The complexity and stability of ecosystems
NaturePublished 1 January 1984
Stuart L. Pimm
Citations3,051
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score18.29
SNIP10.16
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
Early studies suggested that simple ecosystems were less stable than complex ones, but later studies came to the opposite conclusion. Confusion arose because of the many different meanings of 'complexity' and 'stability'. Most of the possible questions about the relationship between stability–complexity have not been asked. Those that have yield a variety of answers.
Keywords
Social SciencesEnvironmental Science
The American NaturalistCommunity Structure, Population Control, and Competition
3,432 Citations1960Nelson G. Hairston, Frederick E. Smith +1 more
Populations of producers, carnivores, and decomposers are limited by their respective resources in the classical density-dependent fashion and interspecific competition must necessarily exist among the members of each of these three trophic levels.
NaturePopulation biology of infectious diseases: Part I
3,243 Citations1979Roy M. Anderson, Robert M. May
NatureWill a Large Complex System be Stable?
2,895 Citations1972Robert M. May
It is suggested that large complex systems which are assembled (connected) at random may be expected to be stable up to a certain critical level of connectance, and then, as this increases, to suddenly become unstable.
NatureThresholds and breakpoints in ecosystems with a multiplicity of stable states
1,711 Citations1977Robert M. May
This review discusses how alternate stable states can arise in simple 1- and 2-species systems, and applies these ideas to grazing systems, to insect pests, and to some human host–parasite systems.
The American NaturalistOn the Evidence Needed to Judge Ecological Stability or Persistence
1,191 Citations1983Joseph H. Connell, Wayne P. Sousa
An analysis of census data from many long-term studies revealed a continuum of temporal variability in the dynamics of natural populations and communities, with no evidence of multiple stable states in unexploited natural populations or communities.
Ecological Communities
886 Citations1981Alan A. Berryman
NatureConnectance of Large Dynamic (Cybernetic) Systems: Critical Values for Stability
757 Citations1970MARK R. GARDNER, W. Ross ASHBY
The work described here was intended to add to present theoretical knowledge of stability in large systems, for instability usually appears as a self-generating catastrophe.
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesNiche Overlap as a Function of Environmental Variability
714 Citations1972Robert M. May, Robert H. Mac Arthur
There is an effective limit to niche overlap in the real world, and this limit is insensitive to the degree of environmental fluctuation, unless it be very severe.
NatureNumber of trophic levels in ecological communities
689 Citations1977Stuart L. Pimm, John H. Lawton
This work believes that the number of trophic levels is constrained by population dynamics and not by ecological energetics.
The American NaturalistDiversity and Stability of Ecological Communities: A Comment on the Role of Empiricism in Ecology
681 Citations1977S. J. McNaughton
The data on diversity-stability relationships in plant communities indicate that the traditional verbal model is considerably more robust in application than recent "more rigorous" mathematical models.
The American NaturalistCommunity Patterns and Competition in Folivorous Insects
482 Citations1981John H. Lawton, D. R. Strong,
It is argued that classical, interspecific competition for food is weak and infrequent, and that it cannot fill the major ecological and evolutionary role favored for it by many workers on other organisms, and favor the view that most community patterns can be explained without invoking inter specific competition.
The Quarterly Review of BiologyThe Theory of Diversity-Stability Relationships in Ecology
477 Citations1975Daniel Goodman
There is no simple relationship between diversity and stability in ecological systems, and an alternate perspective for interpreting population stability is suggested.
Annals of the Entomological Society of AmericaSpecies Diversity and Insect Population Outbreaks
395 Citations1961David Pimentel
It was concluded that species diversity play an important role in preventing population outbreaks and where possible in cultivation, faunal and floral varieties should be encouraged.
NatureCharacteristics of successful natural enemies in models of biological control of insect pests
381 Citations1978J. R. Beddington, C. A. Free +1 more
Analysis of mathematical models suggests that differential exploitation of patches of the pest in a spatially heterogeneous environment provides the most likely mechanism to account for known successes iniological control of insect pests.
The American NaturalistFluctuations in Abundance of Tropical Insects
340 Citations1978Henk Wolda
The data suggest that physical stability and predictability of the environment are important for determining the AV of the insects and that the wet but seasonal tropics are physically no more stable than the wet temperate zone.
Plant EcologyCommunity stability, complexity and species life history strategies
318 Citations1982Jan Lepš, Jana Osbornová-Kosinová +1 more
There is no causal relationship between species diversity and both kinds of stability, and the results imply the validity of Gleasonian, population-centered explanation of community phenomena.
The American NaturalistStability under Environmental Stress: Resistance, Resilience, Persistence, and Variability
277 Citations1979Gary W. Harrison
Four main contributions are made toward understanding stability and clarifying the ambiguity that has surrounded the term stability in the past, pointing toward a possible resolution of the stability-diversity question.
EcologyStability and Connectance in Food Web Models
269 Citations1975Donald L. De Angelis
Computer studies by Gardner and Ashby (1970) show that large randomly connected systems have a decreasing probability of being stable as the number of connections increases, but if the food web is characterized by low assimilation efficiencies, a bias toward strong self-regulation of higher trophic level species, or a biases toward donor dependence the probability of stability can increase with increasing connectance.
Mathematical BiosciencesCommunity assembly and food web stability
261 Citations1983W. M. Post, Stuart L. Pimm
The results of computer simulations using predator-prey equations allow us to identify three types of food web stability and examine how they may change through development of food webs.
Unifying Concepts in Ecology
248 Citations1975
Diversity, stability and maturity in natural ecosystems
246 Citations1975Gordon H. Orians
Journal of Animal EcologyAre Food Webs Divided into Compartments?
241 Citations1980Stuart L. Pimm, John H. Lawton
Drawing on a number of alternative approaches, the null hypothesis that real food webs are not significantly more compartmented than chance alone dictates is tested.
OikosFood Web Design and the Effect of Species Deletion
233 Citations1980Stuart L. Pimm
Two conclusions are drawn: real systems do not recover, at least quickly, from large perturbations and so requiring model systems to have this feature unlikely to be informative about food web design, and donor-control dynamics do not describe many real systems and, with their rejection goes one of the otherwise more plausible model systems where stability increases with complexity.
Theoretical Population BiologyThe structure of food webs
220 Citations1979Stuart L. Pimm
For nonrandom models of species interaction there is a precipitous decrease in stability as connectance increases, however, the range of stability for different models of the same connectance is large; stability also depends on how the species interactions are organized.
NatureThe stability of a feasible random ecosystem
178 Citations1974Alan Roberts
The weight of the evidence, and the beliefs of most biologists, seem to support the view that ecosystems tend to be more stable, the larger the number of interacting species they contain, and that complexity makes for instability.
OikosComplexity and Stability: Another Look at MacArthur's Original Hypothesis
167 Citations1979Stuart L. Pimm
It is shown that increasing model complexity does not result in increased species deletion stability, and natural ecosystems have not been significantly modified in their structures to maximize their resistance to species deletion.
Journal of PaleontologyPtilodictyoid Cryptostomata Bryozoa from the Middle and Upper Ordovician Rocks of Central Kentucky
164 Citations1983Olgerts L. Karklins
Evolution within each of the Ecologic-Evolutionary Units is tightly constrained by ecologic factors-there are no random adaptive radiations, or genera drifting from one community group to another, i.e., overall behaviors and physiologies are not in a continual state of flux.
Journal of Animal EcologyForaging Strategies, Population Models and Biological Control: A Case Study
142 Citations1980M. P. Hassell
A population model based on that of May (1978), but with k from the negative binomial now a function of host density as observed for Cyzenis, is analysed and the stability properties displayed.
The American NaturalistThe Introduced Hawaiian Avifauna: Biogeographic Evidence for Competition
141 Citations1983Michael P. Moulton, Stuart L. Pimm
Interspecific competition seems to have been an important process in determining extinction rate and, by extension, the equilibrium number of species on these islands.
EcologyProperties of Food Webs
134 Citations1980Stuart L. Pimm
Confirmation of all these predictions from stability analyses suggests that system stability places necessary, though not sufficient, limitations on the possible shapes of food webs.
NatureConnectance in real biotic communities and critical values for stability of model ecosystems
124 Citations1979Marcel Rejmánek, P. Starý
The first extensive empirical data on the relationship between connectance (defined as the fraction of the pairs of species which directly interact) and species richness in biological communities are presented.
ScienceStability and Diversity at Three Trophic Levels in Terrestrial Successional Ecosystems
122 Citations1971Lawrence E. Hurd, Michael V. Mellinger +2 more
An ecosystem perturbation experiment in which inorganic fertilizer was added to two successional old fields of different ages indicated that stability, expressed as resistance to modification by enrichment, increased during succession only at the primary trophic level.
Foundations for undergraduate research in mathematicsPopulation Dynamics of Infectious Diseases
117 Citations2022Glenn Ledder, Michelle Homp
Theoretical Population BiologyA reexamination of stability in randomly varying versus deterministic environments with comments on the stochastic theory of limiting similarity
115 Citations1978Michael Turelli
This paper shows by example that May's qualitative stability criterion does not ensure stability in any sense unless restrictive conditions on the form of the model are satisfied and alternative methods of analysis are proposed.
The Canadian EntomologistCommunity Stability and the Strategy of Biological Control
114 Citations1965Kenneth E. F. Watt
Computer analysis of data collected by the Canadian Forest Insect Survey on forest Macrolepidoptera and their food plants is used to postulate the following hypothesis: too much competition in the entomophagous trophic level will not allow the species in that level to be instable enough to control an unstable pest.
EcologyEffects of Population Density on Growth Rates of Animal Populations
96 Citations1966James T. Tanner
The primary conclusion is that in most animal species a population's growth rate is a decreasing function of density, which explains the relative stability of animal populations, which never continue to increase at rates their fertility would allow, and rarely decrease to extinction.
NatureComplex systems which evolve towards homeostasis
91 Citations1979Ken Tregonning, Alan Roberts
It is shown how, even on assumptions which make large complex and persistent systems highly improbable initially, they can nevertheless be expected to arise in profusion in the normal course of time development.
Journal of Theoretical BiologyDeterminants of stability of large randomly connected systems
66 Citations1975R. E. McMurtrie
Journal of Theoretical BiologyThe concepts of elasticity, invulnerability and invadability
64 Citations1979James V. Robinson, W. Valentine
This work addressed the effect of invasion on the species composition of communities and found that as communities were made more complex the probability of their being stable decreased, but the probabilityof their being invulnerable to invasion by other species increased.
NatureThe robustness of natural systems
53 Citations1980Alan Roberts, Ken Tregonning
Some important conclusions can be made about these model systems: first, an artificial system comparable in its size and complexity could hardly have this robust structure built into it; second, if grossly damaged, a natural system will usually be reduced to one of its viable subsystems.
NatureConnective stability of complex ecosystems
51 Citations1974D.D. Šiljak
It is confirmed by May2 in a study of large systems in the ecological context that probability of stability generally decreases with the increase of the degree of connectedness among the parts of the system.
The American NaturalistThe Stability of Complex Model Ecosystems
46 Citations1980Leonard Nunney
Simulations showed that although increasing complexity generally resulted in decreased stability, some examples exhibited an initial decline in stability as connectance increased but then showed greater stability as Connectance was increased further, which could be due to the effect of complexity in reducing interspecific interactions.
The American NaturalistThe Effects of Connectivity on Community Stability
32 Citations1982Robert A. Armstrong
The stability properties of a highly symmetric two-predator two-prey system were explored using techniques of local stability analysis and it is found that at the "trophic level" level of organization, stability is unaffected by changes in connectivity.
Theoretical Population BiologyReturn time and vulnerability for a food chain model
30 Citations1979Thomas L. Vincent, L. Roderick Anderson
Journal of Theoretical BiologyEcosystem stability: A result from an abstract simulation
27 Citations1974M. P. Austin, B. Cook
An abstract model of an ecosystem is presented which incorporates both population dynamic and energy flow concepts and attempts to avoid the simple assumptions of the Lotka-Volterra or mass-action types of equation.
Bulletin of Mathematical BiologyEcosystem-like behavior of a random-interaction model I
15 Citations1978Ken Tregonning, Alan Roberts
Journal of Theoretical BiologyEfficiency of biomass transfer and the stability of model food-webs
7 Citations1981R.S.M. Kirkwood, John H. Lawton
Low efficiency of biomass transfer enhanced stability in some types of web, but not in others, and increasing connectance decreased the probability of webstability—the opposite of De Angelis's prediction.
Theoretical Population BiologyStability of ecosystems with complex food webs
6 Citations1975Clark Jeffries
Sufficient conditions for stability of an ecosystem are presented and the conditions require that loops in food webs be in a sense “balanced.”
Food web linkage complexity and stability in a model ecosystem
5 Citations1974Michael I. Webber