Unequal to the task: deprivation, health and UK general practice at the millennium.
PubMedPublished 1 June 2001Open access
Norman Beale
Citations35
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The NHS is over 50 years old, but health inequalities remain prevalent in the United Kingdom (UK), and social deprivation is becoming worse while the markers of socioeconomic disadvantage remain unsatisfactory.
Abstract
The NHS is over 50 years old, but health inequalities remain prevalent in the United Kingdom (UK). Material deprivation may be less apparent; however, social deprivation is becoming worse while the markers of socioeconomic disadvantage remain unsatisfactory. Health is an even more elusive concept; nevertheless, the evidence for an increasing association between deprivation, poor health, and early death is overwhelming. Equally unavoidable is the impact of this social degradation on UK primary care. Service industries have deserted deprived communities but, on the whole, GPs struggle on. Denied the supplementary resources they deserve they become disenchanted, too exhausted to convert incentives into rewards. Clear-headed strategic thinking from the top brass is overdue.
Keywords
Social SciencesHealth ProfessionsEconomics, Econometrics and Finance
The Economic JournalPoverty: A Study of Town Life.
1,956 Citations1902L. L. Price, B. Seebohm Rowntree
Social Science & MedicineOn the measurement of inequalities in health
1,734 Citations1991Adam Wagstaff, Pierella Paci +1 more
It is suggested that only two methods--the slope index of inequality and the concentration index--are likely to present an accurate picture of socioeconomic inequalities in health.
DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals)Health and Deprivation: Inequality and the North
1,388 Citations1987Peter Townsend, Peter Phillimore +1 more
BMJIncome distribution and life expectancy.
1,184 Citations1992Richard G. Wilkinson
There is clear evidence of a strong relation between a societys income distribution and the average life expectancy of its population.
BMJThe NHS plan
954 Citations2000J. H. Dixon
The single most important part of the NHS plan is the cash injection to boost capacity, which to anyone who has worked in frontline care, is manna (leaving aside for the moment questions of how and when).
BMJLifetime socioeconomic position and mortality: prospective observational study
623 Citations1997George Davey Smith, Carole Hart +3 more
Assessment of the influence of socioeconomic position over a lifetime on risk factors for cardiovascular disease, on morbidity, and on mortality from various causes found participants' social class at the time of screening was more strongly associated than the other social class indicators with mortality from cancer and from non-cardiovascular, non-cancer causes.
BMJJoining together to combat poverty
607 Citations2000Andy Haines
This editorial has already been published in the BMJ (2000;320:1–2) and on Medscape and it is hoped that a version will appear in many other medical journals and the greater the likely impact of the network.
BMJUnderprivileged areas: validation and distribution of scores.
425 Citations1984B Jarman
Underprivileged areas were identified by weighting several census variables that relate to social conditions, by using weights determined by means of a questionnaire sent to one in 10 of the general practitioners in the United Kingdom, to indicate where problems occur for general practitioners and to extend this work to other primary health care workers.
BMJHigher mortality in deprived areas: community or personal disadvantage?
398 Citations1994Andrew Sloggett, Heather Joshi
The excess mortality associated with residence in areas designated as deprived by census based indicators is wholly explained by the concentration in those areas of people with adverse personal or household socioeconomic factors.
The widening gap: Health inequalities and policy in Britain
292 Citations1999Mary Shaw, Daniel Dorling +2 more
BMJSocioeconomic differences in childhood consultation rates in general practice in England and Wales: prospective cohort study
111 Citations1999Sonia Saxena, Azeem Majeed +1 more
Childhood consultation rates for episodes of illness increase from social classes I-II through to classes IV-V, and the findings on severity of underlying illness suggest the health ofChildren from lower social classes is worse than that of children from higher social classes.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthAn additional dimension to health inequalities: disease severity and socioeconomic position.
105 Citations1999Jenny Eachus, Philip V Chan +3 more
The poorest sector of the population seem to be in double jeopardy: they not only experience a greater burden of chronic morbidity but also a greater severity of hip disease, which has implications for health care provision.
BMJDesigning a deprivation payment for general practitioners: the UPA(8) wonderland.
99 Citations1991Roy Carr‐Hill, T. Sheldon
The formula used as the basis of the deprived area payments is poorly suited to the policy objective of compensating general practitioners for increases in workload and more research is urgently needed to enable the effect of the payment to be monitored and a more empirically sound set of incentives to be developed.
Social Science & MedicineIs general practitioner decision making associated with patient socio-economic status?
96 Citations1996Anthony Scott, Alan Shiell +1 more
International Journal of EpidemiologySocioeconomic Inequalities in Coronary Heart Disease and Stroke Mortality among Australian Men, 1979–1993
95 Citations1996Stan Bennett
Socioeconomic inequalities in CHD mortality continued to widen during the early 1980s, stabilized thereafter and persisted into the 1990s; decreases in blood pressure and smoking prevalence contributed most to declines in coronary risk and to socioeconomic differentials.
BMJ“I'm all right, John”: voting patterns and mortality in England and Wales, 1981–92
91 Citations1996George Davey Smith, Daniel Dorling
Conservative and Labour voting are at least as strongly associated with mortality as is a standard deprivation index, and may add information above that provided by indicators of material deprivation.
Journal of General Internal MedicineThe influence of social class on health status
90 Citations1995Oliver Fein
Clinicians and teachers in internal medicine should incorporate this knowledge in assessing patients and adopt a perspective that takes account of socioeconomic factors in diagnostic and management decisions.
BMJSocioeconomic differentials in wealth and health.
84 Citations1993George Davey Smith, Matthias Egger
Evidence is emerging that increasing mortality differentials have accompanied the social polarisation of the Thatcher years, and redistributive social policies resulted in increasing disparities in wealth and material wellbeing.
BMJUnemployment rates: an alternative to the Jarman index?
82 Citations1991Doug Campbell, J M Radford +1 more
The Jarman index seems to be the least appropriate of these indices for health authority use, and unemployment rate merits further consideration as a simple, up to date marker for deprivation and consequent need for health service provision.
American Journal of EpidemiologySocial Class and Cancer Patient Survival in Finland
81 Citations1995Anssi Auvinen, Sakari Karjalainen +1 more
Findings indicate that social class is an important determinant of cancer patient survival and additional research is required to clarify the etiology of the social class differences and to identify factors that could be used for developing strategies to diminish such inequalities.
BMJPractice based health needs assessment: use of four methods in a small neighbourhood
78 Citations1995Scott Murray, Lesley J C Graham
An extended primary care team with public health support can assess health and health care needs in a neighbourhood by means of a mixture of quantitative and qualitative methods.
PubMedFrom the surgery to the surgeon: does deprivation influence consultation and operation rates?
75 Citations1995Nish Chaturvedi, Yoav Ben‐Shlomo
There are marked socioeconomic differences in consultation ratios for these common conditions which may not be matched by operation ratios, and people in the most deprived quartiles were generally least likely to receive surgery despite being most likely to consult a general practitioner with symptoms.
Archives of Disease in ChildhoodDeprivation and bronchiolitis.
74 Citations1996Nick Spencer, Stuart Logan +2 more
Residence in an area of social and material deprivation increases the risk of admission with bronchiolitis even after taking account of parental smoking and when only more severe cases were considered.
BMJDivided we fall
73 Citations1994Richard G. Wilkinson
The research reported by Phillimore and colleagues suggests that the more deprived sections of the population have paid a heavy price for the official failure to take the social causes of disease seriously.
BMJUnderprivileged areas and health care planning: implications of use of Jarman indicators of urban deprivation.
71 Citations1991Robert J. Talbot
The Jarman index underprivileged area score is an inappropriate measure to use for health care planning and distribution of resources and there is a need for a revised measure for allocating deprivation payments to general practitioners.
BMJAggression and violent behaviour in general practice: population based survey in the north of England
70 Citations2000Andy Ness
To estimate accurately the current frequency of incidents of aggression towards general practitioners, a survey of general practitioners working in a health authority in the north of England was undertaken.
International Journal of EpidemiologyPremature Cardiovascular Mortality in France: Divergent Evolution between Social Categories from 1970 to 1990
69 Citations1995Thierry Lang, Pierre Ducimetière
In men, the inequalities have increased over the last two decades for CHD and have not been reduced for CVD, and the category of employees and workers were found to be at special risk for premature cardiovascular disease mortality.
BMJPrimary and secondary care management of women with early breast cancer from affluent and deprived areas: retrospective review of hospital and general practice records
65 Citations2000Una Macleod
Women living in affluent areas did not receive better NHS care for breast cancer than women in deprived areas, however, women from deprived areas seem to have greater comorbidity, and poorer outcomes from breast cancer among these women is probably due to factors which result in deprived communities having poorer health outcomes.
BMJRelation of out of hours activity by general practice and accident and emergency services with deprivation in Nottingham: longitudinal survey
60 Citations1998R. Carlisle, Lindsay Groom +3 more
High general practice and high accident and emergency activity occurred in the same areas rather than one service substituting for the other, with a disproportionate amount of out of hours workload fell on deprived inner city practices.
BMJAttempt at deriving a formula for setting general practitioner fundholding budgets
59 Citations1994T. Sheldon, Peter Smith +3 more
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthPrediction of general practice workload from census based social deprivation scores.
59 Citations1992Yoav Ben‐Shlomo, Ian R. White +1 more
The Jarman index is less valid than other census based scores because it fails to include car ownership and housing tenure and a more rational scheme for compensating general practitioners would directly weight the capitation fee for children aged under five years and allocate current deprivation payments according to the Townsend index or a similar score.
BMJSecond thoughts on the Jarman index.
59 Citations1991George Davey Smith
The Jarman index was introduced in 1983' as the latest of a series of attempts to identify underprivileged areas for the purposes of health care planning and it has been treated as a marker of deprivation in the consideration of social inequalities in health.
BMJThe effect of deprivation on variations in general practitioners' referral rates: a cross sectional study of computerised data on new medical and surgical outpatient referrals in Nottinghamshire
57 Citations1997Julia Hippisley‐Cox, C Hardy +4 more
Significant associations exist between deprivation as measured by the UPA(8) score and high total referral rates and high medical referral rates.
BMJChange in general practice and its effects on service provision in areas with different socioeconomic characteristics
56 Citations1995B Leese, Nick Bosanquet
The evidence suggests that generally the urban and inner city practices still lag behind practices in rural and suburban areas in terms of practice structure and service provision, although practices in all areas have shown a strong response to the new incentives.
BMJDeprivation and general practitioner workload.
56 Citations1992R Balarajan, Peter P. Yuen +1 more
This deprivation index for general practice overcomes several shortcomings expressed about the underprivileged area score, which has been adopted in the 1990 contract as a basis for allocating deprivation supplements to general practitioners and can be applied nationwide.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthSocioeconomic factors and mortality in urban settings: the case of Barcelona, Spain.
56 Citations1995Carme Borrell, A Arias
The higher the unemployment and illiteracy levels and the older the cars, the greater the comparative mortality figure and ratio of potential years of life lost, and the lower the life expectancy (negative correlations).
BMJCounting the cost of social disadvantage in primary care: retrospective analysis of patient data
55 Citations1997Adrian Worrall, José Rea +1 more
The greater workload caused by social disadvantage has been previously underestimated by simple consultation rates and the absolute difference in costs for socially disadvantaged patients increases as more detailed measures of workload and drug treatment are included.
International Journal of EpidemiologySocioeconomic status within social class and mortality: a prospective study in middle-aged British men
54 Citations1997S. Goya Wannamethee, A G Shaper
Mortality differences within society are greater than indicated by social class based on occupation alone, and men with greater material assets have lower rates of mortality from all causes than men less well endowed, independent of a wide range of lifestyle and biological factors.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthSocial class and cancer survival in Turin, Italy.
53 Citations1997Stefano Rosso, Fabrizio Faggiano +2 more
BMJUsing data from the 1991 census
52 Citations1995Azeem Majeed, Derek G. Cook +2 more
An important innovation of the 1991 census was that the census form included a question on the postcode of respondents that allowed the Office of Population Censuses and Surveys to produce a postcode-enumeration district look up table which overcomes many of the problems previously encountered in trying to assign postcodes to enumeration districts.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthTotal and occupationally active life expectancies in relation to social class and marital status in men classified as healthy at 20 in Finland.
52 Citations1996Jaakko Kaprio, Seppo Sarna +2 more
The social class gradient known to exist for mortality is also present for occupational disability in men classified as healthy as young adults, and social class and marital status differences in mortality are already evident in early adulthood and continue into old age.
BMJAllocating census data to general practice populations: implications for study of prescribing variation at practice level
50 Citations1995G. Scrivener, D. C. Lloyd
Although predicted values correlated with actual values were significant for all four allocation procedures, the failure of the allocation procedures to correctly predict values casts doubt on the validity of similar techniques for allocating census variables to general practice populations.
BMJLow income scheme index: a new deprivation scale based on prescribing in general practice
49 Citations1995D. C. Lloyd, Conrad M Harris +1 more
A new deprivation index based on the percentage of prescribed items exempt from the prescription charge under the low income scheme is described and validated at both family health services authority and practice level, and at practice level the results are sufficiently encouraging to warrant further research.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthLevels of mortality, education, and social conditions in the 107 local education authority areas of England.
49 Citations1996J.N. Morris, David Blane +1 more
Area levels of both educational attainment and deprivation-affluence are strong correlates of local mortality rates in England and educational attainment may be indexing the general cultural level of a community.
BMJBetter ways of assessing health needs in primary care
42 Citations1995J. Shanks, Sean Kheraj +1 more
Needs assessment has become an important task for public health doctors and others working in commissioning authorities, and a more rational and scientific method is put forward as an improvement over the former approach to allocating health funding.
International Journal of EpidemiologySocial Inequality in Mortality in São Paulo State, Brazil
36 Citations1995Bruce Bartholow Duncan, Davi Rumel +4 more
Data support the contention that mortality for Brazilian adults, even more so than for adults of the world's more economically developed nations, is inextricably bound to the issue of social equity.
BMJHealth inequalities in women and men
33 Citations2000Denny Vågerö
Health inequalities in women and men : studies of specific causes of death should use household criteria and not general cause of death criteria.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyInequalities in health in intensive care patients
32 Citations1991Jos Maria Latour
There is an inverse relationship between SES and ICU mortality, and the mortality excess in the low SES patients is largely accounted for by the covariates of the high SES (especially their high age and severity of illness on admission).
BMJDeprivation payments to general practitioners: limitations of census data
32 Citations1996Azeem Majeed, David Martín +1 more
The census data from which deprivation payments have been calculated since June 1995 suffer from limitations including underenumeration; under counting of homeless people and refugees, and artefactual errors because of the way in which the 1991 census data were tabulated.
BMJHealth action zones
32 Citations1998B. Jacobson, Leong Yen
Is the health action zone initiative likely to succeed in its challenging aims of creating and sustaining partnerships to reduce inequalities and improve the clinical effectiveness and cost effectiveness of services?
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthSocioeconomic circumstances and the risk of bowel cancer in Northern Ireland.
29 Citations1996Frank Kee, Richard H. Wilson +5 more
In this population, the colorectal cancer incidence is associated with the level of material deprivation and the disease stages at the time of diagnosis in patients from more deprived areas seem to be comparable with those of patients from affluent areas.
BMJComparison of two scores for allocating resources to doctors in deprived areas.
28 Citations1989A Hutchinson, C Foy +1 more
Two methods of identifying deprived populations--the underprivileged area score and the material deprivation score--were compared to determine whether they result in similar allocation of resources to regions.
BMJCatchment areas in general practice and their relation to size and quality of practice and deprivation: a descriptive study in one London borough
24 Citations1996Claire Jenkins, John Campbell
Large variations exist in the size of catchment areas of inner city practices even when corrected for numbers of doctors and patients, and these differences are associated with variations in quality of care.
BMJDeprivation payments revisited (again)
23 Citations1996Russell Hobbs, Timothy J. Cole
The short report in this week's BMJ models the effects of applying census data to the existing rigid formula for allocating deprivation awards and finds a lottery of winners and losers has been predicted since the introduction of deprivation payments.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthDoes increased investment in coronary angiography and revascularisation reduce socioeconomic inequalities in utilisation?
22 Citations1999C. J. Manson-Siddle, Michael B. Robinson
Early indications are that additional resources for tertiary cardiology may have reduced socioeconomic inequities in angiography, without being specifically targeted at the needier, more deprived groups.
PubMedCalculation of the underprivileged area score for a practice in inner London.
21 Citations1991Hannah Chase, Philip Davies
A study was undertaken in a London inner city practice to determine an underprivileged area score for the practice based on information derived from questionnaires completed by 773 patients, highlighting the differing workloads of practices in the same area and provides a means by which to make comparisons between practices.
BMJSocioeconomic variation in hysterectomy up to age 52: national, population based, prospective cohort study
19 Citations2000Suzanne Marshall
This study examined whether the social gradient in hysterectomy attenuated among women between the ages of 43 and 52 years, and found that it did not.
PubMedGeneral practice in deprived areas: problems and solutions.
19 Citations1993Adrian Hastings, Aly Rashid
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthGeneral practice consultation in childhood in The Netherlands: sociodemographic variation.
18 Citations1995Marc Bruijnzeels, Johannes C. van der Wouden +1 more
Data for children 0 to 14 years from the Dutch national survey of morbidity and interventions in general practice, carried out by The Netherlands Institute of Primary Health Care (NIVEL) between April 1987 and March 1988 is used.
BMJHigh and low incomes in general practice.
18 Citations1989B Leese, Nick Bosanquet
In a study on general practice the distribution of high and low incomes was assessed, and high income practices were more likely to be larger, to have younger partners, and to be located in affluent areas.
The LancetLooking beyond the next patient: sociology and modern health care
17 Citations1999Jiri Chard, Richard Lilford +1 more
In this review, some of the major areas of health sociology are summarized, and how many of these areas have been incorporated into clinical practice in the past decade are shown.
PubMedHow much does self-reported health status, measured by the SF-36, vary between electoral wards with different Jarman and Townsend scores?
17 Citations2000Patricia Marsh, R. Carlisle +1 more
Only two of the eight SF-36 domains were significantly associated with Jarman scores, whereas seven domains were associated with the Townsend score, and unemployment showed the weakest association.
PubMedProviding census data for general practice. 1. Feasibility.
13 Citations1987A Hutchinson, C Foy +1 more
In a feasibility study it is shown how a population registered with a general practice may be linked through postcodes to computerized enumeration district data.
PubMedProviding census data for general practice. 2. Usefulness.
13 Citations1987Christopher Foy, Allen Hutchinson +1 more
Computerized census data are described in relation to a general practice population with particular reference to developing a profile of the practice and to planning prevention and anticipatory care.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthPredicting the workload in urban general practice in The Netherlands from Jarman's indicators of deprivation at patient level.
13 Citations1996Sijmen A. Reijneveld
It is concluded that most of the Jarman indicators can be used to predict Amsterdam GP workload at patient level, but that their relative weights should be adapted for this aim.
BMJA new approach to weighted capitation
13 Citations1994Ken Judge, Nicholas Mays
The allocation of resources to hospital and community health services has become progressively more complicated and controversial since the publication of the report of the Resource Allocation Working Party in 1976.
BMJCross sectional study of social variation in use of an out of hours patient transport service
12 Citations1999Catherine O’Donnell, Alex McConnachie +4 more
Out of hours primary care has undergone radical reorganisation in recent years, with increasing numbers of general practitioner cooperatives operating from primary care emergency centres, and a major issue continues to be equity of access, particularly in areas of socioeconomic deprivation.
BMJHow many general practitioners for 1433 patients?
11 Citations1995Scott Murray, Lisa Graham‐Wisener +1 more
The total number of general practitioners and partnerships with patients living in Dumbiedykes and the number of patients registered with each practice were ascertained.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthDeprivation and mortality in non-metropolitan areas of England and Wales.
11 Citations1996E. G. Jessop
There was an association between deprivation and mortality which was clear for all cause mortality, more noticeable for respiratory disease, and less clear for deaths from accident, violence, and poison.
BMJTo coin a phrase
8 Citations2000A. Alment
A few cool days in London in the summer of 1929 are supposed to have given Alexander Fleming the chance to notice penicillin; the former Department of Health and Social Security named its headquarters after him.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthA documentation centre on socioeconomic inequalities in health.
6 Citations1996Karien Stronks, H van Trirum +1 more
The number ofpublications on material/structural and behavioural/cultural explanations respectively was compared, using a selection of publications relating to empirical studies in the United Kingdom, published since 1985, and this selection elicited 40 publications on the socioeconomic distribution of structural factors, whereas for behavioural factors the corresponding number was 89.
BMJHealth costs of social injustice
6 Citations1994Mel Bartley
Reforming energy and social innovation have always been necessary for people to reap the full benefit of economic and scientific advances and the significance of last month's report by the Commission on Social Justice needs to be understood within this history of reform.
PubMedEffect of deprivation on general practitioners referral rates. Analyses should take age and sex into account.
4 Citations1997P. Sturdy, Filomena Pereira
The LancetTransformations in social medicine
3 Citations1999Dorothy Porter
In the last decades of the 20th century social medicine has become the medicine of lifestyle rather than the Medicine of the political economic and social basis of health.
BMJAre there excess Sharons in genitourinary clinics?
1 Citations1999E Foley, Fredric Willmott +3 more
Whether “Essex girls” Tracey, Sandra, and Sharon are really women of easy virtue is established, to establish whether these names are overrepresented among attenders in paediatricians' surgeries.
…