The Public Health versus Clinical Approaches to Maternity Services: The Emperor Has No Clothes

Journal of Public Health PolicyPublished 1 January 1998

Marsden Wagner

DOI10.2307/3343087

Source URL

Citations8

SJR quartileQ2

SJR score0.73

SNIP0.81

TL;DR

The conflict between practice based on science, or based on peers, and between the recommendations of public health agencies and the recommendation of organizations of clinicians is explored, with specific reference to maternity services.

Abstract

This paper explores the conflict between practice based on science, or based on peers, and between the recommendations of public health agencies and the recommendations of organizations of clinicians, with specific reference to maternity services. The WHO European Regional Office, as a public health agency, has been bringing to the attention of the public and of governments two serious problems brought about by the present hegemony of the clinical approach: (1) The reliance on standards of practice rather than scientific evidence, and (2) Having doctors decide health policy, leading to the failure to honour the self-determination of the individual and family and basic human reproductive rights.

Keywords

Social SciencesHealth Professions

American Journal of Obstetrics and GynecologyThe effect of intrapartum epidural analgesia on nulliparous labor: A randomized, controlled, prospective trial

449 Citations1993James A. Thorp, Daniel H. Hu +5 more

In a randomized, controlled, prospective trial epidural analgesia resulted in a significant prolongation in the first and second stages of labor and a significant increase in the frequency of cesarean delivery, primarily related to dystocia.

BMJActive management of labour: current knowledge and research issues

123 Citations1994Jim Thornton, Richard Lilford

The provision of continuous professional support in labour seems to reduce both types of operative delivery, although the effect on caesarean sections is confined to those settings where non-professional companions are not normally present in labour.

MidwiferyPursuing the birth machine: The search for appropriate birth technology

118 Citations1995Karen Connolly

International Journal of Obstetric AnesthesiaA review of prospectively controlled comparisons of epidural with non-epidural forms of pain relief during labour

77 Citations1992Charlotte Howell, Iain Chalmers

Evidence derived from controlled comparisons of epidural with non-epidural forms of pain relief confirms that epidural block provides more effective relief of pain than alternatives; and that if it is continued during the second stage of labour, it can cause a substantial increase in the use of instrumental delivery.

BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics & GynaecologyWHO appropriate technology for birth revisited

69 Citations1992Beverley Chalmers

The validity of WHO recommendations for childbirth care are examined and recommendations is that women participate in decisions about their birth experiences and that separating mothers and babies routinely should be abandoned.

MidwiferyHaving a baby in Europe

40 Citations1986Ann Thomson

Journal of Public Health PolicyReproductive Rights and the Medical Care System: A Plea for Rational Health Policy

5 Citations1993P. A. F. Stephenson, M G Wagner

This work discusses medicine's role as an agent of social control, the medical reconstruction of problems that are social in nature, and the need for a more coherent policy framework to guide physician practices.