Assisted suicide and nursing: Possibly compatible?
Journal of Professional NursingPublished 1 May 1999
Becky Cox White
Citations11
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.02
SNIP1.38
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The American Nurses Association's (ANA) prohibition of nurse-assisted suicide is misguided and the professional has a responsibility to either embrace the public's increasing support of aid in dying or determine why AS is morally indefensible and educate the public.
Abstract
This article argues that the American Nurses Association's (ANA) prohibition of nurse-assisted suicide is misguided. The ANA's reasons for this policy do not provide the necessary conceptual or empirical support for the prohibition. In fact, arguments appear to lead to support for nurse-assisted suicide: (1) because the claim that death is always harmful may be false, the obligation to "do no harm" does not necessarily preclude assisted suicide (AS); (2) currently we have no evidence that AS would erode public trust in nurses; (3) AS may be compatible with the professional integrity of nursing, particularly the commitments to respecting autonomy, promoting patient welfare, and providing compassionate care; (4) nursing's participation would constrain, rather than contribute to, the potential for abuse to vulnerable patient populations; and (5) the professional has a responsibility to either embrace the public's increasing support of aid in dying or determine why AS is morally indefensible and educate the public.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
JAMAA controlled trial to improve care for seriously ill hospitalized patients. The study to understand prognoses and preferences for outcomes and risks of treatments (SUPPORT). The SUPPORT Principal Investigators
2,779 Citations1995Alfred F. Connors, Neal V. Dawson +198 more
The phase I observation of SUPPORT confirmed substantial shortcomings in care for seriously ill hospitalized adults and the phase II intervention failed to improve care or patient outcomes.
JAMAA Controlled Trial to Improve Care for Seriously III Hospitalized Patients
2,284 Citations1995Alfred F. Connors
Annals of Internal MedicinePerceptions by Family Members of the Dying Experience of Older and Seriously Ill Patients
759 Citations1997Joanne Lynn, Joan M. Teno +8 more
The ways in which patients' surrogate decision makers recalled the patients' health, symptoms, functional state, emotional state, preferences for care, use of life-sustaining treatments, and site of death are reported.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Physician's Responsibility toward Hopelessly Ill Patients
438 Citations1989Sidney H. Wanzer, Daniel D. Federman +10 more
The value of a sensitive approach to care is emphasized--one that is adjusted continually to suit the changing needs of the patient as death approaches, and the appropriate and, if necessary, aggressive use of pain-relieving substances is recommended.
The LancetEuthanasia and physician-assisted suicide: attitudes and experiences of oncology patients, oncologists, and the public
373 Citations1996Ezekiel J. Emanuel, Elisabeth R. Daniels +2 more
Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide are important issues in the care of terminally ill patients and while oncology patients experiencing pain are unlikely to desire these interventions patients with depression are more likely to request assistance in committing suicide.
New England Journal of MedicineAttitudes of Michigan Physicians and the Public toward Legalizing Physician-Assisted Suicide and Voluntary Euthanasia
256 Citations1996Jerald G. Bachman, Kirsten H. Alcser +4 more
Most Michigan physicians prefer either the legalization of physician-assisted suicide or no law at all; fewer than one fifth prefer a complete ban on the practice; two thirds of the Michigan public prefer legalization and one quarter prefer a ban.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Role of Critical Care Nurses in Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide
249 Citations1996David A. Asch
As public debate continues about euthanasia and assisted suicide, some critical care nurses in the United States are engaging in the practice.
New England Journal of MedicineLegalizing Assisted Suicide — Views of Physicians in Oregon
238 Citations1996Melinda A. Lee, Heidi D Nelson +4 more
Oregon physicians have a more favorable attitude toward legalized physician-assisted suicide, are more willing to participate, and are currently participating in greater numbers than other surveyed groups of physicians in the United States.
New England Journal of MedicineCare of the Hopelessly Ill
237 Citations1992Timothy E. Quill, C K Cassel +1 more
The philosophy and techniques of comfort care provide a humane alternative to more traditional, curative medical approaches in helping patients achieve this end by allowing hopelessly ill patients to die with as much comfort, control, and dignity as possible.
JAMAGood Care of the Dying Patient
221 Citations1996Ronald M. Davis
This review is the third in a series of reports on physician-assisted suicide requested by the American Medical Association Board of Trustees in response to Resolution 3 at the 1993 House of Delegates Annual Meeting.
Feminism & bioethics beyond reproduction
177 Citations1996Susan M. Wolf
Taking readers beyond reproduction, not to the brink of revolution, but toward reconstruction in bioethics, Wolf's volume proceeds by illuminating how the field, its categories, and its arguments were constructed in the first place, within necessarily gendered institutions and discourses.
Annals of Internal MedicineThe History of Euthanasia Debates in the United States and Britain
154 Citations1994Ezekiel J. Emanuel
Examination of past debates on euthanasia in the United States and Britain during the late 19th and early 20th centuries may help illuminate the justifications currently offered for euthanasia and arguments against it.
Philosophy and medicineEvaluation and Explanation in the Biomedical Sciences
131 Citations1975H. Tristram Engelhardt, Stuart F. Spicker
JAMAThe Practice of Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide in the United States
123 Citations1998Ezekiel J. Emanuel, Elisabeth R. Daniels +2 more
Intractable pain or poor physical functioning seem to be nearly absolute requirements for physicians to perform euthanasia or PAS; only one third of cases are performed consistently with proposed safeguards.
The Hastings Center ReportThe Physician's Obligation to Prolong Life: A Medical Duty without Classical Roots
123 Citations1978Darrel W. Amundsen
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare EthicsThe Difference That Culture Can Make in End-of-Life Decisionmaking
120 Citations1998Herbert E Hern, Barbara A. Koenig +2 more
Cultural difference has been largely ignored within bioethics, particularly within the end-of-life discourses and practices that have developed over the past two decades in the U.S. healthcare system, but should culture be taken into account?
New England Journal of MedicineWhat Are the Potential Cost Savings from Legalizing Physician-Assisted Suicide?
62 Citations1998Ezekiel J. Emanuel, Margaret P. Battin
The issue of the potential cost savings from legalizing physician-assisted suicide, and how the savings might influence decision making by health care institutions, physicians, families, and terminally ill patients, is particularly sensitive in discussions about legalization.
Annals of Internal MedicineVoluntary Death: A Comparison of Terminal Dehydration and Physician-Assisted Suicide
57 Citations1998Franklin G. Miller, Diane E. Meier
Clinical, ethical, and policy issues relating to terminal dehydration as an alternative to physician-assisted suicide are analyzed, building on the foundation laid in 1993 by Bernat and colleagues in their seminal article on patient refusal of hydration and nutrition.
Annals of Internal MedicineThe Debate over Physician-Assisted Suicide: Empirical Data and Convergent Views
56 Citations1998Timothy E. Quill, Diane E. Meier +2 more
Nursing EthicsThe Role of Nurses in Euthanasia: a Dutch study
55 Citations1998Ada van de Scheur, Arie van der Arend
A study to gain insight into the role of nurses in euthanasia was split up into four phases: observation of a request for euthanasia; decision making; carrying out of the request; and after-care.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Legalization of Physician-Assisted Suicide
53 Citations1996David Orentlicher
It is argued here that this interpretation of the recent events suggest that the distinction between the withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment and assisted suicide is being abandoned and that the law is undergoing a profound change.
PubMedOncology nurses' practices of assisted suicide and patient-requested euthanasia.
39 Citations1998Marianne Matzo, Ezekiel J. Emanual
Nurses in this study received fewer requests to perform euthanasia than physicians, but they performed patient-requested euthanasia four times more frequently than physicians.
New England Journal of MedicineEuthanasia and Nursing Practice — Right Question, Wrong Answer
36 Citations1996Colleen Scanlon
In an era of unprecedented technological progress and postponement of delay, assisted suicide and euthanasia has led to intense debate, controversy, and confusion.
Annals of Internal MedicineCare of the Dying: Clinical and Financial Lessons from the Oregon Experience
32 Citations1998Susan W. Tolle
Oregon's low rate of in-hospital deaths suggests the presence of a high level of advanced care planning and respect for patient wishes, and Quill and colleagues call for the increased use of hospice and palliative care in assuring comfort during terminal illness.
Nursing OutlookNurses' attitudes toward active euthanasia
31 Citations1995Anne J. Davis, Linda G. Phillips +4 more
Nurses have a responsibility to examine how they feel about euthanasia, about the processes available today for extending life, and whether their patients have a right to choose their own fate.
Regulating how we die : the ethical, medical, and legal issues surrounding physician-assisted suicide
27 Citations1998Linda L. Emanuel
The Bell Tolls for a Right to Suicide and The False Promise of Beneficent Killing are considered.
Gender, Feminism, and Death: Physician-Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia
24 Citations1996Susan M. Wolf
Philosophy and medicineHow Virtues Become Vices: Values, Medicine and Social Context
24 Citations1975Alasdair MacIntyre
I begin with three distinct groups of problems, each so urgent that the medical conscience ought to be — and indeed clearly is — haunted by them — and not only themedical conscience.
Journal of Legal MedicineRegulating how we die: The ethical, medical, and legal issues surrounding physician‐assisted suicide
20 Citations1999L J D Kathy Cerminara
Regulating how the authors die describes the ethical, medical, and legal issues surrounding physician‐assisted suicide as well as the political, legal, and social contexts in which these decisions are made.
Journal of the American Geriatrics SocietyPhysician‐Assisted Suicide in Alzheimer's Disease
17 Citations1997Stephen G. Post
It is concluded that caution in moving toward AD-PAS is necessary, and where PAS is legalized, it may be difficult to justify precluding people with AD from access.
Nursing EthicsRequests for Assisted Suicide: a nursing issue
14 Citations1998Beverly Kopala, Susan Lorraine Kennedy
The ethical, professional and legal issues to be considered by the nurses in the United States who are facing patients’ requests for assisted suicide are addressed.
Nursing EthicsAn Ethical Perspective on Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide in the Netherlands from a Nursing Point of View
14 Citations1998Arie JG van der Arend
In the Netherlands, euthanasia and assisted suicide are formally forbidden by criminal law, but, under certain strictly formulated conditions, physicians are excused for administering these to patients on the basis of necessity.
JAMAMedicine's Position Is Both Pivotal and Precarious in Assisted-Suicide Debate
13 Citations1995Paul Cotton
Assisted suicide involves "actively participating in the killing of a living, breathing, functioning, cognitive human being who has a terminal illness," says Thomas R. Reardon, MD, an internist in Portland, Ore.
Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public HealthNurses' attitudes to active voluntary euthanasia: a survey in the ACT
12 Citations1998Betty A. Kitchener
It appears that nurses are less in favour of AVE than the public, but more in favour than medical practitioners.
Journal of Gerontological NursingLEGALIZATION OF ASSISTED SUICIDE: A Pilot Study of Gerontological Nurses
9 Citations1998Joan Beder
Nurses in this pilot study were divided in their support of legalization of physician-assisted suicide for all ages but showed stronger support for legalization when applied to the elderly, and while supported conceptually, the actual practice of doctor- assisted suicide was not supported by many who were in favor of legalization.
The Journal of Law Medicine & EthicsProfessional Norms and Physician Attitudes Toward Euthanasia
8 Citations1994Thomas A. Preston
The chair of the ethics committee of a major medical center agonized over how he, as a physician, and his organization should deal with Initiative 119, which, if passed, would legalize physician involvement in active, voluntary euthanasia in Washington State.
Choice Reviews OnlinePhysician-assisted suicide
6 Citations1998Fred Rosner, P Rogatz +8 more
The Position Statement of the Committee onBioethical Issues of the Medical Society of the State ofNewYork indicates that physicians respect the principle of patient autonomy, which requires that Physicians respect the decision-making capacity to go life-sustaining treatment.
Physician-Assisted Suicide, Abortion, and Treatment Refusal: Using Gender to Analyze the Difference
4 Citations1997Susan M. Wolf
By analyzing the structure and central concerns of abortion rights and rights to refuse treatment, the chapter demonstrates flaws in the effort to build a right to physician assistance with suicide on those rights.
PubMedAttitudes of physicians regarding physician-assisted suicide.
4 Citations1995Michelle Reisner, Damato An
A survey of New Jersey physicians reveals no clear consensus as to whether physician-assisted suicide should be legalized, and most physicians stated that they would not participate in such activities where it is legal to do so.
DigitalGeorgetown (Georgetown University Library)Attitudes of Physicians Regarding Physician-Assisted Suicide
3 Citations1995Reisner, Michelle, Damato, Anthony N.