Positive Psychology in Cancer Care: A Story Line Resistant to Evidence
Annals of Behavioral MedicinePublished 1 February 2010Open access
James C. Coyne, Howard Tennen, Adelita V. Ranchor
Citations113
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.49
SNIP1.30
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Positive psychology’s interpretations of the literature regarding positive psychological states and cancer outcomes represent a self-perpetuating story line without empirical support.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Aspinwall and Tedeschi (Ann Behav Med, 2010) summarize evidence they view as supporting links between positive psychological states, including sense of coherence (SOC) and optimism and health outcomes, and they refer to persistent assumptions that interfere with understanding how positive states predict health. PURPOSE: We critically evaluate Aspinwall and Tedeschi's assertions. METHODS: We examine evidence related to SOC and optimism in relation to physical health, and revisit proposed processes linking positive psychological states to health outcomes, particularly via the immune system in cancer. RESULTS: Aspinwall and Tedeschi's assumptions regarding SOC and optimism are at odds with available evidence. Proposed pathways between positive psychological states and cancer outcomes are not supported by existing data. Aspinwall and Tedeschi's portrayal of persistent interfering assumptions echoes a disregard of precedent in the broader positive psychology literature. CONCLUSION: Positive psychology's interpretations of the literature regarding positive psychological states and cancer outcomes represent a self-perpetuating story line without empirical support.
Keywords
PsychologyHealth Professions
Handbook of Positive Psychology
9,096 Citations2001
New England Journal of MedicineTrastuzumab plus Adjuvant Chemotherapy for Operable HER2-Positive Breast Cancer
5,353 Citations2005Edward H. Romond, Edith A. Perez +23 more
Tastuzumab combined with paclitaxel after doxorubicin and cyclophosphamide improves outcomes among women with surgically removed HER2-positive breast cancer.
The LancetTamoxifen for early breast cancer: an overview of the randomised trials
4,105 Citations1998Early Breast Cancer Tr.group, -, Klijn, Jan
The absolute improvement in recurrence was greater during the first 5 years, whereas the improvement in survival grew steadily larger throughout the first 10 years, and these benefits appeared to be largely irrespective of age, menopausal status, daily tamoxifen dose, and of whether chemotherapy had been given to both groups.
Authentic Happiness: Using the New Positive Psychology to Realize Your Potential for Lasting Fulfillment
3,969 Citations2002Martin E. P. Seligman
Borderline Conditions and Pathological Narcissism
2,881 Citations1995Otto F. Kernberg
PubMedPolychemotherapy for early breast cancer: an overview of the randomised trials. Early Breast Cancer Trialists' Collaborative Group.
2,156 Citations1998C. Focan, S. M. Steinberg +225 more
Psychological BulletinDoes positive affect influence health?
2,080 Citations2005Sarah D. Pressman, Sheldon Cohen
This review highlights consistent patterns in the literature associating positive affect (PA) and physical health and raises serious conceptual and methodological reservations, but suggests an association of trait PA and lower morbidity and of state and traitPA and decreased symptoms and pain.
Psychosomatic MedicinePositive Psychological Well-Being and Mortality: A Quantitative Review of Prospective Observational Studies
1,566 Citations2008Yoichi Chida, Andrew Steptoe
Positive psychological well-being was significantly associated with reduced cardiovascular mortality in healthy population studies, and with reduced death rates in patients with renal failure and with human immunodeficiency virus-infection.
Through Paediatrics to Psychoanalysis
1,074 Citations2018Donald W. Winnicott, M. Masud R. Khan
This book is not concerned with innovation in basic psychoanalytic concepts or techniques, but with the formulation and testing-out of ideas whose origin was in the challenge of day-to-day clinical work that was the staple of Winnicott's medical experience throughout his professional life.
PubMedTamoxifen for early breast cancer: an overview of the randomised trials. Early Breast Cancer Trialists' Collaborative Group.
903 Citations1998Early Breast Cancer Trialists' Collaborative Group (EBCTCG), Anthony Howell
The absolute improvement in recurrence was greater during the first 5 years, whereas the improvement in survival grew steadily larger throughout the first 10 years, and these benefits appeared to be largely irrespective of age, menopausal status, daily tamoxifen dose and of whether chemotherapy had been given to both groups.
Annals of Behavioral MedicineOptimism and Physical Health: A Meta-analytic Review
765 Citations2009Heather N. Rasmussen, Michael F. Scheier +1 more
Optimism is a major predictor of positive physical health outcomes and a significant predictor of health outcomes or markers according to objective measures of physical health.
Journal of Psychosomatic ResearchThrough paediatrics to psychoanalysis
576 Citations1993Mark Berelowitz
BMJData dredging, bias, or confounding
496 Citations2002George Davey Smith, Shah Ebrahim
On 4 October 2002, women who were moderate drinkers received good news: their risk of breast cancer was not raised, according to a report in the Lancet, but on 13 November the message was reversed: alcohol did increase the risk of Breast cancer after all, but smoking was declared innocent.
CirculationOptimism, Cynical Hostility, and Incident Coronary Heart Disease and Mortality in the Women’s Health Initiative
481 Citations2009Hilary A. Tindle, Yue‐Fang Chang +6 more
Optimism and cynical hostility are independently associated with important health outcomes in black and white women and future research should examine whether interventions designed to change attitudes would lead to altered risk.
History of the Idea of Progress
366 Citations2017Robert Nisbet
Social Science & MedicineSome conceptual considerations on the sense of coherence
296 Citations1997Siegfried Geyer
Some aspects of SOC that have not sufficiently been considered in the SOC literature are discussed and directions for further research are proposed.
Gedrag & OrganisatieBright-sided. How the relentless promotion of positive thinking has undermined America
281 Citations2010Petra Verdonk, Inge Houkes
Annals of Behavioral MedicinePositive Psychology in Cancer Care: Bad Science, Exaggerated Claims, and Unproven Medicine
270 Citations2010James C. Coyne, Howard Tennen
The incoherence of claims about the adaptational value of benefit finding and post-traumatic growth among cancer patients, and the implausibility of claims that interventions that enhance benefit finding improve the prognosis of cancer patients by strengthening the immune system are noted.
Annals of Behavioral MedicineThe Value of Positive Psychology for Health Psychology: Progress and Pitfalls in Examining the Relation of Positive Phenomena to Health
254 Citations2010Lisa G. Aspinwall, Richard G. Tedeschi
This article considers research on optimism, sense of coherence, and posttraumatic growth that predates the contemporary emphasis on positive psychology, but has clear and increasingly well-supported connections to health psychology and examines several potential mechanisms through which such positive phenomena may influence the etiology, progression, and management of illness.
American Journal of EpidemiologySense of Coherence and Mortality in Men and Women in the EPIC-Norfolk United Kingdom Prospective Cohort Study
251 Citations2003P. G. Surtees
Results suggest that a strong sense of coherence may confer some resilience to the risk of chronic disease, independent of age, sex, and prevalent chronic disease.
Journal of Clinical OncologyDispositional Optimism Predicts Survival Status 1 Year After Diagnosis in Head and Neck Cancer Patients
215 Citations2003Paul Allison, Christophe Guichard +2 more
The results of this study of a cohort of French H&N cancer patients indicate that dispositional optimism predicts 1-year survival independent of other sociodemographic and clinical variables.
The OncologistFacts and Controversies in Systemic Treatment of Metastatic Breast Cancer
177 Citations2004Chantal Bernard-Marty, Fátima Cardoso +1 more
The potential role of tumor molecular profile(s) in the selection of patients that could benefit the most from each strategy/agent will be discussed and the current knowledge and controversial issues related to systemic therapy of metastatic breast cancer will be summarized.
Military PsychologyRelevance of Hardiness Assessment and Training to the Military Context
160 Citations2007Salvatore R. Maddi
Psychological BulletinPsychotherapy and survival in cancer: The conflict between hope and evidence.
139 Citations2007James C. Coyne, Michael Stefanek +1 more
A systematic critical review of the relevant literature concludes that an adequately powered study examining effects of psychotherapy on survival after a diagnosis of cancer would require resources that are not justified by the strength of the available evidence.
Sociology of Health & IllnessSporting cancer: struggle language in news reports of people with cancer
119 Citations2001Clive Seale
The History of Positive Psychology: Truth Be Told
104 Citations2004Jeffrey J. Froh
Social Science & MedicineComparing sense of coherence, depressive symptoms and anxiety, and their relationships with health in a population-based study
96 Citations2008Hanna Konttinen, Ari Haukkala +1 more
The size of the overlap between the SOC and depression scales was the same as between depression and anxiety measures, indicating that future studies should examine the discriminant validity of different psychosocial scales more closely, and should compare them in health research in order to bring parallel concepts into the same scientific discussion.
Military PsychologyThe Need for Positive Meaning in Military Operations: Reflections on Abu Ghraib
81 Citations2005Paul T. Bartone
The Scientific World JOURNALWhy is Antonovsky's sense of coherence not correlated to physical health? Analysing Antonovsky's 29-item sense of coherence scale (SOC-29)
78 Citations2005Trine Flensborg‐Madsen, Søren Ventegodt +1 more
Whether the questions in the SOC scale actually represent the universe of factors necessary to describe the phenomenon of SOC, which is an important supplement to the statistically means of investigating validity and reliability, is analyzed.
American Psychological Association eBooksMedical illness and positive life change: Can crisis lead to personal transformation?
73 Citations2009
This book focuses on how positive life change might be fostered in the context of medical illness and draws out implications for research and clinical practice.
CancerEmotional well‐being does not predict survival in head and neck cancer patients
67 Citations2007James C. Coyne, Thomas F. Pajak +5 more
The objective of the current study was to examine whether emotional well‐being predicted survival in a large sample of patients with head and neck cancer who were participating in multicenter clinical trials.
CancerFinding what is not there
53 Citations2009Michael Stefanek, Steven C. Palmer +2 more
It is argued that much needs to be learned at the more basic biobehavioral level about the impact of stress or psychological factors on tumor biology before even considering whether large clinical trials are warranted and detracts from the potential significant benefits of psychological interventions related to quality of life.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthDo different scales measure the same construct? Three Sense of Coherence scales: Table 1
51 Citations2008Martin Olsson, Jan Gassne +1 more
Two versions of Antonovsky’s original scale (SOC-13 and SOC-29), translated into Swedish, and a three-item scale that claims to measure Sense of Coherence are compared.
Journal of Psychosomatic ResearchThe sense of coherence and incidence of cancer—role of follow-up time and age at baseline
51 Citations2006Esko Poppius, Hanna Virkkunen +2 more
A strong SOC seemed to delay the onset of cancer more clearly among men over 55 years of age, and the length of the follow-up in that association was extended.
The Future of Positive Psychology; A Declaration of Independence
35 Citations2001
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthThe sense of coherence and risk of injuries: role of alcohol consumption and occupation
15 Citations2007Esko Poppius, Hanna Virkkunen +2 more
There was an effect of SOC on the incidence of injury especially among blue collar workers, and a substantial part of the effect was mediated by alcohol consumption.