Costs and benefits of community postnatal support workers: a randomised controlled trial.
Health Technology AssessmentPublished 1 January 2000Open access
C Jane Morrell, Helen Spiby, Paul W. Stewart, Stephen J. Walters, Anne Morgan
Citations166
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.36
SNIP1.69
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Although women valued the service, there was no evidence of any health benefit at the 6-week or 6-month follow-up, no difference in use of NHS services, and the additional cost of the service provision would be around pound 180 per woman.
Abstract
Although women valued the service, there was no evidence of any health benefit at the 6-week or 6-month follow-up, no difference in use of NHS services, and the additional cost of the service provision would be around pound 180 per woman.
Keywords
Medicine
An Introduction to the Bootstrap
39,744 Citations1994Bradley Efron, Robert Tibshirani
PubMedThe MOS 36-item short-form health survey (SF-36). I. Conceptual framework and item selection.
33,975 Citations1992John E. Ware, Cathy D. Sherbourne
A 36-item short-form survey designed for use in clinical practice and research, health policy evaluations, and general population surveys to survey health status in the Medical Outcomes Study is constructed.
The British Journal of PsychiatryDetection of Postnatal Depression
13,913 Citations1987J. L. Cox, Joan Holden +1 more
The development of a 10-item self-report scale (EPDS) to screen for Postnatal Depression in the community was found to have satisfactory sensitivity and specficity, and was also sensitive to change in the severity of depression over time.
ScienceSocial Relationships and Health
7,039 Citations1988James S. House, Karl R. Landis +1 more
Experimental and quasi-experimental studies suggest that social isolation is a major risk factor for mortality from widely varying causes and the mechanisms through which social relationships affect health remain to be explored.
Psychosomatic MedicineSocial Support as a Moderator of Life Stress
6,764 Citations1976Sidney Cobb
It appears that social support can protect people in crisis from a wide variety of pathological states: from low birth weight to death, from arthritis through tuberculosis to depression, alcoholism, and the social breakdown syndrome.
Medical CareThe MOS 36-Item Short-Form Health Survey (SF-36)
6,672 Citations1993Colleen A. McHorney, WARE JOHNE +1 more
Cross-sectional data from the Medical Outcomes Study were analyzed to test the validity of the MOS 36-Item Short-Form Health Survey (SF-36) scales as measures of physical and mental health constructs and found the social functioning, vitality, and general health perceptions scales had the most complex interpretation.
BMJValidating the SF-36 health survey questionnaire: new outcome measure for primary care.
4,682 Citations1992John Brazier, Robert A. Harper +5 more
The SF-36 was able to detect low levels of ill health in patients who had scored 0 (good health) on the Nottingham health profile and is a promising new instrument for measuring health perception in a general population.
Methods for the Economic Evaluation of Health Care Programmes
4,559 Citations2005Michael E Drummond, Mark J Sculpher +3 more
Medical CareThe Duke???UNC Functional Social Support Questionnaire
1,291 Citations1988W E Broadhead, Stephen H. Gehlbach +2 more
Factor analysis and correlations with other measures of social support suggest that the three remaining items (visits, instrumental support, and praise) are distinct entities that may need further study.
Journal of Child Psychology and PsychiatryThe Impact of Postnatal Depression on Infant Development
1,102 Citations1992Lynne Murray
Postnatal depression had no effect on general cognitive and language development, but appeared to make infants more vulnerable to adverse effects of lower social class and male gender.
International Journal of EpidemiologyThe use of fractional polynomials to model continuous risk variables in epidemiology
1,084 Citations1999Patrick Royston, Gareth Ambler +1 more
An approach based on transformation and fractional polynomials which yields simple regression models with interpretable curves is proposed and shows that non-linear risk models fit the data better than linear models.
The British Journal of PsychiatryThe Validation of the Edinburgh Post-natal Depression Scale on a Community Sample
900 Citations1990Lynne Murray, Andrew D. Carothers
The Edinburgh Post-natal Depression Scale was validated on a community sample of 702 women at six weeks post-partum using Research Diagnostic Criteria for depression to offer improved guidelines for the use of the EPDS by the primary care team.
American Journal of EpidemiologyPSYCHOSOCIAL ASSETS, LIFE CRISIS AND THE PROGNOSIS OF PREGNANCY12
810 Citations1972Katherine B. Nuckolls, John C. Cassel +1 more
Quality of Life ResearchTesting the validity of the Euroqol and comparing it with the SF-36 health survey questionnaire
708 Citations1993John Brazier, Norman Jones +1 more
Testing a recent example of a general health measure designed to derive a single index, the Euroqol (EQ), and a comparison with a new, influential profile measure, the Short Form 36 (SF-36) Health Survey Instrument are presented.
The British Journal of PsychiatryLife Events and Social Support in Puerperal Depression
689 Citations1980Eugene S. Paykel, E. M. Emms +2 more
The findings indicate the importance of social stress in puerperal depression, and postpartum blues were only associated with depression in the absence of life events, suggesting a small hormonal sub-group.
The British Journal of Psychiatry“Atypical” Depression Following Childbirth
612 Citations1968Brice Pitt
BMJImpact of maternal postnatal depression on cognitive development of young children.
582 Citations1986S. R. Cogill, Hyman Caplan +3 more
Marital conflict and a history of paternal psychiatric problems were independently linked with lower cognitive test scores and together with a working class home background these were the only factors that contributed to the deleterious effect of maternal postnatal depression.
Journal of Abnormal PsychologyControlled prospective study of postpartum mood disorders: Comparison of childbearing and nonchildbearing women.
547 Citations1990Michael W. O’Hara, Ellen M. Zekoski +2 more
There were no differences between CB and NCB Ss with respect to rates of minor and major depression during pregnancy or after delivery, however, CB women experienced significantly higher levels of depressive symptomatology and poor social adjustment than NCB women during late pregnancy and the early puerperium.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Effect of a Supportive Companion on Perinatal Problems, Length of Labor, and Mother-Infant Interaction
452 Citations1980Roberto Sosa, John H. Kennell +3 more
There may be major perinatal benefits of constant human support during labor, and mothers who had a doula present during labor were awake more after delivery and smiled at, stroked, and talked to their babies more than the control mothers.
BMJWest Berkshire perineal management trial.
428 Citations1984Jennifer Sleep, Adrian Grant +4 more
Findings provide little support either for liberal use of episiotomy or for claims that reduced use of the operation decreases postpartum morbidity.
BMJEffects of social support during parturition on maternal and infant morbidity.
275 Citations1986M. Klaus, John H. Kennell +2 more
It is suggested that constant human support may be of great benefit to women during labour and that women who have supportive female companions throughout labour have significantly fewer perinatal complications.
The British Journal of PsychiatryPrevalence of Postnatal Psychiatric Morbidity in Mothers and Fathers
274 Citations1994Clive Ballard, Robert G. Davis +3 more
The hypothesis that different aetiological factors would be important in brief and persistent disorders in mothers was upheld and mothers had a significantly higher prevalence of psychiatric ‘caseness’ at both six weeks and six months postpartum than fathers.
BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics & GynaecologySocial support and pregnancy outcome
255 Citations1990Ann Oakley, Lynda Rajan +1 more
Intervention group mothers and babies were significantly healthier in the early weeks than those in the control group as judged by reported physical and psychosocial health and use of health services.
BMJEvaluation of a stroke family care worker: results of a randomised controlled trial
231 Citations1997Martin Dennis, Suzanne O’Rourke +3 more
The introduction of a stroke family care worker improved patients' and their carers' satisfaction with services and may have had some effect on psychological and social outcomes but did not improve measures of patients' physical wellbeing.
The LancetRandomised, controlled trial of efficacy of midwife-managed care
230 Citations1996Deborah Tumbull, Ann Holmes +10 more
It is concluded that midwife-managed care for healthy women, integrated within existing services, is clinically effective and enhances women's satisfaction with maternity care.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyPregnancy, breast feeding, and oral contraceptives and the risk of epithelial ovarian cancer
216 Citations1990Marta Gwinn, Nancy C. Lee +3 more
A marked reduction in risk was associated with ever having breast fed or used oral contraceptives, while the decrease in risk from additional months of either of these exposures was less than that for pregnancy.
BMJEpidural anaesthesia and long term backache after childbirth.
199 Citations1990Christine MacArthur, Michael B. Lewis +2 more
A significant association was found between backache and epidural anaesthesia and it seems to result from a combination of effective analgesia and stressed posture during labour, which is probably causal.
Journal of Community PsychologySocial support in the transition to parenthood
186 Citations1980Lois Pall Wandersman, Abraham Wandersman +1 more
BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics & GynaecologyEffects of psychosocial support during labour and childbirth on breastfeeding, medical interventions, and mothers' wellbeing in a Mexican public hospital: a randomised clinical trial
180 Citations1998Ana Langer, Lourdes Campero +2 more
The effects of psychosocial support during labour, delivery and the immediate postpartum period provided by a female companion (doula) are evaluated.
Social Science & MedicineThe measurement of social support in population surveys
173 Citations1987Kristina Orth‐Gomér, Anna‐Lena Undén
Social support instruments, which were potentially applicable in population studies, were reviewed and their conceptual framework, their reported predictive capacity and their psychometric properties were compiled and systematically compared.
The British Journal of PsychiatryMaternal Depression and the Emotional Development of the Child
159 Citations1989Hyman Caplan, S. R. Cogill +4 more
Children who scored below average on the McCarthy scales of cognitive abilities were reported by their mothers to have more behavioural problems, but the children's behavioural difficulties at four showed no clear links with postnatal depression.
Health Professions and the State in Europe
148 Citations2005
This chapter discusses the changing response of the Medical Profession to Alternative Medicine in Britain and the role of governmentality and the Institutionalization of Expertise in this profession.
The Medical Journal of AustraliaIncreased risk of postnatal depression after emergency caesarean section
146 Citations1992Philip Boyce, Angela Todd
To examine whether women having an emergency caesarean section are at increased risk of developing postnatal depression at one, three and six months postpartum, a large number of women have had the operation.
MidwiferyWhat influences the uptake and early cessation of breast feeding?
123 Citations1998Debra Bick, Christine MacArthur +1 more
Examining obstetric, maternal and social factors associated with the uptake and early cessation of breast feeding and women's reasons for altering from breast to bottle feeding found factors within the woman's social environment were found to influence early cessation.
BirthVolunteer Peer Counselors Increase Breastfeeding Duration Among Rural Low‐Income Women
121 Citations1998Elisabeth Schäfer, Mary Kay Vogel +2 more
A volunteer peer counseling program that provides low-income women with role models, accurate information, support, and encouragement can increase the duration of breastfeeding, and thus contribute to healthier infants.
BirthWhat Determines Quality in Maternity Care? Comparing the Perceptions of Childbearing Women and Midwives
119 Citations1998Sue Proctor
An understanding of the concerns of women by maternity care staff is important in the development of a woman-focused service, in line with current policy recommendations, and has implications for risk management and improving the service quality for those who provide and experience the service.
Social Science & MedicineA comparison of social support variables between women who intend to breast or bottle feed
117 Citations1992J. Renee Matich, Laura S. Sims
Predictors such as level of education, a belief that breastfeeding was better for health and emotional closeness, fewer children, moderate tangible and emotional support and more informational support were identified for women who intended to breastfeed.
BMJLong term backache after childbirth: prospective search for causative factors
110 Citations1996Robin Russell, Ruth Dundas +1 more
The use of epidural analgesia in labour had no effect on the incidence of postpartum backache and motor block resulting from epidural local anaesthetic administration was not a significant factor in the development of backache.
BMJSocial adversity and perinatal complications: their relation to postnatal depression.
104 Citations1989Alan Stein, Peter Cooper +3 more
Electrophysiological elicitation of the bulbocavernosus reflex showed a normal latency of 26 ms to the onset of response, and computerised analyses of both dorsal and cavernosal arterial Doppler waveforms, recorded during the tumescent phase, proved normal, thus there was no evidence of penile haemodynamic disturbance.
Arteriosclerosis Thrombosis and Vascular BiologyAortic Aneurysm Diameter and Risk of Cardiovascular Mortality
104 Citations2001Tony Brady, F.G.R. Fowkes +2 more
The significant association between aortic diameter and cardiovascular mortality, excluding aneurysm-related deaths, suggests that aneurYSm diameter is an independent marker of cardiovascular disease risk.
Journal of Reproductive and Infant PsychologySocial support in pregnancy: Does it have long-term effects?
96 Citations1996Ann Oakley, Deborah Hickey +2 more
The results confirm the health-promoting effect of social support, and the importance of providing supportive care within the routine maternity services, not only as a means to improve wo...
BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics & GynaecologyA randomized controlled trial of the provision of a social support service during pregnancy: the South Manchester Family Worker Project
95 Citations1989Brenda Spencer, Helen Thomas +1 more
Early Human DevelopmentGastroenteritis, diarrhoea and breast feeding
89 Citations1997Jean Golding, Pauline Emmett +1 more
It is shown that in the developed as well as the developing world, there is consistent evidence of a protective effect of exclusive breast feeding in the first 4-6 months of life.
Journal of Biosocial ScienceFactors influencing the duration of breast-feeding
80 Citations1980Christine P. West
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsReactions to Motherhood: The Role of Postnatal Care
63 Citations1988Ralph LaRossa, Jean A. Ball
Health EconomicsThe use of condition specific outcome measures in economic appraisal
57 Citations1995John Brazier, Simon Dixon
The potential uses of CSOMs in economics are examined, namely: to provide valid descriptive material, to provide scales for comparing the effectiveness of interventions and to 'validate' the descriptive accuracy of economic measures of benefit.
MidwiferyThe misery of motherhood: alternative approaches to maternal distress
56 Citations1996Lesley Barclay, Beverly Lloyd
This paper was developed from a presentation delivered to the Marce Society Pacific Rim Conference, Childbearing and mental health: risks and remedies, and questions the appropriateness of extending the psychiatric model to the psychological and social changes inherent in parenting.
British Journal of MidwiferyThe extent, severity and effect of health problems after childbirth
56 Citations1995Debra Bick, Christine MacArthur
This article shows, for the first time, the extent, severity and effect of health problems experienced after childbirth and confirms the findings of earlier studies with regard to the high levels of morbidity persisting after birth.
Journal of the Royal Society of MedicineEvaluation of a Home Visiting and Befriending Scheme for Young Mothers: Newpin
53 Citations1991A. D. Cox, Andrea Pound +3 more
Newpin recruits, whether befrienders or befriended had high rates of adverse early experiences, but depression was more common amongst those referred for befriending, and those that did sustain involvement in the scheme were more likely to have had training as volunteers and mental health problems of more than 2 years' duration.
PubMedMothers' moods and social support when a second child is born.
51 Citations1995Laurie N. Gottlieb, Morton J. Mendelson
A short-term longitudinal correlational study to determine second-time mothers' moods relative to dimensions of support, stress, and timing of support and found depressed, angry, and/or tired mothers reported inappropriate amounts of support.
Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic & Neonatal NursingNurse-Managed Postpartum Home Care
48 Citations1993Lenore R. Williams, Mary Koechley Cooper
Outcomes of the home-centered postpartum recovery program are described in terms of type and frequency of nursing diagnoses found on home visits, readmission rates, cost savings, and consumer satisfaction.
Child Care Health and DevelopmentThe influence of additional information, advice and support on the success of breast feeding in working class primiparas
44 Citations1988Sue Jenner
There was a significant difference between the two groups in level of breast feeding success, and explanations for this effect are put forward in terms of the experimental intervention components.
BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics & GynaecologyHow does the mode of delivery affect the cost of maternity care?
43 Citations1991Liane Clark, Miranda Mugford +1 more
International Journal of Nursing StudiesThe profession of maternity home care assistant and its significance for the Dutch midwifery profession
41 Citations1990Edwin van Teijlingen
Maternity home care assistants in the Netherlands assist the midwife (or GP) during the delivery, help and advise the new mother with the baby during the postnatal period at home and enables pregnant women to consider giving birth at home or during a short-stay hospital delivery.
BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics & GynaecologyAn economic evaluation of daycare in the management of hypertension in pregnancy
34 Citations1992Sara Twaddle, Valerie Harper
Evaluating the efficiency of daycare in the management of hypertension in pregnancy compared with inpatient management with prior domiciliary visits to find out if it reduces the need for inpatient treatment.
Journal of Public HealthIs antenatal care apportioned according to obstetric risk? The Scottish antenatal care study
33 Citations1994Janet Tucker, C D Florey +3 more
In all types of hospital, high-risk women and those who changed to high risk were more likely to have hospital admission than those who continued as low risk and significantly more women in the high- risk categories experienced adverse pregnancy outcomes than women who continued at low risk.
Journal of Public HealthEpisiotomy and perineal tears in low-risk UK primigravidae
33 Citations1998Fiona Williams, C D Florey +2 more
The rates of episiotomy in women from the Indian sub-continent and Orient were very high compared with those for white women, and this requires clarification and explanation, as they are contrary to rates experienced in these ethnic groups in other countries.
Journal of Health Services Research & PolicyThe Costs of Alternative Types of Routine Antenatal Care for Low-Risk Women: Shared Care Vs Care by General Practitioners and Community Midwives
32 Citations1996Julie Ratcliffe, Mandy Ryan +1 more
GP/midwife antenatal care is a satisfactory option for low-risk pregnant women in Scotland provided that clinical outcomes and women's satisfaction are at least the same as those of women with shared care.
PubMedSocial isolation and support in pregnancy loss.
29 Citations1994LiteratureC Rajan
It is revealed that many of the women experienced social isolation and did not receive the support they needed from partners, relatives, friends and health professionals.
PubMedDo breast feeding mothers get the home support they need?
28 Citations1981Houston Mj, Howie Pw +2 more
It was possible to achieve a very high degree of successful breast feeding with the provision of consistent home support with the support of midwifery sisters and the effect of social class was shown by a progressive decline in continuation rates down the gradient ofsocial class.
MidwiferyAn evaluation of postnatal care individualised to the needs of the woman
26 Citations1993Sara Twaddle, Xiao Hui Liao +1 more
Assessment of the effects of introducing individualised postnatal care at Glasgow Royal Maternity Hospital found continuity of care was improved with individualising care to the needs of the woman and women were satisfied with this type of care.
PubMedSupport behaviors identified as helpful and desired by second-time parents over the perinatal period.
26 Citations1989Jordan Pl
The purpose of this secondary analysis was to describe the types of social support and the specific behaviors identified as helpful or desired by mothers and fathers having a second child.
MidwiferyBarriers to breast feeding: Choice of feeding method in a sample of working class primiparae
24 Citations1985James McIntosh
It is argued that the relatively low incidence and early discontinuation of breast feeding in this group of mothers is not so much a product of negative attitudes than of practical constraints and inadequate support.
MidwiferyThe profession of midwife in the Netherlands
23 Citations1987Edwin van Teijlingen, Peter McCaffery
The Dutch system, giving midwives a high degree of responsibility and of financial independence, can give rise to tensions between midwives and obstetricians, but limits unnecessary medicalisation of childbirth.
Health Care For Women InternationalSocial support and the transition to the maternal role
22 Citations1987JANICE L. MAJEWSKI
Mothers who attended a parent support group tended to have more difficulty in making the transition to the maternal role than those who did not, and those who identified nonimmediate family members as most supportive showed more difficulties inMaking the transition.
British Journal of MidwiferyThe costs to the NHS of maternity care: midwife-managed vs shared
19 Citations1997Denise Young, Sara Twaddle +1 more
The main outcome measures were the costs to the NHS of providing the two alternative types of maternity care and the cost of midwife-managed care and shared care.
PubMedIntention and reality in infant feeding.
18 Citations1994Kamila Hawthorne
Women who gave later first feeds, or who were offered supplementary feeds in the postnatal ward, were more likely to be bottlefeeding at eight weeks, and hospital stays of less than 24 hours were strongly associated with successful feeding.
Journal of Advanced NursingPatient satisfaction with home‐birth care in The Netherlands
17 Citations1994Jan J. Kerssens
The patient perspective of maternity home care is acknowledged in order to contribute to its organization and it is relatively inexpensive and contributes to the satisfaction of recipients.
BMJRelative costs of home and hospital confinement.
17 Citations1979John Stilwell
The first study in a series concerned with the costs of different strategies of maternity care showed the differences between the cost of booked confinement at home, in a GP hospital for 48 hours, and in a consultant obstetric unit for 48Hours to be small.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyMidwifery teams and caseloads
17 Citations1993C Flint
Community based teams Duty rotas Hospital teams Team building Disadvantages and hurdles Use of health care assistants within the NHS Independent midwives in partnership Birth Centre Conclusions References Index.
MidwiferyInfant feeding practice in mothers at risk of low birth weight delivery
16 Citations1990Lynda Rajan, Ann Oakley
It is suggested that improved social support from health professionals and others in the postnatal period can increase breast feeding success rates.
British Journal of MidwiferyDo we need support workers in the maternity services?
15 Citations1997H. Francomb
There has been relatively little discussion in the literature regarding the National Vocational Qualification (NVQ) support worker in midwifery, however, some have challenged whether midwives can offer the full range of midwives' care without assistance.
Obstetrical & Gynecological SurveyPregnancy, Breast Feeding, and Oral Contraceptives and the Risk of Epithelial Ovarian Cancer
15 Citations1991Marta Gwinn, Nancy C. Lee +3 more
British Journal of MidwiferyPrevention and treatment of postnatal psychiatric disorders
13 Citations1995Rajeev Kumar, Maureen Marks +1 more
The aetiology, indicators of risk and possible treatments for postnatal depression and midwives have a key preventive role in that they are in continuing contact with women who are at risk and are therefore in a position to detect early symptoms and arrange speedy referrals.
Journal of Health PsychologyStress, Social Support and Coping in Pregnancy
13 Citations1996Rebecca P. Cameron, Jennifer Wells +1 more
Researchers are challenged to examine the relevance of work on social support and coping to women of varying ethnicities and economic circumstances and to present a new model of coping that reframes women's coping as prosocial, active and effective.
Health & Social Care in the CommunityContradictions of support and self-help: views from providers of community health and social services to families with young children
12 Citations2007Jeanette Edwards, Jennie Popay
MidwiferyFactors affecting the duration of postnatal visits
12 Citations1991Jon W. Marsh, Elizabeth Sargent
Analysis revealed that 10 factors were significantly associated with the duration of visits, and the presence of health, social or emotional problems, or the lack of family/partner support was not associated with longer visits.
BMJMidwifery: Teams and Caseloads
11 Citations1994Angela Douglas
The present organisation of maternity services makes it possible for a woman to come into contact with upwards of 30 different professionals during the course of one pregnancy, delivery, and puerperium.
MidwiferyAssessing postnatal uterine involution: a review and a challenge
8 Citations1994Elsa Montgomery, Jo Alexander
No evidence was found that any form of anthropometric assessment of uterine involution in the early postnatal period has either preventative or predictive value.
BMJLong term backache after childbirth: prospective search for causative factors
8 Citations1996Robin Russell, Ruth Dundas +1 more
The use of epidural analgesia in labour had no effect on the incidence of postpartum backache and motor block resulting from epidural local anaesthetic administration was not a significant factor in the development of backache.
PubMed'My baby doesn't need me': understanding bonding failure.
6 Citations1993Andy Sluckin
Andy Sluckin describes and analyses the experiences of six women in the context of recent studies into bonding failure and puts the case for specialist therapy, without which, he suggests, improving the relationship between mother and child may be slow and only partially successful.
British Journal of MidwiferyPostnatal care cannot be ignored
5 Citations1995Debra Bick
The need for evaluation and further research into the organisation of postnatal care should be addressed if women are to receive the most appropriate care after their delivery, as well as during pregnancy and labour.
British Journal of MidwiferyPostnatal depression: a normal response to motherhood?
4 Citations1995Katherine Paradice
How PND could be an understandable reaction to the changes that most women have to confront when they become mothers is discussed.
…