Can we improve on how we select medical students?
Journal of the Royal Society of MedicinePublished 1 January 2002Open access
Patricia Hughes
Citations69
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Keywords
Social SciencesMedicine
Psychological BulletinThe validity and utility of selection methods in personnel psychology: Practical and theoretical implications of 85 years of research findings.
3,951 Citations1998Frank L. Schmidt, John E. Hunter
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyInfluence of extraversion and neuroticism on subjective well-being: Happy and unhappy people.
2,095 Citations1980Paul T. Costa, Robert R. McCrae
Psychological BulletinValidity and utility of alternative predictors of job performance.
1,467 Citations1984John E. Hunter, Ronda F. Hunter
Journal of Applied PsychologyComprehensive meta-analysis of integrity test validities: Findings and implications for personnel selection and theories of job performance.
1,069 Citations1993Deniz S. Öneş, Chockalingam Viswesvaran +1 more
Journal of Applied PsychologyThe validity of employment interviews: A comprehensive review and meta-analysis.
682 Citations1994Michael A. McDaniel, Deborah L. Whetzel +2 more
European Journal of EducationOrigins and Destinations: Family, Class and Education in Modern Britain
530 Citations1980Roger L. Geiger, A. H. Halsey +2 more
New England Journal of MedicineSome Psychologic Vulnerabilities of Physicians
440 Citations1972George E. Vaillant, Nancy Corbin Sobowale +1 more
Journal of GerontologyPersonal Adjustment to Aging: Longitudinal Prediction from Neuroticism and Extraversion
140 Citations1981Paul T. Costa, Robert R. McCrae +1 more
It was shown that enduring personality disposition antedate and predict measures of personal adjustment to aging and that "Thinking Introversion" was related only to positive attitudes toward religion.
BMJThe objective structured interview for medical student selection
129 Citations1988David Powis, Roderick Neame +2 more
The interview as a whole, and especially some of the subscales, appears to identify students who may fail to complete the course: it may also help to predict which students are likely to graduate with honours.
Academic MedicineTraditional predictors of performance in medical school
129 Citations1990Karen Mitchell
Reported validity data affirm the substantial value of traditional academic predictors of performance in medical school, and medical schools should assess the validity of their selection systems.
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyLongitudinal consistency of adult personality: Self-reported psychological characteristics across 45 years.
103 Citations1984James J. Conley
JAMAAffirmative Action and Other Special Consideration Admissions at the University of California, Davis, School of Medicine
91 Citations1997Robert C. Davidson
An admissions process that allows for ethnicity and other special characteristics to be used heavily in admission decisions yields powerful effects on the diversity of the student population and shows no evidence of diluting the quality of the graduates.
Journal of Consulting and Clinical PsychologyPersonality stability and change over a 30-year period--middle age to old age.
90 Citations1979Gloria R. Leon, Brenda Gillum +2 more
Academic MedicineWhen are students most at risk of encountering academic difficulty? A study of the 1992 matriculants to U.S. medical schools
88 Citations1999Kristen Huff, Di Fang
The results confirm previous findings that increased risk of academic difficulty is associated with low MCAT scores, low science GPA, low undergraduate institutional selectivity, being a woman, being of a racial-ethnic underrepresented minority, or being older.
Academic MedicineAcademic and personal predictors of clinical success in medical school
86 Citations1978Rhiannon Murden, G. Galloway +2 more
Analysis of admissions interview data and college academic credentials of University of Missouri-Columbia medical students suggested that additional emphasis during selection upon applicants' personal characteristics would have enhanced the clinical success of these students.
The LancetTime for a review of admission to medical school?
83 Citations1995Isobel Rolfe, Sallie‐Anne Pearson +2 more
Admission criteria that may predict performance in the first postgraduate (intern) year were identified and students who had earlier studied both humanities and science were twice as likely to complete their medical degree as those who had studied science alone.
BMJProspective survey of performance of medical students during preclinical years.
78 Citations1986I. C. McManus, Peter Richards
The performance during the preclinical course of 517 students who had applied to this medical school for admission in 1981 and who had been accepted by the school or by another British medical school was analysed in relation to variables measured at the time of application to find factors that predicted success in the pre clinical course.
Medical EducationAcademic selection criteria and subsequent performance
66 Citations1990William E. Montague, Frank C. Odds
Academic MedicineThe Ability of a Medical School Admission Process to Predict Clinical Performance and Patientʼs Satisfaction
63 Citations2000William T. Basco, Gregory E. Gilbert +2 more
The admission ranking and interview process at this medical school did not predict clinical performance or patients' satisfaction on this OSCE.
Medical EducationShould medical students be selected only from recent school‐leavers who have studied science?
63 Citations1992Roderick Neame, David Powis +1 more
Investigation of the apparently widespread belief that aspiring candidates must have a sound academic background based predominantly on the study of the natural sciences, be school‐leavers aged about 18 and preferably be men offers no support for the current selection criteria dominating medical school admissions processes.
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related ResearchPredictors of Success in Medicine
61 Citations1999Joan Y. Reede
Even though underrepresented minority applicants to medical school tend to have lower grade point averages and Medical College Admission Test scores than majority applicants, ultimate success in postgraduate training and as practicing physicians is equivalent to that attained by majority students.
Academic MedicineSubjective and objective admissions factors as predictors of clinical clerkship performance
54 Citations1982Keith Meredith, Margaret Reed Dunlap +1 more
Objective and subjective measures are distinct, identifiable structures both at admission and during the third year of medical school, and prediction formulas will vary depending on what outcome variables are chosen.
Medical EducationSelecting medical students: a case report of the need for change
49 Citations1999Marley, Carman
To review the selection of medical students by academic score alone, a comparison of the results of the A-level and B-schools in the United States over a 25-year period from 1993 to 2002 is suggested.
Medical EducationMedical training and English language proficiency
43 Citations1993Susan Hayes, Douglas Farnill
English proficiency was found to be consistently correlated with first‐ and second‐year university results and initiatives taken to support students with language disadvantages and to ensure that graduates will be able to communicate effectively with patients are outlined.
Australian and New Zealand Journal of MedicineThe structured interview as a tool for predicting premature withdrawal from medical school
41 Citations1992David Powis, T. Bristow +2 more
Whether comments written about a candidate during a semi-structured interview can identify students likely to withdraw from a medical course better than global numerical scores is assessed.
BMJWhat patients want from their doctors
40 Citations2003Malcolm Stone
Patients want many things from their doctors, not all of which are possible, and which should be possible.
JAMAMedical Students From Natural Science and Nonscience Undergraduate Backgrounds
39 Citations1980R. L. Dickman
It is suggested that admissions committees, premedical advisors, and students reconsider their attitudes about the necessity of concentration in the natural sciences before entering medical school.
Medical EducationEntry to medical school: an audit of traditional selection requirements
36 Citations1995Jo Collins, G R White +1 more
A longitudinal study of 413 successful applicants found a correlation between overall marks in the school‐leaving examination and the annual Grade Point Averages and no predictions could be made on the basis of overall marks.
Academic MedicineCognitive and noncognitive predictors of academic difficulty and attrition
36 Citations1997Liza Cariaga-Lo, C E Enarson +3 more
Medical EducationMedical school entrants: semi‐structured interview ratings, prior scholastic achievement and personality profiles
35 Citations1993P. J. M. Tutton
Interview ratings are analysed in relation to both prior scholastic results and scores obtained on the CPI, suggesting that the CPI could be advantageously used as another component of the selection process.
Medical EducationPremedical training, personal characteristics and performance in medical school
35 Citations1981Mary W. Herman, J. Jon Veloski
It was concluded that all groups had adequate science preparation for medical school, and there was no greater risk of producing doctors with low levels of clinical competence associated with accepting students from groups with lower science performance.
Academic MedicineComparison of medical school performances and career plans of students with broad and with science-focused premedical preparation
34 Citations1992Judith Anderson Koenig
A method for classifying students according to the breadth of their premedical preparation is useful and that the students with less premedical focus in the sciences were able to perform well, and a comparison of the medical school performances and career plans of the students thus classified is reported.
Academic MedicineAssessing correlations between black and white studentsʼ perceptions of the medical school learning environment, their academic performances, and their well-being
34 Citations1989Gregory Strayhorn, Henry T. Frierson
There were important differences between black and white medical students' perceptions of the medical school's learning environment and the predictors of their academic success and mental and social well-being that should be considered when resources are developed to assist students with their academic performance and the maintenance of their social and mental well- Being.
Academic MedicineOlder medical studentsʼ performances at McGill University
34 Citations1998D. Feil, Michelle Kristian +1 more
Different scores in admission criteria suggest that McGill uses different standards to select older medical students, and older students admitted under different criteria do just as well as do younger students by their clinical years.
Medical EducationSelecting candidates for a medical school: an evaluation of a selection model based on cognitive and personality predictors
32 Citations1988Michal Weiss, Ilana Lotan +2 more
Two studies were conducted to attempt to evaluate the selection procedures used in Hadassah Medical School and the predictors assessed were the Israeli high school matriculation examinations, a general aptitude test, an interview and a semi‐projective test designed to assess personality pathology.
Medical EducationThe relative role of ‘A’ level chemistry, physics and biology in the medical course
31 Citations1977R. W. S. Tomlinson, Gillian B Clack +3 more
The performance of 209 students in the 2nd MBBS, first clinical year and final MBBS examinations has been compared retrospectively with their grades in chemistry, physics and biology at ‘A’ level.
BMJReliability of interviewing in medical student selection
30 Citations1988Peter Richards, I. C. McManus +1 more
Six interviewing panels which had assessed candidates for places at a medical school in 1984 were reconvened in 1987 to assess videotapes of the interviews conducted by themselves and by other panels, and showed excellent reliability within panels and high reliability between panels.
BMJIntake, output, and drop out in United Kingdom medical schools: Table 1
30 Citations1996James Parkhouse
Comparison shows differences of 9-56 in the annual intake numbers for 1990-3 over all UK medical schools.
PubMedThe impact of nonacademic variables on performance at two medical schools.
28 Citations1997Carmen T. Webb, William E. Sedlacek +5 more
This study investigated the relationship between nonacademic variables and performance at two very different medical schools by administering the Noncognitive Questionnaire to 104 students at School A and 102 at School B.
Medical EducationA structured panel interview and group exercise in the selection of medical students
25 Citations1995Jo Collins, G R White +2 more
The authors have developed a process to assess the personal attributes of applicants that included a structured panel interview carried out twice on each applicant by independent interviewers and a group exercise in which several applicants were observed whilst discussing a problem.
Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of LondonSelection of Medical Students at McMaster University
25 Citations1978B. M. Ferrier, Ronald G. McAuley +1 more
The aims are that the graduates of McMaster's MD programme will have acquired or developed the knowledge, abilities, and attitudes necessary to qualify for further education in any medical career.
BMJChoosing tomorrow's doctors
25 Citations1996S. Goldbeck-Wood
Being good at science is now far more likely to be quoted as a reason for applying to medical school than in 1966, even though selectors themselves agree that these academic requirements far exceed what is needed to be able to complete the course.
Hospital TopicsPersonality Antecedents of Burnout among Middle-aged Physicians
25 Citations1989Edward W. McCranie, Jeffrey M. Brandsma
Results revealed that higher burnout scores were significantly correlated with a number of standard and special MMPI scales measuring low self-esteem, feelings of inadequacy, dysphoria and obsessive worry, passivity, social anxiety, and withdrawal from others.
BMJDrop out rate in medical schools seems reasonable
23 Citations1996I. C. McManus
The drop out rate from medical schools in the United Kingdom ranges “from 11.7% to 14.1%.” if true, this suggests serious problems.
Medical EducationSchool results as predictors of medical school achievement
21 Citations1988A. Lipton, G. J. Huxham +1 more
In Queensland, scores in the final 2 years of secondary school scaled by an independent aptitude test are used to determine admission to tertiary education and the validity of this procedure for medical school enrolment has been investigated.
Journal of the Royal Society of MedicineMedical Student Selection – Time for Change: Discussion Paper
21 Citations1989G D Roberts, Alice Porter
In the United Kingdom, medical student selection is based on the information contained on UCCA forms and usually an interview, while a young man expressing an interest in a short service commission in the British Army is subjected to a prolonged selection procedure.
Academic MedicinePredicting academic performance at a predominantly black medical school
19 Citations1986D G Johnson, Steven Lloyd +2 more
The competitiveness of the undergraduate college attended was found to contribute significantly to the prediction of all measures of medical school performance, including grade-point average and GPA.
Academic MedicineGender differences in predictors of performance in medical training
18 Citations1987E V Calkins, Leslie Arnold +1 more
Academic MedicinePredicting the medical school progress of minority students who participated in a preparatory program
17 Citations1989S McGlinn, Evelyn W. Jackson
Although those retained had higher SPC ratings than those not retained, stepwise regression revealed that none of the variables predicted retention, and the MCAT Reading score was the only significant predictor of progress.
The Medical Journal of AustraliaOn our selection: predictors of medical school success
13 Citations1993Gordon Parker
To review predictors of academic success in one Australian medical course, a large number of indicators were found to be related to prior academic success.
Academic MedicineRelationship of medical studentsʼ admission interview scores to their deanʼs letter ratings
10 Citations1992Frances R. Hall, Martha Regan-Smith +1 more
It is suggested that admission interview scores help schools to identify more clearly those applicants most likely to become strong, competitive performers in residency and that the significant relationship between interview scores and dean's letter ratings indicates a need to discover what qualities the interview actually measures.
Psychological ReportsRelationship between Locus of Control and Performance on the National Board of Medical Examiners, Part I, among Black Medical Students
10 Citations1993Carmen T. Webb, Fredericka E. Waugh +1 more
An internal locus of control was correlated with test performance, whereas the more traditional index of the Medical College Admissions Test was not.
Psychological ReportsThe Structured Interview: A Selection Device
9 Citations1972Michael Burgess, V Calkins +1 more
The structured interview results were related to the admissions decision and the influence on admissions decisions of interviewer recommendations (by both physicians and non-physicians) was low.