported, designed to assess abilities related conceptually to four legal standards for competence to consent to treatment.
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseInsight and the Clinical Outcome of Schizopheric Patients
252 Citations1989Joseph P. McEvoy, Susan Freter +5 more
Patients with more insight were significantly less likely to be readmitted over the course of follow-up, suggesting that insight may influence outcome independently of aftercare environment.
Psychiatric ServicesThe Hopkins Competency Assessment Test: A Brief Method for Evaluating Patients' Capacity to Give Informed Consent
212 Citations1992Jeffrey S. Janofsky, Robert J. McCarthy +1 more
The results suggest that the HCAT is a useful tool for rapidly screening patients for competency to make treatment decisions.
Psychosomatic MedicineThe role of denial in recovery from coronary heart disease.
210 Citations1987Jacob Levine, Stephen Warrenburg +8 more
It is suggested that denial of illness is adaptive during acute hospital recovery, but is maladaptive in the long‐run after hospital discharge.
Archives of General PsychiatryAnother View of Schizophrenia Subtypes
186 Citations1976William T. Carpenter
Almost A Revolution
186 Citations1994Paul S. Appelbaum
DigitalGeorgetown (Georgetown University Library)Almost a Revolution: Mental Health Law and the Limits of Change
170 Citations1994Paul S. Appelbaum
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseEarly Insight and the Management of Schizophrenic Decompensation
161 Citations1985Douglas W Heinrichs, Barry P. Cohen +1 more
The feasibility of an early intervention strategy designed to abort decompensations in schizophrenic patients in their earliest stages before florid psychosis and rehospitalization occur is supported and early insight is an important patient attribute that predicts successful implementation of this treatment.
Palgrave Macmillan UK eBooksMaking Health Care Decisions
158 Citations1992Miriam K. Mills
This chapter deals with an approach taken to evaluate various treatment protocols based on a variety of criteria to make one’s thinking manifest.
Comprehensive PsychiatryWhy must some schizophrenic patients be involuntarily committed? The role of insight
152 Citations1989J P McEvoy, Paul S. Applebaum +3 more
Although psychopathology diminished significantly in both committed and voluntary patients over the course of hospitalization, only in voluntary patients did insight increase significantly, andability to see the self as ill seems to be a persistent trait in some schizophrenic patients.
Acta Psychiatrica ScandinavicaThe assessment of insight in clinical psychiatry: a new scale
140 Citations1992Ivana S. Marková, G. E. Berrios
It is postulate that other factors (such as intellect, past experience, personality etc.) must be involved in modulating the expression of insight in patients suffering from schizophrenia or depression.
PubMedInsight and adherence to medication in chronic schizophrenics.
134 Citations1979Ih Foo Lin, Ralph Spiga +1 more
Patients who had insight, perceived benefits from medication and also perceived a relation between the 2 were more likely to take medication than those who did not have insight nor perceive benefits.
American Journal of PsychiatryEmpirical assessment of competency to consent to psychiatric hospitalization
132 Citations1981Paul S. Appelbaum, S A Mirkin +1 more
Limits in the applicability of the legal model of informed consent to the psychiatric setting are suggested after a majority of patients appeared to have severe impairment of competency.
The Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) Network (American Medical Association)Informed Consent: A Study of Decisionmaking in Psychiatry
124 Citations1984Charles W. Lidz, Alan Meisel +4 more
Schizophrenia BulletinInsight and Interpretation of Illness in Recovery From Psychosis
113 Citations1989Dorothy A. Greenfeld, John S. Strauss +2 more
The concept of insight as it applies to patients suffering from psychotic illness is reviewed and some preliminary findings regarding the association of patterns of insight with diagnosis and chronicity of illness are presented.
The British Journal of PsychiatryMorbidity in the Community of Schizophrenic Patients Discharged from London Mental Hospitals in 1959
108 Citations1964J. K. Wing, Elizabeth Monck +2 more
The social and clinical progress of a group of male schizophrenic patients who left London mental hospitals during 1959 and were followed up for one year are described.
Journal of the American Geriatrics SocietyDepression in the Elderly: Effect on Patient Attitudes toward Life‐Sustaining Therapy
102 Citations1992Melinda A. Lee, Linda Ganzini
The aim of this study is to determine the effect of depression on preferences for life‐sustaining therapy in older persons and to establish a baseline for this research.
Psychiatric ServicesMeasuring Chronic Schizophrenic Patients' Attitudes Toward Their Illness and Treatment
102 Citations1981Joseph P. McEvoy, Jack Aland +3 more
It is suggested that many chronically mentally ill patients lack sufficient insight into their condition to make sound judgments about medication and treatment, and even those patients who improved with medication did not improve in their insight into the need for treatment.
International Journal of Law and PsychiatryCompetency to decide about treatment or research
96 Citations1982Loren H. Roth, Charles W. Lidz +5 more
Law and Human BehaviorMentally ill and non-mentally-ill patients' abilities to understand informed consent disclosures for medication: Preliminary data.
93 Citations1991Thomas Grisso, Paul S. Appelbaum
Generally, hospitalized schizophrenic patients manifested significantly poorer understanding of “informed consent” disclosures about potential medication than did the other groups and was related to a number of clinical and demographic variables.
American Journal of PsychiatryThe right to refuse treatment with antipsychotic medications: retrospect and prospect
91 Citations1988Paul S. Appelbaum
These findings point up the essential illogic of allowing committed persons to refuse treatment that would permit their freedom to be restored.
JAMAClinical Handbook of Psychiatry and the Law
89 Citations1982Manuel P. Pardo
The authors' title selection is certainly apropos for this masterful work on psychiatry and the law, and the book has successfully achieved what the authors stated it consistently strives to accomplish.
Archives of General PsychiatrySchizophrenic and Medical Inpatients as Informed Drug Consumers
87 Citations1978David A. Soskis
The fact that schizophrenic inpatients readily shared their reluctance to take medication with an interviewer may offer an avenue for detection and intervention to improve prospects for outpatient compliance.
Archives of General PsychiatryInforming Patients About Tardive Dyskinesia
86 Citations1985Mark R. Munetz
While information about tardive dyskinesia can be safely disclosed to schizophrenic outpatients, such disclosure is evidently most meaningful when repeated informally in the context of a therapeutic relationship.
American Journal of PsychiatryPreliminary findings on psychiatric patients as research participants: a population at risk?
69 Citations1981Bárbara Stanley, Michael Stanley +3 more
Although Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale scores clearly differentiated between psychiatric and nonpsychiatric patients, psychopathology did not correlate with willingness to participate in any of the studies.
American Journal of PsychiatryPsychotic patients' understanding of informed consent
69 Citations1985Michael R. Irwin, A. Lovitz +5 more
Although most patients stated they had understood informed consent material, objective ratings did not support this, and impaired understanding was significantly associated with thought disturbance but did not affect hypothetical acceptance or refusal of antipsychotics.
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseDepressed Subjects Unwittingly Overreport Poor Social Adjustment Which They Reappraise When Recovered
66 Citations1991J.M.F. Ferreira, Megan M. Smith +2 more
It is indicated that acutely depressed patients overreport social maladjustment, which they then more accurately reappraise when symptoms remit, which indicates that patients are completely unaware of both the initial bias and of the reappraisal.
Law and Human BehaviorInformation disclosure, subject understanding, and informed consent in psychiatric research.
63 Citations1988Paul R. Benson, Loren H. Roth +3 more
It is suggested that the degree of improvement in understanding obtainable for severely disordered subjects is substantially lower than it is for others and the implications for informed consent, the regulation of medical research, and the protection of human subjects are discussed.
Australian & New Zealand Journal of PsychiatryPsychiatric Disturbance and Decisionmaking
60 Citations1986Mark Radford, Leon Mann +1 more
The relationship between psychiatric disorder and decisionmaking behaviour was examined in a sample of hospitalised patients and it was revealed that patients were strikingly slow in answering the questionnaires and often attempted to make no response.
Comprehensive PsychiatryFlexible System Criteria in chronic schizophrenia
59 Citations1986William H. Wilson, Thomas A. Ban +1 more
Law and Human BehaviorCompetence to consent to treatment as a psycholegal construct.
58 Citations1984Allan M. Tepper, Amiram Elwork
Following a review and analysis of the relevant legal and psychological literature, a comprehensive construct of competency to consent to treatment is proposed and future directions for research are discussed.
American Journal of PsychiatryUse of psychopathology vignettes by patients with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder and by mental health professionals to judge patients' insight
58 Citations1993J P McEvoy, Nina R. Schooler +3 more
Failure to acknowledge conceptual disorganization, avolition-apathy, and affective blunting and the failure to view hallucinatory behavior and suspiciousness as signs of mental illness, which proved to be additive in this study, contribute to deficits in insight.
The GerontologistThe Functional Competency of Elderly at Risk1
56 Citations1988Bárbara Stanley, Michael Stanley +2 more
American Journal of PsychiatryInformed consent in voluntary mental hospital admissions
54 Citations1975G B Olin, Harry S. Olin
The authors studied the amount of understanding that 100 mental hospital patients had a voluntary admission application they signed upon entering the hospital, finding that few voluntary patients are fully informed to give consent to hospitalization.
British Journal of Clinical PsychologyIllusory correlations in paranoid and non‐paranoid schizophrenia
53 Citations1984Jerry Brennan, D. R. Hemsley
Assessment of paranoids, non-paranoid schizophrenics and normals found that paranoids show stronger illusory correlations than normals due to the predominance of their schemata when processing information, and non-Paranoids would show weaker correlations thannormals because of their impaired ability to establish conceptual categories.
American Journal of PsychiatryInformed consent and tardive dyskinesia
50 Citations1989Irwin Kleinman, Debbie Schachter +1 more
To determine whether a formalized informing process transmitted knowledge concerning the risks and benefits of neuroleptic medication, particularly the risk of tardive dyskinesia, to stable schizophrenic outpatients, the authors administered a multiple-choice questionnaire to patients who were read a standardized information form.
JAMAThe Mentally Disabled and the Law
49 Citations1987Louis L. Lunsky
This is the third edition of a very comprehensive book, the size of a telephone directory, dealing with the mentally disabled, which deals with all facets of the law.
Journal of Legal MedicineInformed consent does not mean rational consent
48 Citations1990Jon F. Merz, Baruch Fischhoff
If all decisions by the patient could be made on an intelligent basis; if the physician were not faced with any of the impediments of superstition, superstition and other extraneous influences, doctor‐patient accord would be a problem of manageable proportions.
The British Journal of PsychiatryThe Concept of Negative Symptoms
48 Citations1989J. K. Wing
In a recent edition of the Schizophrenia Bulletin devoted to negative symptoms, the editor suggested at the beginning of his preface that what he called the “positive–negative symptom distinction” had been introduced into psychiatry only a decade previously (Levine, 1985).
The Journal of UrologyAspiration and Tetracycline Sclerotherapy of Hydroceles
43 Citations1988Laurence A. Levine, William C. DeWolf
The experience with modification of this procedure in the treatment of 28 hydroceles with a 10 per cent solution of tetracycline hydrochloride used as the sclerosant found it to be an effective outpatient procedure.
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseDrug Information Disclosed to Patients Prescribed Antipsychotic Medication
41 Citations1984Paul R. Benson
The neuroleptic drug disclosure practices of 60 North Carolina psychiatrists are examined, utilizing survey data collected in 1979, and patient racial and diagnostic characteristics, as well as physician medical and psychiatric journal use, were found to be significant predictors of drug disclosure in the multivariate analyses.
American Journal of PsychiatryState hospital patients and their medication--do they know what they take?
38 Citations1982Jeffrey L. Geller
The finding that few patients were knowledgeable about their medication raises doubts about recent court rulings on patients' competency to refuse medication.
Psychiatric Services<i>Rivers</i> in Practice: Clinicians' Assessments of Patients' Decision-Making Capacity
34 Citations1989Karen McKinnon, Francine Cournos +1 more
The findings suggest that psychiatrists may view capacity assessments as irrelevant because of the manifestly grave nature of patients' illnesses or may not differentiate the capacity assessment from the mental status examination.
Psychiatric ServicesAssessing the Psychiatric Patient's Ability to Meet the Literacy Demands of Hospitalization
28 Citations1980Allan Berg, Karleen B. Hammitt
The readability of literature intended to inform patients about various aspects of their hospitalization was evaluated to determine if a significant discrepancy existed between literacy demands on patients and their literacy skills.
Schizophrenia BulletinInformation and Consent in Schizophrenic Patients in Long-term Treatment
24 Citations1981M. Linden, Roberto Chaskel
Issues considered include the extent to which highly compliant patients know important facts about their treatment, how satisfied they are with the information given to them, and the implications for informed consent.
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseDecision Making in Clinically Depressed Patients
22 Citations1991Mark Radford, Yoshibumi Nakane +3 more
It was found that depression had a greater effect on decision making in Australian patients than in Japanese patients, and there appears to be an important interactional effect of culture and depression on decisionMaking.
The Canadian Journal of PsychiatryA Study of Competence to Consent to Treatment in a Psychiatric Hospital <sup>*</sup>
22 Citations1992Brian F. Hoffman, J. Srinivasan
The study outlines the major difficulties in the assessment of competence to consent to psychiatric treatment and suggests that 74% of patients found incompetent using the current definition in the MHA ( Ontario) would fail almost any reasonable test.
DigitalGeorgetown (Georgetown University Library)Competency : a study of informal competency determinations in primary care
18 Citations1991Mary Ann G. Cutter, Earl E. Shelp
This book discusses Competence, a concept at the Intersection of Law, Medicine, and Philosophy, and Judgments about Patient Competence in Health Care.
Law and Human BehaviorDecision making in a schizophrenic population.
16 Citations1992Barry Rosenfeld, Eric Turkheimer +1 more
Results suggest that competence assessments that rely primarily on verbal abilities may be inadequate to assess competence in acutely ill psychiatric patients.
Psychiatric ServicesLiteracy Skills of Long-Term Hospitalized Mental Patients
16 Citations1978Gerald S. Coles, Laura Roth +1 more
From the findings, both in-hospital and aftercare programs must recognize that literacy level is an important factor in the the rehabilitation or recidivism of patients.
Law and Human BehaviorThe evolution of commitment law in the nineteenth century: A reinterpretation.
14 Citations1982Paul S. Appelbaum, Kathleen N. Kemp
Examination of the evolution of commitment law in Pennsylvania in the nineteenth century reveals that Pennsylvania law underwent a slow accretion of procedural protections, with the essential discretionary role of families, friends, and physicians left undisturbed.
The Journal of Psychiatry & LawSchizophrenic Patients’ Self-perceptions: Legal and Clinical Implications
14 Citations1989Elaine F. Walker, Judith Pratt Rossiter
Patients who stated that they perceived themselves to be mentally ill had a shorter duration of most recent hospitalization, a smaller number of previous hospitalizations, and greater compliance with treatment.
Comprehensive PsychiatryCommunicating with patients about antipsychotic drugs
13 Citations1979David A. Soskis, Richard L. Jaffe
In a review of medication compliance problems (which are not limited to schizophrenic patients), Blackwell has cited several high-risk factors, including chronicity of illness, symptom suppressive as opposed to curative action of the medication, delayed relapse with cessation of medications, ambivalent feelings about dependency issues, multiple medications, and social isolation.
Journal of Advanced NursingCan the client with chronic schizophrenia consent to nursing research?
12 Citations1984R Davidhizar, David F. Wehlage
The legal standards of informed consent and the legally accepted standards of competency are elucidated and four issues are considered: evidencing a choice, factual understanding of the issues, rational manipulation of information, and appreciation of the nature of the situation.
PubMedProblems of long-term informed consent.
8 Citations1986Richard L. Jaffe
There was a remarkable similarity in the degree of comprehension between psychiatric and medical outpatient groups; this suggests that psychiatric patients need not be considered any less competent than medical outpatients in assimilating necessary medication information.
Philosophy and medicineMedical Treatment Decisions and Competency in the Eyes of the Law: A Brief Survey
3 Citations1991Patricia D. White, Susan Hankin Denise
A person can be legally incompetent in some areas while remaining legally competent in others, since the law requires a lower degree of capacity in the making of wills than it does for the execution of contracts.
PEDIATRICSIn Reply: To Tap, or Not to Tap, in the Febrile Convulsion
2 Citations1973John H. Menkes
I would never dispute Dr. Kafka, whose years of pediatric practice support his clinical intuition, if he were to discharge an infant who had just experienced his first febrile convulsion without performing a lumbar puncture.
…