Assessing the benefits of participatory research: a rationale for a realist review

Global Health PromotionPublished 19 May 2011Open access

Ann C. Macaulay, Justin Jagosh, Robbyn Seller, Jim Henderson, Margaret Cargo, Trisha Greenhalgh

Citations83

TL;DR

This work proposes to conduct a systematic realist review of PR, which can be understood as a theory-driven qualitative review capable of capturing the often complex, diffuse and obtuse evidence concerning participation.

Abstract

Participatory research (PR) experts believe that increased community and stakeholder participation in research augments program pertinence, quality, outcome, sustainability, uptake, and transferability. There is, however, a dearth of assessments and measurement tools to demonstrate the contribution of participation in health research and interventions. One systematic review of PR, conducted for the Agency for Health Research and Quality (AHRQ), provided no conclusive evidence concerning the benefits of community participation to enhance research and health outcomes. To overcome methodological gaps and barriers of the AHRQ review, we propose to conduct a systematic realist review, which can be understood as a theory-driven qualitative review capable of capturing the often complex, diffuse and obtuse evidence concerning participation. Reviewing how PR mechanisms and contextual factors mediate and moderate outcomes, the review will generate and test hypotheses (middle-range theories) conceptualizing the benefits of participation and will portray the manner and circumstances in which participation influences outcomes.

Keywords

Health Professions

Annual Review of Public HealthREVIEW OF COMMUNITY-BASED RESEARCH: Assessing Partnership Approaches to Improve Public Health

5,852 Citations1998Barbara A. Israel, Amy J. Schulz +2 more

This review provides a synthesis of key principles of community- based research, examines its place within the context of different scientific paradigms, discusses rationales for its use, and explores major challenges and facilitating factors and their implications for conducting effective community-based research aimed at improving the public's health.

Journal of Health Services Research & PolicyRealist review - a new method of systematic review designed for complex policy interventions

3,230 Citations2005Ray Pawson, Trisha Greenhalgh +2 more

A model of research synthesis designed to work with complex social interventions or programmes, and which is based on the emerging ‘realist’ approach to evaluation is offered, to enable decision-makers to reach a deeper understanding of the intervention and how it can be made to work most effectively.

DigitalGeorgetown (Georgetown University Library)Community-Based Participatory Research for Health

2,365 Citations2002Meredith Minkler, Nina Wallerstein

This special issue of the Michigan Journal and Meredith Minkler and Nina Wallerstein’s edited volume, Community-Based Participatory Research for Health, offer evidence that the field of community-based participatory research (CBPR) has reached an important developmental point as a field.

Annual Review of Public HealthThe Value and Challenges of Participatory Research: Strengthening Its Practice

1,456 Citations2008Margaret Cargo, Shawna L. Mercer

A critical review of the PR literature culminates in the development of an integrative practice framework that features five essential domains and provides a structured process for developing and maintaining PR partnerships, designing and implementing PR efforts, and evaluating the intermediate and long-term outcomes of descriptive, etiological, and intervention PR studies.

PubMedCommunity-based participatory research: assessing the evidence.

969 Citations2004Meera Viswanathan, Alice Ammerman +13 more

The EPC paired trained abstractors with a senior reviewer, who used an analytic framework to guide development of abstraction tables, and used the same framework to rate the quality of both the primary research and primary community-based participation elements.

View PDF

BMJParticipatory research maximises community and lay involvement

647 Citations1999Ann C. Macaulay, L Commanda +5 more

This article summarises the final draft of the North American Primary Care Research Group's ploicy statement for participatory research, which was developed to help improve social and economic conditions, to effect change, and to reduce the distrust of the people being studied.

Environmental Health PerspectivesCommunity-based participatory research as a tool to advance environmental health sciences.

606 Citations2002Liam R. O’Fallon, Allen Dearry

These projects demonstrate that community-based participatory research can be an effective tool to enhance the authors' knowledge of the causes and mechanisms of disorders having an environmental etiology, reduce adverse health outcomes through innovative intervention strategies and policy change, and address the environmental health concerns of community residents.

View PDF

Environmental Health PerspectivesCommunity-Based Participatory Research: Lessons Learned from the Centers for Children’s Environmental Health and Disease Prevention Research

600 Citations2005Barbara A. Israel, Edith A. Parker +15 more

A definition and set of CBPR principles are provided to describe the rationale for and major benefits of using this approach, to draw on the experiences of six of the Children’s Centers in using CBPR, and to provide lessons learned and recommendations for how to successfully establish and maintain CBPR partnerships.

View PDF