Infant Suffering and Nurse Advocacy in Neonatal Intensive Care
Nursing Clinics of North AmericaPublished 1 December 1989
Joy Hinson Penticuff
Citations46
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score0.74
SNIP0.84
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is hoped that nurses in neonatal intensive care will use the ideas presented here as a starting point for their individual and collective examination of what constitutes an ethic of the good.
Abstract
This discussion of nurse advocacy and infant suffering in neonatal intensive care was based on content analysis of interviews of 20 neonatal nurses in three NICUs over a period of 6 years. Throughout that span of time, nurses experienced significant emotional distress when they believed that therapies resulted in infant suffering without proportional benefit. In all of the nurses interviewed, infant suffering triggered a variety of acts of advocacy, ranging from changes in nursing care to decrease infant distress to formal requests that the medical plan of care be reviewed. Characteristics of infants, nurses, and the NICU organization were described as possibly influential to nurse advocacy. Finally, some thoughts about an ethic of the good were presented. Gajardo-Velasquez noted, "Nothing really great and important can be obtained without a certain amount of sacrifice; therefore, suffering is present in every human action that tends to transform and create new conditions for life." Our technology in the NICU has saved many lives and prevented much suffering and avoidable disability. It has also, for some, been a source of profound suffering. It is hoped that nurses in neonatal intensive care will use the ideas presented here as a starting point for their individual and collective examination of what constitutes an ethic of the good. Perhaps such an ethic can minimize the cost in suffering of the powerful technology of neonatal intensive care.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
Journal of Abnormal & Social PsychologyBehavioral Study of obedience.
4,768 Citations1963Stanley Milgram
This article describes a procedure for the study of destructive obedience in the laboratory, ordering a naive S to administer increasingly more severe punishment to a victim in the context of a learning experiment, which created extreme levels of nervous tension in some Ss.
Handbook of infant development
2,272 Citations1979Joy D. Osofsky
New England Journal of MedicineThe Nature of Suffering and the Goals of Medicine
2,075 Citations1982Eric J. Cassel
PEDIATRICSVisual Following and Pattern Discrimination of Face-like Stimuli by Newborn Infants
1,155 Citations1975Carolyn Goren, Merrill E. Sarty +1 more
The preference for the proper face stimulus by infants who had not seen a real face prior to testing suggests that an unlearned or "evolved" responsiveness to faces may be present in human neonates.
Infant Mental Health JournalToward a synactive theory of development: Promise for the assessment and support of infant individuality
600 Citations1982Heidelise Als
PEDIATRICSIndividualized Behavioral and Environmental Care for the Very Low Birth Weight Preterm Infant at High Risk for Bronchopulmonary Dysplasia: Neonatal Intensive Care Unit and Developmental Outcome
506 Citations1986Heidelise Als, Gretchen Lawhon +5 more
The hypothesis that very low birth weight preterm babies profit significantly both medically and developmentally from individualized behavioral care in the neonatal intensive care unit is supported.
The Psychoanalytic Study of the ChildLibidinal Object Constancy and Mental Representation
171 Citations1969Selma Fraiberg
Nursing ResearchMeasuring Moral Judgment in Nursing Dilemmas
148 Citations1981Patricla Crisham
Findings verified the significance of formal education and previous involvement with similar dilemmas in enhancing principled thinking and raised questions about the relative strength of practical considerations in the hospital milieu.
Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent MedicineA Genetic Field Theory of Ego Formation.
147 Citations1960Henry H. Work
In this brief but neatly organized lecture Spitz correlates what is currently known about infantile progress and the dependence of the child's attainments on successful completion of earlier stages of growth.
NeuropediatricsSTATE ORGANIZATION IN NEONATES: DEVELOPMENTAL INCONSISTENCY INDICATES RISK FOR DEVELOPMENTAL DYSFUNCTION
129 Citations1981Evelyn B. Thoman, Victor H. Denenberg +3 more
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorPrognostic Conflict in Life-and-Death Decisions: The Organization as an Ecology of Knowledge
129 Citations1987Renée R. Anspach
It is suggested that medical practice has been characterized by a diminishing attention to patients' subjective symptoms, a waning confidence in clinical observation, and an increasing reliance on diagnostic technology, which complicate life-and-death decisions.
Nursing ResearchA New Method To Quantitatively Describe Pain Behavior in Infants
119 Citations1986Linda S. Franck
This pilot study demonstrated a method by which quantitative data regarding pain responses in infants can be obtained and evaluated.
Nursing ResearchMoral Reasoning and Moral Behavior Among Selected Groups of Practicing Nurses
114 Citations1981SHAK KETEFIAN
This study examined the relationship between moral reasoning and moral behavior in 79 practicing nurses using Judgments about Nursing Decisions, developed by the investigator, and found no differences between these groups with respect to the perception of realistic moral behavior component of JAND.
The Hastings Center ReportFrom Loyalty to Advocacy: A New Metaphor for Nursing
108 Citations1984Gerald R. Winslow
An evolving transformation in nursing ethics is examined in terms of two basic metaphors of the nurse's role and its norms and virtues, supporting this change while cautioning that attention should be given to clarifying the meaning of advocacy.
Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic & Neonatal NursingA National Survey of the Assessment and Treatment of Pain and Agitation in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
86 Citations1987Linda S. Franck
There is a lack of consistency in both attitudes and practices among neonatal intensive care unit staff with regard to pain assessment and management in neonates, and methods for assessing the presence of pain or evaluating the effectiveness of treatment appeared inadequate for critically ill infants.
SciencePhysical and Social Environment of Newborn Infants in Special Care Units
84 Citations1981Allen W. Gottfried, Patricia Wallace-Lande +4 more
Infants in newborn intensive and convalescent care units are exposed to large amounts of sensory stimulation of various sorts, but there is no diurnal rhythmicity in physical and social stimulation across days.
American Journal of PsychiatryDevelopmental structuralist approach to the classification of adaptive and pathologic personality organizations: infancy and early childhood
82 Citations1981Stanley I. Greenspan, Reginald S. Lourie
A developmental structuralist approach, which focuses on an organism's manner of organizing and differentiating its experience of the world (structures) at each developmental level, is suggested for understanding adaptive and maladaptive infant functioning, environmental patterns, and principles of preventive intervention.
PEDIATRICSDirect Computer Recording of Premature Infants and Nursery Care: Distress Following Two Interventions
71 Citations1983Peter A. Gorski, William T. Hole +2 more
A new methodology for continuous naturalistic computer-assisted recording of infants in nursery care is described, and an infant's responses to two seemingly contrasted care-giver interventions were analyzed: chest physical therapy and close social interaction.
New England Journal of MedicineNursing as Metaphor
58 Citations1983Claire M. Fagin, Donna Diers
A study of the reactions of people the authors meet socially to being told, "I am a nurse" and the response to this statement.
Clinics in PerinatologyThe Study of Sensory and Learning Processes of the Newborn
44 Citations1977Lewis P. Lipsitt
An overview of recent advances made in the documentation of sensoiy and learning processes of newborns is provided, both about the behavior of infants and about the nervous system that mediates developmental change.
American Journal of Law & MedicineLimits of Guardian Treatment Refusal: A Reasonableness Standard
38 Citations1984Robert M. Veatch
Under the model for guardian decision making presented here, bonded Guardians should be preferred over nonbonded guardians, and bonded guardians should be allowed discretion to make treatment choices, limited only by a standard of reasonableness policed by the courts.
JAMAEthical Dimensions in the Health Professions
32 Citations1982Kenneth L. Vaux
The authors intend to provide a handbook for student and practitioner in the allied health professions: therapists, pharmacists, technologists, to increase an ethical awareness and raise the moral consciousness of professionals by educating them to the "stuff" of ethics that characterizes their clinical practice.
BirthNeonatal Intensive Care: Parents’Role in Ethical Decision Making
22 Citations1986Helen Harrison
Parents can take steps to enter the decision-making process in newborn intensive care, and the sometimes disastrous use of unproved medications and procedures in what amounts to uncontrolled experimentation on NICU populations.
The Journal of Perinatal & Neonatal NursingNeonatal intensive care: Parental prerogatives
20 Citations1988Joy Hinson Penticuff
Infant Behavior and DevelopmentThe interaction of ward personnel with infants in the premature nursery
12 Citations1980Peter Marton, Heather Dawson +1 more
The results indicated that infants have contact with ward personnel for a relatively short period, approximately 8 minutes per hour, and there were differences in the nature of the contact between infants in intensive and post-intensive care.
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseEnvironmental Analysis of Neonatal Intensive Care
11 Citations1982Coryl LaRue Jones
Personal attention correlated significantly with medical care, and at even a higher level with general care, personal attention independent of tasks, and staff rank order of preference for individual infants, thus differentiating between the nurturing care of preferred infants and the more impersonal care provided to infants lower in staff preference.
Critical Care Nursing QuarterlySuffering and dying under intensive care
5 Citations1987James F. Bresnahan