The approach to consistency in the analytic hierarchy process

Abstract

In his first book on the Analytic Hierarchy Process, T. L. Saaty left open several mathematical questions about the structure of the set of positive reciprocal matrices. In this paper we consider three of these questions: Given an eigenvector and all matrices which give rise to it, can one go from one of them to any order by making small perturbations in the entries? Given two positive column vectors v and w is there a perturbation which carries the set of all positive reciprocal matrices with principal right eigenvector v to the set of positive reciprocal matrices with principal right eigenvector w? Does the set of positive reciprocal n×n matrices whose left and right principal eigenvectors are reciprocals coincide with the set of consistent matrices for n⩾4?