Survey on Recent Results in the Stability and Control of Time-Delay Systems*
Journal of Dynamic Systems Measurement and ControlPublished 1 June 2003
Keqin Gu, Silviu‐Iulian Niculescu
Citations618
SJR quartileQ2
SJR score0.46
SNIP0.78
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
This paper gives a broad overview of the stability and control of time-delay systems. Emphasis is on the more recent progress and engineering applications. Examples of practical problems, mathematical descriptions, stability and performance analysis, and feedback control are discussed.
Keywords
Computer ScienceEngineering
Applied mathematical sciencesIntroduction to Functional Differential Equations
5,657 Citations1993Jack K. Hale, Sjoerd M. Verduyn Lunel
The present book builds upon the earlier work of J. Hale, "Theory of Functional Differential Equations" published in 1977 and attempts to maintain the spirit of that book and have retained approximately one-third of the material intact.
Birkhäuser Boston eBooksStability of Time-Delay Systems
5,472 Citations2003Keqin Gu, Vladimir L. Kharitonov +1 more
Transactions of the American Society of Mechanical EngineersOptimum Settings for Automatic Controllers
5,173 Citations1942Jens Ziegler, Nancy B. Nichols
Robust and optimal control
3,722 Citations2002John C. Doyle
Physics Letters AContinuous control of chaos by self-controlling feedback
3,271 Citations1992K. Pyragas
Journal of Dynamic Systems Measurement and ControlOptimum Settings for Automatic Controllers
2,448 Citations1993Jens Ziegler, Nancy B. Nichols
In this paper, the three principal control effects found in present controllers are examined and practical names and units of measurement are proposed for each effect.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlBilateral control of teleoperators with time delay
2,119 Citations1989Robert J. Anderson, Mark W. Spong
Springer optimization and its applicationsDifferential and Integral Inequalities
1,544 Citations2019Dorin Andrica, Themistocles M. Rassias
IEEE Journal of Oceanic EngineeringStable adaptive teleoperation
1,393 Citations1991G. Niemeyer, J.-J.E. Slotine
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlFinite spectrum assignment problem for systems with delays
1,119 Citations1979A. Manitius, A.W. Olbrot
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlLinear systems with delayed controls: A reduction
1,076 Citations1982Zvi Artstein
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlA delay-dependent stability criterion for systems with uncertain time-invariant delays
820 Citations1999PooGyeon Park
A new delay-dependent robust stability criterion for systems with time-invariant uncertain delays is derived, which is shown by an example less conservative than existing stability criteria.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlAn exact method for the stability analysis of time-delayed linear time-invariant (LTI) systems
656 Citations2002Nejat Olgaç, Rifat Sipahi
This study presents a unique explicit analytical expression in terms of the system parameters which not only reveals the stability regions (pockets) in the domain of time delay, but it also declares the number of unstable characteristic roots at any given pocket.
Elsevier eBooksTime-Delay Systems: Analysis, Optimization and Applications
635 Citations1987M. Malek‐Zavarei, Mohammad Jamshidi
This paper presents a meta-modelling of Time-Delay (TD) Systems using the Generalized Riccati Method and a new approach called Nondelay Conversion Approach, which addresses the problem of suboptimal control of Nonlinear TD Systems.
AutomaticaCriteria for robust stability and stabilization of uncertain linear systems with state delay
477 Citations1997Xi Li, Carlos E. de Souza
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlDelay-dependent robust stability and stabilization of uncertain linear delay systems: a linear matrix inequality approach
471 Citations1997Xi Li, Carlos E. de Souza
Methods for robust stability analysis and robust stabilization are developed dependent on the size of the delay and are given in terms of linear matrix inequalities.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlNew results on the synthesis of PID controllers
454 Citations2002G.J. Silva, Aniruddha Datta +1 more
This paper considers the problem of stabilizing a first-order plant with dead time using a proportional-integral-derivative (PID) controller using a version of the Hermite-Biehler theorem that is applicable to quasi-polynomials.
Birkhäuser Boston eBooksDeterministic and Stochastic Time-Delay Systems
452 Citations2002El‐Kébir Boukas, Zi-Kuan Liu
Recent developments on the class of uncertain deterministic/stochastic dynamical systems with time-delay, including problems such as stochastic stability, stabilizability under memory and memoryless state feedback control, Hinfinite control, filtering and its robustness are treated.
AutomaticaDelay-dependent robust H∞ control of uncertain linear state-delayed systems
432 Citations1999Carlos E. de Souza, Xi Li
Methods of robust stabilization and robust H"~ control which are dependent on the size of the delay and are based on the solution of linear matrix inequalities are developed.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlControl Lyapunov-Razumikhin functions and robust stabilization of time delay systems
413 Citations2001Mrdjan Janković
It turns out that the domination redesign control law applies, achieving global practical stability and, under an additional assumption, global asymptotic stability.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyAnalysis and Synthesis of Time Delay Systems
357 Citations1989Henryk Mikołaj Górecki
This book gives emphasis to methods and results which are applicable to analysis and synthesis of industrial control systems with time delays, and is designed for those with knowledge of mathematical methods of control theory.
Journal of Sound and VibrationA Novel Active Vibration Absorption Technique: Delayed Resonator
356 Citations1994Nejat Olgaç, Brian T. Holm-Hansen
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlDelay-dependent robust stabilization of uncertain systems with multiple state delays
356 Citations1998Yong‐Yan Cao, Youxian Sun +1 more
A new method for achieving robust stabilization is presented for a class of uncertain time-delay systems via linear memoryless state feedback control through linear matrix inequalities.
Journal of the American Rocket SocietyAspects of Combustion Stability in Liquid Propellant Rocket Motors Part I: Fundamentals. Low Frequency Instability With Monopropellants
323 Citations1951L. CROCCO
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlOn the modified Smith predictor for controlling a process with an integrator and long dead-time
314 Citations1999Miroslav R. Mataušek, Aleksandar Micić
A dead- time compensator for controlling higher-order processes with integral action and long dead-time is proposed, and the same setpoint response is obtained as in the modified Smith predictor, while the load disturbance rejection is considerably faster.
IEE Proceedings D Control Theory and ApplicationsDirect method for TDS stability analysis
303 Citations1987K. Walton, John Marshall
Physics Letters AOn analytical properties of delayed feedback control of chaos
300 Citations1997Hiroyuki Nakajima
Systems & Control LettersA new method for computing delay margins for stability of linear delay systems
287 Citations1995Jie Chen, Guoxiang Gu +1 more
Delayed Positive Feedback Can Stabilize Oscillatory Systems
280 Citations1993Chaouki T. Abdallah, P. Dorato +2 more
Journal of Dynamic Systems Measurement and ControlTurbocharged Diesel Engine Modeling for Nonlinear Engine Control and State Estimation
261 Citations1995Minghui Kao, John J. Moskwa
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlStabilizability, detectability, and spectrum assignment for linear autonomous systems with general time delays
258 Citations1978A.W. Olbrot
AutomaticaContinuous pole placement for delay equations
254 Citations2002Wim Michiels, Koen Engelborghs +2 more
A stabilization method for linear time-delay systems which extends the classical pole placement method for ordinary differential equations, which does not render the closed loop system but consists of controlling the rightmost eigenvalues.
Annual Reviews in ControlRobust stability analysis of time delay systems: A survey
254 Citations1999Vladimir L. Kharitonov
The main aim of the paper is to discuss some basic techniques used for deriving tractable stability and robust stability conditions in linear time delay systems with parameter uncertainty.
International Journal of ControlA further refinement of discretized Lyapunov functional method for the stability of time-delay systems
252 Citations2001Keqin Gu
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlFrequency sweeping tests for stability independent of delay
251 Citations1995Jie Chen, Haniph A. Latchman
This work considers specifically the notion of asymptotic stability independent of delay, and presents for each class of systems a necessary and sufficient condition in terms of structured singular values, and demonstrates how these conditions may be extended to study stabilityIndependent of delay for uncertain systems.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlGlobal asymptotic stabilization for chains of integrators with a delay in the input
249 Citations2003Frédéric Mazenc, Sabine Mondié +1 more
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlDelay and its time-derivative dependent robust stability of time-delayed linear systems with uncertainty
242 Citations2001Jin-Hoon Kim
This paper considers the robust stability of time-delayed linear systems with uncertainties, which are time-varying and unknown but are norm-bounded, and the time-delay is time-Varying.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlAdditional dynamics in transformed time-delay systems
228 Citations2000Keqin Gu, Silviu‐Iulian Niculescu
Lecture notes in control and information sciencesStability and robust stability of time-delay systems: A guided tour
215 Citations2005Silviu‐Iulian Niculescu, Erik I. Verriest +2 more
In this chapter, some recent stability and robust stability results on linear time-delay systems are outlined and some references where the reader can find more details and proofs are pointed out.
AutomaticaAnalysis of a high-order iterative learning control algorithm for uncertain nonlinear systems with state delays
214 Citations1998YangQuan Chen, Zhiming Gong +1 more
The tracking error bound is proven to be a class-K function of the bounds of reinitialization errors, uncer- tainties and disturbances to the systems, and the time delays in the system states do not play a significant role in the ILC convergence property.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlStability of time-delay systems: equivalence between Lyapunov and scaled small-gain conditions
205 Citations2001Jianrong Zhang, C.R. Knopse +1 more
It is demonstrated that many previously reported Lyapunov-based stability conditions for time-delay systems are equivalent to the robust stability analysis of an uncertain comparison system free of delays via the use of the scaled small-gain lemma with constant scales.
Direct method for TDS stability analysis
205 Citations1987K. Walton, John Marshall
The finite polynomials arising in this direct method are shown to have useful sensitivity properties and to be stable independent of delay.
Journal of vibration and acousticsSpecial Aspects of Chatter in Milling
203 Citations1983J. Tlusty, F. Ismail
International Journal of ControlOn the Liapunov-Krasovskii functionals for stability analysis of linear delay systems
200 Citations1999V.B. Kolmanovskii
Journal of Dynamic Systems Measurement and ControlInput/Output Linearization Using Time Delay Control
198 Citations1992Kamal Youcef‐Toumi, S.-T. Wu
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlRobust stability for time-delay systems: the edge theorem and graphical tests
191 Citations1989Minyue Fu, A.W. Olbrot +1 more
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlOn ℋ/sub ∞/ control for dead-time systems
166 Citations2000Gjerrit Meinsma, Hans Zwart
A mixed sensitivity H∞ problem is solved for dead-time systems and all suboptimal controllers are parameterized, and the central controller is shown to be a feedback interconnection of a finite-dimensional system and a finite memory system, both of which can be implemented.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlLimitations of a class of stabilization methods for delay systems
164 Citations2001Koen Engelborghs, Michel Dambrine +1 more
Limits of certain stabilization methods for time-delay systems are investigated and instability of the difference part of the control law leads to instability in the closed-loop system, in the case that implementation is done via numerical quadrature.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlMemoryless stabilization of uncertain linear systems including time-varying state delays
162 Citations1992S. Phoojaruenchanachai, K. Furuta
The main contribution given is to enlarge the class of time-delay systems for which one can construct a stabilizing memoryless linear feedback controller.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlRobust stability of time-delay systems
160 Citations1994Vladimir L. Kharitonov, Alexey P. Zhabko
The main objects of the paper are the developing of the concept of convex directions for quasipolynomials and exploiting this concept for construction of testing sets for quAsipoly Nomial families.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlFurther remarks on additional dynamics in various model transformations of linear delay systems
155 Citations2001Keqin Gu, Silviu‐Iulian Niculescu
Journal of Differential EquationsA Liapunov functional for a matrix difference-differential equation
153 Citations1978E. F. Infante, W.B Castelan
Journal of Mathematical Analysis and ApplicationsGeneralization of Liapunov's theorem in a linear delay system
146 Citations1989Wenzhang Huang
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlRobust stability of uncertain time-delay systems
143 Citations2000Kemin Zhou, Yun-Ping Huang
Sufficient stability conditions are derived by using the small /spl mu/ theorem and it is shown that most existing results in the literature are much more conservative than this condition.
Journal of Dynamic Systems Measurement and ControlActive Vibration Control of Distributed Systems Using Delayed Resonator With Acceleration Feedback
143 Citations1997Nejat Olgaç, Hakan Elmali +2 more
IEEE Control Systems MagazineModeling of an internal combustion engine for control analysis
138 Citations1988J.A. Cook, B.K. Powell
Quarterly of Applied MathematicsNonlinear oscillations in a distributed network
134 Citations1967Robert K. Brayton
Systems & Control LettersOn delay-dependent stability conditions
133 Citations2000Vladimir L. Kharitonov, Daniel Melchor‐Aguilar
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlOn computing the maximal delay intervals for stability of linear delay systems
121 Citations1995Jie Chen
Physica D Nonlinear PhenomenaLimitation of generalized delayed feedback control
119 Citations1998Hiroyuki Nakajima, Yoshisuke Ueda
Delay effects on stability: a survey
111 Citations2003V.B. Kolmanovskii, Silviu‐Iulian Niculescu +1 more
Designing force reflecting teleoperators with large time delays to appear as virtual tools
104 Citations2002G. Niemeyer, J.-J.E. Slotine
Using the notion of wave variables for the analysis and implementation, and making appropriate design choices, a telerobot system with consistent and predictable behavior is constructed, following the design goal of a virtual tool accounting for the implicit limitations imposed by the delay.
Lecture notes in control and information sciencesFinite-Spectrum Assignment for Time-Delay Systems
101 Citations1999Qing‐Guo Wang, Tong Heng Lee +1 more
Time-Delay Systems, FSA Algorithms Development, Closed-loop Process Identification, Controller Design and Tuning, Robustness Analysis and Design are presented.
Delay-dependent stability of linear systems with delayed state: an LMI approach
99 Citations2002Silviu‐Iulian Niculescu, Alexandre Trofino +2 more
International Journal of ControlUniform ultimate boundedness of the solutions of uncertain dynamic delay systems with state-dependent and memoryless feedback control
99 Citations1983Arild Thowsen
AutomaticaTwo Degree-of-Freedom Smith Predictor for Processes with Time Delay
98 Citations1998Weidong Zhang, Youxian Sun +1 more
The conventional Smith predictor is modified, which leads to significant improvements in its regulatory capacities for reference inputs and disturbances, and decouples the setpoint response from the disturbance response.
Journal of Dynamic Systems Measurement and ControlSteady Modes in Relay Control Systems With Time Delay and Periodic Disturbances
93 Citations2000Emilia Fridman, Leonid Fridman +1 more
Journal of Dynamic Systems Measurement and ControlAnalysis of Linear Time Invariant Systems With Time Delay
87 Citations1992Kamal Youcef‐Toumi, Suresh B. Reddy
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlRobust stabilization of uncertain systems with time-varying multistate delay
84 Citations1998Yong‐Yan Cao, Youxian Sun
The authors deal with the problem of stabilizing a class of uncertain linear systems with time-varying multi-state delay and subject to norm-bounded parameter uncertainty via memoryless linear state feedback, and derive sufficient conditions for the robust stabilizability.
On robust stability of time-delay systems with norm-bounded uncertainty
81 Citations2001Qing‐Long Han, Keqin Gu
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlBounded real criteria for linear time-delay systems
80 Citations1998U. Shaked, I. Yaesh +1 more
Both delay-independent and delay-dependent bounded real criteria are derived which provide sufficient conditions for the system to possess an H/sub /spl infin//-norm which is less than or equal to a prescribed bound.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlOn robust stability of time-delay systems with norm-bounded uncertainty
75 Citations2001Qing‐Long Han, Keqin Gu
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlRobust H/sub ∞/ performance for linear delay-differential systems with time-varying uncertainties
74 Citations1998H. Kokame, Hirokazu Kobayashi +1 more
A simple criterion is proposed which assures the pseudo-quadratic stability as a well as an H/sub /spl infin//-norm bound in the form of a linear matrix inequality which is affine or convex in additional scalar parameters.
IEEE Control SystemsNeural control of a steel rolling mill
69 Citations1993Daniel Sbárbaro, D. Neumerkel +1 more
Analysis of a fluid approximation to flow control dynamics
67 Citations1992Jean-Chrysostome Bolot, A. Udaya Shankar
The authors first model the flow control mechanism by a discrete-space stochastic process and define appropriate performance measures for transient and steady-state regimes, then simplify it to a continuous-space deterministic model for which closed-form solutions can be derived easily.
Journal of Sound and VibrationINTRODUCTION TO THE DUAL FREQUENCY FIXED DELAYED RESONATOR
63 Citations1996Nejat Olgaç, Hakan Elmali +1 more
AutomaticaVariable structure robust control of uncertain time-delay systems
60 Citations1998Reyad El-Khazali
A variable structure output feedback robust control for uncertain time-delay systems is introduced and two types of control laws are introduced by which an estimate of a region of asymptotic stability to the origin and a regions of attraction to the switching manifold are defined.
Journal of Applied PhysicsKinetics of the Circulating-Fuel Nuclear Reactor
58 Citations1954W.K. Ergen
Journal of Dynamic Systems Measurement and ControlOn Time Delay in Noncolocated Control of Flexible Mechanical Systems
57 Citations1992B. Yang, C. D. Mote
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlAsymptotic tracking of a nonminimum phase nonlinear system with nonhyperbolic zero dynamics
53 Citations2000Jie Huang
IMA Journal of Mathematical Control and InformationStability radii for some propagation models
52 Citations1997A. Halanay
Journal of Dynamic Systems Measurement and ControlStability of Uncertain Linear Systems With Time Delay
51 Citations1991Kamal Youcef‐Toumi, J. Bobbett
International Journal of ControlState difference feedback for stabilizing uncertain steady states of non-linear systems
51 Citations2001Hideki Kokame, Kentaro Hirata +2 more
A rigorous stability analysis has been executed for the case where state deviations are controllable by a single input variable and has led to a favourable conclusion that if the number of unstable modes is just two, and if they are not associated with the origin in the complex plane, the controller is always able to find a controller which stabilizes the deviations from the unknown steady state.
IFAC Proceedings VolumesStability of Systems with Distributed Delays
47 Citations1995Erik I. Verriest
Linear systsems with rational distributed delay: Reduction and stability
40 Citations1999Erik I. Verriest
A reduction method for the class of distributed delay systems with rational kernel transforms the delay system to one with fixed crisp delays and applications in stability analysis and realization with integrators and (fixed) delay lines is shown.
SIAM Journal on Control and OptimizationAnalysis and Optimization of Feedback Control Algorithms for Data Transfers in High-Speed Networks
39 Citations1996Rauf Izmailov
Two linear feedback control algorithms for handling and preventing congestion in high-speed networks are proposed and analyzed and it is suggested that these parameters are globally optimal as well.
Elsevier eBooksAN ALGORITHM FOR COMPUTING LIAPUNOV FUNCTIONALS FOR SOME DIFFERENTIAL-DIFFERENCE EQUATIONS
38 Citations1972Richard Datko
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlRobust control in the gap: a state-space solution in the presence of a single input delay
36 Citations1997Gilead Tadmor
A solution is provided to the problem of (sub)optimal robust design in the gap for a system with a single input lag and a parameterized differential matrix Riccati equation is presented in terms of a neutral equation model.
Lecture notes in control and information sciencesNumerics of the stability exponent and eigenvalue abscissas of a matrix delay system
36 Citations2005James Louisell
Delay-dependent closed-loop stability of linear systems with input delay: an LMI approach
36 Citations2002Silviu‐Iulian Niculescu, Minyue Fu +1 more
This paper focuses on the problem of computing a control law which maximizes the delay of the closed-loop system for a class of linear systems with delayed input and uses the Razumikhin based method and a frequency-filtering based method.
Robustness analysis with time-delays
34 Citations2002Gérard Scorletti
AutomaticaH∞ control of dead-time systems based on a transformation
30 Citations2003Qing‐Chang Zhong
This paper presents a transformation that makes all the robust control problems of dead-time systems able to be solved similarly as in the finite-dimensional situations.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlAbsolute stability in linear delay-differential systems: ill-posedness and robustness
27 Citations1995James Louisell
The author shows that system stability for all values of the delay vector lying in a sector will imply absolute stability, and shows that absolute stability is ill-posed with respect to arbitrarily small perturbations of thedelay ratios.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic ControlVibrational feedback control of time delay systems
27 Citations1997Khalil Shujaee, Brad Lehman
IFAC Proceedings VolumesOn the extraction of dead-time controllers from delay-free parametrizations *
25 Citations2000Leonid Mirkin
Journal of Dynamic Systems Measurement and ControlNoncolocated Control of a Damped String Using Time Delay
24 Citations1992B. Yang
AutomaticaThe edge theorem and graphical tests for robust stability of neutral time-delay systems
23 Citations1991Minyue Fu, A.W. Olbrot +1 more
The robust stability problem for a class of uncertain neutral time-delay systems where the characteristic equations involve a poly tope P of quasipoly neutrals of neutral type is considered and the D-stability problem of a higher dimensional polytope is reduced to a finite number of pairwise convex combinations of vertices.
…