Baby Doe Five Years Later
New England Journal of MedicinePublished 13 August 1987
John D. Lantos
Citations43
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score19.08
SNIP13.47
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Five years ago, an unfortunate baby with Down's syndrome and esophageal atresia was allowed to die of starvation in Indiana, coming 10 years after the Supreme Court decision that legalised abortion.
Abstract
Lantos reviews the public and political controversy over withholding\nlife-prolonging treatment from handicapped newborns that began in 1983 with\nthe highly publicized death of "Baby Doe" in Bloomington, Indiana. He places\nthe controversy into its historical context and discusses the implications of\nthe resulting federal legislation (the amended Child Abuse Prevention and\nTreatment Act) for the Reagan administration, pediatricians, advocates for the\nhandicapped, and parents. Lantos's central concern is the impact that the\nissue of neonatal intensive care has had on child health in the United States. \nHe argues that the focus on technology-based interventions diverts attention\nfrom the real problem, which is a high rate of infant mortality resulting\nprimarily from low birth weight. In Lantos's opinion, the Baby Doe\ncontroversy has removed important preventive medicine programs from political\nand clinical agendas. (KIE abstract)
Keywords
Medicine
New England Journal of MedicineThe Contribution of Low Birth Weight to Infant Mortality and Childhood Morbidity
2,130 Citations1985Marie C. McCormick
Continuation of the current decline in neonatal mortality and reduction of the mortality differentials between high- and low-risk groups require the identification and more effective implementation of strategies for the prevention of low-weight births.
New England Journal of MedicineMoral and Ethical Dilemmas in the Special-Care Nursery
484 Citations1973Raymond S. Duff, A. G. M. Campbell
After careful consideration of each of these 43 infants, parents and physicians in a group decision concluded that prognosis for meaningful life was extremely poor or hopeless, and therefore rejected further treatment.
Developmental Medicine & Child NeurologyResults of Treatment of Myelomeningocele
300 Citations1971John Lorber
It has been shown that, in the absence of treatment, most infants born with myelomeningocele die early in infancy, and it is inferred that almost all the more severe cases do so.
PEDIATRICSEarly Management and Decision Making for the Treatment of Myelomeningocele
81 Citations1983Richard H. Gross, Alan Cox +3 more
PEDIATRICSPediatricians' Attitudes Affecting Decision-Making in Defective Newborns
74 Citations1977I. David Todres, Diane Krane +2 more
A questionnaire designed to identify the factors that influence the resolution of ethical dilemmas was returned by 230 Massachusetts pediatricians and found that willingness of the parents to care for the child would influence the decision to take heroic measures.
PubMedPediatricians' attitudes affecting decision-making in defective newborns.
74 Citations1977Todres Id, Diane Krane +2 more
JAMAReducing Black Neonatal Mortality
55 Citations1985Nancy Binkin
It was found that at any combination of birth weight and gestational age, black neonates weighing less than 3,000 g had lower mortality rates than whites, but this survival advantage was outweighed by considerably higher rates of low birth weight among blacks.
Journal of Pediatric SurgeryCongenital intrinsic duodenal obstruction: A twenty-year review of its surgical management and consequences
52 Citations1974David Girvan, Clinton A. Stephens
The findings in 158 cases of congenital intrinsic duodenal obstruction seen at the Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, between 1952 and 1971 are presented, with a survival rate of 67%.
The Hastings Center ReportThe Final, Anticlimactic Rule on Baby Doe
38 Citations1985Thomas H. Murray, Kathleen Kerr
The gist of the Department of Health and Human Services' final rule on the care of handicapped infants is discussed, and it is concluded that society remains ambivalent toward the disabled.
PEDIATRICSInfant Death Rates Among the Poor and Nonpoor in Kentucky, 1982 to 1983
25 Citations1987Carl W. Spurlock, M W Hinds +2 more
It was found that the poor infant was at a significantly greater risk for death than the nonpoor infant but only during the postneonatal period (relative risk 2.04, P = .0003), and Sudden infant death syndrome and infections were largely responsible for the poor infants' higher postNeonatal mortality risk.
The Hastings Center ReportThe Baby Doe Rule: Still a Threat
25 Citations1986John C. Moskop, Rita L. Saldanha +1 more
Current federal policy, as reflected in the final Baby Doe rule, will have a chilling effect on the ability of doctors to care appropriately for severely disabled infants and will force physicians to violate a duty to do no harm without compensating benefit.
Mayo Clinic ProceedingsEthical Dilemmas in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
17 Citations1987Carol Lynn Berseth
American Journal of Law & MedicineInfanticide, Physicians, and the Law: The “Baby Doe” Amendments to the Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act
15 Citations1985Nelson Lund
The genesis of legislation designed to curtail the practice of infanticide by the medical profession is traced, the problem to which it is addressed is addressed, and its prospects for success are evaluated.
Journal of Health Politics Policy and LawThe Antiabortion Movement and Baby Jane Doe
12 Citations1986Constance Paige, Elisa B. Karnofsky
Activists in the antiabortion movement chose the issue of Baby Jane Doe because they believed it would attract welcome publicity, give them the appearance of supporting civil rights, and enhance their argument as to the legal rights of the fetus and thus strengthen the case against abortion.
The Hastings Center ReportLaw and the Life Sciences: Baby Doe Redux: Doctors as Child Abusers
12 Citations1983George J. Annas
Judge Annas charges that the federal government's revised "Baby Doe" regulations subvert the traditional role of the hospital as a haven for abused children by casting the physician as a potential abuser and the nurse as an informant.
Journal of Health Politics Policy and LawCivil Rights and Regulatory Wrongs: The Reagan Administration and the Medical Treatment of Handicapped Infants
11 Citations1986Lawrence D. Brown
The episode offers insights into the dynamics of the U.S. system of separated powers, the limitations of the "civil rights" approach, and the importance of negotiating structures for the resolution of private moral dilemmas with public implications.
Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent MedicineLongitudinal Development in Pediatric Residents of Attitudes Toward Neonatal Resuscitation
7 Citations1986Carol Lynn Berseth
Data acquired both cross-sectionally and longitudinally indicated that attitudes toward neonatal resuscitation changed during residency training, and residents showed significantly increased reluctance to resuscitate infants at the end of the first year of training and again at theend of the third year ofTraining.