Resuscitation Policy Concerning Older Adults: Ethical Considerations of Paternalism Versus Autonomy
Journal of Applied GerontologyPublished 1 March 1995
Pamela B. Teaster
Citations2
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.02
SNIP1.07
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
An examination of physician paternalism versus patient autonomy concerning do-not-resuscitate (DNR) orders within the context of utilitarian ethical theory is examined.
Abstract
The heated national debate concerning health care must include a discussion of a patient's wishes and the implications of his or her right to determine individual medical treatment decisions, especially at the end of life. This article is an examination of physician paternalism versus patient autonomy concerning do-not-resuscitate (DNR) orders within the context of utilitarian ethical theory. The author proposes effective compromise between the two; consideration of decision making on a case-by-case basis; enhanced education for all actors concerning cardiopulminary resucitation (CPR), DNR, and advanced directives; and consensus reached through democratic debate regarding the allocation of health care resources.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
JAMAFutility and the Ethics of Resuscitation
265 Citations1990Tom Tomlinson
Real patient interests can better be saved by a broad public dialogue around judgments of medical reasonableness and medical futility, rather than concern for the form but not the substance of patient autonomy.
New England Journal of MedicineSources of Concern about the Patient Self-Determination Act
158 Citations1991Susan M. Wolf, Peter Boyle +14 more
The Patient Self-Determination Act of 1990 (PSDA)1 went into effect, the first federal statute to focus on advance directives and the right of adults to refuse life-sustaining treatment.
Johns Hopkins University Press eBooksEthics in an Aging Society
121 Citations1996Harry R. Moody
Harry R. Moody pays special attention to the ethical problems associated with two particularly timely concerns--Alzheimer's disease and the increasingly controversial issue of "rational suicide" for reasons of age.
Journal of the American Geriatrics SocietyEducating the Elderly: Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation Decisions before and after Intervention
96 Citations1991Ronald S. Schonwetter, Thomas A. Teasdale +3 more
It is emphasized that most elderly male veterans are willing and want to discuss their CPR attitude with physicians and that most have fixed CPR decisions which may be elicited under stable clinical conditions.
JAMAFamily Consent to Orders Not to Resuscitate
92 Citations1990Jim Hackler
Policy should be changed to allow physicians to write a do-not-resuscitate order over family objections when the patient lacks decision-making capacity, and the burdens of treatment clearly outweigh the benefits.
The Hastings Center ReportDo-Not-Resuscitate Orders: No Longer Secret, but Still a Problem
90 Citations1987Stuart J. Youngner
Concerns about DNR should not divert us from looking closely and rigorously at other, more common treatment/nontreatment decisions in the critical care setting.
Journal of the American Geriatrics SocietyOutcomes of Skilled Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in a Long‐Term‐Care Facility: Futile Therapy?
80 Citations1992Sissay Awoke, Charles P. Mouton +1 more
To assess whether cardiopulmonary resuscitation performed by in‐house physicians is effective for long‐term‐care residents, a large number of patients with severe chest pains are referred to the hospital's emergency department.
PubMedThe Patient Self-determination Act. An early look at implementation.
66 Citations1993Mathy Mezey, Beth Latimer
JAMAFutility in Context
60 Citations1990Stuart J. Youngner
By offering life-sustaining treatment that they consider futile, physicians may actually undermine patient and family autonomy, suggesting a real choice when none exists.
The American Journal of MedicineEffect of New York state's do-not-resuscitate legislation on in-hospital cardiopulmonary resuscitation practice
50 Citations1990Russell S. Kamer, Eileen M. Dieck +3 more
Journal of the American Geriatrics SocietyUse of Life‐Sustaining Care for the Elderly
48 Citations1991Laura C. Hanson, Marion Danis
Intensive care is being used less frequently prior to death for elderly patients, based on diagnosis and functional status as well as chronologic age, which is lower for elderly than for younger patients receiving IC.
The Hastings Center ReportAfter the Patient Self-Determination Act The Need for Empirical Research on Formal Advance Directives
47 Citations1993Joanne Lynn, Joan M. Teno
The issues needing to be addressed about formal advance directives and an overview of what is now known are outlined and the merits of this decisionmaking model are studied empirically, although virtually no such research has been done.
Social Science & MedicineMedicalization, public policy and the elderly: Social services in jeopardy?
40 Citations1990Elizabeth A. Binney, Carroll L. Estes +1 more
Findings include: HHAs were more likely to report adding highly medical services and cited social/supportive services as the most commonly requested services they cannot provide, while policy effects and societal implications of the medicalization of home care are considered.
The Hastings Center ReportIn Death's Shadow: The Meanings of Withholding Resuscitation
31 Citations1987Kathleen Nolan
The language of resuscitation and resuscitative decisionmaking and the contexts in which these decisions are made have multiple and often conflicting symbolic and emotional meanings for patients, families, and clinicians, and recognizing this divergence is essential to communication and to decisionmaking.
Journal of Medical EthicsInvolving patients in do not resuscitate (DNR) decisions: an old issue raising its ugly head.
27 Citations1991Erich H. Loewy
It is suggested that patients, if they acknowledge their valid interest in making their own choices, must themselves be allowed to make a prior choice about choosing and may allow another to choose for them.
The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of MedicineAn Ethical Framework for Rationing Health Care
21 Citations1992Nancy S. Jecker, Robert A. Pearlman
It is submitted that a just health care system will not limit basic health care to persons unable to pay for it, and that justice in health care requires limiting publicly-financed non-basic health care.
JAMAMust We Always Offer the Option of CPR? The Law in New York
10 Citations1988Fred Rosner
New York State law 1 requires that the issues of cardiopulmonary resuscitation and do not resuscitate orders be discussed in advance with all hospitalized patients and/or their surrogates to ensure that the patient's wishes are honored.
The Hastings Center ReportSurely the Wizard Will Help Us, Toto? Implementing the Patient Self-Determination Act
7 Citations1993Charles P. Sabatino
Concerns expressed by providers and consumer advocacy groups regarding implementation of the Patient Self-Determination Act are reviewed, as reflected in their comments on the interim final rule submitted to HCFA.
The Hastings Center ReportEthics Committees As Corporate and Public Policy Advocates
7 Citations1990C. M. S. Cohen
The "Ethics committees" column in this issue of the Hastings Center Report features an introduction by Cynthia B. Cohen and four brief commentaries on the roles hospital ethics committees may play in the making of institutional and public health care policy in the 1990s.
PubMedEquality, autonomy, and efficiency: what health care system should we have?
7 Citations1992Paul T. Menzel
The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of MedicineEquality, Autonomy, and Efficiency: What Health Care System Should We Have?
6 Citations1992Paul T. Menzel
Despite pluralistic systems' apparent advantage in allowing subscribers to choose their own forms of rationing, problems in translating serious long-term subscriber choices into actual medical practice may be greater in pluralistic than in unitary systems.
Journal of Applied GerontologyThe Specification of Levels of Active Intervention in a Chronic Care Hospital
4 Citations1993John P. Hirdes, Nancy J. Martin
Patients with comfort measures only specified were significantly more likely to be older, recently admitted, incontinent, requiring special nutritional regimens, and were less likely to have been visited recently by key contact persons.
Can We Set Limits and Enhance Autonomy?
1 Citations2019Lawrence J. Schneiderman
JAMAFamily Consent to Orders Not to Resuscitate
1 Citations1991Grant E. Steffen
It is argued that treatment goals are legitimate if, among other things, they are empirically possible and ethically justified and in the two cases that Hackler and Hiller describe, the surrogates' treatment goals were not legitimate.
The Appropriateness of Life-Sustaining Care for Older People
1 Citations2019Donald J. Murphy