Know thyself: Metacognitive networks and measures of consciousness
CognitionPublished 11 September 2010
Antoine Pasquali, Bert Timmermans, Axel Cleeremans
Citations106
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.69
SNIP1.55
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is hypothesize that wagering and other subjective measures of awareness reflect metacognitive capacities subtended by self-developed metarepresentations that inform an agent about its own internal states that influence PDW as a measure of awareness.
Abstract
Subjective measures of awareness rest on the assumption that conscious knowledge is knowledge that participants know they possess. Post-Decision Wagering (PDW), recently proposed as a new measure of awareness, requires participants to place a high or a low wager on their decisions. Whereas advantageous wagering indicates awareness of the knowledge on which the decisions are based, cases in which participants fail to optimize their wagers suggest performance without awareness. Here, we hypothesize that wagering and other subjective measures of awareness reflect metacognitive capacities subtended by self-developed metarepresentations that inform an agent about its own internal states. To support this idea, we present three simulations in which neural networks learn to wager on their own responses. The simulations illustrate essential properties that are required for such metarepresentations to influence PDW as a measure of awareness. Results demonstrate a good fit to human data. We discuss the implications of this modeling work for our understanding of consciousness and its measures.
Keywords
PsychologyNeuroscience
Cognitive ScienceFinding Structure in Time
10,841 Citations1990Jeffrey L. Elman
A proposal along these lines first described by Jordan (1986) which involves the use of recurrent links in order to provide networks with a dynamic memory and suggests a method for representing lexical categories and the type/token distinction is developed.
CognitionInsensitivity to future consequences following damage to human prefrontal cortex
6,128 Citations1994Antoine Bechara, António R. Damásio +2 more
Using a novel task which simulates real-life decision-making in the way it factors uncertainty of premises and outcomes, as well as reward and punishment, it is found that prefrontal patients are oblivious to the future consequences of their actions, and seem to be guided by immediate prospects only.
Cognitive Brain ResearchPremotor cortex and the recognition of motor actions
4,748 Citations1996Giacomo Rizzolatti, Luciano Fadiga +2 more
It is suggested that the development of the lateral verbal communication system in man derives from a more ancient communication system based on recognition of hand and face gestures.
Choice Reviews OnlineBeyond modularity: a developmental perspective on cognitive science
2,643 Citations1993
Neural NetworksMultiple paired forward and inverse models for motor control
2,140 Citations1998Daniel M. Wolpert, Mitsuo Kawato
A modular approach to motor learning and control based on multiple pairs of inverse (controller) and forward (predictor) models that can simultaneously learn the multiple inverse models necessary for control as well as how to select the inverse models appropriate for a given environment is proposed.
Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal BehaviorImplicit learning of artificial grammars
1,947 Citations1967Arthur S. Reber
Behavioral and Brain SciencesSemantic activation without conscious identification in dichotic listening, parafoveal vision, and visual masking: A survey and appraisal
1,293 Citations1986Daniel Holender
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B Biological SciencesAbnormalities in the awareness and control of action
1,217 Citations2000Chris Frith, Sarah‐Jayne Blakemore +1 more
The location of the neural damage associated with these disorders suggests that representations of the current and predicted state of the motor system are in parietal cortex, while representations of intended actions are found in prefrontal and premotor cortex.
Behavioral and Brain SciencesCharacteristics of dissociable human learning systems
1,178 Citations1994David R. Shanks, Mark John
The distinction between instance and rule learning is a sound and meaningful way of taxonomizing human learning and various computational models of these two forms of learning are discussed.
Consciousness and CognitionBeyond the comparator model: A multifactorial two-step account of agency
1,047 Citations2007Matthis Synofzik, Gottfried Vosgerau +1 more
A sharp distinction is drawn between a non-conceptual level of feeling of agency and a conceptual level of judgement of agency, which is able to provide a unified account for the sense of agency for both actions and thoughts.
The foundations of mind: Origins of conceptual thought.
673 Citations2004Jean M. Mandler
This chapter discusses how to build a baby, Piaget's Sensorimotor Infant, and some Preverbal Concepts, as well as some differences between Percepts and Concepts.
CognitionThe phenomenology of action: A conceptual framework
595 Citations2007Élisabeth Pacherie
This paper argues in favor of a three-tiered dynamic model of intention, link it to an expanded version of the internal model theory of action control and specification, and uses this theoretical framework to guide an analysis of the contents, possible sources and temporal course of complementary aspects of the phenomenology of action.
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesA reexamination of the evidence for the somatic marker hypothesis: What participants really know in the Iowa gambling task
547 Citations2004Tiago V. Maia, James L. McClelland
It is shown that participants have much more knowledge about the game than previously thought, and that when they behave advantageously, their verbal reports nearly always reveal evidence of quantitativeknowledge about the outcomes of the decks that would be sufficient to guide such advantageous behavior.
Neural ComputationFinite State Automata and Simple Recurrent Networks
462 Citations1989Axel Cleeremans, David Servan‐Schreiber +1 more
A network architecture introduced by Elman (1988) for predicting successive elements of a sequence and shows that long distance sequential contingencies can be encoded by the network even if only subtle statistical properties of embedded strings depend on the early information.
Nature NeurosciencePost-decision wagering objectively measures awareness
459 Citations2007Navindra Persaud, Peter McLeod +1 more
It is shown that participants fail to maximize cash earnings by wagering high following correct decisions in blindsight, the Iowa gambling task and an artificial grammar task, demonstrating, without the uncertainties associated with the conventional subjective measures of awareness, that the participants were not aware that their decisions were correct.
Consciousness and CognitionMeasuring consciousness: Is one measure better than the other?
446 Citations2010Kristian Sandberg, Bert Timmermans +2 more
PAS seems to be the most exhaustive measure of awareness, and support for above-chance performance in the absence of subjective awareness is found, but such unconscious knowledge only contributes to performance when the authors observe conscious knowledge as well.
The nature of consciousness : philosophical debates
267 Citations1997Ned Block, Owen Flanagan +1 more
Journal of Experimental Psychology Learning Memory and CognitionComparing direct (explicit) and indirect (implicit) measures to study unconscious memory.
251 Citations1991Philip M. Merikle, Eyal M. Reingold
PsychopathologyNeurocognitive Models of Schizophrenia: A Neurophenomenological Critique
244 Citations2004Shaun Gallagher
This paper argues that Frith's account of the positive symptoms of schizophrenia in terms of a disruption of metarepresentational self-monitoring is inadequate, and develops a neurophenomenological explanation for the loss of the sense of agency and the misattribution of actions and thoughts to others in such symptoms.
Progress in brain researchA higher order Bayesian decision theory of consciousness
174 Citations2007Hakwan Lau
This work presents a model that is free from the strong assumption that consciousness predicts superior performance, based on Bayesian decision theory, and outlines three possibilities of how conscious perception might be affected by failures of 'higher-order' representation.
Consciousness and CognitionGambling on the unconscious: A comparison of wagering and confidence ratings as measures of awareness in an artificial grammar task
156 Citations2009Zoltán Dienes, Anil K. Seth
It is shown that when people are just as ready to bet on a genuine random process as their own classification decisions, their classifications are still above baseline, indicating knowledge participants are not aware of having.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Learning Memory and CognitionThe conscious, the unconscious, and familiarity.
134 Citations2008R. B. Y. Scott, Zoltán Dienes
The results provide decisive evidence that familiarity is the essential source of knowledge in artificial grammar learning while also supporting a dual-process model of implicit and explicit learning.
Memory & CognitionSubjective measures of awareness and implicit cognition
113 Citations2003Richard J. Tunney, David R. Shanks
It is shown that participants are better able to place their phenomenal states on a binary scale, as compared with a continuous scale, which indicates that confidence was related to accuracy.
Progress in brain researchConsciousness: the radical plasticity thesis
106 Citations2007Axel Cleeremans
This chapter sketches a conceptual framework which takes it as a starting point that conscious and unconscious cognition are rooted in the same set of interacting learning mechanisms and representational systems, and proposes the hypothesis that consciousness emerges in systems capable not only of learning about their environment, but also about their own internal representations of it.
Journal of Experimental Child PsychologySource Monitoring and False Memories in Children: Relation to Certainty and Executive Functioning
105 Citations2001Ted Ruffman, Charlotte L. Rustin +2 more
Children's hit rate for remembering whether events occurred and their tendency to make false alarms, their memory for the context in which events occurred, and their certainty about hits, false alarm, and source monitoring revealed deficits in children's understanding of when they had erred on source questions and ofWhen they had made false alarms.
Consciousness and CognitionImplicit sequence learning and conscious awareness
96 Citations2007Qiufang Fu, Xiaolan Fu +1 more
The Process Dissociation Procedure is used to explore whether people can acquire unconscious knowledge in the serial reaction time task and the results help resolve some current debates about the role of conscious awareness in sequence learning.
Neural NetworksConsciousness and metarepresentation: A computational sketch
90 Citations2007Axel Cleeremans, Bert Timmermans +1 more
Simulations in which two networks interact provide the beginnings of a computational mechanism to account for mental attitudes, that is, an understanding by a cognitive system of the manner in which its first-order knowledge is held.
Perception & PsychophysicsUnconscious perception: The need for a paradigm shift
87 Citations2004Daniel Holender, Katia Duscherer
All three dual-process models, which are based on both conscious and unconscious perception, should be rejected in favor of the single-process conscious perception model.
Consciousness and CognitionPost-decision wagering measures metacognitive content, not sensory consciousness
83 Citations2007Anil K. Seth
This note critiques the authors' claim that their method "measures awareness directly" and proposes a novel technique, 'post-decision wagering', in which subjects place bets on the correctness of decisions or discriminations.
Trends in Cognitive SciencesImplicit memory: intention and awareness revisited
74 Citations2001Laurie T. Butler, Dianne C. Berry
It is suggested that the term implicit memory might have outgrown its usefulness as an overall descriptor and one solution might be to modify the current terminology.
Nature NeuroscienceBetting the house on consciousness
69 Citations2007Christof Koch, Kerstin Preuschoff
This new paper shows that asking subjects to wager on whether their response to a stimulus is correct can solve the problem of studying consciousness.
Cerebral CortexAware or Unaware: Assessment of Cortical Blindness in Four Men and a Monkey
59 Citations2002Petra Stoerig
A non-verbal procedure that was previously used in hemianopic monkeys with a verbal one commonly used to assess visual awareness showed a close correspondence between the two measures of awareness in the human subjects who signalled 'stimulus' only for targets that also evoked verbal aware responses, validating the non- verbal approach.
Implicit knowledge in people and connectionist networks
46 Citations1995Zoltán Dienes, Josef Perner
Consciousness and CognitionWagering demonstrates subconscious processing in a binary exclusion task
43 Citations2007Navindra Persaud, Peter McLeod
Results suggest that the briefly presented stimuli were processed subconsciously and given the chance to wager low or high on their choices after short duration stimuli, participants declined to wagers high even when they were correct.