Depression, somatization and the “new cross-cultural psychiatry”
Social Science & Medicine (1967)Published 1 January 1977
Arthur M. Kleinman
Citations1,141
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Material from field research in Taiwan and data from recent anthropological and clinical investigations are used to support the opposite view that such differences exist and are a function of the cultural shaping of normative and deviant behavior.
Abstract
Contrary to Singer's contention that the features of depressive disorders do not exhibit significant cross-cultural differences, the author uses material from field research in Taiwan and data from recent anthropological and clinical investigations to support the opposite view that such differences exist and are a function of the cultural shaping of normative and deviant behavior. Somatization amongst Chinese depressives is used as an illustration. This discrepancy reflects substantial changes in the nature of more recent cross-cultural studies by anthropologists and psychiatrists, changes which are giving rise to a new cross-cultural approach to psychiatric issues. Some features and implications of that approach are described.
Keywords
PsychologyArts and Humanities
American Sociological ReviewCulture and Symptoms--An Analysis of Patient's Presenting Complaints
759 Citations1966Irving Kenneth Zola
It is suggested that a socially conditioned selective process may be operating in what is brought in for medical treatment and not etiological ones which account for many of the previously unexplained epidemiological differences between societies and even between subgroups within a society.
ManTahitians: Mind and Experience in the Society Islands.
753 Citations1975G. B. Milner, Robert I. Levy
Annual Review of PsychologySocial and Cultural Influences on Psychopathology
519 Citations1974Bruce P. Dohrenwend, Barbara Snell Dohrenwend
New England Journal of MedicineSocial Psychologic Factors Affecting the Presentation of Bodily Complaints
473 Citations1972David Mechanic
Patients often recognize symptoms for which they seek medical assistance, but, on the basis of a history and physical and laboratory examination, the physician cannot obtain evidence to account for these symptoms.
American AnthropologistPsychosocial Homeostasis and Jen: Conceptual Tools for Advancing Psychological Anthropology
345 Citations1971Francis L. K. Hsü
American Journal of Public Health and the Nations HealthPSYCHIATRIC DISORDER AMONG THE YORUBA
261 Citations1964John C. Cassell
Not only is sociocultural disintegration shown to have a similar relationship to psychiatric disorder in two widely differing settings (Stirling County and western Nigeria), but there are indications that these social factors may be related to a wide spectrum of disorders including many that are not traditionally regarded as psychiatric.
PsychiatryA Study of the Incidence of Mental Disorder in Chinese and other Cultures<sup>†</sup>
246 Citations1953Tsung-Yi Lin
Culture, Behavior and Personality
233 Citations2018Robert A. Levine
American AnthropologistSome Implications of Medical Beliefs and Practices for Social Anthropology
227 Citations1976Allan H. Young
A people's medical beliefs and practices persist because they answer instrumental and moral imperatives, and they are empirically effective, which enables sickness episodes to communicate and confirm ideas about the real world.
ScienceThe Need for an Ethnomedical Science
218 Citations1975Horacio Fábrega
In focusing on fundamental properties of disease in man, ethnomedicine can also help to clarify the effects and meanings of disease and thereby make its control more rational.
Annals of Internal MedicineFolk Medical Beliefs and Their Implications for Care of Patients
204 Citations1974Loudell F. Snow
The folk medical system of low-income black Americans is described, from an ethnographic study of a black neighborhood in Tucson, Arizona, from Comparable beliefs among Mexican-Americans.
Comprehensive PsychiatryThe nature of somatic complaints among psychiatric patients: The Chinese case
182 Citations1975Wen-Shing Tseng
Clinical surveys of psychiatric outpatients in Taiwan who are eventually diagnosed as having a neurosis or other minor mental disorder revealed that, regarding the nature of the complaints made by the patients at their first visit to the psychiatric clinic, about 40% complained only of somatic symptoms and 30% of predominantly somatic complaints with some emotional problems, while the remaining 30% complainedonly of emotional problems.
JAMAThe Hot-Cold Theory of Disease
169 Citations1971Alan Harwood
To achieve maximum therapeutic benefit for Puerto Rican patients who adhere to the Hippocratic humoral theories of disease, the physician is advised to work within its framework in prescribing medicines and diet.
The LancetMANIPULATING THE PATIENT A COMPARISON OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF PHYSICIAN AND CHIROPRACTOR CARE
107 Citations1974Robert L. Kane, Donna M. Olsen +3 more
Social Science & Medicine (1967)Depressive disorders from a transcultural perspective
92 Citations1975K. Singer
It is concluded that there is insufficient evidence to support a prevalent view that depressive illness in primitive and certain other non-Western cultures has outstanding deviant features.
Knowledge of Illness in a Sepik Society
89 Citations2021Gilbert N. Lewis
Psychosomatic MedicineProblems Implicit in the Cultural and Social Study of Depression
77 Citations1974Horacio Fábrega
Empirical questions as well as factors involving the influence of social factors in the onset, duration and manifestations of depression are given attention in the attempt to bring out fundamental dilemmas tied to the social study of psychiatric disease.
Systems Research and Behavioral ScienceThe study of disease in relation to culture
70 Citations1972Horacio Fábrega
Con conceptual issues stemming from contrasting medical orientations and from adopting a dualistic approach to illness are reviewed and related and a frame of reference is outlined that may be followed in studying health and illness cross-culturally.
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseCULTURE, SOCIAL STRUCTURE AND PSYCHOPATHOLOGY IN TAIWAN AND JAPAN
65 Citations1973Hsien Rin, Carmi Schooler +1 more
Based on the analysis of symptoms of samples of consecutive admissions to representative mental hospitals in the two cultures, three major findings emerge in this paper.
The LancetPATIENT'S ASSESSMENT OF THE RESULT OF SURGERY FOR PEPTIC ULCER
52 Citations1975ElizabethL Cay, Philip Abraham +3 more
Preliminary figures show that success in the opinion of the patient does not necessarily mean absence of symptoms, while failure is due more to psychosocial than physical factors.
Psychosomatic MedicineAn Integrated Theory of Disease: Ladino-Mestizo Views of Disease in the Chiapas Highlands
49 Citations1973Horacio Fábrega, Peter K. Manning
American Ethnologistwhy Amhara get <i>kureynya</i>: sickness and possession in an Ethiopian <i>zar</i> cult<sup>1</sup>
46 Citations1975Allan H. Young
Social Science & Medicine (1967)The concept of trouble and sources of medical assistance—To whom one can turn, with what and why
42 Citations1972Irving Kenneth Zola
The Affective Disorders: Clinical and Epidemiological Aspects
22 Citations1973Gerald L. Klerman, James E. Barrett
Demonstration of the therapeutic efficacy of psychotropic drugs, and in particular of lithium, has focused greater attention on the diagnosis, the symptomatology, and the clinical course of manic and depressive patients.
JAMAMedicine in Chinese Cultures: Comparative Studies of Health Care in Chinese and Other Societies
19 Citations1977Ilza Veith
Those readers who are interested in the subject of Chinese medicine and medicine in China will find in this collection much rewarding information offered by well-known writers on the subject who congregated for the conference from all over the world.
The LancetCOMPARATIVE PSYCHIATRY
18 Citations1954J J López Ibor, Pogromsky, AY Sasha +1 more
This ebooks is under topic such as comparative psychiatry and tropical psychiatry difficulties of comparative psychiatry: the fiji islands comparative observations in the teaching of psychiatry to emil kraepelin and comparative sociocultural psychiatry psychiatry for general practitioners.
Novartis Foundation symposiumDelineation of Clinical Conditions: Conceptual Models of ‘Physical’ and ‘Mental’ Disorders
11 Citations1976Leon Eisenberg
It is essential to reintegrate 'scientific' and 'social' concepts of disease and illness as a basis for a functional system of medical research and care.