Failures of Engagement: Lessons Learned from a Citizen Science Pilot Study
Applied Environmental Education & CommunicationPublished 1 July 2012
Caroline Gottschalk Druschke, Carrie Seltzer
Citations105
SJR quartileQ2
SJR score0.40
SNIP0.73
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
Citizen science is growing in popularity, but little research addresses participant learning outcomes. We describe the Chicago Area Pollinator Study (CAPS), which relied on citizen scientists to gather information about urban bee diversity and abundance. Based on pre- and post-CAPS participant surveys, we determined that citizen scientists collected an impressive amount of data and enjoyed the experience but did not achieve the educational goals we hoped for. We detail our failure to effectively engage citizen scientists in the learning process, and we make specific recommendations for creating the types of dynamic and mutually successful projects that scientists and citizens deserve.
Keywords
PsychologyAgricultural and Biological SciencesEnvironmental Science
Journal of Marketing ResearchQuestionnaire Design, Interviewing and Attitude Measurement
5,007 Citations1993Gerald Albuam, A. N. Oppenheim
BioScienceCitizen Science: A Developing Tool for Expanding Science Knowledge and Scientific Literacy
2,422 Citations2009Rick Bonney, Caren B. Cooper +5 more
This article describes the model for building and operating citizen science projects that has evolved at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology over the past two decades and hopes that the model will inform the fields of biodiversity monitoring, biological research, and science education while providing a window into the culture of citizen science.
Ecology and SocietyCitizen Science as a Tool for Conservation in Residential Ecosystems
733 Citations2007Caren B. Cooper, Janis L. Dickinson +2 more
International Journal of Science EducationScientific knowledge and attitude change: The impact of a citizen science project
682 Citations2005Dominique Brossard, Bruce V. Lewenstein +1 more
Science EducationThinking scientifically during participation in a citizen-science project
380 Citations2000Deborah J. Trumbull, Rick Bonney +2 more
Ecology and SocietyThe Rauischholzhausen Agenda for Road Ecology
371 Citations2007Inga A. Roedenbeck, Lenore Fahrig +6 more
Journal of the American Statistical AssociationRemarks on Zeros and Ties in the Wilcoxon Signed Rank Procedures
285 Citations1959John W. Pratt
BioScienceCreating a Successful Citizen Science Model to Detect and Report Invasive Species
195 Citations2011Travis Gallo, Damon Waitt
Compared with observations from the Invasive Plant Atlas of New England, a similar citizen science program, confirmed that, given proper training, citizen scientists are able to detect and report invasive plants in their local areas, and the data they collect can be used by professional scientists.
Journal of Wildlife ManagementData‐Mining Discovery of Pattern and Process in Ecological Systems
184 Citations2007Wesley M. Hochachka, Rich Caruana +5 more
The distinctions between data-mining analyses and parametric statistical analyses are presented and useful ways in which data mining and statistical analyses can be integrated into a thorough analysis of data are suggested to facilitate rapid creation of accurate models and to guide further research.
Journal of Research in Science TeachingDeveloping the changes in attitude about the relevance of science (CARS) questionnaire and assessing two high school science classes
152 Citations2003Marcelle A. Siegel, Michael Ranney
EcologySEASONAL AND LATITUDINAL TRENDS IN CLUTCH SIZE: THERMAL CONSTRAINTS DURING LAYING AND INCUBATION
131 Citations2005Caren B. Cooper, Wesley M. Hochachka +2 more
Using general linear mixed models, it is found that large-scale nesting patterns of Eastern Bluebirds and Red-winged Blackbirds are consistent with the egg-viability hypothesis in that females appear to initiate incubation before clutch completion when they lay large clutches at low latitudes.
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesAdverse effects of acid rain on the distribution of the Wood Thrush <i>Hylocichla mustelina</i> in North America
120 Citations2002Ralph S. Hames, Kenneth V. Rosenberg +3 more
An important role for acid rain is suggested in recent declines of some birds breeding in the eastern United States, particularly in high elevation zones with low pH soils, and the need to consider other large-scale influences, in addition to habitat fragmentation, when addressing bird population declines is shown.
Applied Environmental Education & CommunicationDoes Participation in Citizen Science Improve Scientific Literacy? A Study to Compare Assessment Methods
119 Citations2011Ruth J. Cronje, Spencer Rohlinger +2 more
Science EducationDeveloping materials to promote inquiry: Lessons learned
96 Citations2005Deborah J. Trumbull, Rick Bonney +1 more
Ecology and SocietyCitizen, Science, Highways, and Wildlife: Using a Web-based GIS to Engage Citizens in Collecting Wildlife Information
82 Citations2006Tracy Lee, Michael S. Quinn +1 more
Ecology and SocietyUsing Citizens to Do Science Versus Citizens as Scientists
57 Citations2007Shyamal Lakshminarayanan
Journal of Avian BiologyLatitudinal trends in within‐year reoccupation of nest boxes and their implications
55 Citations2004Caren B. Cooper, Wesley M. Hochachka +1 more
This work analyzed nest box reoccupation by a multiple-brooding species, the eastern bluebird Sialia sialis, reported by volunteers in a citizen-participation project (1998–2002), and found nest boxes in the southern portion of the bluebird range had, on average 17–33% higher likelihood of repeated egg-laying, brooding, and successful fledging events than Boxes in the north.
IbisGeographical and seasonal gradients in hatching failure in Eastern Bluebirds <i>Sialia sialis</i> reinforce clutch size trends
40 Citations2006Caren B. Cooper, Wesley M. Hochachka +2 more
The results demonstrate that investigating causes of variation in demography among local populations across a geographical gradient provides a potential means of identifying selection pressures on life-history traits and warrants further research into other causes of hatching failure.
Mining citizen science data to predict orevalence of wild bird species
38 Citations2006Rich Caruana, M.E. El-Hawary +6 more
It is shown how data mining can be successfully applied, enabling the ecologists to discover unanticipated relationships, and initial results for the impact of important attributes on bird prevalence are presented.
BioScienceEmpowering Citizen Scientists: The Strength of Many in Monitoring Biologically Active Environmental Contaminants
30 Citations2011Alan S. Kolok, Heiko L. Schoenfuss +2 more