Therapeutic landscapes: Medical issues in light of the new cultural geography
Social Science & MedicinePublished 1 April 1992
Wilbert M. Gesler
Citations1,167
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score2.10
SNIP2.01
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The intention of this broad overview is to bring some particularly useful concepts developed in cultural geography to the attention of social scientists interested in matters of health and to stimulate research along new lines.
Abstract
Employing an expanded meaning of the concept of landscape taken from the 'new' cultural geography, this paper explores why certain places or situations are perceived to be therapeutic. Themes from both traditional and recent work in cultural geography are illustrated with examples from the literature of the social science of health care. The themes include man-environment relationships; humanist concepts such as sense of place and symbolic landscapes; structuralist concepts such as hegemony and territoriality; and blends of humanist concerns, structuralist concerns, and time geography. The intention of this broad overview is to bring some particularly useful concepts developed in cultural geography to the attention of social scientists interested in matters of health and to stimulate research along new lines.
Keywords
PsychologySocial SciencesArts and Humanities
Space and Place: Humanistic Perspective
1,015 Citations1979Yi‐Fu Tuan
Annals of the Association of American GeographersPlace as Historically Contingent Process: Structuration and the Time-Geography of Becoming Places
978 Citations1984Allan Pred
Economic GeographyThe Human Experience of Space and Place
478 Citations1981John Western, Anne Büttimer +1 more
American AnthropologistUniversal Aspects of Symbolic Healing: A Theoretical Synthesis
386 Citations1986James Dow
New directions in cultural geography
313 Citations1987Denis Cosgrove, Peter Jackson
Teaching SociologySociology: A Brief but Critical Introduction
264 Citations1988Michael R. Hill, Anthony Giddens
Annals of the Association of American GeographersCONTEMPORARY HUMANISM IN GEOGRAPHY∗
218 Citations1976J. Nicholas Entrikin
Social Science & Medicine Part B Medical AnthropologyWhy do indigenous practitioners successfully heal?
214 Citations1979Arthur Kleinman, Lilias H. Sung
Findings from a follow-up study of patients treated by a shaman ( tâng-ki ) in Taiwan, and early findings from a much larger study of indigenous healing in that Chinese cultural setting, are reported.
Time, Space and Regionalisation
213 Citations1985Anthony Giddens
InquiryMedicine's symbolic reality
163 Citations1973Arthur M. Kleinman
These studies document that medicine, from an historical and cross‐cultural perspective, is constituted as a cultural system in which symbolic meanings take an active part in disease formation, the classification and cognitive management of illness, and in therapy.
Geographical ReviewGeophagy in Africa and in the United States: A Culture-Nutrition Hypothesis
158 Citations1973John M. Hunter
Economic GeographyPlaceways: A Theory of the Human Environment
125 Citations1989James S. Duncan, E.V. Walter
Social Science & Medicine (1967)Disease and “development” in Africa
119 Citations1970Charles C. Hughes, John M. Hunter
PubMedThe changing rural environment and the relationship between health services and rural development.
108 Citations1989Sam Cordes
Author summarizes today's changing rural America and the challenges that health services researchers and policymakers face in relating the rural environment to the problems and possibilities of rural health services delivery.
The Antioch ReviewEthos, World-View, and the Analysis of Sacred Symbols
101 Citations2016Clifford Geertz
Annals of the Association of American GeographersSYMBOLISM AND THE CULTURAL LANDSCAPE
99 Citations1980Lester Rowntree, Margaret W. Conkey
Transactions of the Institute of British GeographersHealth, Disease and Society: An Introduction to Medical Geography
94 Citations1989Mary J. Dobson, Kelvyn Jones +1 more
This major textbook is a comprehensive introduction to the rapidly expanding field of medical geography, illustrating the ideas, methods and debates that inform contemporary approaches to the subject.
Review of Radical Political EconomicsThe Political Ecology of Disease
93 Citations1977Meredeth Turshen
International Journal of Health ServicesThe Underdevelopment of Health or the Health of Underdevelopment: An Analysis of the Distribution of Human Health Resources in Latin America
93 Citations1974Vicente Navarro
The uneven distribution, by type of health care, by region, by social class, and by subsectors (private, public, and social security), of human health resources, is shown to be explained by the same determinants that cause underdevelopment in Latin America.
Social Science & Medicine Part B Medical AnthropologyThe comparative study of medical systems as changing social systems
87 Citations1978John M. Janzen
The integration of the two types of analysis demonstrates, in material from Central Africa, nuances and patterns in the history of a pluralistic medical system not seen in other medical anthropological field studies, which are often encapsulated in a small-scale context, or given to pseudo-universalizations.
Journal of Historical Geography“Fit localities for an asylum”: the historical geography of the nineteenth-century “mad-business” in England as viewed through the pages of the Asylum Journal
85 Citations1987Chris Philo
The institutions of the mid-nineteenth century “mad-business” in England—the public ssylums, charitable lunatic hospitals and private madhouses—possessed intriguing associations with particular places, regions and environments, but historians have rarely considered the way these associations prompted serious debates amongst such interested parties as the medical officers of mental establishments, the Government's Commissioners in Lunacy and even the educated public at large.
Ethnic and Racial StudiesA polyethnic London carnival as a contested cultural performance*
85 Citations1982Abner Cohen
Economic GeographyFactors Influencing Distances Traveled to Hospitals
79 Citations1970Richard L. Morrill, Robert Earickson +1 more
The travel impact of the fact that in most cases the patient's physician, not the patient, chooses the hospital is explored, and the effect of racial, religious, and income variations on the hospital trip is discussed.
Annals of the Association of American GeographersAN IDEALIST ALTERNATIVE IN HUMAN GEOGRAPHY
77 Citations1974Leonard Guelke
PubMedSome ecological differentials in the use of medical services.
68 Citations1971Rashid L. Bashshur, Gary W. Shannon +1 more
P patterns of travel to medical care facilities are investigated to determine the extent to which a sample of urban residents used the facilities nearest their homes, and to explore some social and location variables associated with their deviation from minimal travel.
Social Science & MedicineThe phenomenon, the explanations and the responses: Metaphors surrounding diabetes in urban Canadian Indians
67 Citations1984Rebecca Hagey
The story 'Nanabush and the Pale Stranger', which seemed to put into perspective the nature of diabetes as a phenomenon, provided explanations for it and answered numerous questions (non-biological) associated with the disease and indicated appropriate coping strategies.
The social geography of medicine and health
61 Citations1983John Eyles, Kevin J. Woods
Social Science & MedicineSome implications for the study of the doctor-patient interaction: Power, structure, and agency in the works of Howard Waitzkin and Arthur Kleinman
56 Citations1990Gregory Fernando Pappas
This article critiques two major theoretical perspectives concerning the doctor-patient interaction in medical anthropology represented by the work of Howard Waitzkin and Arthur Kleinman.
Social Science & MedicineConceptions of space and community in British health policy
55 Citations1990Graham Moon
It is suggested that spatial conceptions in health policy reflect a complex amalgam of sociological assumptions which might fruitfully be considered in the light of Giddens' concept of locale.
Annals of the Association of American GeographersHuman Dominion over Nature in the Hebrew Bible
53 Citations1989Jeanne Kay
Social Science & Medicine‘Disease and development’ or ‘the underdevelopment of health’: A critical review of geographical perspectives on African health problems
53 Citations1986Robert Stock
The article examines the legacy in geographical research of the comprehensive review by Hughes and Hunter, "Disease and 'development' in tropical Africa," which was published in 1970, and urges medical geographers to embrance a historical political economic framework in their studies of African health problems.
The Professional GeographerANY PLACE BUT HERE! MENTAL HEALTH FACILITIES AS NOXIOUS NEIGHBORS
52 Citations1981Christopher J. Smith, Robert Q. Hanham
Annals of the Association of American GeographersCALIFORNIA AND THE SEARCH FOR THE IDEAL
51 Citations1972James E. Vance
Transactions of the Institute of British GeographersTime Spacemakers and Entrainment
42 Citations1979Don Parkes, Nigel Thrift
Annals of the Association of American GeographersMetaphorical Vision: Changes in Western Attitudes to the Environment
40 Citations1982W. J. Mills
International Journal of Health ServicesUrban Health Disorders, Spatial Analysis, and the Economics of Health Facility Location
39 Citations1972Paul Gross
Working from health economics–medical sociology concepts, a behavioral model of health services utilization is proposed on the demand side, through a model of the consumer's perception of the total costs facing him in hospital care.
Social Science & MedicineRings of madness: Service areas of 19th century asylums in North America
39 Citations1986John M. Hunter, Gary W. Shannon +1 more
Economic GeographyUrban Ecological Containers, Environmental Risk Cells, and the Use of Medical Services
36 Citations1976Gary W. Shannon, Carl W. Spurlock
An initial empirical exploration of the linkage between the concepts of urban ecological containers, environmental risk cells, and the use of medical services is presented and the activity spaces and travel patterns of 243 families residing in a sub-community of the District of Columbia are compared for differential use of urban space beyond the immediate neighborhood.
PubMedLocating ambulatory medical care facilities for the elderly.
35 Citations1986Ellen K. Cromley, Gary W. Shannon
It is believed that the aggregate activity space represents a dynamic and more functional approach to spatial planning strategies than current approaches and, therefore, that it can be used more effectively to locate services for the elderly.
Geographical ReviewRoot Digging in the Appalachians: The Geography of Botanical Drugs
33 Citations1960Edward T. Price
The medicinal plants and their uses of North America were determined by the pioneer's task of learning to live in North America, and many of the colonists' remedies were adopted directly from the Indians.
Social Science & MedicineBackground to the development of health services in Nigeria
28 Citations1987Dennis A. Ityavyar
The paper ends by stating that the Nigerian nationalists who had struggled and secured Nigeria's political independence eventually became Nigeria's ruling class which now controls the post-colonial state.
Annals of the Association of American GeographersGEOPHAGY IN A MISSISSIPPI COUNTY∗
27 Citations1975Donald E. Vermeer, Dennis A. Frate
Social Science & Medicine Part B Medical AnthropologyAlternative therapeutic systems in belize: A semiotic framework
26 Citations1981Kathryn Vance Staiano
It is concluded that the sign of disorder in this context has no single interpretant and there exist a variety of interpretants from which the therapist and patient may select.
Australian GeographerUnderdevelopment theory: a geographical review
21 Citations1982Peter J. Rimmer, Dean Forbes
The Professional GeographerCAREGIVING ENVIRONMENTS AND ELDERLY RESIDENTIAL MOBILITY∗
19 Citations1989Judith W. Meyer, Ellen K. Cromley
A recently proposed developmental model of elderly mobility that focuses on caregiving and health is evaluated and expanded to include an anticipatory stage of mobility during which older Americans consciously try to organize their environments.
Social Science & MedicineLocation-allocation models, social science and health service planning: An example from North East England
18 Citations1983John Mohan
This project was set up in the context of a dispute on hospital strategy between the relevant Regional and Area Health Authorities and so the development of the dispute is outlined and some reservations about the techniques employed are put forward.
Social Science & MedicineInternational behavioral responses to a health hazard: AIDS
17 Citations1990Robert Earickson
This paper expands on Jonathan Mann's third wave of the AIDS pandemic: the epidemic of economic, social, political, and cultural reaction and response to the HIV infection and to AIDS, and suggests it is possible to approach AIDS much as the authors do natural and technological hazards.
Yearbook - Association of Pacific Coast GeographersThe Themes of Cultural Geography Rethought
17 Citations1975Philip L. Wagner
Social Science & Medicine (1967)The incompatibility of the medical model and the therapeutic community
15 Citations1977Irwin Z. Hoffman, Paul R. Singer
The thesis of the paper is that the inevitable in-hospital amalgamation of the agenda of the medical model and the Agenda of the therapeutic community results in anti-therapeutic double messages to patients.
Social Science & Medicine Part A Medical SociologyImplications of the ideology and implementation of health policy in a developing country
13 Citations1981F.M. Mburu
It is argued that the health policy formulators and implementors are bound partly by their own values, partly by the values of the intended clients and least by ethical or moral considerations, which will contribute to existing inequality of distribution and accessibility.
Social Science & MedicineIndividualist and structuralist perspectives on nutrition education for Canadian children
8 Citations1984Rhonda Love, Ilze Kalnins
The authors discuss the conflict between the two perspectives and suggest that synthesis is needed for progressive health promotion for Canadian children to occur.
Canadian Geographies / Géographies canadiennesHUMANS, LAND, AND LANDSCAPE: A PROPOSAL FOR CULTURAL GEOGRAPHY
7 Citations1987William Norton
Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciencesThe syntax of symbolism in an African religion
4 Citations1966Victoria Turner
Social Science & Medicine Part D Medical GeographyThe effects of regional planning on a rural hospital: A case study
3 Citations1979Stephen J. Kunitz, Andrew A. Sorensen
The successful effort to build a new hospital in one local community has resulted in the attraction of new physicians to the community, which had until then been in danger of losing the few physicians who still provided care to local residents.