What's it all about, empathy?
Nurse Education TodayPublished 1 April 1997
Vincent Price, John Archbold
Citations47
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.48
SNIP2.03
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is concluded that empathy remains a poorly defined, multidimensional concept which still remains not fully identified.
Abstract
This paper investigates the concept of empathy, a core element of all helping relationships. A discussion of its prevalence in the nursing literature is traced, before a discussion ensues as to whether it is a naturally acquired ability which develops with maturity, or whether it is a skill that can be taught and learnt. It is concluded that empathy remains a poorly defined, multidimensional concept which still remains not fully identified.
Keywords
Psychology
Psychological ReviewSelf-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change.
42,551 Citations1977Albert Bandura
Psychological ReviewSelf-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change.
35,454 Citations1977Albert Bandura
An integrative theoretical framework to explain and to predict psychological changes achieved by different modes of treatment is presented and findings are reported from microanalyses of enactive, vicarious, and emotive mode of treatment that support the hypothesized relationship between perceived self-efficacy and behavioral changes.
Journal of Consulting PsychologyThe necessary and sufficient conditions of therapeutic personality change.
5,438 Citations1957Carl R. Rogers
An attempt to state, informal terms, a theory of psychotherapy, of per-sonality, and of interpersonal relationships which will encompass and contain the phenomena of the experience of the therapist.
Empathy and its development
1,671 Citations1987Nancy Eisenberg, Janet Strayer
AJN American Journal of NursingNursing Diagnosis: Process and Application
534 Citations1983Ann Marriner, Marjory Gordon
On the Problem of Empathy
270 Citations1964Edith Stein
Human DevelopmentEmpathy: Historic and Current Conceptualizations, Measurement, and a Cognitive Theoretical Perspective
226 Citations2009Francine M. Deutsch, Ronald A. Madle
A selective review of various conceptual positions within a historic framework is used to address four issues: whether an empathic response is a response to an object, another’s affect, and/or circumstance; which mechanisms explain empathy, and is self-other differentiation required by various definitions.
Journal of Advanced NursingBeyond empathy: expanding expressions of caring
202 Citations2006Janice M. Morse, Joan L. Bottorff +3 more
A model describing nurses' responses to patients who are suffering is presented and four types of communication patterns are identified: engaged responses (first-level) are used in a connected relationship; when the nurse responses reflexively and is focused on him-/herself, the response is reflected.
PsychotherapyEmpathy, warmth, and genuineness in psychotherapy: A review of reviews.
191 Citations1984C. H. Patterson
Physical TherapyWhat Is Empathy, and Can Empathy Be Taught?
151 Citations1990Carol M. Davis
It is suggested that the act of empathizing cannot be taught, and promoting attitudes and behaviors such as self-awareness, nonjudgmental positive regard for others, good listening skills, and self-confidence are suggested as important in the development of clinicians who will demonstrate an empathic willingness.
Journal of Advanced NursingBeyond empathy: expanding expressions of caring
129 Citations1992Janice M. Morse, Joan L. Bottorff +3 more
Nursing ResearchThe Unpopular Patient
110 Citations1973Fellelty Stockwell, Doris Schwartz
Some descriptive terms used by American student and graduate nurses to describe the "good" patient, obtained from 500 written questionnaires and over 1,000 informal interviews are obtained.
Journal of Advanced NursingThe influence of elderly patients’ mental impairment on nurse‐patient interaction
98 Citations1986Christopher Armstrong-Esther, Kevin D. Browne
The results reveal very low levels of staff-patient communication.
Nursing ResearchDuration of Pain Condition and Physical Pathology as Determinants of Nurses?? Assessments of Patients in Pain
98 Citations1984Ann Gill Taylor, J. A. Skelton +1 more
The data indicate the chronic pain sufferer is negatively stereo-typed by staff, and a need exists to develop and disseminate more integrative models of the pain experience.
AJN American Journal of NursingWhat Is Empathy?
84 Citations1973Beatrice J. Kalisch
Since a nurse is human and, thus, less than perfect, her perceptions will not always be accurately empathic with all of the patients all of the time.
Journal of Advanced NursingA silent conspiracy: coping with dying cancer patients on an acute surgical ward
79 Citations1981Mary Knight, David Field
The problems and strategies of coping with terminal cancer patients on an acute surgical ward and the problems of junior nurses who are primarily responsible for the care of these dying patients are examined.
Research in Nursing & HealthThe use of modeling to teach empathy to nursing students
68 Citations1979Janice M. Layton
The treatment was effective for junior students but not for senior students, and only the groups receiving the rehearsal conditioning performed better than the control group, thus lending support to their construct validity.
Image the Journal of Nursing ScholarshipNurses' Reactions to Difficult Patients
68 Citations1988Debra L. Podrasky, Dorothy L. Sexton
The purpose of this study was to determine whom nurses identify as difficult patients and how nurses might react to them emotionally and behaviorally.
Journal of Counseling PsychologyThe development of ideas about empathy.
49 Citations1963Arnold Buchheimer
Advances in Nursing ScienceExploration of Empathy in Nurse-Client Interaction
45 Citations1979Garyfallia L. Forsyth
Journal of Advanced NursingThe effects of brief psychiatric training on the attitudes of general nursing students to psychiatric patients
44 Citations1982Deanna L. Wilkinson
Psychiatric training did not eliminate students' distrust of psychiatric patients, and it is suggested that students should work with psychiatric patients earlier in their course, and the scope of psychiatric training should be broadened and improved to make this a more attractive, worthwhile option.
Journal of Advanced NursingEmpathy: a review of the literature with suggestions for an alternative research strategy
43 Citations1990Dinah Gould
Nurse Education TodayNurse education as social control
43 Citations1987Immy Holloway, Jenny Penson
In describing some of the major aspects of control, the authors hope to heighten awareness of both manifest and latent processes which exert constraints on nurses, and to point to some the implications for the changes embodied in Project 2000.
Nurse Education TodayA study of empathy in student nurses
39 Citations1988William Reynolds, A. S. Presly
It is suggested that state empathy may not be stable, and that it is a promising target for nurse educators, while trait empathy was shown to be more closely associated with other (stable) aspects of personality than was state empathy.
Nursing ResearchNursing Students Attitudes toward Alcoholics
35 Citations1973Nancy J. Schmid, Donald T. Schmid
Nursing students have a less accepting attitude toward alcoholics than toward the physically disabled, and these attitudes remain stable.
Nursing ResearchRelationship of Perceived Empathy to Nursesʼ Communication
32 Citations1977Cheryl B. Stetler
A broad theoretical model of the perception of empathy is suggested, one incorporating all three channels of communication (verbal, nonverbal, and vocal) and accounting for the congruency among these channels.
Nursing ResearchFaculty Consensus as a Socializing Agent in Professional Education
30 Citations1977W A Gliebe
Consensus among student attitudes was found to increase during the educational program, and attitudes of nursing students did approach those of their instructors, which was suggested as a major determinant of the effectiveness of the socialization process in professional schools.
Nursing ResearchNurse Perceptions of Patient Characteristics
26 Citations1977Paula A. Larson
Nurses were found to stereotype lower-class patients as dependent, passive, unintelligent, noncomprehending, ummotivated, lazy, forgetful, inaccurate, careless, uninformed, unsuccessful, and unreliable.
Journal of Advanced NursingAssessment of nurses' attitudes towards cancer: a critical review of research methods
25 Citations1988Jessica Corner
This paper looks critically at the research into the attitudes of nurses towards cancer and calls for more innovative methods than have been used to date to be used.
Issues in Mental Health NursingEmpothic communication and its effect on client outcome
25 Citations1979Leonard Carol, R.N. Elaine
Nurse Education TodayEmpathy: we know what we mean, but what do we teach?
23 Citations1987WJ Reynolds
There is a need for nurse teachers to define what they mean by empathy, and it is proposed that all teachers should be trained in experiential teaching methods, and that the effects of structured empathy training should be investigated within an experimental research design.
Journal of Psychosocial Nursing and Mental Health Servicessetting: a contextual variable associated with empathy
14 Citations1977Stephanie L Sparling, Susan L. Jones
The study supported the notion that nurses working in a psychiatric setting are significantly more empathic than nurses worked in a non-psychiatric setting, and the demographic variables of age, sex, marital status, educational level, and length of experiences were not significantly related to empathy.
Journal of Advanced NursingTeaching nurses therapeutic conversation: a pilot study
13 Citations1988Roger Paxton, David Rhodes +1 more
A 2-day video-based workshop developed for teaching psychiatrists was used to instruct learner psychiatric nurses in the conversational model of psychotherapy, which can be used by nurses, including those still in training.
Counselor Education and SupervisionAn Investigation of the Validity of Empathy Measures
13 Citations1975R. C. Conklin, Allan Stockton Hunt
Counselor Education and SupervisionThe Function of Automaticity in Counselor Information Processing
7 Citations1988Lewis E. Patterson
