Efficacy and safety of electroconvulsive therapy in depressive disorders: a systematic review and meta-analysis
The LancetPublished 1 March 2003
Citations1,635
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score12.11
SNIP22.72
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
A systematic overview and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials and observational studies for the efficacy and safety of electroconvulsive therapy with simulated ECT, ECT versus pharmacotherapy, and different forms of ECT for patients with depressive illness found ECT is an effective short-term treatment for depression.
Abstract
ECT is an effective short-term treatment for depression, and is probably more effective than drug therapy. Bilateral ECT is moderately more effective than unilateral ECT, and high dose ECT is more effective than low dose.
Keywords
Medicine
Controlled Clinical TrialsMeta-analysis in clinical trials
39,316 Citations1986Rebecca DerSimonian, Nan M. Laird
This paper examines eight published reviews each reporting results from several related trials in order to evaluate the efficacy of a certain treatment for a specified medical condition and suggests a simple noniterative procedure for characterizing the distribution of treatment effects in a series of studies.
Journal of Educational StatisticsStatistical Methods for Meta-Analysis
10,479 Citations1988Stanley Wasserman, Larry V. Hedges +1 more
Elsevier eBooksStatistical Methods for Meta-Analysis
2,526 Citations1985
The aim of this paper is to introduce several widely-used statistical methods of Meta-analysis, applied generally in medical literatures.
New England Journal of MedicineEffects of Stimulus Intensity and Electrode Placement on the Efficacy and Cognitive Effects of Electroconvulsive Therapy
930 Citations1993Harold A. Sackeïm, Joan Prudic +7 more
increasing the electrical dosage increases the efficacy of right unilateral electroconvulsive therapy, although not to the level of bilateral therapy, and unilateral treatment is associated with less severe cognitive side effects after treatment.
Archives of General PsychiatryA Prospective, Randomized, Double-blind Comparison of Bilateral and Right Unilateral Electroconvulsive Therapy at Different Stimulus Intensities
795 Citations2000Harold A. Sackeïm, Joan Prudic +7 more
Right unilateral ECT at high dosage is as effective as a robust form of BL ECT, but produces less severe and persistent cognitive effects.
JAMAContinuation Pharmacotherapy in the Prevention of Relapse Following Electroconvulsive Therapy
679 Citations2001Harold A. Sackeïm, Roger F. Haskett +8 more
It is indicated that without active treatment, virtually all remitted patients relapse within 6 months of stopping ECT, and the combination of nortriptyline and lithium is more effective, but the relapse rate is still high, particularly during the first month of continuation therapy.
Statistics in MedicineBayesian approaches to random‐effects meta‐analysis: A comparative study
583 Citations1995Teresa Smith, David J. Spiegelhalter +1 more
It is described how a full Bayesian analysis can deal with unresolved issues, such as the choice between fixed- and random-effects models, the choice of population distribution in a random- effects analysis, the treatment of small studies and extreme results, and incorporation of study-specific covariates.
Biological PsychiatrySubcortical hyperintensities on magnetic resonance imaging: Clinical correlates and prognostic significance in patients with severe depression
402 Citations1995Ian B. Hickie, Elizabeth Scott +4 more
Preliminary evidence supporting the clinical and prognostic significance of extensive white matter hyperintensities in patients with severe depression is provided.
Journal of Affective DisordersAntidepressant efficacy of Sudarshan Kriya Yoga (SKY) in melancholia: a randomized comparison with electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) and imipramine
381 Citations2000N. Janakiramaiah, Bangalore N. Gangadhar +4 more
It can be concluded that, although inferior to ECT, SKY can be a potential alternative to drugs in melancholia as a first line treatment.
Archives of General PsychiatryMortality in Depressed Patients Treated With Electroconvulsive Therapy and Antidepressants
350 Citations1976David Avery
The electroconvulsive therapy group had a significantly lower mortality than the inadequate antidepressant treatment group and the group that received neither ECT nor antidepressants, which underscores the importance of adequate treatment of depression, especially in the older man.
Archives of General PsychiatryTitrated Moderately Suprathreshold vs Fixed High-Dose Right Unilateral Electroconvulsive Therapy
336 Citations2000W. Vaughn McCall, David M. Reboussin +2 more
The antidepressant efficacy and cognitive side effects of RUL ECT are dependent on the magnitude of the stimulus dose relative to the seizure threshold, and a dose-response relationship extends through at least 12 times the seizure thresholds.
American Journal of PsychiatryEffects of electrode placement on the efficacy of titrated, low-dose ECT
302 Citations1987Harold A. Sackeïm, Paolo Decina +3 more
A dose in excess of seizure threshold may contribute to the efficacy of ECT, particularly with a unilateral right electrode placement, according to a double-blind, random-assignment study on patients with primary major depressive disorder.
The LancetTHE NORTHWICK PARK ELECTROCONVULSIVE THERAPY TRIAL
239 Citations1980EveC. Johnstone, P.G. Lawler +5 more
In the real-ECT group memory was impaired during treatment but memory tests revealed no difference between the groups at six-month follow-up, and the therapeutic benefits of electrically induced convulsions in depression were more transient than has been claimed.
The British Journal of PsychiatryA Controlled Comparison of Simulated and Real ECT
187 Citations1978John Lambourn, D. Gill
The results suggest that the ECT pre-treatment procedure has an important therapeutic effect, and casts some doubt on current views of the effectiveness of electro-convulsive therapy in general, and of brief pulse unilateral ECT in particular.
American Journal of PsychiatryVariation in ECT use in the United States
178 Citations1995Richard C. Hermann, Robert A. Dorwart +2 more
The extent of variation suggests psychiatrists continue to lack consensus regarding the use of ECT, and better data on the effectiveness of psychiatric treatments may lead to a broader professional consensus and may narrow variations in clinical practices.
BMJElectroconvulsive therapy: results in depressive illness from the Leicestershire trial.
172 Citations1984S. Brandon, P Cowley +4 more
Electroconvulsive therapy was effective in depression associated with delusions and in depressionassociated with retardation and showed a significantly greater improvement than simulated treatment.
BMJInterpreting the results of secondary end points and subgroup analyses in clinical trials: should we lock the crazy aunt in the attic?
170 Citations2001Nick Freemantle
The interpretation that may be placed on the results of secondary end points and subgroup analyses in the context of clinical practice and health policy is examined.
The LancetDOUBLE-BLIND CONTROLLED TRIAL OF ELECTROCONVULSIVE THERAPY (E.C.T.) AND SIMULATED E.C.T. IN DEPRESSIVE ILLNESS
159 Citations1978C. P. Freeman, John Basson +1 more
Electroconvulsive therapy is significantly superior to simulated E.C.T. in the treatment of depressive illness and is recommended on a double-blind basis.
Psychological MedicineTherapeutic advantage of bifrontal electrode placement in ECT
154 Citations1993F. J. J. Letemendia, Nicholas J. Delva +5 more
Because BF ECT causes fewer cognitive side effects than either RU or BT, and is independently more effective, it should be considered as the first choice of electrode position in ECT.
The British Journal of PsychiatryA Comparison of the Effects on Depression and Memory of Bilateral E.C.T. and Unilateral E.C.T. to the Dominant and Non-Dominant Hemispheres
149 Citations1968A. M. Halliday, Kenneth Davison +2 more
BMJElectric convulsion therapy in depression: a double-blind controlled trial.
144 Citations1981E. D. West
The therapeutic effect of simulated and real bilateral electric convulsion therapy was examined in a double-blind, randomised trial on 22 patients with a primary depressive illness and it is suggested that the convulsion is important for the therapeutic effect.
American Journal of PsychiatryAntidepressant and cognitive effects of twice- versus three-times- weekly ECT
141 Citations1995Bernard Lerer, Bracha Shapira +6 more
ECT twice a week is an effective schedule for clinical practice and is potentially advantageous in view of a therapeutic outcome identical to that of ECT three times a week and less severe cognitive effects.
The British Journal of PsychiatryA Comparison of Techniques in Electro-Convulsive Therapy
134 Citations1968Max Valentine, KENNETH M.G. KEDDIE +1 more
Electroconvulsive therapy, modified by intravenous anaesthesia and muscle relaxants, has long been accepted as a satisfactory form of treatment and seems almost in danger of becoming fixed indefinitely in its present form.
The British Journal of PsychiatryThe Nottingham ECT Study
133 Citations1985Susan Gregory, Charles R. Shawcross +1 more
It is suggested that both bilateral and unilateral ECT are highly effective treatments for depression and are significantly superior to simulated ECT.
Acta Psychiatrica ScandinavicaElectroconvulsive therapy vs. paroxetine in treatment‐resistant depression — a randomized study
132 Citations1997Here Folkerts, N. Michael +4 more
The present study found ECT to be superior to paroxetine in medication‐resistant major depression, in terms of both degree and speed of response.
The LancetPOST-COLONOSCOPIC RETROGRADE ILEOGRAPHY
122 Citations1988Peter J. Whorwell, D G Maxton +1 more
Description d'une nouvelle technique facilitant l'introduction d'un catheter dans l'ileon lors de la colonoscopie lors ofertaine.
The British Journal of PsychiatryComparison of Electroconvulsive Therapy with Imipramine in Endogenous Depression: A Double Blind Study
122 Citations1982Bangalore N. Gangadhar, R. L. Kapur +1 more
Electroconvulsive therapy was compared with imipramine in the treatment of endogenous depression in a double blind randomized controlled trial and both treatments produced equally significant improvement which was equally maintained till the end of six months.
The British Journal of PsychiatryAudit of Electroconvulsive Treatment in two National Health Service Regions
119 Citations1992John Pippard
The use of ECT has fallen by 55% in North East Thames Region since 1979, but has risen by 20% in the East Anglian Region, and there are up to 12–fold differences in usage between districts.
Acta Psychiatrica ScandinavicaUnilateral and bilateral ECT in elderly patients A COMPARATIVE STUDY
112 Citations1980R. M. Fraser, R. M. Fraser +6 more
Depressed elderly patients receiving ECT were randomly assigned to a unilateral or bilateral group; post‐ictal recovery times, memory changes, and clinical improvement during and after each course were measured.
Archives of General PsychiatryA Comparison of Electroconvulsive Therapy and Combined Phenelzine-Amitriptyline in Refractory Depression
96 Citations1978Jonathan Davidson
Electroconvulsive therapy is still considered to be the treatment of choice for severe depression, whereas the combination of low doses of phenelzine and amitriptyline are ineffective, and this treatment modality needs further investigation.
Acta Psychiatrica ScandinavicaA comparison of electroconvulsive therapy with a combined lithium and tricyclic combination among depressed tricyclic nonresponders
95 Citations1989Timothy G. Dinan, Siobhan Barry
It is suggested that in otherwise physically healthy patients who are tricyclic nonresponders, the addition of U may be a more rapid treatment than the use of ECT.
Archives of General PsychiatryEpidemiologic Considerations in Electroconvulsive Therapy
89 Citations1984Haroutun M. Babigian
Both prevalence and incidence analyses showed increasing specificity over time of ECT use in cases of depression, and lengths of hospital stay for patients receiving ECT were generally longer than for other depression hospitalizations, both for first ECT and later ECT series.
Archives of General PsychiatryAntidepressant Effects of High-Dose Right Unilateral Electroconvulsive Therapy
85 Citations1991Richard Abrams
The suprathreshold character of the stimulus, about 2.5 times the expected seizure threshold, may have contributed to the high efficacy of brief-pulse right unilateral electroconvulsive therapy found in this study.
The British Journal of PsychiatryCost and benefit in the choice of ECT schedule
83 Citations1998Baruch Shapira, Nurith Tubi +4 more
PubMedEffect of ECT on mortality and clinical outcome in geriatric unipolar depression.
79 Citations1995Robert A. Philibert, Lindsey E. Richards +2 more
Patients who received ECT were more likely to exhibit psychomotor retardation and to have had prior courses of ECT than those who did not receive ECT and to demonstrate greater clinical improvement than those treated only with pharmacotherapy.
American Journal of PsychiatryBilateral and Unilateral ECT: Follow-Up Study and Critique
77 Citations1970T. George Bidder, James J. Strain +1 more
The authors conclude from their work and from a critical review of the literature that unilateral ECT is likely to result in reduced memory dysfunction during the immediate treatment period and to require more treatment sessions for satisfactory immediate therapeutic response.
American Journal of PsychiatryBilateral versus unilateral electroconvulsive therapy: efficacy in melancholia
76 Citations1983Richard M. Abrams, Melissa Taylor +4 more
Patients with endogenous depression who were randomly assigned to bilateral or unilateral ECT received more total treatments and were more frequently switched to bilateral ECT, independent of age, severity of illness, or sedative drug administration.
American Journal of PsychiatryDifferential Effect of Unilateral and Bilateral ECT
73 Citations1970J. J. Fleminger, David Horné +2 more
It is concluded that unilateral ECT to the nondominant hemisphere reduced the chance of memory disturbance and offered the best chance of quick recovery with few side effects when ECT is given for depression.
Acta Psychiatrica ScandinavicaECT and cerebral atrophy
69 Citations1981S. P. Calloway, Raymond J. Dolan +2 more
The case‐notes of 41 elderly depressives who underwent computed tomography were examined and the ECT history of each patient was assessed, and a significant relationship was demonstrated between frontal lobe atrophy and ECT.
The British Journal of PsychiatryThe Amnesic and Therapeutic Effects of Bilateral and Unilateral ECT
68 Citations1970C. G. Costello, Gerald P. Belton +2 more
Evidence suggests that unilateral ECT admin istered to the non-dominant hemisphere produces less memory impairment than bilateral ECT, and these two methods of treatment do not differ significantly in their therapeutic effects.
The LancetCOMPARATIVE TRIAL OF L-TRYPTOPHAN AND E.C.T. IN SEVERE DEPRESSIVE ILLNESS
66 Citations1974R. N. Herrington, A. Bruce +2 more
The possibility remains that L-tryptophan is devoid of effectiveness in severely depressed patients, supported by patients who failed to respond to tryptophan subsequently responding to other treatments.
Journal of Mental ScienceA Controlled Comparison of Imipramine and Electroplexy
65 Citations1962A. A. Robin, J. A. Harris
PubMedA comparison of standard alternating current and low-energy brief-pulse electrotherapy.
62 Citations1977Weaver La, Ives Jo +2 more
The results show the LEBS to require equal voltage, less current, and only one-half the total energy to produce clinically manifest convulsions, and there was no apparent difference between methods on any outcome measure.
The British Journal of PsychiatryAuditing electroconvulsive therapy
59 Citations1998Richard Duffet, Paul Lelliott
This is the third large-scale audit in the past 20 years and compares the practice of electroconvulsive therapy in England and Wales with the standards derived from the Royal College of Psychiatrists' 2nd ECT handbook.
British Journal of Social and Clinical PsychologyA Synonym Learning Test for Use with Elderly Psychiatric Subjects: A Validation Study*
57 Citations1965D. C. Kendrick, ROSE‐CECILE PARBOOSINGH +1 more
The validity of the new form of the Walton-Black Test as assessed against psychiatric diagnosis, the Inglis' Paired Associate Learning Test and by factor analytic methods is investigated.
American Journal of PsychiatryCLINICAL EVALUATION OF UNILATERAL EST
55 Citations1965Winston Martin, HAMILTON F. FORD +2 more
This study was an attempt to determine clinically the therapeutic efficacy and degree of memory impairment of unilateral ECT as compared to bilateral ECT, and it would indicate that the desirable benefit of ECT is the same for both types of treatment but with considerably less memory impairment with unilateral treatment.
Journal of NeuropsychiatryBalancing risks and benefits: another approach to optimizing diagnostic tests
52 Citations1992Douglas Mossman, Eugene Somoza
This article shows how tests can be used to maximize the "expected utility" associated with a clinical decision.
Journal of Affective DisordersTwice versus thrice weekly ECT in melancholia: a double-blind prospective comparison
51 Citations1993Bangalore N. Gangadhar, N. Janakiramaiah +3 more
The results indicate that ECT given thrice a week conferred no advantage over ECTgiven twice a week.
The British Journal of PsychiatryTreatment of Depression: A Comparative Study of E.C.T. and Six Drugs
48 Citations1963John T. Hutchinson, Daphne Smedberg
Since the introduction of drug therapy in depression, a wide range of pharmacological substances has been made available and it is possible to show that many of these substances are more effective than a placebo in the treatment of depression.
American Journal of PsychiatryA CONTROLLED COMPARISON OF AMITRIPTYLINE AND ELECTROCONVULSIVE THERAPY IN THE TREATMENT OF DEPRESSION
47 Citations1966Ian M. McDonald, Marjorie Perkins +2 more
There was no appreciable difference after one month of treatment between the therapeutic effects of amitriptyline and ECT.
Annals of Clinical PsychiatryDoes Treatment Influence Mortality in Depressives?: A Follow-up of 1076 Patients with Major Affective Disorders
43 Citations1989Donald W. Black, George Winokur +3 more
There were no significant differences in the risk for suicides, or deaths from all causes combined, among patients in the four treatment groups, and mortality did not differ between patients having a lifetime history of ECT and patients never having had ECT.
NatureECT has proved effective in treating depression…
36 Citations2000Max Fink
Peter Sterling argues that history will view ECT as another “great and desperate cure” akin to psychosurgery, and argues that the cure for depression “requires this procedure to be repeated 10–20 times over a week or so”.
The British Journal of PsychiatryThe Clinical Evaluation of Unilateral Electroconvulsive Therapy
34 Citations1968Raymond Levy
Electroconvulsive therapy (E.C.T.), first introduced in 1937, rapidly became accepted as playing an important part in the treatment of depression, but little attention has been paid to improvements in the method of treatment as such.
Acta Psychiatrica ScandinavicaOnce vs. three times weekly ECT in melancholia: a randomized controlled trial
33 Citations1998N. Janakiramaiah, S. Motreja +3 more
Although three times weekly ECTs are superior, 55% of patients responded to once weekly E CTs, and there is therefore a need for research to identify the patients for whom onceweekly ECT may be sufficient.
American Journal of Geriatric PsychiatryComparison of the Efficacy of Titrated, Moderate-Dose and Fixed, High-Dose Right Unilateral ECT in Elderly Patients
33 Citations1995W. Vaughn McCall, Brian A. Farah +2 more
The authors compared the efficacy of titrated, moderate-dose and fixed, high-dose strategies for right unilateral (RUL) electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in a group of elderly patients and found that final depression ratings and memory self-ratings were similar for the two groups.
PubMedWeekly ECT in Geriatric Depression.
32 Citations1992Charles H. Kellner, Russell R. Monroe +4 more
It is concluded that the traditional three-times-weekly schedule of ECT may optimally balance speed of antidepressant response and cognitive impairment.
PubMedA controlled comparative trial of unilateral and bilateral sinusoidal and pulse E.C.T. in endogenous depression.
32 Citations1979Carney Mw, Rogan Pa +2 more
Overall, there was a highly significant improvement but among the 3 groups there were no significant differences, findings not accounted for by differences in mean age, numbers of E.C.T. given or mean initial Hamilton's score among the groups.
American Journal of PsychiatryA COMPARATIVE TRIAL OF ECT AND TOFRĀNIL
31 Citations1960Errollyn Bruce, Nora Crone +6 more
The proportion of patients who improved during the first month of treatment was higher in the group given ECT but over 60% of those given Tofrānil showed a good response in that time, perhaps justifying the view that TofRānil may often serve as a substitute for ECT.
Archives of General PsychiatryComparing Bilateral to Unilateral Electroconvulsive Therapy in a Randomized Study With EEG Monitoring
30 Citations1985Robert Lynn Horne
When ECT is monitored via EEG to assure the presence of an adequate seizure, bilateral and nondominant unilateral placement yield equivalent responses, and if ECT had not been readministered immediately following a missed seizure, unilateral patients would have had significantly more missed seizures.
PubMedThe relative ability of three ictal EEG frequency bands to differentiate ECT seizures on the basis of electrode placement, stimulus intensity, and therapeutic response.
30 Citations1996Andrew D. Krystal, Richard D. Weiner +5 more
The frequency band that best differentiated these groups depended on the EEG measure used, the temporal portion of the seizure, and whether ELPL, Dose, or therapeutic response was being compared.
The British Journal of PsychiatryMemory Test Performance Under Three Different Waveforms of ECT for Depression
26 Citations1984Eric W. Warren, David Groóme
A marked improvement in both verbal and nonverbal memory scores was attributed to the lifting of depression in patients given a course of ECT (Electroconvulsive therapy) in one of three waveforms.
Acta Psychiatrica ScandinavicaComputed tomographic scans in ECT‐patients
25 Citations1986H. Kolbeinsson, Ö. S. Arnaldsson +2 more
The present data are consistent with recent reports that affective disorders may be associated with enlarged brain ventricles, although the clinical significance of such findings remains unclear.
The British Journal of PsychiatryIs Old-Fashioned Electroconvulsive Therapy More Efficacious?
21 Citations1992Allan Scott, Colin R. Rodger +2 more
It is concluded that the policy of bilateral suprathreshold modern ECT monitored by EEG is as efficacious as traditional ECT.
PubMedA Double-Blind Comparison of Sinusoidal Wave and Brief-Pulse Electroconvulsive Therapy in Endogenous Depression.
19 Citations1988Chittaranjan Andrade, Bangalore N. Gangadhar +3 more
For endogenous depression treated with ECT, it is concluded that cumulative seizure duration may not be a parameter of significance, that overall rate of recovery in ECT responders is independent of stimulus waveform, and that some depressives may respond to SW but not to BP ECT.
Journal of Mental HealthA trial to determine any difference between two and three times a week ECT in the rate of recovery from depression
18 Citations1998REINOUT VIEWEG CHARLES R. SHAWCROSS
It is concluded that ECT given three times a week provides no advantage over twice a week administration and once a week ECT is the preferred frequency.
Journal of Mental ScienceA clinical comparison of phenelzine and electro-convulsive therapy in the treatment of depressive illness
16 Citations1962W. J. Stanley, Harold Fleming
A clinical trial is reported in which a comparison was made between the effects of electro-convulsive therapy and phenelzine (“Nardil”) in the treatment of depressive illness, and it is concluded that pheneizine is much inferior to electro- Convulsive therapy.
American Journal of PsychiatryIncreases in prolactin levels following bilateral and unilateral ECT
15 Citations1984Yiannis G. Papakostas, C. Stefanis +4 more
Plasma prolactin levels were studied after bilateral and unilateral ECT in eight female melancholic patients, and patients who received bilateral ECT had significantly higher prol actin levels than did those who received unilaterally ECT.
The British Journal of PsychiatryShort-Term Cognitive Effects of Unilateral and Bilateral ECT
13 Citations1985Michael Alan Taylor, Richard Abrams
It is concluded that neither B/ECT nor U/ECT substantially worsen non-memory cognitive performance in depressed patients, yet both result in significant clinical improvement.
The British Journal of PsychiatryPerceptual Learning with Right Unilateral versus Bilateral Electroconvulsive Therapy
11 Citations1984Walter F. Daniel, Herbert F. Crovitz +1 more
The theoretical issue of whether an electrical or a seizure difference between bilateral and right unilateral ECT is responsible for inter-group learning or memory differences is discussed, as well as practical issues related to the choice of electrode placement.
Comprehensive PsychiatryElectroconvulsive therapy and the diencephalon: A preliminary report
10 Citations1974Richard Abrams, Michael Alan Taylor
The suggestion is made that direct stimulation of the diencephalon is a critical variable for the fully developed therapeutic effect of ECT.
PubMedEvaluation of cognitive effects of ect (preliminary observations).
9 Citations1981Bagadia Vn, Shah Lp +3 more
No Post ECT cognitive deficit was observed on the test battery though some patients did complain of forgetfulness subjectively.
Journal of Mental Science<i>Vertical Oculo-motor Crises in Post-encephalitic Parkinsonism [Les Crises Oculogyres Verticales da Parkinsonisme Post-encéphalitique], (L'Encéph., March</i>, 1925.) <i>Bing, R., and Schwartz, L.</i>
4 Citations1926W. D. Chambers
…