Research With Vulnerable Families Caring for Children With Life-Limiting Conditions
Qualitative Health ResearchPublished 3 December 2009Open access
Michael Stevens, Bruce Lord, Marie-Thérèse Proctor, Sue Nagy, Elizabeth O'Riordan
Citations59
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Although some issues associated with researching sensitive topics were anticipated, others were encountered that were not expected and insights gained are discussed in relation to factors that influence effectiveness of recruitment, the quality of data collection, and the safety of participants and researchers.
Abstract
Methodological challenges associated with sensitive research, such as research with vulnerable families, have been well described, but there are few examples of how such challenges have been addressed in specific projects. To help address this gap, we describe how we designed and conducted a qualitative study of 91 members of 29 families caring for children or young people with life-limiting conditions. Although some issues associated with researching sensitive topics were anticipated, others were encountered that were not expected. We discuss insights gained from this study in relation to factors that influence effectiveness of recruitment, the quality of data collection, and the safety of participants and researchers.
Keywords
Social SciencesMedicine
Qualitative ResearchDoing sensitive research: what challenges do qualitative researchers face?
888 Citations2007Virginia Dickson‐Swift, Erica L. James +2 more
A grounded theory analysis revealed that researchers can face a number of challenges while undertaking qualitative research, including issues relating to rapport development, use of researcher self-disclosure, listening to untold stories, feelings of guilt and vulnerability, leaving the research relationship and researcher exhaustion.
BMJHow to read a paper: Papers that go beyond numbers (qualitative research)
750 Citations1997Trisha Greenhalgh, Rod S Taylor
Qualitative methods aim to make sense of phenomena in terms of the meanings people bring to them and use “a holistic perspective which preserves the complexities of human behaviour.”
Journal of Pediatric PsychologyPredictors of Distress in Parents of Children With Cancer: A Prospective Study
369 Citations2000Patricia Sloper
Investigation of levels of psychological distress in parents of children with cancer and relationships between distress and measures of illness variables, appraisal, psychosocial resources and coping strategies points to the importance of identification of those at risk at an early stage and provision of ongoing support.
Qualitative Health ResearchRisk to Researchers in Qualitative Research on Sensitive Topics: Issues and Strategies
295 Citations2008Virginia Dickson‐Swift, Erica L. James +2 more
Analysis of the in-depth, face-to-face unstructured individual interviews with 30 Australian public health researchers provided evidence that researchers do confront a number of physical and emotional risks when undertaking research.
Journal of Advanced NursingIssues in phenomenology for researchers of nursing
284 Citations1994Melanie Jasper
The author discusses the relevance of phenomenology for nursing, and concludes that, as a research method within the qualitative paradigm, it has a great deal to offer nursing as a humanistic discipline.
Qualitative Health ResearchCollecting Sensitive Data: The Impact on Researchers
263 Citations2003Barbara Johnson, Jill Macleod Clarke
The findings indicate that researchers experienced a number of difficulties that centered around issues of lack of training, confidentiality, role conflict, costs to the participants, the desire for reciprocity, and feelings of isolation while conducting fieldwork.
European Journal of Cancer CareResearch sensitivities to palliative care patients
236 Citations2002Julia Addington‐Hall
To ensure that the voices of palliative care patients and their families are heard by both service providers and policy-makers, research in this area needs to address the methodological challenges raised in this paper, as well as continuing to explore users' views.
Supportive Care in CancerAdjustment and coping by parents of children with cancer: a review of the literature
233 Citations1997Martha A. Grootenhuis, B F Last
Results concerning parental adjustment in terms of psychological distress, marital distress, and family functioning were summarized and the use of coping strategies such as social support, communication, and search for meaning were described.
Journal of Advanced NursingConducting a qualitative child interview: methodological considerations
207 Citations2003Riitta‐Liisa Kortesluoma, Maija Hentinen +1 more
The theoretical premises of child interviewing are illustrated and some practical methodological solutions used during interviews are described to describe some of the factors that influence data gathered from children and strategies for taking these factors into consideration during the interview.
The LancetParents' accounts of obtaining a diagnosis of childhood cancer
181 Citations2001Mary Dixon‐Woods, Michelle Findlay +3 more
Investigation of parents' narratives about the period before their child's diagnosis of cancer or brain tumour offers valuable insights into their experiences of obtaining a diagnosis of childhood cancer and into possible sources of delays in this complex process.
Journal of college student development(Re)Writing the Word: Methodological Strategies and Issues in Qualitative Research.
140 Citations2002Susan R. Jones
A previous impression that corticotrophin provided prophylaxis against delayed traumatic facial palsy has now been confirmed by the results obtained from the first 50 patients so treated.
Palliative MedicineDying from cancer: the views of bereaved family and friends about the experiences of terminally ill patients
133 Citations1991JM Addington-Hall, LD MacDonald +2 more
Interviews with principal carers eight weeks after the death of cancer patients who had been routinely notified by hospital staff and had entered a district wide trial of a new service for terminally ill cancer patients identified areas where improvements in care are needed.
Nurse ResearcherUnderstanding the phenomenological approach to research
99 Citations1995Christine E. Hallett
Pediatric Hematology and OncologyADAPTATIONAL PROCESS OF PARENTS OF PEDIATRIC ONCOLOGY PATIENTS
78 Citations2000Chao-Hsing Yeh, Ting‐Ting Lee +2 more
The findings suggest that parents adapt to their children's cancer by a dynamic process; i.e., they modify their coping tasks and related strategies as clinical events occur.
Journal of Chronic DiseasesNational Hospice Study analysis plan
66 Citations1983David S. Greer, Vincent Mor +3 more
The evaluation employs a quasi-experimental design in which the impact of hospice care (with and without reimbursement) on quality of life and costs are compared to non-hospice (conventional) terminal care.
Journal of Clinical NursingDealing with chaos and complexity: the reality of interviewing children and families in their own homes
63 Citations2008Kath MacDonald, Alison Greggans
It is concluded that interviewing parents and their children with cystic fibrosis in their own homes, is chaotic and appears to threaten the rigour of data collection processes.
Oxford University Press eBooksEvaluating palliative care : establishing the evidence base
55 Citations1998Margaret Robbins
This paper focuses on the evaluation of palliative care in home and family carers and professional carers, and examines service activity and cost data.
European Journal of Cancer CareGreek parents’ reactions, difficulties and resources in childhood leukaemia at the time of diagnosis
53 Citations2000Evangelia Patistea, Pinelopi Makrodimitri +1 more
Hope, social support and the marital relationship were the most helpful resources in managing the multifaceted problems caused by the diagnosis of childhood leukaemia and nurses have a key role in assessing the individual parent, the marital unit and the entire family system and planning appropriate interventions.
PubMedTrajectory of certain death at an unknown time: children with neurodegenerative life-threatening illnesses.
50 Citations2000Rose Steele
In this grounded theory study, families moved through a process of navigating uncharted territory as they lived with their dying child, with periods of instability originated in subsequent precipitating events in the process that led to families dropping off the plateau on the way to the child's inevitable death.
Archives of Disease in ChildhoodLife threatening illness and hospice care.
48 Citations1989Alan Stein, Gillian Forrest +2 more
While families felt greatly helped over symptom control, a proportion remained very worried about certain symptoms, particularly breathlessness, seizures, and pain, the impact of chronic and life threatening illness on the families was substantial.
International Journal of Palliative NursingExperiences of families in which a child has a prolonged terminal illness: modifying factors
43 Citations2002Rose Steele
The strategies that families used to manage this phenomenon were influenced by four intervening conditions that reflected the broader structural context of the phenomenon; relationships with healthcare providers, availability of information, gender differences, and communication between parents.
Nursing EthicsThe Authenticity and Ethics of Phenomenological Research: How to Overcome the Researcher's Own Views
43 Citations1999Arja Häggman‐Laitila
Practical aspects and their theoretical grounds that are of crucial importance in overcoming a researcher's views in data gathering and analysis are described.
Journal of Health Organization and ManagementLeadership in Health Services
43 Citations2009Antonino Neri
This work represents an evaluation of the only leadership programme in Wales, and the application of learning through the performance of leadership roles in the projects led to improvements.
Journal of Palliative CareParents’ and Children's Perspectives of a Children's Hospice Bereavement Program
40 Citations2007Betty Davies, John B. Collins +4 more
When assessing their group experiences, children and parents most appreciated the support and understanding they received, the freedom to express themselves, a diminished sense of isolation, and the normalization of their emotions.
BMJHelen House--a hospice for children: analysis of the first year.
36 Citations1984S R Burne, Frances Dominica +1 more
Journal of Palliative CareStrategies used by Families to Navigate Uncharted Territory when a Child is Dying
26 Citations2005Rose Steele
The eight families in this grounded theory study moved through a process of navigating uncharted territory as they lived with a child who was tying from a neurodegenerative, life-threatening illness, characterized by four dimensions: entering unfamiliar territory, shifting priorities, creating meaning, and holding the fort.
PubMedThe role of the hospice for the dying child.
23 Citations1987Frances Dominica
Health authorities and individuals involved in the care of children with life-threatening disease are expressing concern about the suggested proliferation of children's hospices, and they are right in their concern.
Journal of Palliative CareNavigating Uncharted Territory: Experiences of Families when a Child is Dying
23 Citations2005Rose Steele
In this grounded theory study, eight families moved through a process of navigating uncharted territory as they lived with their child who was dying from a neurodegenerative illness, characterized by four dimensions.
Palliative MedicineThe cost-effectiveness of the Citymission Hospice Programme, Melbourne
14 Citations1989David Dunt, Annie M. Cantwell +1 more
It is concluded that the cost and effectiveness of this programme of hospice care is at least equivalent to the best traditional care.
Journal of Psychosocial OncologyEssential Work for Mothers of Children Living with Cancer
11 Citations2006Juanne N. Clarke
The advocacy work in which mothers engaged during the period of diagnosis and treatment is described, based on focus group interviews with mothers whose children have had cancer.
PubMedPalliative home care program for terminally ill children.
3 Citations1992Rosalyn Singleton
A study conducted for the Dr. Charles A. Janeway Child Health Centre determined that pediatric oncology patients and their families had needs that were not being met by the existing program of care, and a multidisciplinary palliative home care program was established to address them.