Reasons for physically restraining patients and residents: a systematic review and content analysis
International Journal of Nursing StudiesPublished 1 September 2002
David Evans, Mary FitzGerald
Citations130
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score2.82
SNIP3.21
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The most common reason for using restraints related to patient-oriented issues such as ensuring the safety of people, however, they are also commonly used to facilitate treatment, maintain the social environment and because of issuessuch as understaffing.
Abstract
Twenty-three studies were identified. The most common reason for using restraints related to patient-oriented issues such as ensuring the safety of people. However, they are also commonly used to facilitate treatment, maintain the social environment and because of issues such as understaffing.
Keywords
PsychologyArts and Humanities
Health Care For Women InternationalContent analysis: Method, applications, and issues
2,613 Citations1992Barbara Downe‐Wamboldt
Because of its focus on human communication, content analysis offers practical applicability, promise, and relevance for research involving the practice and education of nurses and other helping professionals.
Qualitative Health ResearchRationale and Standards for the Systematic Review of Qualitative Literature in Health Services Research
998 Citations1998Jennie Popay, Anne Rogers +1 more
It is argued that three interrelated criteria can be identified as the foundation of good qualitative health research: interpretation of subjective meaning, description of social context, and attention to lay knowledge.
Nurse ResearcherContent analysis: concepts, methods and applications
967 Citations1997Stephen Cavanagh
Key concepts and methodological issues, including strategies for data analysis, are explained, using applications from the nursing and health literature, to enhance understanding of the data.
Nursing ResearchPhysical Restraint of the Hospitalized Elderly
259 Citations1988Neville E. Strumpf, Lois K. Evans
The findings suggest that the use of physical restraint is not a benign practice and support the need for developing alternatives more consistent with professional practice and quality care.
American Journal of Public HealthTobacco and alcohol use behaviors portrayed in music videos: a content analysis.
205 Citations1997Robert H. DuRant, Ellen S. Rome +4 more
These data indicate that even modest levels of viewing may result in substantial exposure to glamorized depictions of alcohol and tobacco use and alcohol use coupled with sexuality.
Journal of the American Geriatrics SocietyPhysical Restraints and Agitation in Nursing Home Residents
164 Citations1989Perla Werner, Jiska Cohen‐Mansfield +2 more
Results indicate that restraint use does not decrease agitation in nursing home residents, and the act of restraining may itself contribute to manifestations of agitation.
Journal of the American Geriatrics SocietyBinding the Elderly: A Prospective Study of the Use of Mechanical Restraints in an Acute Care Hospital
152 Citations1987Laurence J. Robbins, Edward J. Boyko +3 more
Daily direct observation of patients and hospital record review provided data on potential predictors of restraint, reasons for their application, complications, and outcome.
Journal of the American Geriatrics SocietyA Further Exploration of the Use of Physical Restraints in Hospitalized Patients
143 Citations1989Lorraine C. Mion, J. Dermot Frengley +2 more
It was found that the presence of cognitive and physical impairments were highly predictive of restraint use in both populations.
Journal of the American Geriatrics SocietyRestraint Reduction Reduces Serious Injuries Among Nursing Home Residents
136 Citations1999Richard R. Neufeld, Leslie S. Libow +4 more
To describe how removing physical restraints affected injuries in nursing home settings, physical restraints were removed in residential and social services settings and inpatient settings.
Journal of the American Geriatrics SocietyIncidence of Physical Restraints on Acute General Medical Wards
123 Citations1986J. Dermot Frengley, Lorraine C. Mion
JONA The Journal of Nursing AdministrationPrevalence and Patterns of Physical Restraint Use in the Acute Care Setting
108 Citations1998Ann F. Minnick, Lorraine C. Mion +3 more
New patterns in the rationale and types of restraints used are revealed and how the results can be used in measuring success and allocating resources for restraint reduction programs is discussed.
PubMedFreedom from restraint: consequences of reducing physical restraints in the management of the elderly.
90 Citations1989Colin Powell, L Mitchell-Pedersen +2 more
There was a 40% reduction in the use of chemical restraints (psychotropic drugs other than hypnotic and antidepressant agents) during the study period and here it is recorded how this change in practice occurred and persisted.
Journal of Advanced NursingUsing restraint with nursing home residents: a qualitative study of nursing staff perceptions and decision‐making
82 Citations2000Virpi Hantikainen, Silvia Käppeli
In nursing practice, as far as issues of restraint are concerned, greater attention should be devoted to the relationship between elderly residents' self-determination and responsibility for their actions.
Communications of the ACMBreaking loose
82 Citations2001Leonard Kleinrock
The Internet’s ultimate utility depends on the authors' ability and willingness to make the network at least as pervasive, convenient, and invisible as electricity is today.
International Journal of Nursing StudiesSurvey findings describing the use of physical restraints in nursing homes in Victoria, Australia
80 Citations1998Andrew Retsas
The extent that physical restraints are being used in nursing homes in Victoria is high, particularly in the context of a general view in the literature that their use should be minimised, if not avoided entirely.
Clinical Effectiveness in NursingSystematic reviews of qualitative research
74 Citations2001David Evans, A. Pearson
The current methods used for the review of qualitative studies are presented and some areas in need of further exploration are highlighted.
Journal of the American Geriatrics SocietyPhysical Restraints in Geriatric Care in Sweden: Prevalence and Patient Characteristics
61 Citations1996Stig Karlsson, Gösta Bucht +2 more
This study investigated the prevalence of the use of physical restraints in geriatric care and the way in which patient characteristics are related to the useof physical restraints.
Journal of Nutrition EducationComparative content analysis of food and nutrition advertisements in Ebony, Essence, and Ladies' Home Journal
58 Citations1995Charlotte Pratt, Charlotte A. Pratt +2 more
Investigating the frequencies and forms of food, beverage, and nutrition advertisements in three U.S. consumer magazines during two 3-year periods suggested the need for of the advertising, food, and Nutrition industries to the health risks of consumers.
Journal of Advanced NursingUse of physical restraints on elderly patients: an exploratory study of the perceptions of nurses in Hong Kong
52 Citations1999Diana Lee, Chan +2 more
It was found that nurses had an overriding concern in ensuring elderly patients' physical safety and using restraints therefore provided them with a sense of security and the deleterious impact of restraint on the care received by elderly patients was largely unrecognized.
Orthopaedic NursingNurses?? Attitudes Toward Older Persons on Their Use of Physical Restraints
40 Citations1995Amy Helmuth, Amy Helmuth
Results indicated that nurses with negative attitudes toward older persons were likely to favor the use of restraints with older persons, and strategies other than changing nurses' attitudes may be more effective in reducing restraint use.
Journal of Nutrition EducationHealth and Nutrition Messages in Food Advertisements: A Comparative Content Analysis of Young and Mature Australian Women's Magazines
33 Citations1996Jan M. Hill, Kathy Radimer
There is a need to more fully explore attitudes to food and food purchasing behavior in young women and to develop nutrition education strategies to counter the advertising of predominantly nonmeal-type foods with low nutrient density in youngWomen's magazines.
Scandinavian Journal of Caring SciencesPhysical Restraints in Geriatric Care
33 Citations1998Stig Karlsson, Gösta Bucht +1 more
Significant differences between various staff categories were found concerning knowledge about the use of restraints; nurse aids had the lowest and physicians the highest scores on the knowledge test and nurse aids demonstrated the least negative attitudes and Physicians the most negative.
JONA The Journal of Nursing AdministrationTaking Charge
30 Citations1997Joan M. Dunbar, Richard R. Neufeld +3 more
The role of nursing administrators in reducing the use of physical restraints as part of a 2-year, national nursing home restraint-reduction project is described.
International Journal of Nursing StudiesUse of physical restraints in nursing homes in New South Wales, Australia
28 Citations1998Andrew Retsas, Heather Crabbe
The findings of this research indicate that the extent to which physical restraints are currently being used in nursing homes in New South Wales should be of concern.
Journal of Gerontological NursingInstitutional Policy USE OF RESTRAINTS IN EXTENDED CARE AND NURSING HOMES
26 Citations1993Rose Magee, Elizabeth Hyatt +4 more
Upon examining institutional restraint policy, nurses should be prepared to implement changes in documentation format, provide staff education regarding restraint use and alternatives available, institute a rehabilitative and restorative nursing care and fall prevention program, redesign the physical environment, and designate adequate resources for an effective diversion activity program.
International Journal of Nursing StudiesNurses' awareness of restraint use with elderly people in Greece and the U.K.: a cross-cultural pilot study
25 Citations1996Alex Molassiotis, Robert Newell
A small pilot study of nurses' attitudes towards and knowledge of restraint use with older patients and the need for education, restraint policies and multidisciplinary decision-making about restraint use is examined.
Journal of Gerontological NursingPerceptions of Acute Care Nurses in THE USE OF RESTRAINTS
23 Citations1995Anita Thomas, L Redfern +1 more
This stratified, random sample demonstrated that LPNs consistently attached greater importance to the use of restraints than either RNs or Managers, suggesting that the educational level of nurses may have an impact on the continued use of physical restraints.
PubMedUse of patient restraints in four Australian teaching hospitals.
21 Citations1997Craig Whitehead, Paul Finucane +3 more
Although the overall prevalence of restraint use increased with age, the hospital with the oldest patients used restraints least, and there was scant documentation in the case notes concerning the use of restraints, the prevalence of restraints use varies widely in different hospitals.
Archives of Physical Medicine and RehabilitationRestraint use in inpatient rehabilitation: Incidence, predictors, and implications
16 Citations1994Randal E. Schleenbaker, Susan M. McDowell +3 more
Collegian Journal of the Royal College of Nursing AustraliaUse of physical restraints in nursing homes in Queensland, Australia
14 Citations1997Andrew Retsas, Heather Crabbe
The findings of this research indicate that the extent to which physical restraints are currently being used in nursing home residents in Queensland should be of concern, particularly in the context of a general, contemporary professional belief that the use of physical restraints in nursing homes should be minimised, if not entirely avoided.
PubMedThe use of physical restraints in Western Australian nursing homes.
12 Citations1997Andrew Retsas
The study found that physical restraints had been applied to 26% (n = 787) of the 3028 nursing home residents and the extent to which they were used is cause for concern.
International Journal of Language & Communication DisordersA content analysis of the professional journal of the British Society of Speech Therapists I: The first 10 years. Spotlight on ‘Speech’ 1935–1945
11 Citations1996Linda Armstrong, Jois Stansfield
The 24 editions of the professional journal 'Speech' published between 1935-1945 were examined by use of content analysis, enabling an in-depth survey of theprofessional, clinical and political issues of the period which saw the beginning of speech and language therapy as a profession.
PubMedReducing restraint use in a nursing home.
11 Citations1994Kramer Jd
CNSs are uniquely qualified to move a facility toward the goal of reducing the use of restraints, and their skills as leaders, educators, change agents, consultants, and systems experts are most essential.
Nursing ManagementHelp the Health Care Team Release Its Hold on Restraint
9 Citations1999Karen Lamb, Ann F. Minnick +3 more
A survey instrument was created to measure staff's knowledge, unit beliefs about practice patterns, ethical concerns, and more in a three-site cooperative physical restraint reduction program in acute-care hospitals.
Australian Journal on AgeingUse of Physical Restraints in South Australia's Nursing Homes
6 Citations1997Andrew Retsas
The extent to which physical restraints are used is cause for concern and further efforts, particularly through education programs which fully apprise all staff of the deleterious effects of physical restraints, are needed.
