Thoughts on the therapeutic use of narrative in the promotion of coping in cancer care
European Journal of Cancer CarePublished 11 August 2004
Alison Carlick, Francis C. Biley
Citations118
SJR quartileQ2
SJR score0.74
SNIP0.88
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is concluded that narratives can help patients cope with their cancer and nurses are urged to incorporate the use of narratives into their practice.
Abstract
When a life is struck by cancer the very foundations of that life are shaken. The safety of 'everydayness' is replaced with a fear and uncertainty of tomorrow and the human need to make sense of life is the driving force behind coping. After initial diagnosis patients must begin to piece together their lives and build new and stronger foundations. This paper identifies a growing awareness of the role that narratives can play in helping cancer patients cope with their illness. Narratives can be used to objectify and distance oneself from problems in order to gain understanding, establish meaning, develop greater self-knowledge and decrease emotional distress. This review concludes that narratives can help patients cope with their cancer and urges nurses to incorporate the use of narratives into their practice.
Keywords
PsychologyMedicineHealth Professions
LanguageLanguage in the inner city: studies in the Black English Vernacular. By William Labov. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1972. Pp. xxiv, 412. $6.95.
3,033 Citations1975Robbins Burling
Social Science & MedicinePositive psychological states and coping with severe stress
1,807 Citations1997Susan Folkman
Coping processes that are associated with positive psychologicalStates in the context of intense distress are described and the theoretical implications of positive psychological states in the coping process are discussed.
Image the Journal of Nursing ScholarshipTelling Stories: Narrative Approaches in Qualitative Research
896 Citations1991Margarete Sandelowski
This paper presents narrative as a framework for understanding the subject and interview data in qualitative research and examples of narrative approaches are offered, narrative analyses are contrasted with other kinds of qualitative analyses, and truth in narratives is considered.
Social Science & MedicineThe relationship between coping and emotion: Implications for theory and research
863 Citations1988Susan Folkman, Richard S. Lazarus
The ways emotion and coping influence each other in what must ultimately be seen as a dynamic, mutually reciprocal relationship are explored.
Sociology of Health & IllnessIllness narratives: fact or fiction?
824 Citations2001Mike Bury
Given the complex character of illness narratives, their social and psychological functions, together with the motivational issues to which they relate, it is suggested that they constitute a major challenge for sociological analysis.
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyAccelerating the coping process.
601 Citations1990James W. Pennebaker, Michelle Colder +1 more
No effects emerged as a function of when people wrote, suggesting that the coping process can be accelerated and for comparing insight treatments with catharsis, and for distinguishing between objective and self-report indicators of distress.
Social Science & MedicineDisclosure of traumas and psychosomatic processes
559 Citations1988James W. Pennebaker, Joan R. Susman
Results from a series of studies are summarized in support of a general theory of inhibition and psychosomatics, suggesting childhood traumatic experiences, particularly those never discussed, are highly correlated with current health problems and ruminations about the traumas.
Health PsychologyPatterns of coping with cancer.
479 Citations1992Christine Dunkel‐Schetter, Lawrence G. Feinstein +2 more
Coping through social support, focusing on the positive, and distancing was associated with less emotional distress, whereas using cognitive and behavioral escape-avoidance wasassociated with more emotional distress.
Image the Journal of Nursing ScholarshipNursing as Informed Caring for the Well‐Being of Others
442 Citations1993Kristen M. Swanson
Assumptions about four main phenomena of concern to nursing (persons/clients, health/well-being, environments and nursing) are presented and an elaboration is made of the structure of a theory of caring.
Qualitative Health ResearchThe Standpoint of Storyteller
409 Citations2000Arthur W. Frank
The legitimacy of an interest in illness narratives that is therapeutic, emancipatory, and pre-occupied with ethics is defended and how qualitative methods can inform changing relationships between illness, health, medicine, and culture is considered.
Psycho-OncologyAdjustment to cancer?coping or personal transition?
362 Citations2001James Brennan
This paper combines the complementary assets of coping theory and social‐cognitive theory and proposes the Social‐Cognitive Transition (SCT) model of adjustment, a clinical model which also accounts for the frequent reports of healthy personal growth associated with cancer.
Sociology of Health & IllnessReneotiating identity: cancer narratives
335 Citations1995Cynthia M. Mathieson, Hendaikns J. Stam
‘Identity work’ is used to describe the process of patients' evaluations of the meaning of their illness within the actual context of ongoing, organised social relationships, including the medical system.
Social Science & MedicineIllness narratives: time, hope and HIV
283 Citations2000Douglas Ezzy
Drawing on a combined quantitative and qualitative study of people living with HIV/AIDS in Australia, three different narratives that people use to make sense of their illness experience are identified: linear restitution narratives, linear chaotic narratives and polyphonic narratives.
Advances in Nursing ScienceThe role of experience, narrative, and community in skilled ethical comportment
239 Citations1991Peter Benner
Two major types of narrative—constitutive or sustaining narratives and narratives of learning—are presented to illustrate the functions of narrative in everyday ethical expertise and socially embedded caring practices.
Qualitative Health ResearchTalk that Talk: Storytelling and Analysis Rooted in African American Oral Tradition
236 Citations2002JoAnne Banks‐Wallace
A comprehensive analytic process for gathering and interpreting stories rooted in African American oral tradition is outlined and dialogues about storytelling and storytaking are revisited and critiqued.
Journal of Transcultural NursingUtilizing Traditional Storytelling to Promote Wellness in American Indian Communities
177 Citations2002Felicia Schanche Hodge, Anna Pasqua +2 more
The project utilized stories to help motivate tribal members to once more adopt healthy, traditional life-styles and practices and to come to their own conclusions after personal reflection.
Cancer NursingCoping strategies of long-term cancer survivors
177 Citations1994Marilyn Tuls Halstead, Jayne I. Fernsler
Results of this study increase nurses' awareness of effective coping strategies and the importance of assessment of coping in long-term survivors of cancer.
The Crisis of Physical Illness
172 Citations1984Rudolf H. Moos, Jeanne A. Schaefer
Patients and staff are considered by considering physical illness as a life crisis and by describing how patients and staff cope with the stress of illness and of treatment.
Health An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of Health Illness and MedicineManaging a Disrupted Lifecourse: Issues of Identity and Emotion Work
142 Citations2001Catherine Exley, Gayle Letherby
This article draws on the experiences of a group of people who have defined, or still define themselves as ‘infertile’ and/or ‘involuntarily childless’, and of people with cancer who have a terminal prognosis, who may be perceived as dying ‘prematurely’.
Journal of Holistic NursingWe are the Stories we Tell
133 Citations1994Margarete Sandelowski
Why caregivers have become interested in narratives, the nature and function of stories for patients, the location of stories in the diagnostic and healing functions of the nurse, and the significance of Stories for holistic nursing practice are considered.
Journal of Social and Clinical PsychologyEmotional Expression in Written Essays and Psychotherapy
131 Citations1989Edward J. Murray, Alisa Lamnin +1 more
Health An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of Health Illness and MedicineStories of illness as care of the self: a Foucauldian dialogue
117 Citations1998Arthur W. Frank
The works of the classicist Page duBois and the philosopher Charles Taylor are used to provide a reconceptualized version of ‘care of the self’ and suggest that empowerment through narrative formulations of identity remains possible, though Foucault teaches us that telling the authors' ‘own stories’ is never straightforward.
Research in Nursing & HealthTime and qualitative research
112 Citations1999Margarete Sandelowski
Qualitative research designs may be oriented to synchronic and/or diachronic analyses, and the Trajectory Model is a useful framework for sampling, data collection, and analysis.
Image the Journal of Nursing ScholarshipEmancipatory Potential of Storytelling in a Group
104 Citations1998JoAnne Banks‐Wallace
Group storytelling can create an environment that supports evaluation of experience and promotes problem-solving and is useful for learning more about historical and contextual factors affecting the well-being of women of African descent and for improving their lives.
Journal of Narrative and Life HistoryConstruing Experience: Some Story Genres
91 Citations1997James R. Martin, Guenther Plum
Social Science & MedicineAccommodation, resistance and transcendence: three narratives of autism
85 Citations2001Stacy W. Gray
The three narratives presented display both conformity and non-conformity with the official narrative of autism offered by the autistic treatment centre where the research was based, and are described as narratives of accommodation, resistance and transcendence.
PubMedTransformation of tragedy among women surviving breast cancer.
84 Citations2000Taylor Ej
The author observed a basic social-psychospiritual process of transforming personal tragedy that involved phases labeled as encountering darkness, converting darkness, encountering light, and reflecting light.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyArt and Aesthetics in Nursing
79 Citations1994Peggy L. Chinn, Jean Watson
Music, narrative, painting, and more are presented as viable therapeutic modalities essential for reclaiming nursin g as a human art and science.
DigitalGeorgetown (Georgetown University Library)Caring as Healing: Renewal Through Hope
75 Citations1994Delores A. Gaut, Anne Boykin
Advances in Nursing ScienceHealth within illness
74 Citations1989Susan Diemert Moch
Adoption of this perspective in current health care would initiate drastic changes and provide endless possibilities for a more positive, less judgmental attitude toward the experience of illness.
Advances in Nursing ScienceWomanspirit: A Journey into Healing Through Art in Breast Cancer
74 Citations1996Elizabeth Predeger
Womanspirit, the unifying essence underlying personal and collective knowledge, is presented and allowing the meaning of experience to become visible through art in a collective is advocated.
Journal of Advanced NursingWomen’s narratives during the acute phase of their myocardial infarction
73 Citations2001Marianne Svedlund, Ella Danielson +1 more
It seems that relatives and the staff at CCU were not allowed to share the burden of being afflicted with an AMI, and guilt and shame may have led to a deterioration of communication.
Sociology of Health & IllnessThe aesthetics of illness: narrative, horror and the sublime
72 Citations1999Alan Radley
Journal of Advanced NursingThe political role of illness narratives
63 Citations2000Jurate A. Sakalys
Gadow's concept of the relational narrative is proposed as a way to restore patient subjectivity and agency and establish the dialogue necessary for cultural pluralism in nursing and health care.
Nursing InquiryTelling a story, writing a narrative: terminology in health care
60 Citations1995John Wiltshire
It is argued that the focus on narrative forms is related to nursing's professional development of an alternative epistemology to science, and to nursing theorists' mistrust of 'Enlightenment' modes.
Cancer NursingStorytelling
53 Citations2000Jane Harper Chelf, Amy M. B. Deshler +2 more
The purpose of this focused program evaluation was to explore attitudes and beliefs about storytelling as a strategy for coping with cancer among participants who attended a cancer-related storytelling workshop, and found that 97% of the respondents agreed that storytelling was a helpful way to cope with cancer.
Education for HealthSongs and Storytelling: Bringing Health Messages to Life in Uganda
51 Citations2001David Silver
Utilizing existing community traditions such as songs and storytelling offers culturally appropriate ways of enhancing the communications component of the health care system to make it serve the poor majority in a readily comprehensible, credible, affordable, and accessible form.
Cancer NursingThe Meaning of “Not Giving In”
48 Citations2000Kirsten Pryds Jensen, Siv Bäck‐Pettersson +1 more
The meaning to women with breast cancer of "not giving in" is explored, including six key constituents: accepting the challenge to go on living, working actively on the healing process, finding something important to live for, gaining insights about life itself, experiencing awareness and avoidance, and introducing radical change in life.
Nursing InquiryNarrative and exploration: toward a poetics of knowledge in nursing
48 Citations1995Sally Gadow
The dualism of subject and object has been a traditional model for nursing knowledge but that model is portrayed here as an epistemological exile, which can be remedied by inquiry based on engagement rather than distance.
Issues in Mental Health NursingTRANSFORMATION OF STORY TO PRACTICE: AN INNOVATIVE APPROACH TO LONG-TERM CARE
41 Citations1999Diane Heliker
The purpose of this article is to demonstrate how the functions of storytelling can be applied in the long-term care setting using the themes that emerge in the life story of a particular resident.
Medical HumanitiesNarrative in psychiatry and psychotherapy: the evidence?
39 Citations2000Jeremy Holmes
Life history research, the “adult attachment interview” and other research approaches to narrative in psychiatry and psychotherapy are described, calling for an integration of narrative and evidence-based medicine.
Research and Theory for Nursing PracticeAttentively Embracing Story: A Middle-Range Theory With Practice and Research Implications
39 Citations1999Mary Jane Smith, Patricia Liehr
The proposed middle-range theory of attentively embracing story is offered for critical examination by the nursing community as a guide for practice and research aimed at the promotion of human growth and change.
Journal of Advanced NursingLanguage, discourse and the chronotope: applying literary theory to the narratives in health care
36 Citations2000Jane Harden
It is argued that a less naive understanding of the complexities of the language with which the individual speaks is needed, which can be achieved by adopting post-structural analyses of the spoken or written word, from both the originator's and recipient's experiences.
Narrative InquiryCollected Stories in the Life Narratives of Holocaust Survivors
33 Citations2001Brian Schiff, Chaim Noy +1 more
Advances in Nursing ScienceBakhtin, Nursing Narratives, and Dialogical Consciousness
31 Citations1997Rick Bowers, Katherine Moore
Mikhail Bakhtin's dialogical narrative approach to nursing practice is related, which is directly related to nursing concepts of narrative, interaction, and personhood and suggestive of a postmodern clinical epistemology.
Counselling Psychology QuarterlyThe experience of ‘healing stories’ in the life narrative: A grounded theory
29 Citations1999Susan Swaton, Jean O’Callaghan
Journal of Holistic NursingA Narrative Approach to Quality Care in Long-Term Care Facilities
24 Citations1997Diane Heliker
Personal and common meanings embedded in the lived lives of five older women residing in a long-term care facility are interpreted using a seven-stage Heideggerian henneneutical phenomenological approach.
Illness Crisis & LossCare beyond Cancer: The Culture of Creativity
22 Citations2002Beth Ferris, Youpa Stein
This article examines the key concepts developed by Living Art, a nonprofit organization, in its “Cancer, Courage, and Creativity” ten-week expressive arts therapy groups for cancer survivors.
PubMedAmeliorating the tension: use of forgiveness for healing.
22 Citations2001Jacqueline Ruth Mickley, Kathleen V. Cowles
A cancer diagnosis promotes the rethinking of life priorities regardless of the stage of disease and forgiveness was used to help clarify personal values and to help eliminate negative emotions from an inflicted hurt.
Journal of Advanced NursingCaring and cancer nursing: framing the reality using selected social science theory
21 Citations1998Daniel Kelly
By examining the context of cancer, it is argued that effective caring deserves to be recognized as an important clinical variable which can influence a diverse range of issues such as patient satisfaction or therapeutic outcome.
Cancer NursingAn Overview of Psychosocial Support Services
21 Citations2000Judith Johnson
Psychosocial support services of various types need to be made available throughout the cancer experience to restore a sense of wholeness to one's mind, body, and spirit.
Advances in Nursing ScienceEnhancing esthetic knowledge
20 Citations1992Mary Jane Smith
A teaching strategy that has been used with graduate students to enhance their esthetic knowing through representing, interpreting, and envisioning the lived experience of a caring presence in nursing practice is described.
JAMAOrdinary Life: A Memoir of Illness
20 Citations1997Hu Da-Shih
The writing is brisk and expressive, and the author makes apt observations about the health care system and the burden of being ill, but the content is disagreeable.
Seminars in Oncology NursingThe story behind the story: The use of storytelling in spiritual caregiving
19 Citations1997Elizabeth Johnston Taylor
International Journal of Palliative NursingProtective coping: a grounded theory of educative interactions in palliative care nursing
16 Citations2001Adrian Morgan
A research project undertaken in Western Australia examined the symbolic nature and characteristics of educative interactions, which their therapeutic value was interpreted in order to construct a theory, which in turn, explained their function.
Alternative Therapies
15 Citations1996Lili A Sacks Laury, Mckean J.Markbray
Journal of Narrative and Life HistoryConstruing Experience: Some Story Genres
14 Citations1997James R. Martin, Guenther Plum
Journal of Advanced NursingDeath, portry, psychotherapy and clinical supervision (the contribution of psychodynamic psychotherapy to palliative care nursing)*
13 Citations1997Alun Jones
The author proposes that engagement in a therapeutic relationship with a dying person presents the worker with parallel struggles manifesting in elementary feelings which require discernment, and recommends that the rich symbolic language and metaphors, redolent in art and poetry, be harnessed as a potent therapeutic tool.
Health An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of Health Illness and MedicineTalking about Cigarettes: Conversational Narratives of Health and Illness
13 Citations1999Éric Laurier
It is argued that conversational narration is a joint activity and that the form and context of its telling can tell us as much about lay understandings of health as can the content of its stories.
Medical HumanitiesOpening the Word Hoard
6 Citations2007Gillie Bolton, Yvonne Yi Wood Mak +4 more
Every issue of Medical Humanities will contain a section of original creative writing, offering a window onto the practice, experience, thought and feeling of colleagues, through their writing.
Journal of Medical EthicsLaw and Medical Practice: Rights, Duties, Claims and Defences
4 Citations2000Max Charlesworth
Studies in Psychology Estudios de PsicologíaTiempo calculado y tiempo narrado
4 Citations2002Piero Paolicchi, Alberto Rosa
Nursing StandardFlorence Nightingale’s Notes on NursingFlorence Nightingale’s Notes on Nursing V Skretkoivicz Scutari Press 212pp £14.99 1-871364-63-9
2 Citations1992Caroline Richens