Two models of mistake-making in professional practice: moving out of the closet
Nursing PhilosophyPublished 1 January 2005
Nancy Crigger
Citations33
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score0.94
SNIP1.39
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
Nurses make mistakes in practice despite the culturally based expectation of perfection. Such a disparity between reality and expectation calls members of the profession to question the current attitudes toward mistakes in practice. Two explanatory models of the origin of mistakes are presented. The Perfectibility Model holds that any error or harm is caused by an individual practitioner's lack of knowledge or motivation. The Faulty Systems Model offers a broader explanation of human error. I conclude that a Faulty Systems Model is more comprehensive and more effective for managing mistakes. Integrating the Faulty Systems Model into practice and education can result in more ethically fitting responses to errors and ultimately better outcomes for nurses, institutions and patients.
Keywords
Health Professions
Choice Reviews OnlineOur posthuman future: consequences of the biotechnology revolution
1,809 Citations2002
The dramatic advances in DNA technology over the last few years are the stuff of science fiction, but is it now not only possible to clone human beings it is happening, and is this the end of human beings?
New England Journal of MedicineViews of Practicing Physicians and the Public on Medical Errors
774 Citations2002Robert J. Blendon, Catherine M. DesRoches +8 more
Though substantial proportions of the public and practicing physicians report that they have had personal experience with medical errors, neither group has the sense of urgency expressed by many national organizations to advance their agenda.
JAMADo House Officers Learn From Their Mistakes?
566 Citations1991Albert W. Wu
House officers who accepted responsibility for the mistake and discussed it were more likely to report constructive changes in practice and residents were less likely to make constructive changes if they attributed the mistake to job overload.
JAMAFactors that prompted families to file medical malpractice claims following perinatal injuries
375 Citations1992Gerald B. Hickson
New England Journal of MedicineFacing Our Mistakes
275 Citations1984David Hilfiker
Looking at the appointment book for July 12, 1978, I notice that Barb Daily will be in today for her first prenatal examination, and "Wonderful," I think, remembering my joy as I helped her deliver her daughter.
Philosophical PsychologyThe use of crying over spilled milk: A note on the rationality and functionality of regret
273 Citations1999Marcel Zeelenberg
Social Science & MedicineManaging medical mistakes: Ideology, insularity and accountability among internists-in-training
220 Citations1984Terry Mizrahi
The whole system of accountability during graduate medical specialty training was found to be a variable, and at times, contradictory process.
The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of MedicineToward a Theory of Medical Fallibility
173 Citations1976Samuel Gorovitz, A. MacIntyre
AJN American Journal of NursingAn Error by Any Other Name
102 Citations2004Ann Freeman Cook, Helena Hoas +2 more
Findings from multimethod research conducted over three years in 29 small rural hospitals in nine Western states suggest that institutional processes used to identify errors, assign responsibility for them, and resolve patient-safety issues may have unintended, harmful effects on nurse recruitment and retention.
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare EthicsMorally Managing Medical Mistakes
84 Citations2000Martin L. Smith, Heidi P. Forster
A mistake can result in serious and permanent damage for the patient, such as the failure to consider epiglottitis in an initial differential diagnosis, resulting in a chronic vegetative state for a seven-year-old boy.
New England Journal of MedicineA Broader Concept of Medical Errors
57 Citations2002Thomas H. Lee
The goal — a health care system that can reliably provide high-quality care with minimal waste to all in need is challenged; some cite inequities in access to care; others emphasize gaps in quality that transcend race, sex, and social class.
New England Journal of MedicineA Series on Patient Safety
56 Citations2002Lucian L. Leape, Arnold M. Epstein +1 more
When the Institute of Medicine released its report, To Err Is Human, the speed and intensity with which it captured media, public, political, and professional attention surprised everyone.
The Hastings Center Report"How Can They Act like That?": Clinicians and Patients as Characters in Each Other's Stories
48 Citations2002Arthur W. Frank
This essay addresses the question of what that "spirit" is in clinician-patient relationships that most observers might shake their heads over, but that hardly seem to merit an ethics consult, much less a write-up as a case study.
Kennedy Institute of Ethics journalInstitutional Responses to Medical Mistakes: Ethical and Legal Perspectives
43 Citations2001Andy Thurman
A health care institution should implement a written policy providing for disclosure of medical errors, using a process such as that outlined in the article.
Nursing EthicsNursing Practice: compassionate deception and the Good Samaritan
18 Citations1999Anthony Tuckett
The article concludes that a caring nurse, responding virtuously, acts by being compassionate, for a time recognizing the prima facie nature of the rules or principles of truth telling.
The Hastings Center ReportBiotech & JUSTICE: Catching up with the Real World Order
13 Citations2003Lisa Sowle Cahill
This essay will argue that bioethics can find resources for this task in political science literature on globalization, on the still weakening sovereignty of the nation-state, and on the quest for a normative and constructive approach to governance in what has been hailed as the new world order.
PubMedNew standards, new dilemmas--reflections on managing medical mistakes.
13 Citations2001Georg Hamm, Steve S. Kraman
This article describes one hospital's development of a proactive, patient centered program, which emphasizes total honesty in dealing with all aspects of patient care, which includes the full and timely disclosure of errors which affect the patient's health and well being.
PubMedHeartland Regional Medical Center makes a "fitting response" to medical mistakes.
10 Citations2001Landis Downing, Robert Potter
Heartland Regional Medical Center in St. Joseph, Missouri, asked these questions about medication errors and the response model they developed shows how a facility can go from an ethical analysis to fixing the problem.
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare EthicsHonest Mistakes: From the physician father of a Young Patient
4 Citations1994Steve Heilig
Nursing EthicsNursing Practice: compassionate deception and the Good Samaritan
3 Citations1999Anthony Tuckett