Should physicians tell patients the truth?
PubMedPublished 1 July 1995
Atsushi Asai
Citations52
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
This work proposes a simple strategy to break this long-standing ethical dilemma--physicians must develop the habit of inquiring about their patients' preferences.
Abstract
The medical literature suggests that most patients want to be told the truth about a diagnosis of cancer. Despite this evidence of their patients' wishes, physicians in many countries still hesitate to disclose this and other diagnoses. Physicians frequently ignore their patients' wishes when they consider the appropriateness of truth telling. A complete shift from nondisclosure to mandatory disclosure without considering patients' preferences may lead to serious harm to patients who do not want to be told the truth. Because physicians cannot satisfactorily treat patients without knowing their preferences toward disclosure of a diagnosis, I propose a simple strategy to break this long-standing ethical dilemma--physicians must develop the habit of inquiring about their patients' preferences.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
The LancetWhat do gastroenterologists in Europe tell cancer patients?
263 Citations1993Ole Østergaard Thomsen, Henrik R. Wulff +2 more
The variation in attitudes among European gastroenterologists to truth telling in cases of cancer probably reflects differences in both doctors' attitudes and patients' expectations.
Cancer InvestigationPsychosocial Issues: An International Survey of Physician Attitudes and Practice in Regard to Revealing the Diagnosis of Cancer
199 Citations1987Jimmie C. Holland, Jimmie C. Holland +3 more
Data revealed that use of the word “cancer” was often avoided in discussions with the patient, and words commonly substituted for cancer were those that implied a “swelling” and “inflammation,” or a pathophysiologic change.
General Hospital PsychiatryThe effects of culture on illness behavior and medical care
155 Citations1993Tana Nilchaikovit, James M. Hill +1 more
It is proposed that understanding the patients' self-concepts and patterns of self-other relationships is essential for an objective understanding of the Patients' experience of illness, and can profoundly affect the quality of the physician-patient relationship and medical care.
Archives of Internal MedicineOffering truth. One ethical approach to the uninformed cancer patient
124 Citations1993Benjamin Freedman
A significant minority of cases in which patients are never informed that they have cancer or, although informed of the diagnosis, are not informed when disease progresses toward a terminal phase challenge the understanding of and commitment to an ethical physician-patient relationship.
PubMedEthical dilemmas in a cross-cultural context. A Chinese example.
116 Citations1992Jessica Müller, Breeda Desmond
Through the analysis of a case involving the hospital admission and death of a Chinese woman with metastatic lung cancer, some ethical dilemmas that develop in multicultural settings are examined and their effect on the patient, family, and physicians are examined.
Social Science & MedicineCommunication between patients and physicians about terminal care: A survey in Japan
106 Citations1993Ichiro Kai, Gen Ohi +5 more
The analysis by kappa coefficients showed that the concordance between patients' preferences and physicians' estimation was not far from a figure expected by chance alone.
PubMedMedical disclosure and refugees. Telling bad news to Ethiopian patients.
97 Citations1992Yewoubdar Beyene
Being sensitive to patients' worldviews may reduce the frustration and conflict experienced by both refugees and American physicians.
Annals of OncologyDisclosure of breast cancer diagnosis: Patient and physician reports
90 Citations1991Paola Mosconi, Beth E. Meyerowitz +2 more
Comparison of patient and physician reports should not be used to validate either source of information, but the degree of patient-physician disagreement found in this research may alert physicians to potential difficulties that can arise in communicating with cancer patients.
Journal of Medical EthicsAttitudes of a Mediterranean population to the truth-telling issue.
78 Citations1992Panagiota Dalla-Vorgia, Klea Katsouyanni +4 more
The conclusion is that, emphasising the need for good communication between doctors and patients, doctors should not lie, but should disclose to their patients the part of the truth they are ready to accept.
Annals of OncologyCancer diagnosis disclosure in a Spanish hospital
69 Citations1992J. Estapé, H. Palombo +6 more
It is hoped that more modern cancer education will lead to the gradual elimination of this taboo in the authors' society and the mandatory uniform disclosure of the true diagnosis is not likely to be constructive at present.
Respiratory MedicineCommunicating the diagnosis of lung cancer
64 Citations1993Lea Sell, Bernie Devlin +4 more
In general, patients wanted to be told their diagnosis truthfully and required a high level of information, and felt reassured by the discussion of such details.
Social Science & MedicineThe patient's right to information in Japan—Legal rules and doctor's opinions
57 Citations1991Hiroyuki Hattori, Stephan M. Salzberg +4 more
It was found that when Japanese physicians were faced with special cases such as prior to administering high-risk diagnostic procedures, prior to disclosing the presence of cancer in their patients, or when faced with patients unwilling to receive treatment, the involvement of the patient's family members in the decision-making process was preferred so as not to aggravate the patients' emotional anxiety.
General Hospital PsychiatryFamily dynamics in end-of-life treatment decisions
41 Citations1994Ellen Rothchild
Understanding the range of factors--internal and external, confronting the individual members and the family as a whole--that can influence family responses helps in working with families at this critical juncture in an illness.
The Hastings Center ReportMedical Ethics the Japanese Way
40 Citations1985Eric A. Feldman
Japanese attitudes toward a variety of specific bioethical issues, including artificial insemination by donor, in vitro fertilization followed by embryo transfer, care of handicapped newborns, brain death, organ transplantation, and truthtelling to terminally ill patients are discussed.
Social Science & MedicineSelf care: Japan and the U.S. compared
35 Citations1991Marie R. Haug, Hiroko Akiyama +3 more
Compared between Japan and the United States, experience of common symptoms and subsequent self care behaviors among older adults are compared, and perceived susceptibility to illness and belief in the efficacy of physician care were selected as major explanatory concepts for the decision to use self care for a complaint.
PubMedOlder Russian emigrés and medical care.
35 Citations1992Meryl S. Brod, Suzanne Heurtin‐Roberts
The influences of culture and aging on older emigrés' health and interaction with the American medical system are described and recommended solutions include educating emigrate and health care professionals, integrating mental health services into the primary care setting, and expanding supportive services in the community such as adult day health care.
PubMedThe French are different. French and American medicine in the context of AIDS.
10 Citations1992Jodi Feldman
Research on French and American medical perspectives on the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) challenges this view by exploring differences in the structure of health care, the physician-patient relationship, and the conceptualizations of disease, particularly AIDS.
PubMed[Notification of cancer in breast cancer patients].
8 Citations1991Kojiro Shimozuma, T Tominaga +3 more
A survey by questionnaire on the notification of cancer in 100 patients with breast cancer found that many of them were suffered from advanced cancer and a human relationship with the family and friends aggravated few of them and improved in 30% (family) and 18% (friends), respectively.
Journal of Nippon Medical SchoolA survey on informed consent. Approach to cancer treatment.
6 Citations1991Daisuke Kojima
In Japan, there is still much controversy surrounding the merits and demerits of informing patients of a cancer diagnosis, but some comparisons were made with the present situation in the U.S where informed consent for cancer therapy is generally accepted.
PubMedEthics and the oncologist.
1 Citations1993Pfeffer Mr
Several of the ethical questions in the treatment of cancer patients are discussed, particularly the issues of disclosing the diagnosis of cancer to the patient, the place of mutilative surgery and other aggressive modalities in cancer treatment, and the ethics of randomized clinical trials.