Importance of air quality and related factors in the prevention of infection in orthopaedic implant surgery
Journal of Hospital InfectionPublished 1 July 1998
P.E. Gosden, Alasdair MacGowan, G.C. Bannister
Citations117
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.02
SNIP1.15
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
Small numbers of organisms can cause orthopaedic implant infections, which give rise to a considerable degree of morbidity and also mortality. The periprosthetic infection rates have been shown to correlate with the number of airborne bacteria within 30 cm of the wound. This is influenced by factors such as the number of operating theatre personnel, their clothing and the type of ventilation system used. Guidance on routine bacteriological monitoring of ultraclean air theatres, based on the Department of Health document Health Technical Memorandum 2025, is discussed. Factors important in minimizing the number of postoperative implant infections such as the use of ultraclean air, ultraviolet radiation, different types of surgical clothing, prophylactic antibiotics and host-related factors are also discussed. The importance of proper scientific investigation into the effectiveness of practical preventative measures in the operating room is emphasized.
Keywords
DentistryMedicine
BMJEffect of ultraclean air in operating rooms on deep sepsis in the joint after total hip or knee replacement: a randomised study.
694 Citations1982O. M. Lidwell, E. J. L. Lowbury +4 more
In the patients whose prostheses were inserted in an operating room ventilated by an ultraclean-air system the incidence of joint sepsis confirmed at reoperation within the next one to four years was about half that of patients who had had the operation in a conventionally ventilated room at the same hospital.
Acta Orthopaedica ScandinavicaPrognosis of total hip replacement in Sweden: Follow-up of 92,675 operations performed 1978–1990
603 Citations1993Henrik Malchau, Peter Herberts +1 more
A prospective, national multi-center study of all reoperations after total hip replacement (THR) was started by the Swedish Orthopedic Association in 1979, demonstrating that the average orthopedic surgeon cannot match the results achieved by experts.
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related ResearchSECTION II GENERAL ORTHOPAEDICS Postoperative Infection after Total Hip Replacement with Special Reference to Air Contamination in the Operating Room
434 Citations1972John Charnley
British journal of surgeryPostoperative infection in total prosthetic replacement arthroplasty of the hip-joint with special reference to the bacterial content of the air of the operating room
422 Citations1969John Charnley, Nas S. Eftekhar
It is a paradox that simple adherence to Listerian principles has abolished virulent postoperative infection, but infection by mildly pathogenic staphylococci appears to be increasingly common.
The LancetPROPHYLACTIC CEFAZOLIN VERSUS PLACEBO IN TOTAL HIP REPLACEMENT Report of a Multicentre Double-blind Randomised Trial
374 Citations1981Catherine Hill, F Mazas +2 more
Hip infections were less common in the four centres with hypersterile operating theatres, and the benefits of prophylactic antibiotics were restricted to patients having hip replacement operations in conventional theatres.
Journal of Bone and Joint SurgeryInfection rates after 3175 total hip and total knee replacements performed with and without a horizontal unidirectional filtered air-flow system.
295 Citations1982Eduardo A. Salvati, Raymond P. Robinson +4 more
To determine the effect of the ventilation system on infection rates after total hip and total knee arthroplasties performed in operating rooms with and without a horizontal unidirectional filtered air-flow system, using modern antiseptic conditions and antibiotic prophylaxis, all of the single-stage procedures were subjected to statistical analysis.
Journal of Hospital InfectionAirborne contamination of wounds in joint replacement operations: the relationship to sepsis rates
280 Citations1983O. M. Lidwell, E. J. L. Lowbury +4 more
During operations for total joint replacement done in operating rooms with conventional ventilation the mean air contamination varied considerably among the 15 hospitals studied, and it would seem that by far the largest proportion of bacteria found in the wound after the prosthesis had been inserted reached it by the airborne route.
Journal of Hospital InfectionThe importance of airborne bacterial contamination of wounds
277 Citations1982W. Whyte, R.D. Hodgson +1 more
Investigation into the sources of bacterial contamination of hip and knee joint replacement operations carried out in either a conventionally-ventilated or a laminar-flow operating room showed that the most important and consistent route of contamination was airborne, however, on occasions when patients had exceptionally high skin carriage of bacteria, gross wound contamination occurred.
Acta Orthopaedica ScandinavicaUltraclean air and antibiotics for prevention of postoperative infection: A multicenter study of 8,052 joint replacement operations
230 Citations1987O. M. Lidwell, Reginald A. Elson +5 more
To determine the value of ultraclean air in operating rooms, 8,052 operations for total hip- or knee-joint replacement were followed up for 1-4 years and staphylococcus aureus was the commonest joint pathogen, but infections with other organisms were almost as numerous.
Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery - British VolumeThe outcome of infected arthroplasty of the knee
180 Citations1986DP Johnson, G.C. Bannister
Arthrodesis, in 11 out of 12 cases, provided the painfree gait these patients desire, and Rheumatoid arthritis, the use of constrained prostheses and the presence of a superficial wound infection, all predisposed to deep infection.
Journal of Bone and Joint SurgeryCloxacillin in the Prophylaxis of Postoperative Infections of the Hip
176 Citations1973Carl Ericson, Lars Lidgren +1 more
In two widely separated hospitals a double-blind study of 171 hip operations was done, one group of patients receiving prophylactic cloxacillin, the other receiving a placebo, and ten of the twelve infections were staphylococcal.
British Journal of DermatologyDispersal of skin microorganisms
175 Citations1975W. C. Noble
Any organism found on the skin surface wi'l be dispersed including fluorescent corynebacteria (Somerville-Millar, personal communication), fungi, fungi (Clayton & Noble, 1963; Noble, Lidwell & Kingston, 1963) and presumably viruses.
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related ResearchSystemic Antibiotics and Gentamicin-Containing Bone Cement in the Prophylaxis of Postoperative Infections in Total Hip Arthroplasty
164 Citations1981Göran Josefsson, Lars Lindberg +1 more
In a prospective controlled multicenter study, the prophylactic effect of gentamicin-containing bone cement on postoperative infections in total hip arthroplasties was compared with that of systemically given antibiotics.
Acta Orthopaedica ScandinavicaProphylactic Antibiotics Against Early and late Deep Infections after total Hip Replacements
155 Citations1977Äke S. Carlson, Lars Lidgren +1 more
A review with a longer observation period is performed of a previously published double-blind investigation of the prophylatic value of cloxacillin against late infections after total hip replacements, finding that 15.4 per cent deep, late infections were found in the group without proPHylaxis and 20 per cent in the one with prophYLaxis.
Annals of SurgeryEvaluation of Wound Irrigation by Pulsatile Jet and Conventional Methods
138 Citations1978Lyle L. Brown, Harold T. Shelton +2 more
Journal of Hospital InfectionPrevention of sepsis in total joint arthroplasty
136 Citations1996Y.H. An, Richard J. Friedman
Because of the adoption of effective prophylactic measures such as improved operating room techniques and systemic antibiotics, the prosthetic infection rate for artificial joint procedures has been reduced to 1-2%.
Journal of Hospital InfectionAir, antibiotics and sepsis in replacement joints
128 Citations1988O. M. Lidwell
Reducing bacterial contamination of the wound by limiting dispersal from the operating staff through the wearing of special occlusive clothing and by employing directional flow ventilating systems substantially reduces the risk of later joint sepsis.
Journal of Hospital InfectionSuggested bacteriological standards for air in ultraclean operating rooms
125 Citations1983W. Whyte, O. M. Lidwell +2 more
Methods for determining 10 m-3 is suggested as the highest acceptable value for an ultraclean system and methods for determining this are described.
Journal of Bone and Joint SurgeryThe use of bone allografts in two-stage reconstruction after failure of hip replacements due to infection.
124 Citations1991D J Berry, Hugh P. Chandler +1 more
The results suggest that allografts of bone are useful for the reconstruction of osseous deficiencies in carefully selected patients who have a hip arthroplasty after infection.
Journal of Hospital InfectionClothing in laminar-flow operating theatres
114 Citations1996M. J. W. Hubble, A. E. Weale +4 more
The relative contribution of hats, masks and clothing to the control of wound contamination in both ultraclean (enclosed vertical laminar-flow) and conventional (plenum ventilated) airflow theatres was clarified.
Clinical Infectious DiseasesAntibiotic Prophylaxis in Orthopedic Surgery
112 Citations1991C. W. Norden
For routine dental work in most patients with total joint replacement, there is insufficient evidence to support antibiotic prophylaxis; for such individuals with periodontal disease or potential dental infection, antimicrobial prophYLaxis seems indicated.
PubMedTotal hip arthroplasty sepsis. Prevention and diagnosis.
111 Citations1992Robert H. Fitzgerald
Although major referral centers have managed to achieve exceptionally low incidences of postoperative sepsis with the prophylactic administration of antimicrobial agents and discipline within the operating room, these advances have not translated into a similar reduction of the national experience.
BMJRelation between mouth and haematogenous infection in total joint replacements
107 Citations1994C.A. Bartzokas, Rodney A. Johnson +4 more
The mouth was probably the source of bacterial infection in the prosthetic joints of these patients; the route of infection was possibly haematogenous andipient oral infection should be treated before joint replacement, and oral health should be maintained indefinitely.
Orthopedic Clinics of North AmericaTotal Hip Arthroplasty Sepsis
98 Citations1992Robert H. Fitzgerald
Annals of SurgeryQuantitative Bacterial Analysis of Comparative Wound Irrigations
91 Citations1975Merlin L. Hamer, Martin C. Robson +2 more
Data on tissue biopsies support previous reports using surface and wound exudate cultures and the pulsating jet lavate was found to be significantly better than gravity flow irrigation or wound irrigation with a bulb syringe.
Journal of HygieneBacterial dispersion in relation to operating room clothing
84 Citations1976W. Whyte, D. Vesley +1 more
The dispersal chamber could simulate conditions as expected both in down-flow unidirectional ultra-clean systems and in a conventional turbulent plenum-ventilated system and showed good correlation between the operating room and the chamber with the non-woven fabric gown but the total-body exhaust system did not perform as well in the Operating room the difference being possibly due to the contribution from the patient.
Infection Control and Hospital EpidemiologyThe Evolution of the Surgical Mask: Filtering Efficiency versus Effectiveness
68 Citations1997Nathan L. Belkin
In-vitro and in-vivo studies indicate that a mask may not be universally necessary in today's surgical environment.
British journal of surgeryThe efficiency of surgical masks of varying design and composition
65 Citations1975L. B. QUESNEL
Five different types of surgical mask of varying design and composition of natural and synthetic fibres were tested for their efficiency in vivo by means of a special test chamber, showing a significant difference between the best and worst masks.
Journal of Hospital InfectionWound disinfection with ultraviolet radiation
61 Citations1995Gordon Taylor, G.C. Bannister +1 more
In conventional and laminar flow theatres air and wound counts correlated closely but in UVC theatres wound counts were lower than levels expected from prevailing air counts suggesting that UVC kills bacteria in wounds as well as in air.
Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery - British VolumeUltraviolet radiation compared to an ultra-clean air enclosure. Comparison of air bacteria counts in operating rooms
55 Citations1991Mark A. Berg, B. Bergman +1 more
Ultraviolet light was more efficient than the ultra-clean air enclosure, and occlusive clothing on its own or in combination also produced improvement, which is important during joint replacement surgery.
Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery - British VolumeBacterial infection and acrylic cement in the rat
50 Citations1977RA Elson, A E Jephcott +2 more
In thirty-one rat tibiae, plugs of plain acrylic cement were inoculated with Staphylococcus aureus and Gentamicin, to which the organisms were fully sensitive, was efficacious in controlling the infection (90 per cent plugs proving sterile after two weeks).
Acta Orthopaedica ScandinavicaAir contamination during hip and knee arthroplasties: Horizontal laminar flow randomized vs. conventional ventilation
47 Citations1995Torbjöm Ahl, Nils Dalén +2 more
It is concluded that hip and knee arthroplasties can be performed in operating theaters with conventional ventilation when occlusive staff garments are used, however, laminar air flow ventilation in knee surgery, preferably in combination with Occlusive garments, resulted in a substantially lower air contamination and should be preferred.
Journal of Hospital InfectionThe prevention of orthopaedic implant and vascular graft infections
44 Citations1995C.J.L. Strachan
Large well-designed clinical trials have begun and are needed to confirm the forecast of improved long-term clinical outcomes.
Journal of Clinical PathologyWound infections acquired from a disperser of an unusual strain of <i>Staphylococcus aureus</i>
43 Citations1967G.A.J. Ayliffe, Beverly Collins
Seven post-operative wounds were infected with a strain of Staphylococcus aureus, probably acquired from a theatre orderly who suffered from a dry generalized eczema, and this strain was found to lose resistance to neomycin when subcultured in the absence of the antibiotic.
Infection Control and Hospital EpidemiologyThe Evolution of the Surgical Mask: Filtering Efficiency Versus Effectiveness
42 Citations1997Nathan L. Belkin
The Journal of ArthroplastyAir contamination during total hip arthroplasty in an ultraclean air enclosure using different types of staff clothing
37 Citations1990Lennart Sanzén, KE S. CARLSSON +1 more
It is concluded that both specially designed scrub suits and exhaust gowns can further reduce an already low level of bacterial air contamination in a down-flow, clean air enclosure.
The LancetEFFECTS OF ADHESIVE DRAPES ON CONTAMINATION OF OPERATION WOUNDS
37 Citations1970H. A. Lilly, E. J. L. Lowbury +2 more
Journal of Hospital InfectionAn investigation of occlusive polyester surgical clothing
36 Citations1990W. Whyte, D. L. Hamblen +3 more
The bacterial dispersion rate of people wearing operating room clothing made from several types of polyester fabric was compared to conventional cotton clothing, total-body exhaust gowns and disposable clothing to demonstrate the superiority of the polyester clothing.
Journal of HygieneA bacteriological evaluation of laminar-flow systems for orthopaedic surgery
33 Citations1973W. Whyte, B. H. Shaw +1 more
It has been demonstrated that velocities in the region of 0·3–0·4 m/sec.
Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery - British VolumeReduction of contamination at total hip replacement by special working clothes
32 Citations1990Gudmund Blomgren, J Hoborn +1 more
The combined use of zonal ventilation and the coverall achieved ultra-clean air conditions and the polypropylene coverall was associated with significantly lower air and wound counts.
Journal of Hospital InfectionRisk of airborne transmission in an operating theatre containing four ultraclean air units
31 Citations1995J.R. Babb, P. Lynam +1 more
This study shows that a single, large, operating theatre (barn) containing four ultraclean operating units (cabins), was highly effective in reducing the number of airborne bacteria in the operating fields providing all occupied Ultraclean cabins were functioning correctly.
Journal of Hospital InfectionBacterial contamination of air and surgical wounds during joint replacement operations. Comparison of two different types of staff clothing
30 Citations1991Jens Scheibel, Ingrid Jensen +1 more
The use of commercially available non-woven swabs for sampling bacteria from the surgical wound compared favourably with the use of specially prepared velvet pads and the importance of a clean air system for performing joint replacement operations is stressed.
Journal of Hospital InfectionIsolation of anaerobic and aerobic bacteria from clean surgical wounds: an experimental and clinical study
24 Citations1983E. Benediktsdóttir, Anna Hambræus
The pad method was superior to the wound wash-out method when sampling wounds in hip surgery and knew quantities of Staphylococcus aureus from experimental wounds in rabbits performed gave a threefold better recovery than with a swab.
Journal of Hospital InfectionSurvey of operating theatres in Great Britain and Ireland
23 Citations1995H. Humphreys, A. Stacey +1 more
There is some confusion over the indications for bacteriological monitoring and what constitutes acceptable standards and the use of non-ventilated theatres, except for the most minor of procedures, is of some concern and should be phased out.
Orthopedic Clinics of North AmericaThe Effect of Chronic Orthopedic Infection on Quality of Life
23 Citations1991Martin D. Cheatle
The patient with chronic orthopedic infection presents a unique challenge to the Orthopedic surgeon, who must not only possess an expertise in constantly evolving diagnostic and treatment techniques but also be able to identify numerous related problems and direct the patient in receiving the most appropriate treatment.
Journal of Hospital InfectionUltraviolet radiation and air contamination during total hip replacement
23 Citations1986Åke Carlsson, Björn Nilsson +2 more
In operating rooms fitted with a 'zonal ventilation' system and with an air change rate of about 70 h-1, the addition of uv irradiation during surgery may achieve 'ultra clean' air, but in conventionally ventilated operating rooms uv-irradiation alone is probably not sufficient to do so.
JAMAPrinciples and Management of Surgical Infections
16 Citations1991Jerry D. Smilack
The authors are at the threshold of monoclonal antibody treatment of sepsis and a number of vaccines previously undreamed of.
Lippincott eBooksPrinciples and management of surgical infections
14 Citations1991John M. Davis, G. Tom Shires
The editors have dedicated a chapter to each of the following specialties: burns, cardiovascular, orthopedics, pediatrics, transplantation, trauma, urology, and gynecology, and infections specific to these areas are detailed.
Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery - British VolumeShortwave ultraviolet radiation in operating rooms
10 Citations1989Mark A. Berg, B. Bergman +1 more
There was a significant reduction in the number of bacteria when compared with the use of sham blue light, and the reduced level was comparable with that suggested for ultraclean air ventilation systems.
Journal of Hospital InfectionAssessment of airborne bacterial contamination of clean wounds: results in a tissue model☆
9 Citations1992Gordon Taylor, John P. Leeming +1 more
Pulsed jet lavage with membrane filtration of the recovered fluid showed substantially better recovery, less variability and correlated more closely with controls than a tetrazolium stained 5 microns membrane filter imprint technique.
PubMedCombined prophylactic effect of ultraclean air and cefuroxime for reducing infection in prosthetic surgery.
4 Citations1991L. Klenerman, David Seal +1 more
No acute infections of a prosthesis occurred, while the rate was 2.9% for purulent wound infection which did not involve the prostheses, highlighting the need to continue the combined use of ultraclean air and antibiotics for hip and knee prosthetic surgery.
The Medical Journal of AustraliaIMPLANT INFECTION IN ORTHOPAEDICS
4 Citations1974Ian Stratton
It is thought that almost all implant wounds that become infected do so at the time of surgery, and if this is accepted then it stands to reason that measures taken to improve operating theatre environment should lower the infection rate.