The Dynamics of the Species-Area Relation in Marine Fouling Systems: 1. Biological Correlates of Changes in the Species-Area Slope
The American NaturalistPublished 1 September 1981
Amy Schoener, Thomas W. Schoener
Citations82
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.26
SNIP1.10
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Immigration differences are nearly entirely responsible for the species-area relation in Puget Sound, Washington, and the relative proportion of edge-to-center space on panels appears in part to determine their relative rates of filling up.
Abstract
After creating an archipelago of fouling panel islands, spanning three orders of magnitude in area, in Puget Sound, Washington, we monitored colonization at frequent intervals for 13/4 yr. The larger panels fill up more slowly than the smaller panels and accumulate a larger fraction of the species pool. The latter would be expected even if the species pool were constant through time, but in this temperate region, the pool changes seasonally, further contributing to the increased species number on large panels. The relative proportion of edge-to-center space on panels appears in part to determine their relative rates of filling up. Slopes of species-area curves computed for these artificial islands rapidly rise for 10 wk, then remain fairly constant. Extinction rates are negligible in this 10-wk period; thus immigration differences are nearly entirely responsible for the species-area relation. Both colonial and solitary species are present throughout the observation period: The former predominate initially, giving way to the latter.
Keywords
Earth and Planetary SciencesEnvironmental Science
The American NaturalistFood Web Complexity and Species Diversity
5,350 Citations1966Robert T. Paine
It is suggested that local animal species diversity is related to the number of predators in the system and their efficiency in preventing single species from monopolizing some important, limiting, requisite in the marine rocky intertidal.
The American NaturalistMechanisms of Succession in Natural Communities and Their Role in Community Stability and Organization
4,397 Citations1977Joseph H. Connell, Ralph O. Slatyer
In the majority of natural communities succession is frequently interrupted by major disturbances, such as fires, storms, insect plagues, etc., starting the process all over again, but if not interrupted, it eventually reaches a stage in which further change is on a small scale as individuals die and are replaced.
Ecological MonographsCompetition, Disturbance, and Community Organization: The Provision and Subsequent Utilization of Space in a Rocky Intertidal Community
2,412 Citations1971Paul K. Dayton
This study presents an experimental evaluation of the effects of natural physical disturbances and competitive interactions on populations of sessile organisms in the rocky intertidal community, for which space can be demonstrated to be the most important limiting resource.
EvolutionAN EQUILIBRIUM THEORY OF INSULAR ZOOGEOGRAPHY
2,113 Citations1963Robert H. MacArthur, Edward O. Wilson
As the area of sampling A increases in a ecologically uniform area, the number of plant and animal species s increases in an approximately logarithmic manner, or s = bAk, (1) where k < 1, as shown most recently in in the detailed analysis of Preston (1962).
The American NaturalistSpecies Diversity Gradients: Synthesis of the Roles of Predation, Competition, and Temporal Heterogeneity
1,119 Citations1976Bruce A. Menge, John P. Sutherland
It is suggested that the "predation" and "competition" hypotheses of community organization and species diversity are complementary, and that Predator-mediated escapes by primary producers from herbivores may explain the apparent importance of interspecific competition in certain primary producer associations.
Ecological MonographsOrganization of the New England Rocky Intertidal Community: Role of Predation, Competition, and Environmental Heterogeneity
990 Citations1976Bruce A. Menge
The influences of predation, competition, biological disturbance, exposure to wave action, and inclination and heterogeneity of the substratum on the structure of the rocky intertidal community of New England were studied with a combination of experiments and observations at six areas in Maine and Massachusetts from 1972—1975.
The American NaturalistCompetition on Marine Hard Substrata: The Adaptive Significance of Solitary and Colonial Strategies
839 Citations1977Jeremy B. C. Jackson
Recognition of the generalist-specialist and early-late "successional" roles of most solitary versus colonial animals leads to predictions that solitary animals should recruit more heavily and be more palatable to predators than are colonial animals.
The American NaturalistMammals on Mountaintops: Nonequilibrium Insular Biogeography
758 Citations1971James H. Brown
Paleontological evidence suggests that the mountains were colonized by a group of species during the Pleistocene when the climatic barriers that currently isolate them were abolished, and subsequent to isolation of the mountains, extinctions have reduced the faunal diversity to present levels.
Ecological MonographsExperimental Investigations of Disturbance and Ecological Succession in a Rocky Intertidal Algal Community
756 Citations1979Wayne P. Sousa
The results of this study do not support the classical facilitation model or the tolerance (competitive) model of ecological succession, which were investigated by field experiments in a rocky intertidal algal community in southern California.
EcologyExperimental Zoogeography of Islands: The Colonization of Empty Islands
756 Citations1969Daniel Simberloff, Edward O. Wilson
The first evidence of faunistic equilibrium obtained through controlled, replicated experiments is reported, together with an analysis of the immigration and extinction processes of animal species based on direct observations, to indicate strongly that a dynamic equilibrium number of species exists for any island.
The American NaturalistMultiple Stable Points in Natural Communities
756 Citations1974John P. Sutherland
Evidence is presented which indicates the importance of historical events in determining the structure of a variety of natural communities, and multiple stable points are an undeniable reality in space and time in these systems.
The American NaturalistThe Nature of the Taxon Cycle in the Melanesian Ant Fauna
667 Citations1961Edward O. Wilson
The following rule is predicted: the ecological amplitude of individual species, both expanding and endemic, should be negatively correlated with the size of the local fauna to which they belong and hence thesize of the island on which they occur.
Ecological MonographsCommunity Development and Persistence in a Low Rocky Intertidal Zone
615 Citations1978Jane Lubchenco, Bruce A. Menge
Results of manipulations during both primary and secondary succession indicate that Littorina littorea, the only large, abundant herbivore in the low zone, has no direct effect on perennating or established Chondrus, or on its extensive, encrusting holdfast.
Ecological MonographsThe Establishment and Development of a Marine Epifaunal Community
582 Citations1977Richard W. Osman
Five major factors were found to be important to both the development of the community and its distribution on the rocks: the selectivity of the metamorphosing larvae as to site of attachment; the seasonal fluctuat...
Limnology and OceanographyTHE EFFECTS OF GRAZING BY SEA URCHINS, STRONGYLOCENTROTUS SPP., ON BENTHIC ALGAL POPULATIONS1
523 Citations1969Robert T. Paine, Robert L. Vadas
Observations of the rate and pattern of algal succession for periods of up to three years showed that following an initial establishment of new species, brown algae began to dominate and the rate of domination is related to the area’s tidal height, with succession most rapid in the lower intertidal areas or subtidally.
ScienceDistributional Ecology of New Guinea Birds
504 Citations1973Jared M. Diamond
The concepts by which MacArthur and Wilson have transformed the science of ecology in the past decade, and the results of ecological studies such as mine on New Guinea bird communities, have implications for conservation policies.
EcologyExperimental Zoogeography of Islands: Effects of Island Size
378 Citations1976Daniel Simberloff
The American NaturalistTaxon Cycles in the West Indian Avifauna
355 Citations1972Robert E. Ricklefs, George W. Cox
Analysis of distribution patterns of land birds in the West Indies supports the empirical theory that once species invade islands they progress through a series of evolutionary changes that eventually greatly increase the probability of extinction.
The American NaturalistFish Species Diversity in Lakes
256 Citations1974Clyde D. Barbour, James H. Brown
Preliminary insights into the environmental parameters which influence the number of fish species occurring in lakes are obtained and four patterns of species diversity are distinguished.
NatureEffects of plant type, size of geographical range and taxonomic isolation on number of insect species associated with British plants
245 Citations1977John H. Lawton, D.K. Schroder
It is found that while plant type and geographical range have a considerable effect, taxonomic isolation does not, except in the case of monocotyledonous herbs.
OecologiaDevelopment in an estuarine fouling community: The influence of early colonists on later arrivals
208 Citations1980T. A. Dean, Lawrence E. Hurd
It was found no evidence earlier colonists were essential for establishment of the next developmental stage of an estuarine fouling community at Lewes, Delaware, and inhibitory interactions appeared to be much more prevalent than facilitative interactions.
The American NaturalistInsular Biogeography in Continental Regions. I. The Northern Andes of South America
182 Citations1970François Vuilleumier
In order to test whether the theory of insular biogeography also applies to a continental situation, species diversity and endemism were studied among the birds living in islands of paramo vegetation above timberline in the northern Andes of South America.
Journal of BiogeographyThe Size of Coral Heads and the Community Biology of Associated Decapod Crustaceans
180 Citations1976Lawrence G. Abele, Wendell K. Patton
Predictions of species numbers on coral heads based on rarefaction are consistently and significantly higher than the observed species numbers.
EcologySpecies Numbers, Density Compensation, and Colonizing Ability of Lizards on Islands in the Gulf of California
179 Citations1975Ted J. Case
The distribution of lizard species and numbers on islands in the Gulf of Cali- fornia was examined in light of island biogeographic theory and it was concluded that differences in predation intensity, insect productivity, and possibly competitive interference account for the extremely high number of lizards on some small isolated islands.
EvolutionSMALL ISLANDS AND THE EQUILIBRIUM THEORY OF INSULAR BIOGEOGRAPHY
176 Citations1969Donald R. Whitehead, Claris E. Jones
Certain aspects of the equilibrium model are examined in the light of Carlquist's data on dispersal and the ecological factors which affect establishment, and it appears to us that the application of the model can provide erroneous conclusions in certain instances.
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesCalculation of immigration and extinction curves from the species-area-distance relation
174 Citations1976Michael E. Gilpin, Jared M. Diamond
Quantitative models of the species-area-distance relation, based on equilibria between immigration and extinction rates, have been tested against data for birds on 52 Solomon islands and the resulting curves are very concave.
EcologyTime and the Number of Herbivore Species: The Pests of Sugarcane
167 Citations1977Donald R. Strong, Earl D. McCoy +1 more
Examining the arthropod pests of sugarcane in 51 regions for which dates of introduction, areas in cultivation, and associated pest data are available, it is suggested sufficient evidence has accumulated to justify abandoning nonasymptotic species accumulation models (the "time" and "stability—time" hypotheses), at least for parasite communities.
OecologiaUrban biogeography
136 Citations1978Stanley H. Faeth, Thomas C. Kane
It was found that area alone was the best predictor of species richness, suggesting that increased area acts primarily to reduce extinction rates rather than to provide new habitats for specialized species.
ScienceSpecies Number and Endemism: The Galápagos Archipelago Revisited
128 Citations1973Michael P. Johnson, Peter H. Raven
The proportion of species endemic to the Gal�pagos is highest in the arid, transition zone and on small islands, and lowest in the littoral and mesic zones.
American ZoologistInterphyletic Competition Among Marine Benthos
128 Citations1979Sarah A. Woodin, Jeremy B. C. Jackson
Two groups, tube builders in sediments and sheet-like animals on hard substrata, are examined in detail and there is more evidence for competition between distantly related taxa than between closely related forms.
Ecological studiesFaunal Equilibria and the Design of Wildlife Preserves
123 Citations1975John Terborgh
It is becoming increasingly apparent that the methods and the way of thinking that MacArthur and Wilson developed are extensible to a much larger range of situations, including the design of faunal preserves.
Ornithological ApplicationsShort-Time-Base Studies of Turnover in Breeding Bird Populations on the California Channel Islands
121 Citations1976H. Lee Jones, Jared M. Diamond
The number and identities of species coexisting at a particular locality are not fixed forever, but result from dynamic interplay between local extinctions and immigrations, and it is likely that large differences in turnover rates will be found if one compares the same taxonomic groups on islands of different area, isolation, latitude, and habitat.
OecologiaThe diversity of freshwater snails in view of the equilibrium theory of island biogeography
115 Citations1975Hans Heidemann Lassen
Data indicate that the snail fauna represents a dynamic equilibrium sustained by immigration and extinction, and biotic interrelations may be of main importance in governing the diversity of local faunas.
Systematic BiologyDistribution of Freshwater Mussels: Coastal Rivers as Biogeographic Islands
109 Citations1974J. John Sepkoski, Michael A. Rex
EvolutionNUMBERS OF BIRD SPECIES ON THE CALIFORNIA ISLANDS
109 Citations1972Dennis M. Power
Variation in bird species diversity on islands is related to island area in a simple way and factors such as area, habitat diversity, topography, and distance from the nearest mainland or other islands are considered.
The American NaturalistAn Allometric Interpretation of Species-Area Curves: The Meaning of the Coefficient
106 Citations1979Stephen Jay Gould
I present several invariants, previously unrecognized or identified more circuitously in other ways, that record a size-independent invariant within a system.
The American NaturalistEcological Parameters and Plant Species Diversity
103 Citations1968Michael P. Johnson, Larry G. Mason +1 more
The regulation of plant species diversity was studied for 14 islands, four island groups, and 10 coastal mainland areas of California and Baja California using several kinds of models to suggest area is the best single predictor of species diversity.
ScienceSpecies Abundance: Natural Regulation of Insular Variation
98 Citations1963Terrell H. Hamilton, Ira Rubinoff +2 more
The variation in number of species on large islands can be predicted more accurately than the variation on small ones, and multiple linear regression gives better "goodness of fit" than curvilinear analysis.
EcologyThe Influence of Seasonality and Stability on the Species Equilibrium
87 Citations1978Richard W. Osman
In this study, the distribution of marine epifaunal invertebrates on rocks has been interpreted using this model, and the increase in the number of species with increasing area appears to result from increasing immigration rather than decreasing extinction, as predicted by the model.
ScienceComparative Species Richness in Fluctuating and Constant Environments: Coral-Associated Decapod Crustaceans
85 Citations1976Lawrence G. Abele
There are more species associated with corals in the fluctuating environment than in the constant environment, supporting the hypothesis that species equilibrium within habitats is maintained by measurable ecological factors—in this case, the effects of a natural physical disturbance.
EvolutionAN ESTIMATE OF THE POTENTIAL EVOLUTIONARY INCREASE IN SPECIES DENSITY IN THE POLYNESIAN ANT FAUNA
77 Citations1967Edward O. Wilson, Robert W. Taylor
In the course of current studies on the Indo-Australian fauna, the number of species on an island is well correlated with the island's area, and some related species have acquired complementary (mosaic) interand intra-island distributions that can be explained easily only as the outcome of competitive exclusion.
EvolutionCHANCE, HABITAT AND DISPERSAL IN THE DISTRIBUTION OF BIRDS IN THE WEST INDIES
73 Citations1973John Terborgh
Two problems in the distribution of West Indian birds are explored, one involves the degree of determinism in insular faunas and the other concerns the regulation of sympatry within adaptively related groups of species as a function of faunal size.
EvolutionEVOLUTION OF THE RICHNESS-AREA CORRELATION FOR CYNIPID GALL WASPS ON OAK TREES: A COMPARISON OF TWO GEOGRAPHIC AREAS
70 Citations1979Howard V. Cornell, Jan O. Washburn
Host plants and animals and the parasite species which attack them have recently been shown to conform to the species-area relation consistent with the theory of island biogeography, and it is suggested that parasite species richness asymptotically approaches an upper limit established mainly by host "island" size.
EcologyClumps of Heliconia Inflorescences as Ecological Islands
60 Citations1975Richard P. Seifert
It is postulated that beta diversity is more important in increasing species richness of animals in Heliconia clumps than is alpha diversity (the diversity due to the number of species using a given resource).
EcologyColonization Curves for Planar Marine Islands
54 Citations1974Amy Schoener
Evidence indicates that in areas of substantial seasonal temperature change the shape of the colonization Curve varies seasonally: in warmer months the colonization curve initially rises more rapidly than during colder months.
Marine BiologyTwo contrasting effects of predation on species richness in coral reef habitats
51 Citations1977Robert W. Day
The species richness of sessile organisms on settlement panels on a coral reef was measured by the slope of a regression of loge number of species against loge area of sample and the contrasting effects of predation are probably the result of more selective predation at the cave site than at the other site.
EvolutionTOWARD A PREDICTIVE CAVE BIOGEOGRAPHY: THE GREENBRIER VALLEY AS A CASE STUDY
49 Citations1973David C. Culver, John R. Holsinger +1 more
The islandlike patterns of aquatic and terrestrial cave-limited species in the Greenbrier Valley karst area in West Virginia are examined to better understand the forces that determine the distribution of species.
EcologyGeographic Variation in Artificial Island Colonization Curves
45 Citations1978Amy Schoener, Edward R. Long +1 more
Colonization curves are more peaked in species-rich regions such as the tropics than in poorer ones, and equilibrium species number shows minimal differences between sites, appearing to converge on similar values at all localities.
Fouling Community Structure: Effects of the Hydroid, Obelia Dichotoma, on Larval Recruitment
45 Citations1976Jon D. Standing
Some hydroid epizoites do not occur on hydranths, suggesting either predation on settling larvae or avoidance of the nematocyst-bearing regions by motile forms.
Occidental College Scholar (Occidental College)Numbers of Species and Faunal Resemblance of Marine Fishes in California Bays and Estuaries
41 Citations1976Michael H. Horn, Larry G. Allen
EvolutionISLAND BIOGEOGRAPHY OF ANTS
40 Citations1975Edward L. Goldstein
This report will describe how the geographical distribution of a physical parameter, of demonstrated physiological significance to the taxon studied, can be used to predict the number of species that an area of land will contain.
The American NaturalistSalt Water Tolerance of Seeds of Gossypium Species as a Possible Factor in Seed Dispersal
36 Citations1958S. G. Stephens
The seeds of Gossypium barbadense var.
The American Midland NaturalistHerpetofaunal Colonization Patterns of Atlantic Coast Barrier Islands
28 Citations1978J. Whitfield Gibbons, John W. Coker
The amount of woodland habitat, rather than island size per se, is the island feature most highly correlated with numbers of reptile or amphibian species.
OecologiaIsland ecology of arthropods
23 Citations1977Michael Mühlenberg, D. Leipold +2 more
The composition of the ant fauna on different islands is more constant in undisturbed, autochthonous habitats than in those habitats that are strongly influenced by man.