Relationship between increased personal well-being and enhanced empathy among
Journal of General Internal MedicinePublished 1 July 2005
Tait D. Shanafelt, Colin P. West, Xinghua Zhao, Paul J. Novotny, Joseph C. Kolars, Thomas M. Habermann
Citations339
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.99
SNIP1.71
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
High mental well-being was associated with enhanced resident empathy in this cross-sectional survey, and the importance of a number of personal wellness promotion strategies differed for residents with higher mentalWell-being on the SF-8.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: While resident distress and its potential to negatively effect patient care have been well documented, little is known about resident well-being or its potential to enhance care. OBJECTIVE: We measured resident well-being and explored its relationship with empathy. DESIGN: Anonymous, cross-sectional survey. PARTICIPANTS: Internal medicine residents at Mayo Clinic Rochester (n=165, summer 2003). MEASUREMENTS: Well-being was measured using the previously validated Medical Outcomes Study 8-item Short Form (SF-8). Empathy was measured using the previously validated Perspective Taking (PT) and Empathetic Concerns (EC) Sub-scales of the Interpersonal Reactivity Index (IRI). RESULTS: Eighty-three (50%) residents responded to the survey. Mean scores for well-being as measured by the SF-8 were comparable to the general population, and empathy scores on the IRI were similar to other resident samples. Resident empathy on both the cognitive (PT) and emotive (EC) sub-scales of the IRI was higher for residents with higher mental well-being on the SF-8; however, this difference was statistically significant only for the cognitive sub-scale. The importance of a number of personal wellness promotion strategies differed for residents with higher mental well-being on the SF-8. CONCLUSIONS: High mental well-being was associated with enhanced resident empathy in this cross-sectional survey. Future studies need to explore the potential for high resident well-being to enhance medical care and competency in addition to exploring the negative consequences of resident distress. Studies investigating how to promote resident well-being are needed.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyMeasuring individual differences in empathy: Evidence for a multidimensional approach.
9,585 Citations1983Mark H. Davis
JAMADefining and Assessing Professional Competence
3,027 Citations2002Ronald M. Epstein
An inclusive definition of competence is generated: the habitual and judicious use of communication, knowledge, technical skills, clinical reasoning, emotions, values, and reflection in daily practice for the benefit of the individual and the community being served.
Annals of Internal MedicineBurnout and Self-Reported Patient Care in an Internal Medicine Residency Program
2,163 Citations2002Tait D. Shanafelt, Katharine A. Bradley +2 more
The prevalence of burn out among internal medicine residents in a single university-based program is evaluated and the relationship of burnout to self-reported patient care practices is evaluated.
JAMANarrative Medicine
2,111 Citations2001Rita Charon
By bridging the divides that separate physicians from patients, themselves, colleagues, and society, narrative medicine offers fresh opportunities for respectful, empathic, and nourishing medical care.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyResponse rates to mail surveys published in medical journals
2,098 Citations1997David A. Asch, M.Kathryn Jedrziewski +1 more
Although several mail survey techniques are associated with higher response rates, response rates to published mail surveys tend to be moderate, and investigators, journal editors, and readers should devote more attention to assessments of bias, and less to specific response rate thresholds.
JAMAMindful Practice
997 Citations1999Ronald M. Epstein
Mindful practitioners attend in a nonjudgmental way to their own physical and mental processes during ordinary, everyday tasks, enabling physicians to listen attentively to patients' distress, recognize their own errors, refine their technical skills, make evidence-based decisions, and clarify their values so that they can act with compassion, technical competence, presence, and insight.
American Journal of Preventive MedicinePhysician response to surveys A review of the literature
952 Citations2001Scott Kellerman
Surprisingly, the response rates of mail surveys of physicians compared favorably with those from telephone and personal interview surveys.
JAMACommunication Patterns of Primary Care Physicians
926 Citations1997Debra L. Roter
Primary care communication patterns range from narrowly biomedical to consumerist patterns and parallel the ideal forms of patient-physician relationships described in the literature.
The American Journal of MedicineThe well-being of physicians
792 Citations2003Tait D. Shanafelt, Jeff A. Sloan +1 more
Health PsychologyPhysicians' characteristics influence patients' adherence to medical treatment: Results from the Medical Outcomes Study.
785 Citations1993M. Robin DiMatteo, Cathy D. Sherbourne +6 more
The influence of physicians' attributes and practice style on patients' adherence to treatment was examined in a 2-year longitudinal study of 186 physicians and their diabetes, hypertension, and heart disease patients.
Journal of General Internal MedicineIs the professional satisfaction of general internists associated with patient satisfaction?
718 Citations2000Jennifer S. Haas, E. Francis Cook +4 more
The patients of physicians who have higher professional satisfaction may themselves be more satisfied with their care, according to a cross-sectional survey of patients and physicians in the greater-Boston area.
Medical EducationEmpathy in medical students as related to academic performance, clinical competence and gender
679 Citations2002Mohammadreza Hojat, Joseph S. Gonnella +6 more
It is important to address the measurement of empathy, its development and its correlates in medical schools.
Journal of General Internal MedicineWhat is clinical empathy?
667 Citations2003Jodi Halpern
It is argued that physicians’ emotional attunement greatly serves the cognitive goal of understanding patients’ emotions and has important implications for teaching empathy.
BMJMental health, job satisfaction, and job stress among general practitioners.
623 Citations1989Cary L. Cooper, Usha R. Rout +1 more
Multivariate analysis of a large database of general practitioners compiled from results of confidential questionnaire survey identified four job stressors that were predictive of high levels of job dissatisfaction and lack of mental wellbeing.
Social Science & MedicineDoctors' perceptions of the links between stress and lowered clinical care
501 Citations1997Jenny Firth‐Cozens, Joanne Greenhalgh
This study explores the doctors' views on stress using anonymous questionnaires from a population of 225 hospital doctors and general practitioners, 82 of whom reported recent incidents where they considered that symptoms of stress had negatively affected their patient care.
JAMACalibrating the Physician
450 Citations1997Dennis H. Novack
A "curriculum" of 4 core topics for reflection and discussion of physicians' beliefs and attitudes, physicians' feelings and emotional responses in patient care, challenging clinical situations, and physician self-care is proposed.
JAMAVariation of Mood and Empathy During Internship
408 Citations2002Lisa M. Bellini
Examination of mood patterns and changes in empathy among internal medicine residents over the course of the internship year found that enthusiasm at the beginning of internship soon gave way to depression, anger, and fatigue.
BMJEmotional distress in junior house officers.
407 Citations1987Jenny Firth‐Cozens
Overwork was the most stressful aspect of their jobs, though the number of hours worked was not related to stress levels, unlike diet and sleep, and the more stressed they were the more unfavourably they viewed aspects of their job.
Academic MedicineThe Jefferson Scale of Physician Empathy
405 Citations2002Mohammadreza Hojat, Joseph S. Gonnella +4 more
It is found that female students and physicians scored higher in empathy than males, and a significant overlap between empathy and clinical competence constitutes key validity evidence for the empathy scale.
Journal of General Internal MedicineThe work lives of women physicians
394 Citations2000the SGIM Career Satisfaction Study Group, Julia E. McMurray +5 more
Addressing gender differences in job satisfaction, work life issues, and burnout of U.S. physicians will optimize the participation of female physicians within the medical workforce.
The American Journal of MedicinePredicting and preventing physician burnout: results from the United States and the Netherlands
381 Citations2001Mark Linzer, Mechteld R.M. Visser +4 more
To better understand the interplay of the predictors of physician burnout and to develop strategies for prevention, data from two large physician surveys were compared and data were used to construct and test a predictive model of burnout.
JAMACalibrating the physician. Personal awareness and effective patient care. Working Group on Promoting Physician Personal Awareness, American Academy on Physician and Patient
371 Citations1997Dennis H. Novack
A "curriculum" of 4 core topics for reflection and discussion of physicians' beliefs and attitudes, physicians' feelings and emotional responses in patient care, challenging clinical situations, and physician self-care is proposed.
Annals of Internal MedicineWhat Is Empathy and Can It Be Taught?
366 Citations1992Howard M. Spiro
Conversations about experiences, discussions of patients and their human stories, more leisure and unstructured contemplation of the humanities help physicians to cherish empathy and to retain their passion.
PubMedThe work lives of women physicians results from the physician work life study. The SGIM Career Satisfaction Study Group.
358 Citations2000Janice McMurray, Mark Linzer +4 more
Quality of Life ResearchUsefulness of the SF-8™ Health Survey for comparing the impact of migraine and other conditions
343 Citations2003Diane M. Turner‐Bowker, Martha Bayliss +2 more
A new, even shorter generic health survey, the SF-8 Health Survey (SF-8™), an alternate form that uses one question to measure each of the eight SF-36 Health Survey domains, is tested in a sub-sample of migraine sufferers, indicating that the burden of migraine on functional health and well-being is considerable and comparable to other chronic conditions known to have substantial impact on HRQOL.
Education for HealthTeaching Empathy to First Year Medical Students: Evaluation of an Elective Literature and Medicine Course
280 Citations2004Johanna Shapiro, Elizabeth Morrison +1 more
A brief literature-based course can contribute to greater student empathy and appreciation for the value of humanities in medical education.
Annals of Internal MedicineStress in Medical Residency: Status Quo after a Decade of Reform?
273 Citations2002Virginia U. Collier, Jack D. McCue +2 more
To re-examine current residents' psychological and financial situations, the Resident Services Committee of the Association of Program Directors in Internal Medicine mailed a survey in May 1998 to all 415 internal medicine program directors, who were asked to distribute copies to each of their medicine residents (residents in categorical, preliminary, and combined tracks).
Academic MedicineToward creating physician-healers
267 Citations1999Dennis H. Novack, Ronald M. Epstein +1 more
Goals and objectives for medical education that can promote trainees' self-awareness, personal growth, and well-being are suggested, and how medical educators might achieve and evaluate these goals and objectives are commented on.
Archives of Internal MedicineCareer Satisfaction of US Women Physicians
260 Citations1999Erica Frank
Personal and professional characteristics that were correlated with 3 major outcomes: career satisfaction, desire to become a physician again, and desire to change one's specialty were examined.
Medical CarePhysician and Patient Satisfaction as Factors Related to the Organization of Internal Medicine Group Practices
243 Citations1985Lawrence S. Linn, Robert H. Brook +4 more
Higher satisfaction scores for both physician groups and patients were consistently associated with a greater percentage of patients experiencing continuity of care, lower patient no-show rates, more efficient use of ancillary staff in providing direct patient care, and more reasonable charges for a routine follow-up visit.
Journal of General Internal MedicineSupporting the moral development of medical students
217 Citations2000William T. Branch
Educational interventions that positively influence this process have established regular opportunities for critical reflection by the students in small groups and include faculty development to enhance role modeling and feedback by clinical faculty.
Academic MedicineWhat Is Empathy, and How Can It Be Promoted during Clinical Clerkships?
200 Citations2004Jochanan Benbassat, Reuben Baumal
S sustaining empathy and promoting medical professionalism among medical students may necessitate a change in the prevailing interviewing style in all clinical teaching settings, and a relocation of a larger proportion of clinical clerkships from the hospital setting to primary care clinics and chronic care, home care, and hospice facilities, where students can establish a continuing relationship with patients.
PubMedStress and burnout in oncology.
196 Citations2000Kathryn M. Kash, James Holland +5 more
While the rewards of working in oncology are usually sufficient to keep nurses and doctors in the field, they also experience burnout symptoms that vary by gender and personal attributes, and interventions are needed that address the specific problems of each group.
Medical EducationEvaluating the outcome of communication skill teaching for entry‐level medical students: does knowledge of empathy increase?
190 Citations2000Helen R. Winefield, Anna Chur‐Hansen
While the literature shows the clinical value for medical practitioners of skill in communicating with patients in an empathetic manner, objective evaluations of methods to teach empathy are few.
Archives of Internal MedicineA Stress Management Workshop Improves Residents' Coping Skills
182 Citations1991Jack D. McCue
It is concluded that a modest, inexpensive stress management workshop was received positively, and can lead to significant short-term improvement in stress and burnout test scores for medicine and pediatrics residents.
Journal of General Internal MedicineSympathy, empathy, and physician resource utilization
158 Citations1991Stephen D. Nightingale, Paul R. Yarnold +1 more
These data suggest that the constructs of sympathy and empathy reflect psychological aspects of physicians that have a measurable influence on their practice behaviors.
OncologyThe Well-Being and Personal Wellness Promotion Strategies of Medical Oncologists in the North Central Cancer Treatment Group
155 Citations2005Tait D. Shanafelt, Paul J. Novotny +6 more
Developing an approach/philosophy to dealing with death and end-of-life care, using recreation/hobbies/exercise, taking a positive outlook and incorporating a philosophy of balance between personal and professional life were all rated as substantially more important wellness strategies by oncologists with high well-being.
Academic MedicineCan Poetry Make Better Doctors? Teaching the Humanities and Arts to Medical Students and Residents at the University of California, Irvine, College of Medicine
148 Citations2003Johanna Shapiro, Lloyd Rucker
The Program in Medical Humanities & Arts at the University of California, Irvine, College of Medicine was implemented to enhance aspects of professionalism including empathy, altruism, compassion, and caring toward patients, as well as to hone clinical communication and observational skills.
Western Journal of MedicineA qualitative study of physicians' own wellness-promotion practices
136 Citations2001Eric L. Weiner
Physicians use a variety of approaches to promote their own well-being, which sort themselves into 5 main categories and appear to correlate with improved levels of psychological well- being among users.
Archives of Internal MedicineDepressive Symptoms in Medical House Officers
135 Citations1985David B. Reuben
Prevalence rates fell with each successive year of training, and responses from PGY-1 and PGy-2 residents on intensive care rotations indicated prevalence rates of depressive symptoms for both groups of greater than 33%.
JAMAResident Physician Substance Use in the United States
130 Citations1991Patrick H. Hughes
Current users of benzodiazepines and opiates used these drugs primarily for self-treatment rather than recreation, and these two substances are often associated with impairment at later stages in the physician's career.
Social Science & Medicine Medical Psychology and Medical SociologyJob satisfaction in general practice: Implications for prescribing
129 Citations1980A Melville
Academic MedicineSenior Residentsʼ Views on the Meaning of Professionalism and How They Learn about It
122 Citations2001A. Keith W. Brownell, Luc Côté
Residents' knowledge about professionalism reflects their early stage of development as physicians and their daily activities, where such aspects of professionalism as the social contract, codes of ethics, participation in professional societies, and altruism are not highlighted.
Archives of Internal MedicineHealthy Approaches to Physician Stress
122 Citations1990Timothy E. Quill
The five basic areas described herein can provide a framework for formal attention to physicians' personal development and application of these strategies to the dilemmas cited above are presented.
Teaching and Learning in MedicineEffect of Gender, Age, and Relevant Course Work on Attitudes Toward Empathy, Patient Spirituality, and Physician Wellness
116 Citations2004Lisabeth F. DiLalla, Sharon K. Hull +1 more
Exposure to educational activities in empathy, philosophical values and meaning, and wellness during medical school may increase empathy and wellness in medical practice.
Academic MedicineCorrelates of burnout among family practice residents
96 Citations1988Jeanne Parr Lemkau, Richard R. Purdy +2 more
Although personality factors were more predictive than demographic and situational variables of the variability in burnout among residents in the sample, the variables shared across the sample--long hours, little time for leisure activities and social contact, and compulsive personality characteristics--may contribute to the moderate level of burnout shared by these residents.
PubMedEmotional impairment in internal medicine house staff. Results of a national survey.
95 Citations1986Jay W. Smith, W F Denny +1 more
JAMAThe Ravelled Sleeve of Care
91 Citations1989John M. Colford
The literature describing the stresses experienced by residents in training, the toll these stresses may take on residents, and the suggestions that have been made for reducing these stresses are reviewed.
British Journal of Medical PsychologyMeasuring medical students' empathy skills
89 Citations1993Barry J. Evans, Robb O. Stanley +1 more
Results lead to the conclusion that pencil-and-paper tests of empathy cannot incorporate the range of complex cognitive, emotional and behavioural components of the empathy construct and a research study designed to evaluate a two-stage measurement technique.
PubMedEmpathy: an essential skill for understanding the physician-patient relationship in clinical practice.
67 Citations1993Clive D. Brock, John Salinsky
Development of empathetic skills can occur in Balint training programs, through the use of audio- or videotaped patient encounters, or through one-on-one training with an experienced preceptor.
PEDIATRICSSystematic Study of Four Years of Internship
66 Citations1980Robert Adler, Edwenna R. Werner +1 more
How attitudes toward patients and toward the internship experience become more negative in the course of the internship year is focused on.
PsychosomaticsA comprehensive support system for reducing house staff distress
49 Citations1984David B. Reuben, Dennis H. Novack +2 more
The goal of the Rhode Island Hospital House Staff Support System is to reduce stress among residents by providing them with a forum for their views and by offering counseling to those who need it.
PubMedThe internship--a prospective investigation of emotions and attitudes.
48 Citations1986Donald E. Girard, Diane L. Elliot +5 more
Satisfaction with the decision to become a physician decreased during the 1982-1983 academic year, a change that correlated directly with depression and fatigue and inversely with excitement and importance.
Journal of Clinical OncologyThe Impact of a Physician Awareness Group and the First Year of Training on Hematology-Oncology Fellows
44 Citations2003Mikkael A. Sekeres, Miriam Chernoff +4 more
A physician awareness group was feasible and enhanced fellows' development as physicians and further research is needed to determine how to incorporate such groups into oncology fellowships.
Women & HealthGender Differences in Physician Stress: Why the Discrepant Findings?
41 Citations1998Edith B. Gross
Studies investigating sources of occupational stress as perceived by male and female physicians in the United States, Canada, and Britain are reviewed, revealing ambiguous findings, some discovering gender-specific sources of stress among physicians and some not.
Academic MedicineMedical studentsʼ empathic understanding of their patients
41 Citations1998William T. Branch, Richard J. Pels +1 more
Journal of the Association of American Medical CollegesEducating Medical Students about Law and the Legal System
34 Citations1995Peter C. Williams, William Winslade
Empirical studies over the last 30 years demonstrate patterns of change in the frequency and focus of jurisprudence teaching in medical school curricula that can guide contemporary efforts to devise or refine curricula in medical jur isprudence.
Academic MedicineValues and virtues
33 Citations1999Loretta M. Kopelman
It is argued that a cogent philosophy of education can be neither value-free nor fully independent of moral choices, and within limits, diverse approaches to incorporating values in teaching can be a strength.
Medical EducationMeasuring medical students' empathy: a validation study
33 Citations1977Andrew Hornblow, M. A. Kidson +1 more
This study provides some support for the Empathy Scale as a measure of interpersonal effectiveness, but has not established it as a valid measure of empathy in a clinical setting.
MetamedicineEmpathy as a hermeneutic practice
28 Citations1996Ellen S. More
The history of the concept of empathy in clinical medicine, current definitions and the use of Balint groups in residency training as a way to develop empathic competence in novice physicians are discussed.
Psychological ReportsScores on the Interpersonal Reactivity Index: A Sample of Australian Medical Students
25 Citations1988Greg J. Coman, Barry J. Evans +1 more
The comparison suggests that these medical students' scores are generally comparable, with the exception being the subscale “Fantasy” on which 6th Year women students scored significantly higher than the other three student samples.
Medical EducationPsychological tests to measure the effects of medical education on students’ interpersonal skills
19 Citations1989Barry J. Evans, Robb O. Stanley +2 more
The consulting skills required of medical students and practitioners have been categorized into a number of specific skills, two of which are students’ ability to empathize with the patient and ability to decode non‐verbal cues given by the patient in the interview.
Perceptual and Motor SkillsDoes the Interpersonal Reactivity Index Perspective-Taking Scale Predict Who Will Volunteer Time to Counsel Adults Entering College?
16 Citations2003Patricia A. Oswald
Evidence is provided for the predictive efficacy of Davis's Interpersonal Reactivity Index Perspective-taking scale in identifying those individuals who are more likely to help others and empathy was not significantly related to Perspective- taking or helping.
PubMedThe physician's reaction to a malpractice suit.
11 Citations1988Lavery Jp
This commentary presents an analogy between the physician's reaction to a malpractice suit and the stages of grief described by Elisabeth Kübler-Ross: the sequence of denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance.
Women & HealthBreast Cancer and<i>Women & Health</i>
11 Citations1997Lawrence Garfinkel, Steven D. Stellman
Five breast cancer articles in this issue of Women & Health cover the broad areas of communications, screening, and policy, highlighting the importance of early detection and treatment and illustrating the dynamics of involvement of women's groups and individual women toward solving problems of education, attitudes, and advocacy.