Psychopathology and Obesitya
Annals of the New York Academy of SciencesPublished 1 June 1987
Thomas A. Wadden, Albert J. Stunkard
Citations121
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.46
SNIP1.73
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Emotional difficulties faced by the obese may be largely attributable to an entrenched cultural contempt for the obese and a pervasive preoccupation with thinness.
Abstract
Obesity has historically been linked to emotional factors by clinicians and the lay public alike. Early psychiatric studies reinforced the popular perception that psychopathology is common among the overweight and plays an important role in the development of obesity. This notion has been challenged by recent investigations which suggest that psychological disturbances are more likely to be the consequences than the causes of obesity. Emotional difficulties faced by the obese may be largely attributable to an entrenched cultural contempt for the obese and a pervasive preoccupation with thinness.
Keywords
PsychologyHealth Professions
Archives of General PsychiatryAffective Disorders in a US Urban Community
650 Citations1978Myrna M. Weissman
The current point and lifetime prevalence rates of affective disorders, based on the application of Research Diagnostic Criteria to a US urban community sample, are reported.
American Sociological ReviewCultural Uniformity in Reaction to Physical Disabilities
587 Citations1961Stephen A. Richardson, Norman Goodman +2 more
PubMedBulimia: a report of 34 cases.
583 Citations1981Richard L. Pyle, James E. Mitchell +1 more
The association between stealing behavior, chemical abuse and bulimia suggests problems with impulse control in this population of young females who usually experienced the onset of eating problems by early adulthood.
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyA study of social stereotype of body image in children.
475 Citations1967J. Robert Staffieri
It is reasonable to assume that the individual who is the recipient of statements which are based on another per- son's perception of his body is likely to incorpo- rate these perceptions into his own body concept.
JAMASocial Factors in Obesity
426 Citations1965Phillip B. Goldblatt
The longer a woman's family had been in this country, the less likely she was to be obese and opportunities for more effective weight control measures through programs specially tailored for populations at high risk are suggested.
BMJJolly fat: relation between obesity and psychoneurosis in general population.
380 Citations1976Alex Harley Crisp, Bernadette McGuiness
A significant positive relation was found between substantial obesity and low levels of anxiety and depression in men and women of a middle-aged suburban population.
BMJSelf-induced vomiting and bulimia nervosa: an undetected problem.
285 Citations1982Christopher G. Fairburn, Peter Cooper
The secrecy that surrounds bulimia nervosa is highlighted and it is suggested that it is an important undetected source of psychiatric morbidity.
New England Journal of MedicineObesity — Its Possible Effect on College Acceptance
271 Citations1966Helen Canning, Jean Mayer
The results indicated that there was less obesity in the colleges than in the high schools, and no differences were found in academic criteria and application rates between obese and nonobese high-school students.
JAMAObesity, Social Class, and Mental Illness
263 Citations1962Mary E. Moore
Preliminary analysis revealed a striking relationship between obesity and socioeconomic status of origin, and the prevalence of obesity was 7 times higher among women rearing in the lowest social class category as compared with those reared in the highest category.
Sociology of Work and OccupationsNo Fat Persons Need Apply
245 Citations1979Judith Candib Larkin, Harvey A. Pines
American Journal of Clinical NutritionA Longitudinal Study of Gross Body Composition and Body Conformation and Their Association with Food and Activity in a Teen-Age Population
241 Citations1966Ruth L. Huenemann, Leona R. Shapiro +2 more
American Journal of PsychiatryObesity and the Body Image: II. Age at Onset of Disturbances in the Body Image
241 Citations1967Albert J. Stunkard, VICTOR BURT
Findings of three interrelated studies undertaken to investigate the age at onset of the disturbances in body image reported by some obese persons suggest that adolescence is a critical period for the development of this disorder.
American Journal of PsychiatryObesity and the Body Image: I. Characteristics of Disturbances in the Body Image of Some Obese Persons
209 Citations1967Albert J. Stunkard, Myer D. Mendelson
The disturbance in body image is characterized by a feeling that one's body is grotesque and loathesome and that others view it with hostility and contempt and arises among emotionally disturbed persons whose obesity began prior to adult life.
Journal of Consulting and Clinical PsychologyControlled trial of very low calorie diet, behavior therapy, and their combination in the treatment of obesity.
188 Citations1986Thomas A. Wadden, Albert J. Stunkard
Annals of Internal MedicineDieting and Depression Reexamined
187 Citations1974Albert J. Stunkard, JOHN RUSH
Academic MedicineOverweight as a social disability with medical implications
177 Citations1969George L. Maddox, V Liederman
American Journal of Public HealthEffects of being overweight.
175 Citations1983Andrea Stewart, Robert H. Brook
It is found that 10 percent of this population are moderately overweight and 12 per cent are severely overweight (although 41 per cent perceive they are overweight), and information is provided on morbidity due to being overweight, and on what people are doing to try to lose weight.
American Sociological ReviewVariant Reactions to Physical Disabilities
170 Citations1963Norman Goodman, Sanford M. Dornbusch +2 more
Archives of General PsychiatryBehavior Therapy and Pharmacotherapy for Obesity
169 Citations1981Linda W. Craighead
One-year follow-up of all living patients who completed treatment showed a striking reversal in the relative efficacy of the treatments, and adding pharmacotherapy to behavior therapy apparently compromised the long-term effects of the latter treatment.
New England Journal of MedicinePsychosocial Effects of Intestinal Bypass Surgery for Severe Obesity
147 Citations1974Charles Solow, Peter M. Silberfarb +1 more
The most important psychologic change responsible for improved functioning was the loss of a pervasive sense of entrapment, helplessness and failure associated with massive obesity.
British Journal of Clinical PsychologyBinge eating: A theoretical review
145 Citations1981Jane Wardle, Helen Beinart
The clinical and experimental reports are combined to provide suggestions for the aetiology and treatment of the problem of binge eating.
World Journal of SurgeryGastric bypass for morbid obesity
116 Citations1981Ward O. Griffen, Brack A. Bivins +2 more
This is a report on 402 consecutive gastric bypass operations performed for morbid obesity, where all of the obesity-associated diseases responded favorably, either disappearing or being greatly ameliorated.
American Journal of PsychiatryPsychiatric diagnosis of morbidly obese gastric bypass patients
114 Citations1980Katherine A. Halmi, Michael Long +2 more
There is no evidence of an increased prevalence of major psychiatric disorder in obese persons when strictly defined diagnostic criteria are used.
Journal of Psychosomatic ResearchObesity in women in relation to mental illness, social factors and personality traits
113 Citations1981Tore Hällström, Henry Noppa
There were, however, significant relationships between obesity and the personality traits extraversion (EPI) and sociability (CMPS) when allowance was made for age and social class.
Journal of Psychosomatic ResearchA comparison of the psychological adjustment of obese vs. non-obese children
101 Citations1973Jacqueline Sallade
The overwhelming conclusion of the study was that there are both “striking similarities between the characteristic psychological traits of these obese adolescent girls and those of ethnic and racial minorities”.
American Journal of Clinical NutritionSelf-perceptions of the stigma of overweight in relationship to weight-losing patterns
99 Citations1979Natalie Allon
Youth who viewed overweight as both one's responsibility and as an illness that required the joint efforts of oneself and others, especially professional experts, were more successful in losing weight than those youth who believed that overweight was solely their responsibility or not at all their responsibility.
Advances in psychosomatic medicinePsychosocial Aspects of Obesity
96 Citations2006Varsha Vaidya
The treatment of depression in obesity and the psychiatric evaluation of the pre-bariatric surgery patient are discussed.
Journal of Psychosomatic ResearchMood changes in behavioral weight loss programs
89 Citations1984Rena R. Wing, Leonard H. Epstein +2 more
There was no evidence to indicate that untoward reactions to dieting were frequent, that patients with juvenile-onset obesity experienced more negative mood changes than those with adult-onsets obesity, or that dropping out of treatment was a response to increasing depression.
PubMedPsychologic assessment of morbidly obese patients undergoing gastric bypass: a comparison of preoperative and postoperative adjustment.
80 Citations1984K Gentry, Halverson Jd +1 more
In selected patients with no active psychiatric disease or psychologic instability, gastric bypass, coupled with consistent postoperative reinforcement, produces behavioral changes that can lead to permanent weight loss without concomitant psychologic deterioration.
Journal of Psychosomatic ResearchPsycho-socio-biological correlates of moderate overweight in an industrial population
77 Citations1978France Kittel, R. M. Rustin +3 more
Stepwise discriminant analyses between tertile III and tertile I introducing psychological, social and bioclinical variables showed that the ‘obese’ subjects (tertile III) are less frequently cigarette smokers, are less neurotic, are of a lower occupational class, are more frequently living in Wallonia (south of Belgium) and are more extravert compared to the ’lean’Subjects.
Perceptual and Motor SkillsBody Satisfaction in Adolescence
77 Citations1971Edward Clifford
It is suggested that the relative expression of dissatisfaction with height, weight, chest, waist, and hips may reflect cultural factors associated with concerns with weight gain in an affluent society, rather than concerns with stylized standards of beauty.
Women s Studies International QuarterlyObesity and women—II. A neglected feminist topic
76 Citations1979Orland W. Wooley, Susan C. Wooley +1 more
Psychosomatic MedicineThe Response of Obese Patients to Weight Reduction: A Clinical Evaluation of Behavior
68 Citations1968Myron L. Glucksman, Jules Hirsch
In these patients, psychopathologic adaptations during weight reduction were related to diminished body size, interpersonal transactions in the hospital environment which articulated with earlier injurious experiences, and caloric deprivation.
Women s Studies International QuarterlyObesity and women—I. A closer look at the facts
64 Citations1979Susan C. Wooley, Orland W. Wooley
Research indicates that ‘obese people do not, on the average, eat more than anyone else’, and that contrary to frequent medical insistence on the desirability of dieting, there is an almost inevitable weight gain after dieting.
American Journal of PsychiatryStudies of superobesity: II. Psychiatric appraisal of jejuno-ileal bypass surgery
62 Citations1976Pietro Castelnuovo‐Tedesco, Douglas Schiebel
Although there were no serious postoperative psychiatric complications, patients experienced more mood lability and greater awareness of anxiety, depression, and irritability; their necessary adjustments in lifestyle strained relationships with spouses and parents in some cases.
Addictive BehaviorsMacAndrew addiction scale and other MMPI characteristics associated with obesity, anorexia and smoking behavior
61 Citations1979Gloria R. Leon, Ronette L. Kolotkin +1 more
It appears from the present findings as well as those of other investigators that an elevated score on the MacAndrew Scale can be interpreted as an indication of an addiction problem or addiction proneness, however, not all persons with substance abuse patterns have an elevatedscore on this measure.
Psychosomatic MedicineA Survey of Biographical and Psychological Features in Extraordinary Fatness
61 Citations1967ROLAND ATKINSON, Eugene L. Ringuette
The very obese adults surveyed did not differ from some less obese groups reported by other investigators for frequency of family obesity, reactive eating, reported family feeding conflicts, sibship position, parental overprotection, and psychiatric diagnoses.
Journal of Behavioral MedicineChanges in body image and other psychological factors after intestinal bypass surgery for massive obesity
58 Citations1979Gloria R. Leon, Elka D. Eckert +2 more
A group of massively obese persons was evaluated 6 months prior to intestinal bypass surgery and again while in the hospital awaiting surgery, and a second follow-up group was assessed periodically over the subsequent 1-year period.
Social Science & MedicineThe dieter's dilemma: Eating less and weighing more
57 Citations1984Nancy A. Rigotti
Marriage & Family ReviewMarriage, Obesity and Dieting
52 Citations1984Jeffery Sobal
Work on the prevalence of obesity by marital status; factors associated with obesity as a criterion for entry into marriage; the similarity of fatness in marital partners; changes in weight in relationship to marital problems; and the relationship between obesity and marital termination is reviewed.
PubMedSuper-obesity: a psychiatric profile of patients electing gastric stapling for the treatment of morbid obesity.
50 Citations1981Hutzler Jc, Joyce Keen +2 more
This is a preliminary report designed to identify personality characteristics which are unique to those super-obese electing a surgical intervention for weight loss.
The International Journal of Psychiatry in MedicineStudies of Superobesity: I. Psychological Characteristics of Superobese Patients
50 Citations1975Pietro Castelnuovo‐Tedesco, Douglas Schiebel
Characteristics contribute to the traditional reputation of the obese as “difficult” patients and deserve greater attention to help improve the effectiveness both of standard medical management and of psychotherapy.
Psychosomatic MedicinePersonality and Interest Patterns in Obese Adolescent Girls
47 Citations1967Sidney L. Werkman, ELSA S. GREENBERG
Obese adolescent girls at a medically oriented camp for overweight girls were compared with normal‐weight girls at an ordinary summer camp on a number of personality and interest measures (MMPI, Strong, Semantic Differential, and Sentence Completion).
International Journal of Eating DisordersToward a psychology of obesity: Review of research on the role of personality and level of adjustment
47 Citations1982William T. McReynolds
Psychosomatic MedicineFollow-Up of Patients Starved for Obesity
45 Citations1970David W. Swanson, Frank A. Dinello
For most patients a return to obesity was more comfortable and tolerable than trying to fight with their problem in the presence of environmental demands.
American Journal of Clinical NutritionPersonality characteristics in obesity: relation of MMPI profile and age of onset of obesity to success in weight reduction
42 Citations1976SF Johnson, WM Swenson +1 more
Findings show that certain personality traits as measured by the M MPI may occur more frequently in obese persons, and the individual MMPI profile codes point out the presence of diverse behavior patterns among obese persons rather than a single personality pattern characteristic of obesity.
Archives of General PsychiatrySevere Obesity as a Habituation Syndrome
41 Citations1970David W. Swanson
Psychosomatic MedicineMental Illness in Lower Class Normal, Obese and Hyperobese Women
40 Citations1970Jimmie Holland, Joseph Masling +1 more
The data suggest that it is hazardous to assume a uniform psychodynamic formulation for obesity, applicable to all irrespective of their social or ethnic backgrounds, despite a wide range of scores in all groups.
Archives of SurgeryGastric Bypass for Morbid Obesity
39 Citations1980Edward C. Saltzstein
Patients who did not experience postoperative complications showed significant improvement in depression, hysteria, poor morale, psychoticism, phobias, and health concerns, and psychological changes with surgery did not correlate with weight loss.
Journal of Psychosomatic ResearchTreatment of obesity with special reference to seven severely obese patients
34 Citations1970A. H. Crisp, Edward Stonehill
Annals of Internal MedicineOBESITY IN MEN: A CLINICAL STUDY OF TWENTY-FIVE CASES
28 Citations1961MYER MENDELSON, Norris H. Weinberg +1 more
Current clinical concepts of obesity have been derived almost entirely from the study of obese women, and by chance or by design most obese groups which have been studied have contained few if any overweight people.
Perceptual and Motor SkillsBody Characteristics in Relation to Life Adjustment, Body-Image and Attitudes of College Females
27 Citations1974Helen I. Douty, Justin B. Moore +1 more
A major conclusion was that intervening variables of body-image and self-perception must be examined if the relationship between body and personality is to be clarified.
Archives of General PsychiatryPsychotherapy of Six Hyperobese Adults During Total Starvation
24 Citations1968Christopher V. Rowland
PSYCHOTHERAPY was carried out on hyperobese adults during total starvation of 10 to 50 days on a metabolic research ward and Observations on six patients included the vicissitudes of aggressive and sexual impulses, the impact of fasting and weight loss on the patient's body image, and the psychological effects of the study on the patients.
BMJScreening for Inherited Metabolic Disease by Plasma Chromatography (Scriver) in a Large City
23 Citations1972D. N. Raine, Juniebel Cooke +2 more
The three years' experience in Birmingham showed a three-fold increase in cases detected and suggests criteria for further investigation and treatment.
PubMedPsychosocial functioning of two groups of morbidly obese patients.
21 Citations1983Rosen Lw, Aniskiewicz As
The bypass group demonstrated significantly higher levels of psychosocial stressors and lower levels of adaptive functioning when compared to the non-bypass group, and the bypass patients also had a significantly higher frequency of past suicide attempts.
Psychological ReportsMMPI Profiles of Obese Men and Women
21 Citations1977Anne S. Pomerantz, Isaac Greenberg +1 more
MMPI profiles of 20 male and 20 female patients were chosen at random from the entire patient population of a weight reduction program and indicated passivity and non-assertiveness in both groups.
PsychosomaticsJejunoileal bypass: General and psychiatric outcome after one year
21 Citations1980John M. Kuldau, Colleen S. W. Rand
Most patients lost weight and improved in psychiatric status, although changes in such status often seemed to be related to causes other than the jejunoileostomy.
PubMedPsychological status among female candidates for surgical treatment of obesity.
19 Citations1983Duckro Pn, Leavitt Jn +2 more
The identification of patients who suffer psychosocial complications after surgical treatment for obesity remains an unresolved problem and if reliable psychological subgroups of the population of candidates for surgical treatment can be determined, the prediction of psychological casualties may be significantly advanced.
Journal of Clinical PsychologyJejunoileal bypass procedures in morbid obesity: Preoperative psychological findings
18 Citations1976Warren W. Webb, Robert Phares +4 more
Patients who averaged 155% overweight and requested jejunoileal bypass surgery as a treatment intervention for morbid obesity were studied preoperatively for prominent psychological characteristics and it was found that 89% were judged to be psychologically favorable risks for the operation.
PubMedPsychosocial aspects of extremely obese women joining a diet group.
13 Citations1979Lauer Jb, Wampler Rs +2 more
The most striking finding was that these extremely obese women, who were not alcoholics, showed scores on alcoholism scales which are typical of an alcoholic population.
Journal of Clinical PsychologyCorrespondence of the MMPI and the MMPI-168 with intestinal bypass surgery patients
5 Citations1981Soren Svanum, Joanne B. Lantz +3 more
Although evidence for its use as a screening device to identify those individuals who may be experiencing significant psychological problems is offered, the analyses indicated that the two forms should not be considered equivalent in this setting.