Surveying Physicians
Medical CarePublished 1 July 2002
Terry S. Field, Cynthia Cadoret, Martin L. Brown, Marvella E. Ford, Sarah M. Greene, Deanna L. Hill
Citations163
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.57
SNIP1.38
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Researchers conducting surveys of physicians should consider including all components of the total design approach whenever feasible, as there have been few randomized trials conducted on important aspects of enhancing response in this population.
Abstract
Despite the number of surveys conducted among physicians, their cost, the level of interest in their findings, and in spite of inadequate response rates, there have been few randomized trials conducted on important aspects of enhancing response in this population. Until this gap has been filled, researchers conducting surveys of physicians should consider including all components of the total design approach whenever feasible.
Keywords
Social SciencesEconomics, Econometrics and FinanceHealth Professions
Mail and internet surveys : the tailored design method
9,659 Citations2007Don A. Dillman
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyResponse rates to mail surveys published in medical journals
2,098 Citations1997David A. Asch, M.Kathryn Jedrziewski +1 more
Although several mail survey techniques are associated with higher response rates, response rates to published mail surveys tend to be moderate, and investigators, journal editors, and readers should devote more attention to assessments of bias, and less to specific response rate thresholds.
American Sociological ReviewFactors Affecting Response Rates to Mailed Questionnaires: A Quantitative Analysis of the Published Literature
1,005 Citations1978Thomas A. Heberlein, Robert Baumgartner
American Journal of Preventive MedicinePhysician response to surveys A review of the literature
952 Citations2001Scott Kellerman
Surprisingly, the response rates of mail surveys of physicians compared favorably with those from telephone and personal interview surveys.
Public Opinion QuarterlyEstimating the Effect of Incentives on Mail Survey Response Rates: A Meta-Analysis
704 Citations1993Allan H. Church
PubMedReported response rates to mailed physician questionnaires.
691 Citations2020SM Cummings, Lucy A. Savitz +1 more
Responsibility rates have remained somewhat constant over time, and researchers need to document the efforts used to increase response rates to mailed physician questionnaires.
Public Opinion QuarterlyMail Survey Response Rate: A Meta-Analysis of Selected Techniques for Inducing Response
675 Citations1988Richard J. Fox, Melvin R. Crask +1 more
Public Opinion QuarterlyUnderstanding Mail Survey Response Behavior: A Meta-Analysis
574 Citations1991Francis J. Yammarino, Steven J. Skinner +1 more
Archives of Internal MedicineA Review of the Incorporation of Complementary and Alternative Medicine by Mainstream Physicians
464 Citations1998John A. Astin, Ariane Marie +3 more
New England Journal of MedicineKnowledge and Practices of Generalist and Specialist Physicians Regarding Drug Therapy for Acute Myocardial Infarction
388 Citations1994John Z. Ayanian, Paul J. Hauptman +4 more
Internists and family practitioners are less aware of or less certain about key advances in the treatment of myocardial infarction than are cardiologists, underscoring the need to improve the dissemination of information from clinical trials to generalist physicians, particularly if they are to have an enlarged role in the evolving health care system.
PubMedSurveying general practitioners: does a low response rate matter?
229 Citations1997L Templeton, Ann Deehan +3 more
PubMedPhysician manipulation of reimbursement rules for patients: between a rock and a hard place.
227 Citations2000Matthew K. Wynia, Deborah S. Cummins +2 more
A sizable minority of physicians report manipulating reimbursement rules so patients can receive care that physicians perceive is necessary, and greater utilization restrictions in the health care system are likely to increase physicians' use of such manipulative "covert advocacy" tactics.
Annals of Internal MedicineAttitudes and Practices of U.S. Oncologists regarding Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide
164 Citations2000Ezekiel Emanuel, Diane Fairclough +6 more
The American Society of Clinical Oncology surveyed all of its U.S. members about end-of-life care practices and found that oncologists are likely to have to address the issue of euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide more often than other physicians.
PubMedTelephone versus postal surveys of general practitioners: methodological considerations.
162 Citations1994BS Sibbald, Julia Addington‐Hall +2 more
It is suggested that non-response to the postal survey was associated with lack of activity in the study area and a social desirability bias may have been introduced.
BMJProfessionals as responders: variations in and effects of response rates to questionnaires, 1961-77.
144 Citations1978Anna Cartwright
General conclusions about the representativeness of the respondents when compared with basic data on those who did not respond are that younger better qualified doctors were more likely to respond and among general practioners those who worked in groups were morelikely to respond.
American Journal of Public HealthIncreasing response rates in physicians' mail surveys: an experimental study.
142 Citations1989Brigitte Maheux, Claudine Legault +1 more
It is becoming increasingly difficult to obtain high response rates in physicians' mail surveys, and a handwritten thank you note at the bottom of the letter accompanying the questionnaire and a more personalized mailout package increased response rates.
American Journal of EpidemiologyEFFECTIVENESS OF VARIOUS MAILING STRATEGIES AMONG NONRESPONDENTS IN A PROSPECTIVE COHORT STUDY
132 Citations1990Eric B. Rimm, Meir J. Stampfer +3 more
Although altering the physical appearance of the envelope and using other postal rates were tested, certified mail was the most effective approach for reaching study members who were nonrespondents to a mailed questionnaire.
Medical CareConducting Physician Mail Surveys on a Limited Budget
123 Citations1998David A. Asch, Nicholas A. Christakis +1 more
A $5 bill incentive yielded a higher response rate among the physicians in this study than did a $2 bill incentive, which suggests that resources in a fixed survey budget are allocated more efficiently to increasing the initial incentive rather than to providing a third wave to nonresponders.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyComparison of Open and Closed Questionnaire Formats in Obtaining Demographic Information From Canadian General Internists
120 Citations1999Lauren E. Griffith
Investigators can achieve higher response rates for demographic items using closed format response options, but at the risk of increasing inaccuracy in response to questions requiring computation, according to this study.
American Journal of Public HealthImproving response rates through incentive and follow-up: the effect on a survey of physicians' knowledge of genetics.
116 Citations1993Ellen Tambor, G A Chase +4 more
Efforts to increase response rates to a mailed physician survey were assessed and whether, as a result, nonresponse bias was reduced and this may not be the case for other studies.
Public Opinion QuarterlyPhysician Response to a Mailed Survey an Experiment in Timing of Payment
106 Citations1987Sandra H. Berry, David E. Kanouse
Overall, prepayment had significant positive effects on response rates and raised important questions about how payment "works" in eliciting high response rates in physicians.
Annals of Internal MedicineHow Satisfying Is the Practice of Internal Medicine?
102 Citations1991Charles E. Lewis, Deborah M. Prout +2 more
There is growing dissatisfaction with the practice of internal medicine, primarily related to concerns over loss of clinical autonomy, the increase in administrative burdens, the potential loss of income, and the threat of malpractice litigation.
PubMedThe effect of cash and other financial inducements on the response rate of general practitioners in a national postal study.
100 Citations1997Ann Deehan, L Templeton +3 more
It may now be that, to achieve the response rates needed to validate policy-related research, the offer of inducements will become a necessary part of the research process.
The Journal of Experimental EducationResponse Rates in Survey Research: A Meta-Analysis of the Effects of Monetary Gratuities
90 Citations1992Kenneth D. Hopkins, Arlen R. Gullickson
Public Opinion QuarterlyPhysician Response Rates to Mail and Personal Interview Surveys
88 Citations1979Herschel Shosteck, William R. Fairweather
Overall, mail surveys appear to require less time, to be less costly, and to generate higher response rates than equivalent personal contacts.
Public Opinion QuarterlyIncentives for Increasing Return Rates: Magnitude Levels, Response Bias, amd Format
78 Citations1984J. Scott Mizes, E. Louis Fleece +1 more
Medical CareEffects of Different Monetary Incentives on the Return Rate of a National Mail Survey of Physicians
75 Citations2001Jonathan B. VanGeest, Matthew K. Wynia +2 more
It is suggested that changes in the magnitude of incentive do not automatically result in increases in survey response among physicians, and possible reasons for this lack of effect are addressed.
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsThe Effect of a Monetary Incentive in Increasing the Return Rate of a Survey to Family Physicians
69 Citations1997Sherry A. Everett, James H. Price +2 more
The use of a modest $1 monetary incentive to increase a survey response rate appears to be more cost-effective than a thirdfollow-up (postcard reminder) mailing.
American Journal of Public HealthInterviewing physicians: the effect of improved response rate.
69 Citations1985Marc L. Berk
This analysis of data from the Physicians' Practice Survey indicates that estimates made from early responders closely approximate those obtained at the conclusion of a longer field period.
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsThe Effects of Nonresponse and Late Response on a Survey of Physician Attitudes
66 Citations1989Edward Guadagnoli, Susan J. Cunningham
Although the overall response rate increased from 35% to 58% as a result of the follow-up mailing, nonresponse bias was still present and researchers must focus their attention on increasing the participation of all types of physicians at all points in the data collection process.
American Journal of EpidemiologyThe Effect of Two Mailing Strategies on the Response to a Survey of Physicians
64 Citations1991Patricia H. Shiono, Mark A. Klebanoff
The authors conclude that seemingly minor changes in survey design could have saved from 12% to 19% of the total cost of the study, which tested the effectiveness of two response-enhancing techniques in a survey of pregnancy among 10,047 resident physicians in the United States.
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsThe Effects of Variations in Mode of Delivery and Monetary Incentive on Physicians’ Responses to a Mailed Survey Assessing STD Practice Patterns
63 Citations2001Danuta Kasprzyk, Daniel E. Montaño +2 more
High response rates from busy practicing physicians can be achieved if surveys are relevant to clinical practice, sponsored by a reputable organization, include a monetary incentive, and are delivered by courier.
Public Opinion QuarterlyPhysician Response Rates to a Telephone Survey: Effects of Monetary Incentive Level
61 Citations1981Walter J. Gunn, Isabelle N. Rhodes
An experiment to determine the effectiveness of paying physicians monetary incentives for their participation in a 20-30-minute telephone interview on the subject of influenza immunization.
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsPhysician Participation in Research Surveys
60 Citations1999Gary Donaldson, Carol M. Moinpour +8 more
It is concluded a modest financial reward can significantly improve physician response rates to research surveys but a telephone follow-up may be inefficient and even ineffective.
Family PracticeReducing systematic bias in studies of general practitioners: the use of a medical peer in the recruitment of general practitioners in research
50 Citations1995Alison Heywood, P Mudge +2 more
Results indicate that by specifically addressing strategies which facilitate access to the target population, and increase the legitimacy and credibility of the study, significant improvements in response rates can be achieved.
EpidemiologyDifferent Response Rates in a Trial of Two Envelope Styles in Mail Survey Research
50 Citations1994David A. Asch, Nicholas A. Christakis
It is concluded that the packaging of a mail survey can influence the response rate and that academic physicians' response rates depend on the envelope used to mail the survey.
Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public HealthLabour-saving strategies to maintain survey response rates: a randomised trial
49 Citations1998Jeanette Ward, Tracey Bruce +3 more
The demonstration of a significant interaction between respondent sex and response‐aiding strategy invites further research.
Family PracticeResponse Bias in a Study of General Practice
47 Citations1988Jill Cockburn, Elizabeth Campbell +2 more
Response bias in quality of care research is an important, but largely neglected concern and a method for examining this important area is outlined, in terms of strategies aimed at increasing response rates in qualityof care research.
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsComparing Physicians' Responses to the First and Second Mailings of a Questionnaire
46 Citations1989Jeffery Sobal, Kevin S. Ferentz
The absence of differences in physicians who responded to the follow-up questionnaire suggests that remailings to obtain higher response rates may be unnecessary in some surveys.
Evaluation ReviewFactors Associated With Response Rates in a National Survey of Primary Care Physicians
46 Citations1994Jennifer Parsons, Richard B. Warnecke +3 more
The results and implications of offering a national sample of primary care physicians an option to complete a questionnaire by mail or phone and the importance of a lengthy field period are demonstrated.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyEffects on response rates and costs of stamps vs business reply in a mail survey of physicians
45 Citations1993Nicole Urban, Garnet L. Anderson +1 more
In the general population, the use of stamps rather than business reply postage significantly improves response rates in mail surveys and reduces cost in surveys of physicians; among physicians, a smaller effect might be anticipated due to their greater sophistication.
Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public HealthPrimer postcard improves postal survey response rates
39 Citations1999Marie Pirotta, Jane Gunn +2 more
The effect of an intervention to improve mailed survey response rates is measured and it is found that the response rate to mailed survey questions improves with age, race, ethnicity, and gender.
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsA Randomized Trial of the Impact of Certified Mail on Response Rate to a Physician Survey, and a Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
35 Citations1997Maggi L. del Valle, H Morgenstern +3 more
Use of certified mail is effective in increasing survey response but more costly than first-class mail in the third mailing.
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsThe Use of a Prepaid Incentive to Convert Nonresponders on a Survey of Physicians
32 Citations1993Marc L. Berk, W. Sherman Edwards +1 more
The study examined whether or not the decision to provide a monetary incentive can be postponed until the results of the initial mailing are available, to enable researchers to restrict the use of monetary incentives to surveys where early results indicate response rates may be inadequate.
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsCost-Effectiveness of a Lottery for Increasing Physicians’ Responses to a Mail Survey
32 Citations2001Geneviève Baron, Philippe De Wals +1 more
A lottery resulted in a small but statistically significant increase in the response rate of physicians to a mail survey, suggesting this method may be a cost-effective option when applied to large surveys.
Family PracticeImproving the Response Rates in Primary Care Research. Some Methods used in a Survey on Stress in General Practice since the New Contract (1990)
31 Citations1993Sybil Myerson
This paper describes some methods used to improve the response rates in a survey on "stress in general practice since the new contract", and it discusses some of the literature on this problem.
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsDealing with Nonrespondents in a Mail Survey of Professionals
30 Citations1986Alan C. Ogborne, Brian Rush +1 more
In an experimental study involving health and social service professionals, a second mailing of a questionnaire to initial nonrespondents in a mail survey was found more cost-effective as a means of increasing returns than attempts to conduct telephone interviews.
PubMedEffectiveness of telephone prompts when surveying general practitioners: a randomised trial.
29 Citations1996Michael Osborn, Jayne Ward +1 more
A telephone prompt by a non-medical research assistant will accelerate and enhance response rates to a survey of general practitioners although the differential effectiveness of anon-medical researcher compared to a medical practitioner conducting such prompts remains unstudied.
Psychological ReportsAn Informational versus Monetary Incentive in Increasing Physicians' Response Rates
28 Citations1997Alyssa Easton, Susan K. Telljohann +2 more
Return rates for a cancer prevention survey by pediatricians in relation to an informational booklet versus a monetary incentive in the first of a three-wave mailing indicate the $1.00 incentive was more effective than the informational incentive in increasing return rates in this sample of physicians.
PubMedMaximising response rates in a survey of general practitioners. Lessons from a Victorian survey on sexually transmissible diseases.
26 Citations1998Meredith Temple‐Smith, G Mulvey +1 more
Telephone prompts to encourage GP response in survey research need not be made by a medical practitioner, and other important factors in relation to response rate that should be considered by researchers are GP involvement in the developing and piloting of the survey instrument.
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsThe Cost-Effectiveness of Randomized Incentive and Follow-Up Contacts in a National Mail Survey of Family Physicians
24 Citations1987Patricia Dolan Mullen, Irene Easling +3 more
The withdrawal provision appeared to save a small amount in follow-up costs, although it was also associated with a decrease in the rates offinal response that approached signif icance.
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsUsing Physician Caller Follow-Ups to Improve the Response Rate to a Physician Telephone Survey
22 Citations1992Roberd M. Bostick, Phyllis L. Pirie +2 more
Adding physician investigator telephone contact improved a response rate of 66% to 92%.
Australian Journal of Public HealthIncreasing response rates of gynaecologists to a survey: a randomised trial of telephone prompts
20 Citations1994Jeanette Ward, Gerard Wain
A randomised controlled trial to evaluate the effectiveness of telephone prompts to increase the response rate of gynaecologists to a survey found that a telephone call in anticipation of a mailed questionnaire is highly recommended.
Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health CareDay-of-the-week effect on doctors’ response to a postal questionnaire
15 Citations1995Niels de Fine Olivarius, Anne Helms Andreasen
Responsibility rates in postal surveys sent to doctors cannot be improved by their receiving the questionnaire just before a week-end, and the probability of response was not influenced by receiving the survey just before or just after a month-end.
PubMedTracking managed care: the importance of a cash incentive for medical director response to a survey.
11 Citations2000Jennifer L. Malin, Jeffrey Rideout +1 more
It was found that medical directors who responded to the mailing with the $50 incentive were more likely to report that their organization had staff for quality assurance, and those who responded without the financial incentive had no significant differences.
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsCan Survey Data Be Used to Estimate Physician Practice Costs?
8 Citations1996Marc L. Berk, Curt D. Mueller +1 more
The results suggest that physician surveys may not be the most appropriate source of data about physician practice expenses, and alternative methodologies for incorporating physician practice costs into reimbursement rates are suggested.
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsPhysicians' Attitudes toward Breast Self-Examination
3 Citations1984Janice Marin, Holly L. Howe
The results show that a self-administered mail questionnaire can be used successfully in physician studies and that questionnaire length does affect response rates, but does not affect either respondent characteristics or question response.