Conceptual and methodological issues in comparative studies of psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy, I: Active ingredients and mechanisms of change
American Journal of PsychiatryPublished 1 August 1988
Irene Elkin, Paul A. Pilkonis, John P. Docherty, Stuart M. Sotsky
Citations100
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score5.27
SNIP3.68
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Issues addressed include the need for standardization of treatments, adequate delivery of treatment, and controlling for factors other than the active ingredients of each treatment.
Abstract
There has recently been an increased focus on comparing the effectiveness of drugs and psychotherapy in the treatment of mental disorders. The marked differences between these two treatment forms raise many conceptual and methodological problems for the investigator. In a two-part series, the authors discuss a number of these conceptual issues and their implications for research design, implementation, and interpretation of findings. Part I focuses on differences in the active ingredients and hypothesized mechanisms of change of psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy. Issues addressed include the need for standardization of treatments, adequate delivery of treatments, and controlling for factors other than the active ingredients of each treatment.
Keywords
PsychologyMedicine
The psychotherapeutic process: A research handbook.
1,397 Citations1986Leslie S. Greenberg, William M. Pinsof
Archives of General PsychiatryNIMH Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research Program
523 Citations1985Irene Elkin
The background of the TDCRP, the rationale for the choice of patient population and treatment conditions, and the research plan for both the training/pilot phase and the outcome study currently in progress are presented and the potential contributions of the program to the field of psychotherapy research are discussed.
American Journal of PsychiatryThe Efficacy of Drugs and Psychotherapy in the Treatment of Acute Depressive Episodes
388 Citations1979Myrna M. Weissman, Brigitte A. Prusoff +4 more
It was found that pharmacotherapy and psychotherapy alone were equally efficacious and better than nonscheduled treatment and the combination treatment of psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy was more effective than either treatment alone and delayed the onset of symptomatic failure.
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseTwo Helping Alliance Methods for Predicting Outcomes of Psychotherapy
297 Citations1983Lester Luborsky, Paul Crits-Christoph +3 more
The main findings were: these types of statements were found to be “scorable” with moderate interjudge agreement, and basic background similarities between patient and therapist, such as in age and religious activity, attained highest correlations with the helping alliance measure.
American Journal of OrthopsychiatryExpectations of psychotherapy in patients of lower socioeconomic class.
211 Citations1963Betty Overall, H. Aronson
It was found that the greater the discrepancy between expectation and perception of the interview, the less likely the patient was to return for treatment.
American Journal of PsychiatryTherapeutic alliance scales: development and relationship to psychotherapy outcome
134 Citations1981Elsa Marziali, Charles R. Marmar +1 more
The authors describe the development of patient and therapist alliance scales and their application to the therapies of selected patients with good and poor outcomes following brief psychodynamic psychotherapy, and support the value of separating the contributions to the therapeutic alliance made individually by the therapist and the patient.
PsychopharmacologyDrug, doctor's verbal attitude and clinic setting in the symptomatic response to pharmacotherapy
123 Citations1966E. H. Uhlenhuth, Karl Rickels +4 more
Some striking clinic differences among the characteristics of patients were found, particularly in social class status and the commonly associated styles of complaint and goals and expectations regarding treatment, including with the enthusiastic doctors and the skeptical doctors.
Archives of General PsychiatrySpecific vs Nonspecific Factors in Psychotherapy and the Problem of Control
50 Citations1970Hans H. Strupp
This communication represents a renewed attempt to examine the nature of the psychotherapeutic influence and to point the way toward investigative efforts designed to elucidate the relative contributions of techniques and nonspecific interpersonal factors.
American PsychologistPlanning of research on effectiveness of psychotherapy.
45 Citations1970Donald W. Fiske, Howard F. Hunt +5 more
A M A Archives of Neurology & PsychiatryDrop-Out from Outpatient Psychiatric Treatment
27 Citations1958Norbert Freedman
The patient who drops out of treatment after a few visits constitutes a challenge to the understanding of him and to the ability to provide effective treatment services.
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseTHERAPEUTIC STYLE AND ATTRITION RATE FROM PSYCHIATRIC DRUG TREATMENT
24 Citations1970K.R. Howard, Karl Rickels +4 more
It was suggested that the therapists' approach to treatment might fruitfully be described in terms of a bipolar continuum, ranging from activity to passivity, even in situations where drugs are considered to be the central treatment agent and the population consists of low socioeconomic class patients.
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseSOME FACTORS INFLUENCING THE TREATMENT EXPECTATIONS OF ANXIOUS NEUROTIC OUTPATIENTS
16 Citations1967Henrietta V. Williams, Ronald S. Lipman +4 more