Pathology, Identity and the Social Construction of Alcohol Dependence
SociologyPublished 1 May 2001
Carl May
Citations56
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.50
SNIP2.59
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is argued that the difficulty that medicine faces in the case of the `addict' is not that addiction to alcohol has been medicalised, but rather that over a period of two centuries the medicalising project has been only partially successful.
Abstract
The notion of `addiction' appears to present profound and intractable difficulties for contemporary medicine. Using the problem of alcohol addiction as a mediating example, this paper examines some of the sources of these difficulties, and relates these to critiques of the medicalisation of the addictions. It is argued that the difficulty that medicine faces in the case of the `addict' is not that addiction to alcohol has been medicalised, but rather that over a period of two centuries the medicalising project has been only partially successful. Thus medical knowledge and practice have taken as their focus the problem of susceptibility, but made little headway in the domain of conceptualising recovery. In this context, the clinician is forced to divide the susceptible from the culpable in the diagnosis of addiction, and to explain this in terms of the potential for moral self-actualisation on the part of the addict.
Keywords
PsychologyArts and HumanitiesHealth Professions
Bloomsbury Academic eBooksCulture of Fear : Risk-taking and the Morality of Low Expectation
810 Citations1997
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorNaming and Framing: The Social Construction of Diagnosis and Illness
686 Citations1995Phil Brown
A typology of social construction, involving four combinations based on whether a condition is generally accepted and whether a biomedical definition is applied, is put forth, which detailed a series of stages in the social construction of a condition.
SociologyThe Disappearance of the Sick-Man from Medical Cosmology, 1770-1870
508 Citations1976Nick Jewson
The sick-man may be said to have disappeared from medical cosmology in two related senses during the period 1770-1870 as control over the means of production of medical knowledge shifted away from the sick towards medical investigators.
Edward Elgar Publishing eBooksThe sociology of mental health and illness
237 Citations2023Joan Busfield
Social Science & MedicineThe patient's view
218 Citations1984David Armstrong
It is argued that attempts to establish the authentic version of what the patient says is misplaced as investigation can only reveal what is heard, not what is said.
Social History of MedicineThe Social Construction of Medical Knowledge
133 Citations1995Ludmilla Jordanova
The paper examines some of the ways in which a social constructionist perspective may be useful for social historians of medicine and outlines the streams of thought that, over the last twenty years or so, have contributed to this perspective.
British Journal of AddictionThe Drinking Man's Disease: The ‘Pre‐History’ of Alcoholism in Georgian Britain
126 Citations1985Roy Porter
Drinking played an extremely important social role in eighteenth century England, and heavy drinking was considered manly, and Thomas Trotter was part of a continuing tradition, rather than the beginning of a new one.
British Journal of AddictionA Difficult Business: detecting and managing alcohol problems in general practice
123 Citations1986Betsy Thom, Carlos Téllez
Perceptions of general practitioners’ experiences of their experiences of diagnosing alcohol problems; their difficulties in offering the diagnosis to patients and the strategies they employ in attempting to do so; their attempts to offer help within general practice and their use of hospital services are reported.
Social Science & MedicinePsychosocial theory and the creation of the risky self
101 Citations1995Jane Ogden
This paper examines the transformation of individual identity in twentieth century psychological theory from the passive through to the interactive to the intra-active using models of behaviour, learning, beliefs, stress and pain.
Journal of Behavioral MedicineTrying to stop smoking: Effects of perceived addiction, attributions for failure, and expectancy of success
87 Citations1985J. Richard Eiser, J. van der Pligt +2 more
Sociology of Health & IllnessDoctors and dirty work—the case of alcoholism*
77 Citations1980Philip Strong
It is argued that, although all may be ignorant in some ways and a few are perhaps prejudiced, there are nevertheless other and quite rational grounds for their general avoidance of alcoholics.
Oxford University Press eBooksThe Transformation of Intimacy
61 Citations2017John Tulloch, Belinda Middleweek
Social Science & MedicineMedical knowledge and the intractable patient: the case of chronic low back pain
60 Citations1999Carl May, Helen Doyle +1 more
It is pointed to the extent to which the disparity between expressed symptoms, pathological signs and perceived disability in CLBP has led to the moral character of the sufferer forming a constant subtext to medical discourse about the condition.
International Journal of Health ServicesSpinning on its Axes: DSM and the Social Construction of Psychiatric Diagnosis
56 Citations1998Elizabeth C. Cooksey, Phil Brown
It is concluded that working solely within the confines of a medical framework of diagnosis, with little attention to the wider social and cultural contexts that should surround diagnostic practice, psychiatry will be unable to understand and explain the changing needs of its clientele.
JAMAAn Essay, Medical, Philosophical, and Chemical on Drunkenness and Its Effects on the Human Body
53 Citations1990Donald W. Goodwin
In 1804, the Scottish physician Thomas Trotter declared that drunkenness was a disease, and his book was partly responsible, one of those pivotal works that influence generations to come, often without the generations knowing the history of the influence.
Social History of MedicineThe Early Discovery of Freud by the British General Educated Public, 1912–1919
53 Citations1990Dean Rapp
Journal of Health CommunicationShared Ideology in Alcoholics Anonymous: A Grounded Theory Approach
42 Citations1997KEVIN B. W RIGHT
Ground theory is used to explore the shared ideology espoused in Alcoholics Anonymous, specifically the nature and role of shared ideology in increasing the efficacy of the recovery process, and the features of the group's tenets and meetings that help facilitate members' indoctrination.
Current Opinion in PsychiatryHistory of psychiatry
37 Citations2008Edward Shorter
The present review examines recent contributions to the evolving field of historical writing in psychiatry with an increasing emphasis on topics of current interest such as the history of psychopharmacology, electroconvulsive therapy, and the interplay between psychiatry and society.
Drug and Alcohol DependenceGeneral practice involvement in the management of alcohol misuse: dynamics and resistances
36 Citations1994Mary Alison Durand
While there is a growing body of empirical evidence to suggest that the types of interventions which General Practitioners could offer patients with potential or established alcohol problems are effective, there are still many barriers to the treatment of alcohol problems in the primary care setting.
Journal of Studies on AlcoholThe origins and evolution of the disease concept of treatment.
31 Citations1998Daniel L. Yalisove
It was found that all of the current types of alcoholism treatment programs had their origins in early, informal AA facilities except for outpatient alcoholism clinics, and DCT evolved concurrently in AA facilities, state mental hospitals and detoxification units.
Addiction ResearchGateway to Nowhere: How Alcohol Came to be Scapegoated for Drug Abuse
28 Citations1997Stanton Peele, Archie Brodsky
Pharmacology & TherapeuticsPharmacology versus Social Process
26 Citations1998John B. Davies
A better understanding of the nature of addiction requires a clearer distinction between the pharmacological/physiological approach and the social process/cognitive approach, as both approaches contribute usefully to knowledge and have predictive value.
Growing up with Alcohol
25 Citations2005Emma Fossey
The study questions the effectiveness of past alcohol education and argues strongly that future initiatives should develop innovative and user-friendly alcohol education materials for use in primary as will as in secondary schools and colleges.
Sociology of Health & IllnessConstructing addiction as a moral failing
22 Citations1986Geoffrey Harding
Economy and SocietyBetween social and organic norms: reading Canguilhem and ‘somatization’
21 Citations1998Monica Greco
Addiction ResearchHabitual Drunkards and the Invention of Alcoholism: Susceptibility and Culpability in Nineteenth Century Medicine
13 Citations1997Carl May
An historical perspective is sketched out for contemporary problems in disentangling the relationship between culpability and susceptibility in alcohol dependence by examining the formulation of medical and moral models of habitual drunkenness during the nineteenth century.
Economy and SocietyMedicine and ideology
12 Citations1998Thomas Osborne
It is argued that there are senses in which modern medical rationality is driven by impulses that might – so long as the authors modify some of their traditional preconceptions about the concept – be described as ideological.
Journal of the Royal Society of MedicineLord Moran's Memoir: Shell-Shock and the Pathology of Fear
10 Citations1998Carl May
Charles (later Lord) Moran's memoir is used to explore the tensions between social judgments about culpability and clinical assessments of susceptibility in the medical analysis of a new illness, 'shell shock' or 'war strain'; and to examine the way in which these tensions shifted the definition of courage itself.
Making Doctors
10 Citations2020Simon Sinclair
Journal of Studies on AlcoholLiberating Solutions to Alcohol Problems: Treating Problem Drinkers without Saying No
8 Citations1996Frederick Rotgers
Addiction ResearchShared Care Methadone Clinics a Survey of Patient Satisfaction Behaviour Change and Staff Views
7 Citations1999Mark Gabbay, Sinead Clarke +2 more
It is concluded that shared care opiate misuse clinics provide popular and effective services.
Drugs & SocietyThe Disease Theory of Alcoholism from an Interactionist Perspective:
5 Citations1987Stanton Peele
A body of information about the disease nature of alcoholism is almost universally accepted in contemporary America but actual epidemiological, laboratory, and clinical research contradicts popular assertions about alcoholism by showing them to be overly schematic and to deny drikning's role within the person-environment interaction.
Addiction ResearchControl Policies and Youthful Alcohol Misuse: Effecting Normative Change?
2 Citations1993Carl May
A review is presented of preventative policies, and it is argued that those which impact on the structure of alcohol use, rather than on individual attitudes or values, have a demonstrably greater degree of success.