The process of perceptual retouch: Nonspecific afferent activation dynamics in explaining visual masking
Perception & PsychophysicsPublished 1 January 1984Open access
Talis Bachmann
Citations141
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is concluded that trailing conscious-experience-generating impulses are elicited by collateral activity from the specific information received from the first stimulus, and reach the cortex at the same moment as the specific activity of thesecond (masking) stimulus as coded.
Abstract
A model for visual masking based on the notion of interaction of the specific and nonspecific afferent visual systems is presented. Discussion is focused on nonmonotonic masking functions. In particular, it is proposed that in order for visual information (patterns, forms, etc.) to be consciously perceived, both specific retina-genicula-striate impulses and nonspecific retina-reticulacortical impulses should converge in the same cortical space. Nonspecific activity is shown to be necessary for subjective awareness. This activity is shown to be of longer latency than specific activity. It is concluded that trailing conscious-experience-generating impulses are elicited by collateral activity from the specific information received from thefirst stimulus. These impulses reach the cortex at the same moment as the specific activity of thesecond (masking) stimulus as coded, which has a relatively higher signal-to-noise ratio in the given retinotopically specified cortical space. Consequently, subjects consciously perceive the second stimulus. This operation of awareness generation is termedperceptual retouch and is considered as a special psychological mechanism worthy of psychophysical study.
Keywords
Neuroscience
Electroencephalography and Clinical NeurophysiologyBrain stem reticular formation and activation of the EEG
4,281 Citations1949G. Moruzzi, H. W. Magoun
The possibility is considered that a background of maintained activity within this ascending brain stem activating system may account for wakefulness, while reduction of its activity either naturally, by barbiturates, or by experimental injury and disease, may respectively precipitate normal sleep, contribute to anesthesia or produce pathological somnolence.
ScienceElectrical Signs of Selective Attention in the Human Brain
1,959 Citations1973Steven A. Hillyard, Robert F. Hink +2 more
Auditory evoked potentials were recorded from the vertex of subjects who listened selectively to a series of tone pipping in one ear and ignored concurrent tone pips in the other ear to study the response set established to recognize infrequent, higher pitched tone pipped in the attended series.
Electroencephalography and Clinical NeurophysiologyHuman auditory evoked potentials. I: Evaluation of components
1,487 Citations1974Terence W. Picton, Steven A. Hillyard +2 more
Fifteen distinct components can be identified in the scalp recorded average evoked potential to an abrupt auditory stimulus, and seem to represent widespread activation of frontal cortex.
Perception & PsychophysicsTemporal and spatial characteristics of selective encoding from visual displays
595 Citations1972Charles W. Eriksen, James E. Hoffman
Perception & PsychophysicsVertex potentials evoked during auditory signal detection: Relation to decision criteria
240 Citations1973Kenneth C. Squires, Steven A. Hillyard +1 more
Vertex potentials were recorded from eight Ss performing in an auditory threshold detection task with rating scale responses and it was suggested that the N1 and P3 components represent distinctive aspects of the decision process, with N 1 signifying the quantity of signal information received and P 3 reflecting the certainty of the decisions based upon that information.
Psychological ResearchCentral sources of visual masking: Indexing structures supporting seeing at a single, brief glance
226 Citations1979Claire F. Michaels, M. T. Turvey
Three distinct sources of central masking are inferred from the selective influence of variables at different onset asynchronies, which shows evidence of a replacement principle: the iconic representation of the second field directs attention from that of the first field.
Perception & PsychophysicsAn onset-onset law for one case of apparent motion and metacontrast
220 Citations1967Daniel Kahneman
Perception & PsychophysicsTemporal luminance summation effects in backward and forward masking
209 Citations1966Charles W. Eriksen
Two experiments tested six predictions derived from the assumptions underlying the luminance summation-contrast reduction explanation for certain instances of forward and backward masking effects, finding that forward masks would be more extensive than backward masks under specified luminance arrangements.
Brain ResearchTemporal response characteristics of cells in monkey striate cortex measured with metacontrast masking and brightness discrimination
199 Citations1980Bruce Bridgeman
The results suggest an iterative or recurrent coding of visual information, where the same cells participate in early, late, preresponse coding in different ways.
The American Journal of PsychologySome Factors Determining Efficiency of Selective Attention
154 Citations1970Charles W. Eriksen, John Rohrbaugh
Perception & PsychophysicsSelective encoding from multielement visual displays
154 Citations1973Robert L. Colegatef, James E. Hoffman +1 more
Electroencephalography and Clinical NeurophysiologySelective attention and the auditory vertex potential. I. Effects of stimulus delivery rate
148 Citations1976Vincent L. Schwent, Steven A. Hillyard +1 more
The pattern of attention-related effects on N1 was dissociated from the pattern displayed by the subsequent P3 wave, substantiating the view that the two waves are related to different modes of selective attention.
Perception & PsychophysicsTwo studies of visual search for word targets with controlled rates of presentation*
134 Citations1971Douglas H. Lawrence
Journal of Experimental PsychologyThe time-intensity relation in visual perception as a function of observer's task.
111 Citations1964Daniel Kahneman, Joel Norman
The duration-intensity relationship was investigated for a task in which triads of digits were to be identified and it was concluded that tc varies as a function of perceptual task and that it does not represent the duration of an early "sensory" phase of the visual process.
Biological PsychologySlow negative shifts of the human event-related potential associated with selective information processing
91 Citations1981Tsunetaka Okita
Event-related potentials to random sequences of tones delivered to the right and left ears were recorded during a pitch discrimination task, supporting the view that the negativity reflects further processing carried out on each relevant input after that input is identified.
DigitalGeorgetown (Georgetown University Library)The Neurosciences: Paths of Discovery
87 Citations1975Frederic G. Worden, Judith P. Swazey +1 more
Memory & CognitionDo noise masks terminate target processing?
85 Citations1977Derek W. Schultz, Charles W. Eriksen
The results suggested that efforts to control target processing time through display of a visual noise pattern subsequent to target presentation are methodologically inadequate when devoid of some basic control operations.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceVisual masking during pursuit eye movements.
85 Citations1976Charles White
In three experiments, targets and masking stimuli were briefly flashce while observers visually tracked a moving dot and visual masking during pursuit eye movements depended on the apparent position of the stimuli, not their retinal positions as such, which is in disagreement with previous studies of visual masks during saccadic eye movements.
Perception & PsychophysicsDoes backward masking by visual noise stop stimulus processing?
79 Citations1968Phillip Liss
The results indicate that backward masking impairs identification by interrupting the stimulus processing, not by degrading the stimulus input.
Perception & PsychophysicsApparent movement and metacontrast: A note on Kahneman’s formulation
71 Citations1969Naomi Weisstein, Ronald Growney
Results indicate that the apparent motion hypothesis for metacontrast is untenable and may not be unrelated, however; they might both have something to do with single units in the visualcortex.
PerceptionIntegration and Interruption in the Masking of Form by Form
67 Citations1976Talis Bachmann, Jüri Allïk
The results are interpreted on the basis of a multiple-stage processing model which assumes interaction between stimuli at different levels at different values of t to yield monotonic functions for both backward and forward masking.
Vision ResearchMetacontrast as a function of spatial separation with narrow line targets and masks
63 Citations1977Ronald Growney, Naomi Weisstein +1 more
Vision ResearchCorrelates of metacontrast in single cells of the cat visual system
55 Citations1975Bruce Bridgeman
Curarized cats received light stimuli consisting of two spatially adjacent bars, each flashed for 20 msec with onset asynchronies of 0–120 msec, explaining several paradoxes in the metacontrast literature.
Vision ResearchContrast reduction by small localized stimuli: Extensive spatial spread of above-threshold orientation-selective masking
49 Citations1977Naomi Weisstein, C. Stanley Harris +3 more
Striped gratings and a bullseye were masked by stimuli that look unlike those patterns, but share orientational and spatial-frequency components with them, suggesting some aspects of visual processing may be distributed rather than local in the space-domain.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceRelation of split apparent motion to metacontrast.
45 Citations1977Arnold E. Stoper, Sherry Banffy
Results are interpreted in terms of a "fusion" process underlying metacontrast and a "direction-sensitive unit" underlying apparent motion and interactions between these two processes that might account for the common co-occurrence of motion and metacentrast are proposed.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceFigural relationship effects and mechanisms of visual masking.
45 Citations1979Joseph B. Hellige, David Walsh +2 more
Results indicate that the dominant mechanism of masking at SOAs from 0 to 20 msec is luminance summation over time but that luminance summary gives way to feature-specific interference at longer SOAs.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceEffect of depth separation on metacontrast masking.
43 Citations1980Stephen Lehmkuhle, Robert A. Fox
Bulletin of the Psychonomic SocietyMetacontrast masking as a function of mask energy
41 Citations1978Bruno G. Breitmeyer
PerceptionPerception of an Illusory Triangle with Masked Inducing Figure
40 Citations1980Angus Gellatly
These findings suggest that no single set of mechanisms, physiological or cognitive, will suffice to explain perception of the illusory triangle.
Psychonomic ScienceLuminance summation-contrast reduction as a basis for certain forward and backward masking effects
33 Citations1964Charles W. Eriksen, Joseph S. Lappin
Psychonomic ScienceClarity and recognition of masked and degraded stimuli
33 Citations1968Ralph Norman Haber, Lionel Standing
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceInteraction of stimulus size and retinal eccentricity in metacontrast masking.
32 Citations1979Bruce Bridgeman, Stuart E. Leff
Both foveal metacontrast and peak shifts contradicted predictions made by the hypothesis that metAContrast is mediated by an interaction of sustained and transient channels in the visual system; the data are consistent, however, with a lateral inhibitory model of metacentrast masking and stimulus coding.
Perception & PsychophysicsVisual perceptive simultaneity and masking of letters successively presented
30 Citations1966Paul Fraisse
Vision ResearchMetacontrast and paracontrast suppression of a contourless area
22 Citations1978Arnold E. Stoper, James G. Mansfield
Here it is demonstrated brightness suppression of a contourless area of a target by an adjacent mask that follows a U-shaped function of time similar to those obtained in traditional metacontrast, except that “forward masking” is equal in strength to backward masking.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformancePerceptual delay: A consequence of metacontrast and apparent motion.
21 Citations1980Robert Didner, George Sperling
Temporal-order judgments were used to demonstrate that a later visual stimulus can delay the perception of an earlier one when the two stimuli together produce the phenomenon of metacontrast or of apparent motion.
Psychonomic ScienceBackward masking: Facilitation through increased target-field luminance and duration
20 Citations1969Dean G. Purcell, Alan L. Stewart +1 more
Two experiments support a proposed theory that predicts that, within certain limits, increases in target-field luminance or duration will increase the target’s susceptability to masking.
Perception & PsychophysicsSpatial effectiveness of the mask: Lateral inhibition in visual backward masking
19 Citations1968Dean G. Purcell, Alan L. Stewart +1 more
It is hypothesized that incorporating a figure into the masking flash changes the inhibitory pattern the mask produces in the visual system, resulting in a phenomenal representation different from that produced by either the target or the mask alone.
Vision ResearchPerceptual changes during metacontrast
18 Citations1978Susan Petry
Four variables (brightness of the center, edge, and whole test stimulus, and apparent duration of the test stimulus) were quantified using a magnitude estimation procedure and while all four are described by U-shaped functions, apparent duration was at a minimum at a significantly longer SOA than brightness.
Perception & PsychophysicsVisual recognition as a function of stimulus offset asynchrony and duration
17 Citations1974Lee S. Cohene, Harold P. Bechtoldt
An interaction between bigram letter position and each of bigram duration and percent stimulus asynchrony was observed with recognition accuracy greater in general for the letter in the left half of the field.
Bulletin of the Psychonomic SocietyHemiretinae and nonmonotonic masking functions with overlapping stimuli
16 Citations1973Claire F. Michaels, M. T. Turvey
Under these conditions, U-shaped monoptic masking functions were obtained which did not differ, as a function of hemiretina, in their overall shape or in their points of maximal masking.
PubMedVisual recogition of dot-pattern bigrams: an extension and replication.
15 Citations1975Lee S. Cohene, Harold P. Bechtoldt
PerceptionDoes Integration Produce Masking or Protect from it?
15 Citations1981David Navon, Dean G. Purcell
It is suggested that integration never produces masking, but rather may or may not protect from a disruptive effect of interruption, and that were the visual system to have better visual resolution, it would suffer more given the same masking parameters.
Perceptual and Motor SkillsSerial Processing Shown by Mutual Masking of Icons
11 Citations1975E. Rae Harcum, D. Stephen Nice
In a procedure called mutual masking, two compound words were tachistoscopically exposed successively at the same location to obtain sequential processing of iconic information, with direction of processing determined by specific conditions.
Vision ResearchMetacontrast as a function of the spatial frequency composition of the target and mask
10 Citations1978Ronald Growney
The variation in optimal masking for different stimulus conditions did not correspond to the similarity of spatial frequency components of the target and mask, to the Sustained-Transient hypothesis, or to the luminance near the edge of the mask.
PerceptionEvidence for the Role of Attentive Fields in Masking
8 Citations1980Alexander W. Pressey, Alexander E. Wilson +1 more
A masking task was employed to determine whether predictions derived from the attentive-field postulate of assimilation theory could be verified, and as predicted, masking was greater when the mask was near the center of attention than when it was located at the periphery of the field.
PerceptionMetacontrast as Measured under a Signal Detection Model
7 Citations1977Linda L. Hernández, Lester A. Lefton
The results showed a monotonic increase in sensitivity with increasing mask delay, and an abrupt shift of subjects' response criterion at an 80 ms interstimulus interval.
PerceptionDecrease in Metacontrast Masking following Adaptation to Flicker
7 Citations1979Susan Petry, Antony Grigonis +1 more
Prior adaptation to a continuously present stimulus did not appreciably affect metacontrast masking; however, masking was greatly reduced following adaptation to flickering stimuli.
Physiological PsychologyEvoked responses to retroactively masked stimuli
6 Citations1979Marvin Schwartz, Oncy M. Whittier +1 more
Bulletin of the Psychonomic SocietyA comparison of white and black targets under conditions of masking by a patterned stimulus
5 Citations1975Dean G. Purcell, Alan L. Stewart
Psychonomic ScienceMetacontrast: Further evidence for monotonic functions
5 Citations1970Lester A. Lefton
Neurophysiological Correlates of Central Masking
4 Citations1979Michael L. Lester, M. J. Kitzman +4 more
Bulletin of the Psychonomic SocietyA reassessment of target-mask interaction in visual backward masking
4 Citations1977Kathleen Ann Carlson, M. S. Mayzner
The present study investigates the manner in which a suppressed target alters the perception of a mask and finds that a mutual sort of target-mask interaction is implied.