Social Analyses of Computing: Theoretical Perspectives in Recent Empirical Research
ACM Computing SurveysPublished 1 March 1980
Rob Kling
Citations781
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score5.80
SNIP11.03
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The roles of computer technologies in the workplace, in decision making, in altering power relationships, and in influencing personal privacy are examined and two broad perspectives are contrasted.
Abstract
article Social Analyses of Computing: Theoretical Perspectives in Recent Empirical Research Share on Author: Rob Kling Department of Information and Computer Science and Public Policy Research Organization, University of California at Irvine, Irvine, California Department of Information and Computer Science and Public Policy Research Organization, University of California at Irvine, Irvine, CaliforniaView Profile Authors Info & Claims ACM Computing SurveysVolume 12Issue 1March 1980 pp 61–110https://doi.org/10.1145/356802.356806Online:01 March 1980Publication History 495citation5,330DownloadsMetricsTotal Citations495Total Downloads5,330Last 12 Months97Last 6 weeks19 Get Citation AlertsNew Citation Alert added!This alert has been successfully added and will be sent to:You will be notified whenever a record that you have chosen has been cited.To manage your alert preferences, click on the button below.Manage my AlertsNew Citation Alert!Please log in to your account Save to BinderSave to BinderCreate a New BinderNameCancelCreateExport CitationPublisher SiteGet Access
Keywords
Social SciencesComputer SciencePhysics and Astronomy
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsLabor and Monopoly Capital: The Degradation of Work in the Twentieth Century.
3,003 Citations1976Dale Tomich, Harry Braverman
Social ForcesThe Coming of Post-Industrial Society: A Venture in Social Forecasting.
2,598 Citations1974Guy E. Swanson, Daniel Bell
Teaching SociologyComplex Organizations: A Critical Essay
2,198 Citations1990Neil Fligstein, Charles Perrow
Land EconomicsThe Human Use of Human Beings: Cybernetics and Society
1,664 Citations1951Stephen B. Miles, Norbert Wiener
This book examines the implications of cybernetics for education, law, language, science, technology, as Norbert Wiener anticipates the enormous impact--in effect, a third industrial revolution--that the computer has had on the authors' lives.
American Political Science ReviewDecisions and Nondecisions: An Analytical Framework
1,244 Citations1963Peter Bachrach, Morton S. Baratz
ACM SIGART BulletinComputer power and human reason
1,057 Citations1976Benjamin Kuipers, John McCarthy +1 more
The book mentions some important concerns which are obscured by harsh and sometimes shrill accusations against the Artificial Intelligence research community, but it seems to me that the personal attacks distract and mislead the reader from more valuable abstract points.
Teaching SociologyThe Structure of Sociological Theory
943 Citations1979Gerd Schroeter, Jonathan H. Turner
ComputerPersonal Dynamic Media
645 Citations1977Alan Kay, Athomas Goldberg
The Learning Research Group at Xerox Palo Alto Research Center is concerned with all aspects of the communication and manipulation of knowledge and has designed and built a communications system: the Smalltalk language, implemented on small computers they refer to as "interim Dynabooks".
Management ScienceManagement Information Systems: Appreciation and Involvement
532 Citations1974E. Burton Swanson
The testing of several hypotheses in this setting indicates that managers who involve themselves with the MIS will appreciate the system, and that management who are uninvolved will be unappreciative.
Management SciencePerformance and the Use of an Information System
342 Citations1975Henry C. Lucas
The results confirm the general relationships among classes of variables in the model, but specific relations among variables are complex and depend heavily on the environment of the organization.
Public Administration ReviewApplying Information Technology to Organization Design
339 Citations1973Herbert A. Simon
The normative theory of organization traditionally paid special attention to two problems: how to divide up the work for its efficient performance and in such a way as to keep the needs for coordination of the parts within manageable bounds.
Management ScienceManagement Information Systems: The Challenge to Rationality and Emotionality
255 Citations1971Chris Argyris
ACM Computing SurveysCost-Benefit Analysis in Information Systems Development and Operation
219 Citations1978John Leslie King, Edward L. Schrems
Basic elements of cost-benefit analysis as applied to computerized informatmn systems are reviewed, and dmcussmn of the major problems to be avoided are provided.
MIS QuarterlyThe Organizational Context of User-Centered Software Designs*
181 Citations1977Rob Kling
An expanded conceptual framework which includes both the personal characteristics of designers and features of the organizational settings in which they work is presented and is used to develop a set of policies to help foster the development of usercentered systems.
Journal of the Operational Research SocietyInformation Systems: Theory and Practice
178 Citations1990Simon Peck, John G. Burch +1 more
The Fundamentals of Building Information Systems: Building Innovative Information Systems is presented, which discusses the design of information system blocks and the management of Strategic Information Systems Planning.
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsThe Ungovernable City: The Politics of Urban Problems and Policy Making.
113 Citations1979William Brandt, Douglas Yates
Administrative Science QuarterlyThe Applicability of Organizational Sociology.
105 Citations1973Stanley H. Udy, Chris Argyris
Symbolic InteractionPatterns Of Segmentation And Intersection In The Computing World*
97 Citations1978Rob Kling, Elihu M. Gerson
The relationship of one particular pattern of cleavages—the production system—is described vis-vis other lines of cleavage and segmentation, and the implications of these intersections for the organization of the production system are described.
Communications of the ACMAutomated welfare client-tracking and service integration
95 Citations1978Rob Kling
The major impact of the automated client-tracking system was to enhance the administrative attractiveness of the using agencies in the eyes of funders rather than to increase their internal administrative efficiency.
Columbia University Press eBooksThe Management of Information Systems
91 Citations1981Kenneth L. Kraemer, William H. Dutton +1 more
Advances in computersComputing as Social Action: The Social Dynamics of Computing in Complex Organizations
83 Citations1980Rob Kling, Walt Scacchi
The chapter presents an examination of the usefulness of different social perspectives for explaining how computing developments work in complex organizations and suggests that the six perspectives are best introduced by indicating how they help explain a complex case of computer use.
Political Science QuarterlyModels in the Policy Process: Public Decision Making in the Computer Era, <i>by Martin Greenberger, Matthew A. Crenson and Brian L. Crissey</i>
82 Citations1977Bruce C. Vladeċk
Communications of the ACMValue conflicts and social choice in electronic funds transfer system developments
79 Citations1978Rob Kling
The incentives for EFT developments and the social problems they raise in the context of conflicts between five different value positions that are often implicit in analyses of proposed EFT arrangements are examined.
Administrative Science QuarterlyObservations on the Dynamics of a Change to Electronic Data-Processing Equipment
79 Citations1960Floyd C. Mann, Lawrence K. Williams
Findings from an exploratory, longitudinal study of the effects of a change-over to electronic data-processing equipment in a light and power company are presented.
Symbolic InteractionThe Social Dynamics of Technical Innovation in the Computing World*
78 Citations1977Rob Kling, Elihu M. Gerson
This paper identifies the major orientations taken on by participants in the computing world and examines some of the markets across which innovations are negotiated.
Proceedings of the IEEEApplications of information networks
74 Citations1978J. C. R. Licklider, A. Vezza
A way of estimating the relative importance of various network characteristics and of predicting the suitability of a network or network architecture for a given set of applications, and several issues that relate to the political, social, and economic impacts of networks are considered.
The Computer and the Clerk
74 Citations2018Enid Mumford, Olive Banks
Public Administration ReviewA Realistic Look at the Final Payoffs from Urban Data Systems
54 Citations1967Anthony J. Downs
The author analyzes the types of final payoffs of urban data systems and some of the implications for government and private decision-making in urban areas.
Communications of the ACMThe use of an interactive information storage and retrieval system in medical research
53 Citations1978Henry C. Lucas
The results show the important role played by frequently chosen laboratory reference leaders in influencing the use of this system and the implications for the design of similar systems are discussed.
Communications of the ACMManagement utilization of computers in American local governments
52 Citations1978William H. Dutton, Kenneth L. Kraemer
Management computing is most prevalent in those governments with professional management practices where top management is supportive of computing and tends to control computing decisions and where department users have less control over design and implementation activities.
ACM SIGMIS Database the DATABASE for Advances in Information SystemsInstitutional and ad hoc DSS and their effective use
51 Citations1977John Donovan, Stuart Madnick
Some of the computational facilities used in institutional and ad hoc decision support systems, which are being effectively used to support regional energy decisions in New England, are described.
Administration & SocietyThe Interests Served B Y Technological Reform
47 Citations1979Kenneth L. Kraemer, William H. Dutton
The findings indicate that computer-based systems tend to follow and reinforce the existing pattern of local government power relationships, whether that pattern be pluralistic or centralized in bureaucrats, technocrats, or politicians.
Communications of the ACMOn approaches to the study of social issues in computing
47 Citations1981Abbe Mowshowitz
The analysis of positions documents the close relationship between research and policy formation and reveals the misleading and dangerous character of the presumption of scholarly objectivity in research on social issues.
Public Administration ReviewComputers, Local Governments, and the Litany to EDP
44 Citations1977James Ν. Danziger
There has developed among many local government actors a "litany" to EDP, which consists of certain canons about the beneficial impacts of computers on local government operations, but the evidence suggests that the litany is often misleading and occasionally incorrect.
Communications of the ACMGuidelines for humanizing computerized information systems
41 Citations1974Theodor D. Sterling
An intensive analysis of conditions that may humanize or dehumanize participants in various computerized systems generated during a week-long workshop sponsored in August 1973 by Canada Council at Canada Council's Stanley House.
ACM SIGCAS Computers and SocietyComputers and social power
38 Citations1974Rob Kling
The following essay is an early draft of a major now in progress and the author would appreciate comments and criticism.
ACM SIGMIS Database the DATABASE for Advances in Information SystemsBusiness information characterization study
38 Citations1979David V. Kerner
The Business Information Characterizatio n Study is described which is a logical extension to the BSP methodology via use of Donald Burnstine's BIAIT theory 2 to provide a structured approach for understanding business information systems.
Decision SciencesUNSUCCESSFUL IMPLEMENTATION THE CASE OF A COMPUTER‐BASED ORDER ENTRY SYSTEM
36 Citations1978Henry C. Lucas
The experimental results show a marked reduction in job satisfaction after implementation of the new system, which includes the introduction of an optically scanned order input form and new computer programs.
Operational Research Quarterly (1970-1977)How Computers Affect Management
34 Citations1973J. R. S. Kistruck, Rosemary Stewart
Decision SciencesDIFFERENCES IN ILL‐STRUCTURED PROBLEM SOLVING ALONG THE ORGANIZATIONAL HIERARCHY
32 Citations1978Harvey J. Brightman
A normative model of strategic problem solving is developed based upon Allison's work and three conceptual models are suggested as descriptive frameworks for understanding Simon's decision process.
Communications of the ACMThe impact and use of computer technology by the police
32 Citations1979Kent W. Colton
This paper reports on case studies and surveys which provide insights on the implementation and impact of police computer technology and the relationship of this technology to law enforcement and society.
Communications of the ACMA problem-list of issues concerning computers and public policy
29 Citations1974
Public In this arca, and, of requested, to suggcctlons arc solicttcci, either on quesJerome A .
Automated information systems as social resources in policy making
25 Citations1978Rob Kling
A study of the uses and impacts of automated systems for policy analysis in 42 municipal governments finds that computer-based systems reinforce the existing distribution of power in American municipalities.
ACM SIGMIS Database the DATABASE for Advances in Information SystemsReview of "The Conquest of Will: Information Processing in Human Affairs, by Abbe Mowshowitz." Addison Wesley, Reading, Massachusetts, 1976
25 Citations1977Theodore C. Willoughby
This book is aimed directly at the practical processes and problems of system analysis, and it begins precisely where it should: the organizational setting within which systems analysis must function.
Communications of the ACMComputers as an innovation in American local governments
25 Citations1977James Ν. Danziger, William H. Dutton
It is established that there is substantial variation among the larger local governments in the rate at which they adopt computer technology, in the level of financial support they provide for EDP, and in the extensiveness and sophistication of their automated applications.
Towards a person-centered computer technology
25 Citations1973Rob Kling
eScholarship (California Digital Library)The impacts of computing on the work of managers, data analysts and clerks
23 Citations1978Rob Kling
Overall, respondents report that computer use enlarges their jobs, but does not profoundly alter the character of their jobs.
Telecommunications PolicyInformation systems in policy making
23 Citations1978Rob Kling
The author suggests a coupling of selected organizational rearrangements and automated information systems, using competitive analyses to ensure that political decisions are sensitive to the values of different interests.
Urban SystemsAn assessment of computer technology in U.S. local governments
17 Citations1978James Ν. Danziger, Kenneth L. Kraemer +1 more
An assessment of the use and impacts of computers and electronic data processing in the larger municipal and county governments of the United States, based on extensive data gathered by a major research project.
Advances in computersSoftware in the Soviet Union: Progress and Problems
15 Citations1979S. E. Goodman
The development of Soviet computing has tended to follow closely the US technical pattern, but it has differed considerably in terms of timescale, philosophy, institutional arrangements, capital decisions, and applications.
ACM SIGMIS Database the DATABASE for Advances in Information SystemsMAPP
14 Citations1977Ephraim R. McLean, Thomas F. Riesing
MAPP, which stands for Managerial Analysis for Profit Planning, was developed and installed at Citibank (formerly First National City Bank) in New York City in mid-1975 and is a system designed to support financial planning and budgeting throughout the organization.
Communications of the ACMConsumer difficulties with computerized transactions
14 Citations1979T. D. Sterling
While most management systems may be adequate, results of the survey raise concerns about the timeless and the number of designs of very large linked program packages (as EFT for instance).
Sociology of Work and OccupationsDefusing Technological Change in Juvenile Courts
12 Citations1979Gary L. Albrecht
This study focuses on the ways in which professional groups attempted to gain control of a computerized information system so that they could preserve their professional autonomy, maintain control over their work, and give the appearance of a job well done.
Telecommunications PolicyElectronic funds transfer as a subject of study in technology, society and public policy
11 Citations1978John Leslie King, Kenneth L. Kraemer
The authors propose in detail a long-term study of electronic funds transfer that would cover six major topics: how technology emerges, how new technology is handled by existing institutions; how new technologies are assimilated by the public; what specific impacts new technologies have; hownew technologies create synergistic impacts with other technologies; and how technologies change over time to conform to new circumstances and developments.
Social implications of intelligent machines
10 Citations1978Margaret A. Boden
Precautionary measures that might be taken in the writing and presentation of programs to forestall the social dangers implicit in this area of research are examined.
ACM SIGSOC BulletinThe social dynamics of instrumental computer use
10 Citations1978Rob Kling, Walter Scacchi +1 more
The opportunities and problems of instrumental computer use vary when users utilize different technologies and different organizational arrangements for supporting them, however, as software and hardware developments progress, the social arrangements of computer use will increasingly dominate the attention of users.
Communications of the ACMArguments for a moratorium on the construction of a community information utility
9 Citations1974Laurence I. Press
The conclusion is drawn that society is not yet in a position to justify either the construction of an information utility in a prototype community or the acceptance of a policy in favor of its widespread implementation.
Telecommunications PolicyAlternative EFT developments and the quality of life
8 Citations1979Rob Kling
A conception of quality of life is defined which emphasizes the relative power of participants in a social setting as well as their personal resources and sentiments in the EFT arrangements.
1979 International Workshop on Managing Requirements Knowledge (MARK)MIS effects on managers’ task scope and satisfaction
8 Citations1979Daniel Robey
The purpose of this paper is to shed some empirical light on one hotly debated issue: the impact of management information systems on managers’ tasks and their evaluation of computer-induced changes in tasks.
Technological Forecasting and Social ChangeCriteria for “Good” futures research
8 Citations1974Ida R. Hoos
Justice System JournalThe Effects of Computerized Information Systems on Juvenile Courts.
5 Citations1976Gary L. Albrecht
This paper reports the results of a four-year study that gathered before-and-after data on a newly implemented juvenile court CIS, and discusses the effects of one of these new technolo gies, computerized information systems (CIS), on juvenile courts.
IEEE Transactions on Engineering ManagementAn MIS story
4 Citations1974E. Burton Swanson
The story of the development of an `Activity Reporting Information System' (`ARIS') in the `SQC Engineering' department illustrates three conclusions regarding the design and implementation of management information systems.
Computers and ethical judgment in organizations
4 Citations1978Abbe Mowshowitz
A study in descriptive ethics that seeks to identify and analyze organizational features that enhance or inhibit the making of ethical judgments and a scheme for analyzing ethical conduct is presented.
IEEE SpectrumThe wired household: Teletext services pave the way for a variety of useful monitoring and control features in the home
3 Citations1979E. Bryan Carne
Describes the variety of useful monitoring and control features that advanced electronics can offer to households in addition to the information retrieval now available as Teletext services.
ACM SIGCAS Computers and SocietyThe impact of scanners on employment in supermarkets
2 Citations1979Bruce Gilchrist, Arlaana Shenkin
The following brief examination of the impact of scanners on employment in supermarkets was conducted as part of an ongoing investigation of how computers are affecting employment.
eScholarship (California Digital Library)Metaphors of Instrumental Computer Use: A Case Study
2 Citations1980John S. Conery
There are two metaphors for describing instrumental computer use: the computer as a tool, and a more comprehensive package metaphor that emphasizes all aspects of computer use (hardware, software, and social interactions with vendors and other actors in the computing world).
ACM SIGCAS Computers and SocietyComputers and politics in China
1 Citations1979Andrew C. Gordon
It is believed that computing in China is revealing about larger issues in their society and that an understanding of Chinese priorities can teach us as much about ourselves as about the Chinese.
…