The influence of patients' concerns on surgeons' recommendations for early breast cancer
European Journal of Cancer CarePublished 1 June 2001
Z. Helen Wu, J. L. Freeman, Ann Greer, Daniel Freeman, James S. Goodwin
Citations12
SJR quartileQ2
SJR score0.74
SNIP0.88
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is concluded that surgeons integrate patients' attitudes and concerns into their treatmentRecommendations for breast cancer treatment after adjusting for surgeons' age and the surgeons' treatment preference when presented with a hypothetical patient.
Abstract
This paper examines whether an older patient's concerns about surgical treatment of breast cancer--such as fear of dying or about losing a breast--affect the treatment recommendations by their surgeons. A sample of 137 older women diagnosed with early stage breast cancer between 1994 and 1996 were interviewed within 2 months of diagnosis to determine demographic characteristics, their attitudes about breast cancer treatments, and which surgical treatment their surgeon initially recommended. The treatment preferences of the 35 surgeons treating these women were ascertained by asking them what treatment they would usually recommend to a hypothetical 75-year-old woman with early stage breast cancer. Patients who reported their feelings about losing a breast as 'very important' were less likely to be recommended mastectomy (Odds Ratio (OR) = 0.39; 95% (Confidence Interval) CI 0.16, 0.94), while patients who reported fear of dying from breast cancer as 'very important' were more likely to be recommended mastectomy (OR = 4.60; 95% CI 1.94, 11.59), after adjusting for surgeons' age and the surgeons' treatment preference when presented with a hypothetical patient. It is concluded that surgeons integrate patients' attitudes and concerns into their treatment recommendations.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
Social Science & MedicineShared decision-making in the medical encounter: What does it mean? (or it takes at least two to tango)
4,130 Citations1997Cathy Charles, Amiram Gafni +1 more
This paper attempts to provide greater conceptual clarity about shared treatment decision-making, identify some key characteristics of this model, and discuss measurement issues.
JAMAFour Models of the Physician-Patient Relationship
2,405 Citations1992Ezekiel J. Emanuel
Four models of the doctor-patient interaction are outlined, emphasizing the different understandings of the goals of the physicianpatient interaction, the physician's obligations, the role of patient values, and the conception of patient autonomy, which constitute Weberian ideal types.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Effect of Race and Sex on Physicians' Recommendations for Cardiac Catheterization
1,960 Citations1999Kevin A. Schulman, Jesse A. Berlin +11 more
It is suggested that the race and sex of a patient independently influence how physicians manage chest pain.
JAMAInformation Needs and Decisional Preferences in Women With Breast Cancer
1,116 Citations1997Lesley F. Degner
Priorities for information identified in this study provide an empirical basis to guide communication with women seeking care for breast cancer and suggest systematic approaches to assess and respond to women's desired level of participation in treatment decision making need to be evaluated.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyDecision making during serious illness: What role do patients really want to play?
1,009 Citations1992Lesley F. Degner, Jeffrey A. Sloan
It is suggested that the impact of being diagnosed with a life-threatening illness may influence preferences to participate, and the majority of patients and members of the public wanted their physician and family to share responsibility for decision making if they were too ill to participate.
Social Science & MedicinePatient participation in decision-making
798 Citations1998Edward Guadagnoli, Patricia Ward
It is proposed that methods be developed to evaluate a patient's level of "readiness" to participate in decision-making and that interventions that match the patient'slevel of readiness be applied to increase participation.
JAMAUnderutilization of Breast-Conserving Surgery and Radiation Therapy Among Women With Stage I or II Breast Cancer
367 Citations1991D Lazovich
Despite scientific evidence of the equivalent efficacy of BCS with radiation therapy and mastectomy, BCS is not performed on the majority of women with stage I or II breast cancer, and factors are associated with its use that differ from selection criteria outlined by the National Institutes of Health.
Archives of Internal MedicineAge, Sex, and Race Inequality in Renal Transplantation
293 Citations1988Carl M. Kjellstrand
Age, sex, and race imbalances in the distribution of renal transplantation only partially have a morally neutral biological, medical, social, and cultural explanation and it is believed there should be a fairer distribution of kidney transplants.
CancerInfluence of physician communication on newly diagnosed breast patients' psychologic adjustment and decision-making
285 Citations1994Cleora S. Roberts, Charles E. Cox +3 more
A research study addressed the hypothesis that patients whose surgeons used psychotherapeutic techniques during the cancer diagnostic interview would have better psychologic adjustment to their cancer.
PubMedInformation needs, sources of information, and decisional roles in women with breast cancer.
284 Citations1996Bernard Bilodeau, Lesley F. Degner
To describe preferred and actual roles in treatment decision making among women with newly diagnosed breast cancer, to describe their sources of information, and to identify and prioritize their information needs, a cross-sectional survey was conducted in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada.
Cancer NursingTreatment decision making in women newly diagnosed with breast cancer
275 Citations1996Kinta Beaver, Karen Luker +4 more
The majority of the newly diagnosed women preferred to play a passive role in treatment decision making, leaving the decision-making responsibility to their physician, whereas the benign control group preferred a collaborative role in which joint decisions could be made between the patient and the physician.
Social Science & MedicineThe physician–patient encounter: The physician as a perfect agent for the patient versus the informed treatment decision-making model
270 Citations1998Amiram Gafni, Cathy Charles +1 more
It is argued that the approach of transferring information to the patient is easier (but not easy) and, hence, more feasible than transferring each patient's preferences to the physician in each medical encounter.
CancerDeterminants of cancer therapy in elderly patients
228 Citations1993James S. Goodwin, William C. Hunt +1 more
JAMAUsers' Guides to the Medical Literature<SUBTITLE>XVI. How to Use a Treatment Recommendation</SUBTITLE>
184 Citations1999Gordon H. Guyatt
This work proposes a hierarchy of rigor of recommendations to guide clinicians when judging the usefulness of particular recommendations, and in an era in which clinicians are barraged by recommendations as to how to manage their patients, this hierarchy provides a potentially useful set of guides.
European Journal of CancerTreatment decisions in palliative cancer care: Patients' preferences for involvement and doctors' knowledge about it
144 Citations1997Dietrich Rothenbacher, Manfred P. Lutz +1 more
Most patients wanted to participate in a decision regarding their treatment, although physicians were unaware of their patients' preferences, according to a standardised questionnaire.
CancerThe influence of black race and socioeconomic status on the use of breast-conserving surgery for medicare beneficiaries
128 Citations1997Tracy A. Michalski, Ann B. Nattinger
This study explores the influence of socioeconomic status (SES) and black race on the use of breast‐conserving surgery (BCS) as opposed to mastectomy for early stage breast carcinoma.
Cancer NursingFactors women take into account when deciding upon type of surgery for breast cancer
114 Citations1989Sandra E. Ward, Susan M. Heidrich +1 more
Two factors, concerns about radiotherapy and body integrity, emerged as significantly different for women choosing BC vs. MRM, suggesting that nurses and other care providers are important in supporting women through the decision-making process.
Breast Cancer Research and TreatmentVariations in breast cancer treatment by patient and provider characteristics
96 Citations1996John Z. Ayanian, Edward Guadagnoli
Variations in local and systemic treatment of breast cancer by patient and provider characteristics may arise from insufficient knowledge of or disagreement with guidelines among physicians, inadequate communication between physicians and patients, and individual preferences or clinical attributes of patients.
Journal of Clinical OncologyUse of breast-conserving surgery for treatment of stage I and stage II breast cancer.
93 Citations1998Edward Guadagnoli, Jane C. Weeks +4 more
The rate of breast-conserving surgery in each state was higher than expected based on earlier reports, but the rates differed considerably between states.
The American Journal of SurgeryAre modified radical mastectomies done for T1 breast cancers because of surgeon's advice or patient's choice?
80 Citations1992B. Bus Tarbox, Joli K. Rockwood +1 more
Education of both surgeons and patients is needed to increase the number of patients with T1 breast lesions who can benefit from breast-conserving therapy.
Patient Education and CounselingOffering choice of surgical treatment to women with breast cancer
79 Citations1997Lesley Fallowfield
Hopes that breast conserving techniques would lead to a reduction in some of the psychosocial morbidity experienced, have not materialised and methodologically sound studies reported to date demonstrate few differences in quality of life domains between women whatever their primary surgical treatment.
American Journal of Public HealthThe role of attitudes, beliefs, and personal characteristics of Italian physicians in the surgical treatment of early breast cancer.
76 Citations1991A. Liberati, Giovanni Apolone +7 more
It is suggested that other than scientific factors guide many doctors in their decision making; they may help to explain why the diffusion of research results into clinical practice is often disappointingly slow.
British journal of surgeryBreast conservation or mastectomy: Treatment choice of women aged 70 years and older
70 Citations1996A. Sandison, Darren M. Gold +2 more
It is concluded that elderly women should be involved in deciding the treatment of their breast cancer.
Journal of Evaluation in Clinical PracticePatient, physician and presentational influences on clinical decision making for breast cancer: results from a factorial experiment*
69 Citations1997John B. McKinlay, Risa B. Burns +7 more
Results showed that physicians displayed considerable variability in response to several patient-based factors, thus confirming the complexity of the medical decision-making process.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Effect of Legislative Requirements on the Use of Breast-Conserving Surgery
66 Citations1996Ann B. Nattinger, Raymond G. Hoffmann +3 more
Legislation requiring physicians to disclose options for the treatment of breast cancer appeared to have only a slight and transient effect on the rate of use of breast-conserving surgery.
PubMedPsychosocial and functional status of breast cancer patients. The influence of diagnosis and treatment choice.
62 Citations1993Katharine Kostbade Hughes
Patients' perceptual uncertainty and various aspects of their functional status declined over the initial course of treatment, but that quality of life was unaffected and the results showed no relationship between type of breast cancer treatment and patients' uncertainty, quality oflife, and functional status.
JNCI Journal of the National Cancer InstituteStatutory Requirements for Disclosure of Breast Cancer Treatment Alternatives
54 Citations1994Susan Nayfield, G. C. Bongiovanni +3 more
This paper reviews statutes regarding physician disclosure of treatment alternatives to breast cancer patients in the context of the requirements imposed on the physician as health care provider and the content of medical information presented to the patient as a consequence of the laws.
Journal of Surgical OncologyBreast cancer patients' personality style, age, and treatment decision making
54 Citations1996Julie Johnson, Cleora S. Roberts +4 more
Some authors suggest that patient personality style is an important consideration in decisional preference in breast cancer patients.
PubMedPhysician variability and uncertainty in the management of breast cancer. Results from a factorial experiment.
44 Citations1998John B. McKinlay, Risa B. Burns +7 more
Overall, physicians displayed considerable variability and uncertainty when diagnosing and managing possible breast cancer.
Surgical Clinics of North AmericaPhysician-Patient Communication About Breast Cancer: A Challenge for the 1990s
42 Citations1990Wendy S. Schain
A most useful beacon to guide the physician in this dimly lit path is the notion that "congruence not candor" direct the disclosure.
Archives of Internal MedicineWho Still Prefers Aggressive Surgery for Breast Cancer?
42 Citations1987Raisa Deber
Although equally involved with and cognizant of the value of clinical trials, the modified radical group expressed more skepticism about the ability of trial results to be transferred to practice and to take sufficient account of patient uniqueness, indicating greater focus on variation than mean results.
Medical CarePhysician and Practice Characteristics Associated With Judgments About Breast Cancer Treatment
41 Citations1994Stephanie L. McFall, Richard B. Warnecke +3 more
Clinics in Geriatric MedicineAge and Gender as Factors in Cancer Therapy
32 Citations1993Patricia A. Ganz
The existing patterns of care for older cancer patients must be changed to improve the current cancer survival statistics and health care providers must learn to take the time to include older patients in their medical care and to educate them about the benefits of screening and cancer treatment.
Journal of Surgical OncologyBreast conservation versus mastectomy: Patient preferences in a community practice in kentucky
30 Citations1993Peter S. Tate, Edgar M. McGee +3 more
Overall, 10% of patients underwent breast‐sparing surgery, although this figure had risen to 20% by 1991, and the most frequent reasons for preference of mastectomy were fear and inconvenience of radiotherapy and a perception that survival would be diminished if mastectomy was not done.
Annals of Surgical OncologyProspective hospital-based survey of attitudes of Southern women toward surgical treatment of breast cancer
27 Citations1995John P. Wei, Richard M. Sherry +3 more
Attitudes and fears regarding cancer recurrence and radiation therapy may make women select mastectomy over lumpectomy, and the choice of surgery for breast cancer is an individual process between a woman and her surgeon.
The American Journal of MedicinePhysician Characteristics
26 Citations1997Risa B. Burns, Karen M. Freund +4 more
With the uncertainty of how to diagnose and treat older women with breast cancer, physician specialty, length of time in practice, and concern over malpractice do influence clinical decisions.
PubMedDecision-making for primary breast cancer treatment.
8 Citations1994M T Knobf
Intervention strategies nurses can use to help meet the informational needs of women with breast cancer will be discussed.
PubMedDeterminants of primary therapy of early stage breast cancer.
7 Citations1990Charles M. Ferguson, Aaron Feinstein +1 more
The results of this study suggest that the surgeon consulted is the major determinant of the type of therapy used in the primary management of breast cancer.
PubMedHelping women select primary breast cancer treatment.
4 Citations1998Monson Ma, Harwood Kv
Making a decision about breast cancer treatment is complex for women, and patients and caregivers are given a lot of information, then asked to make choices that affect their lives in many ways.
PubMedManagement of Primary Breast Cancer in Older Patients: Treatment Options.
2 Citations1994Foster Rs
The available data suggest age should be only one consideration in selection of treatment, and to determine optimum therapy, age should not be a criterion to exclude patients from trials.