Methods in epidemiology and public health: does practice match theory?
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthPublished 1 February 2001Open access
Douglas L. Weed
Citations30
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.78
SNIP1.24
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Three methods are of particular interest: meta-analysis, causal inference, and techniques for systematic narrative literature reviews are selected because serious concerns have been raised about how each is practised.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
Journal of the Royal Society of MedicineThe environment and disease: association or causation?
7,311 Citations2015Austin Bradford Hill
The objects of this newly founded Section of Occupational Medicine are to provide a means, not readily afforded elsewhere, whereby physicians and surgeons with a special knowledge of the relationship between sickness and injury and conditions of work may discuss their problems, not only with each other, but also with colleagues in other fields, by holding joint meetings with other Sections of the Society.
Proceedings of the Royal Society of MedicineThe Environment and Disease: Association or Causation?
6,888 Citations1965Austin Bradford Hill
This paper contrasts Bradford Hill’s approach with a currently fashionable framework for reasoning about statistical associations – the Common Task Framework – and suggests why following Bradford Hill, 50+ years on, is still extraordinarily reasonable.
Philosophy and Phenomenological ResearchObjective Knowledge, an Evolutionary Approach.
3,820 Citations1973Harry Ruja, Karl R. Popper
Journal of the American Statistical AssociationEpidemiologic Research: Principles and Quantitative Methods.
2,942 Citations1984Lawrence S. Mayer, David G. Kleinbaum +2 more
BMJ<i>Meta-analysis</i> Spurious precision? Meta-analysis of observational studies
980 Citations1998Matthias Egger, Marc P. Schneider +1 more
A Medline search identified 566 articles published in 1995 and indexed with the medical subject heading (MeSH) term “meta-analysis” and randomly selected 100 articles, finding about half were based on observational studies, mainly cohort and case-control studies of medical interventions or aetiological associations.
American Journal of Public HealthChoosing a future for epidemiology: II. From black box to Chinese boxes and eco-epidemiology.
791 Citations1996Mervyn Susser, Ezra Susser
This paper sees the close of the present era of chronic disease epidemiology and foresees a new era of eco-epidemiology in which the deployment of a different paradigm will be crucial, here a paradigm is advocated for the emergent era.
The Abuse of Casuistry: A History of Moral Reasoning
776 Citations1988Albert R. Jonsen, Stephen Toulmin
The Foundations of Bioethics
683 Citations1996H. Tristram Engelhardt
International Journal of EpidemiologyTraditional reviews, meta-analyses and pooled analyses in epidemiology
600 Citations1999M Blettner
For a full assessment of risk factors with a high prevalence in the general population, pooling of data will become increasingly important and future research needs to focus on the deficiencies of review methods.
American Journal of Public HealthChoosing a future for epidemiology: I. Eras and paradigms.
584 Citations1996Mervyn Susser, Ezra Susser
It is argued that in the present era, the public health has become less central a concern and in epidemiology today the dominant black box paradigm is of declining utility and is likely soon to be superseded.
American Journal of Public HealthTraditional epidemiology, modern epidemiology, and public health.
534 Citations1996Neil Pearce
Ebesity has largely ceased to function as part of a multidisciplinary approach to understanding the causation of disease in populations and has become a set of generic methods for measuring associations of exposure and disease in individuals.
Choice Reviews OnlinePrinciples of health care ethics
438 Citations1995
Partial table of contents: APPROACHes to applied health care ethics and relationships, and ethical problems in Infertility Treatment.
Epidemiologic ReviewsDemonstration of Deductive Meta-Analysis: Ethanol Intake and Risk of Myocardial Infarction
402 Citations1993Malcolm Maclure
Meta-analyses should be analytic and deductive, and a deductive approach starts with alternative generalizations (hypotheses) and uses particular observations to discriminate among them.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyMeta-analysis: Statistical alchemy for the 21st century
339 Citations1995Alvan R. Feinstein
American Journal of EpidemiologyHeterogeneity in Meta-analysis of Data from Epidemiologic Studies: A Commentary
244 Citations1995Graham A. Colditz, Elisabeth Burdick +1 more
Annual Review of Public HealthUnderstanding Research Synthesis (Meta-Analysis)
232 Citations1996Frederick Mosteller, Graham A. Colditz
The approaches to research synthesis that draw on the best available evidence and the use of quantitative summaries through meta-analysis are summarized and Random effects approaches to combining data are recommended, and theUse of regression approaches is emphasized.
PubMedCancer prevention and control.
220 Citations1990Peter Greenwald, Joseph W. Cullen +1 more
The history and present situation of cancer prevention and control in the United States and around the world are reviewed, as well as some of the techniques used in prevention and research, are reviewed.
JAMAClinical Epidemiological Quality in Molecular Genetic Research
176 Citations1999Sidney T. Bogardus, John Concato +1 more
Despite major laboratory advances in molecular genetic analysis, the data suggest that reported applications in clinical journals often have troubling omissions, deficiencies, and lack of attention to the different, but necessary, principles of clinical epidemiological science.
Annual Review of Public HealthA Future for Epidemiology?
146 Citations1999Skyler Schwartz, Ezra Susser +1 more
New ways of thinking about causes and prevention that could guide epidemiology beyond the present era are considered, which aims to preserve and build on the contributions of past eras, as well as the present one.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyThe practice of meta-analysis
124 Citations1995John C. Bailar
Meta-analysis seems to have a potentially useful role in carefully selected situations where the primary literature is of good quality, heterogeneity in the response to treatment of the tested population is small and well-understood, interest centers on estimation of a specific, critical parameter of outcome, and the meta-analyst is deeply expert in the subject matter.
Ethics and Epidemiology
123 Citations2009Levine, Carol
Ethical Issues in International Health Research and Epidemiology, John D. Porter, Carolyn Stephens, and Anthony Kessel, and The Regulatory Context and Professional Education.
International Journal of EpidemiologyOn the use of causal criteria
99 Citations1997Douglas L. Weed
Research on causal inference methodology should be encouraged, including research on underlying theory, methodology, and additional systematic descriptions of how causal inference is practised.
BMJWhen to act on the evidence
97 Citations1998T. Sheldon, Gordon Guyatt +1 more
Clinicians determine the day to day care patients receive in healthcare systems, and user groups are also beginning to play an important role in influencing healthcare decisions.
PubMedThe practice of causal inference in cancer epidemiology.
97 Citations1996Douglas L. Weed, L S Gorelic
This paper reviews two series of review papers published between 1985 and 1994 to find answers to the following questions: which studies and prior review papers were cited, which causal criteria were used, and what causal conclusions and public health recommendations ensued.
American Journal of EpidemiologyComments on a Meta-analysis of the Relation between Dietary Calcium Intake and Blood Pressure
93 Citations1998Nicholas Birkett
The author reviewed the original studies underlying this meta-analysis and discovered that data from one study had been inappropriately extracted and converted, leading to an understatement of the calcium-blood pressure relation by a factor of about 30, raising questions about the extraction and conversion of data from several other studies and about the statistical methods used.
JNCI Journal of the National Cancer InstituteCase-Control Studies of Cancer Screening: Theory and Practice
74 Citations1998Kathleen A. Cronin, Robert Connor +2 more
This review summarizes methodologic theories for the design of cancer screening case-control studies and examines the methods applied in studies published in English from 1980 through 1996, finding methodologic theory and practice to be consistent.
JNCI Journal of the National Cancer InstituteMethodologic Guidelines for Review Papers
71 Citations1997Douglas L. Weed
The purpose of this editorial is to propose a set of guidelines for reviews submitted to the Journal of the National Cancer Institute, a general oncology journal, with specific methodologic considerations in mind.
The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of MedicineBioethics as Methodological Case Resolution: Specification, Specified Principlism and Casuistry
46 Citations2000Ana S. Iltis
This issue of The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy shares the assumption that bioethics is about resolving cases, not about moral theory, and that the best method of bioethical decision-making is that which produces useful answers.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthThe philosophical foundations of public health: an invitation to debate.
46 Citations1994Harry G. J. Nijhuis, L J van der Maesen
The similarities in theme between these articles and a recent Editorial in the Journal of Public Health Medicine indicate that critical thinking about epidemiological concepts, methods and meanings is still required.
Choice Reviews OnlineFragmentation and consensus: communitarian and casuist bioethics
46 Citations1998
American Journal of Public HealthParadigms in epidemiology textbooks: in the footsteps of Thomas Kuhn.
44 Citations1999Raj B
Thomas Kuhn's philosophy of science offers insights into controversies such as whether a paradigm shift is needed or imminent and the gap between epidemiology and public health practice and interaction between science philosophers, epidemiologists, andpublic health practitioners may be valuable.
American Journal of Public HealthEpidemiology, the humanities, and public health.
44 Citations1995Douglas L. Weed
Studying and participating in the humanities may also help epidemiologists focus their professional concerns on the humanity their methods serve.
American Journal of EpidemiologyThe Society for Epidemiologic Research (SER) and the Future of Epidemiology
44 Citations1992Milton Terris
The current tasks of epidemiology are reviewed, as well as the objective and subjective factors which will determine the future of epidemiological research.
Oxford University Press eBooksChoosing a Future for Epidemiology: II. From Black Box to Chinese Boxes and Eco-Epidemiology
44 Citations2009Mervyn Susser, Zena Stein
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthTowards a philosophy of public health.
43 Citations1999Douglas L. Weed
The authors, Nijhuis and Van der Maesen, argued that debates about the pros and cons of public health approaches are often confined to the method ological scientific level, thereby neglecting implicit ontological notions lying behind and presumably influencing the arguments and decisions flowing from them.
Kennedy Institute of Ethics journalUnderdetermination and Incommensurability in Contemporary Epidemiology
41 Citations1997Douglas L. Weed
Suggestions are examined for dealing with the partial incommensurabilities found in the general practice of causal inference in contemporary epidemiology, and two specific examples illustrate these ideas: studies on the relationship between induced abortion and breast cancer and those on the relationships between moderate alcohol consumption and breastcancer.
The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of MedicineVirtue and Truth in Clinical Science
37 Citations1995G Gillett
This essay argues for a recovery of the Aristotelian idea of a techne, where there is a dynamic interplay between praxis and conceptualization, and proposes a post-Kuhnian epistemology for medical science that recognizes the evaluative dimension of knowledge, but that also looks to a Platonic conception of the good as the ultimate constraint on human thought.
American Journal of Public HealthQuality of reviews in epidemiology.
35 Citations1998Rosalind A. Breslow, S. A. Ross +1 more
There is a need to improve the quality of review papers in epidemiology if systematic methodology were followed more frequently and epidemiologic science and its application could be improved.
Annals of EpidemiologyNew Ethics Guidelines for Epidemiology
24 Citations1999Douglas L. Weed, Steven S. Coughlin
The context and rationale for this effort to produce ethics guidelines for epidemiologists, and the purpose and content of ethics guidelines in epidemiology are described, conclude that a new set of guidelines is reasonable and warranted.
American Journal of Public HealthEras, paradigms, and the future of epidemiology.
23 Citations1996Warren Winkelstein
The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of MedicineIncommensurability: Its Implications for the Patient/Physician Relation
17 Citations1995Robert M. Veatch, W. E. Stempsey
This work distinguishes four steps in the process of translating medical science into clinical decisions: the doing of the science, the appropriation of the scientific findings by the clinicians, the transfer of the findings from the clinician to the patient, and the choice of a treatment regimen.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyDiscussion
16 Citations1998Gio Batta Gori
A realistic appraisal finds that multifactorial epidemiology raises warning signals of varying influence, and that the usefulness of epidemiology and public health could be enhanced by conceiving of methods to score the relative strength and priority of such warnings.
Kennedy Institute of Ethics journalBioethics in the Third Millennium: Some Critical Anticipations
16 Citations1999H. Tristram Engelhardt
Without succumbing to a metaphysical scepticism or moral relativism, the bioethics of the future should learn how to live with robust moral diversity.
Annual Review of Public HealthUnderstanding Research Synthesis (Meta-Analysis)
15 Citations1996F. Mosteller
American Journal of EpidemiologyInvited Commentary on Meta-analysis of Epidemiologic Data: The Case of Calcium Intake and Blood Pressure
11 Citations1998Michael A. Stoto
The two papers illustrate how to extract data from published papers, to review the calculations for extraordinarily influential studies to include or for overlapping results to exclude, and to combine results with an appropriate concern for heterogeneity, and the strengths and limits of using metaanalysis to analyze public health policy.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthIn this number
10 Citations1994S. Donnan
Thrombus formation is associated with poorer prognosis and microthrombi at autopsy are found frequently disseminated in the lungs and other organs, which points toward the serious importance of thrombus prevention in the setting of the disease.
The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of MedicineOur World Views (May Be) Incommensurable: Now What?
9 Citations1995Carol Bayley
In focusing their view on Kuhn, Robert Veatch and William Stempsey ignore alternative sources of insight from other voices that could help move us beyond incommensurability.