FORAGING PATCH SELECTION BY SHRUBSTEPPE SPARROWS
EcologyPublished 1 June 1998
John T. Rotenberry, John A. Wiens
Citations58
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score2.04
SNIP1.53
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is suggested that shrubsteppe sparrows “track” interannual variation in patch composition and structure (which is presumably induced by precipitation variation) but maintain nonrandom use patterns within years.
Abstract
We used bird-centered vegetation measurements to assess selection of shrub-defined patches by foraging Sage Sparrows (Amphispiza belli) and Brewer’s Sparrows (Spizella breweri) over a period of 3 yr. Principal components of habitat variation based on a random sample of 900 patches were patch size, species composition (big sagebrush [Artemisia tridentata] vs. green rabbitbrush [Chrysothamnus viscidiflora] vs. gray rabbitbrush [C. nauseosus]), and plant vigor. Both bird species differed from random (P < 0.001) in their selection of patches in each year, but did not differ from each other. Patch structure varied significantly among years (P < 0.001), as did each species’ use of patches. Between-year changes in the two bird species’ selection patterns were highly correlated with changes in the habitat, and with each other. These correlations suggest that shrubsteppe sparrows “track” interannual variation in patch composition and structure (which is presumably induced by precipitation variation) but maintain nonrandom use patterns within years.
Keywords
Environmental Science
Theoretical Population BiologyOptimal foraging, the marginal value theorem
5,274 Citations1976Eric L. Charnov
Acta BiotheoreticaOn territorial behavior and other factors influencing habitat distribution in birds
4,510 Citations1969Stephen D. Fretwell, H. L. Lucas
This study provides a valid example of how the problem can be approached and offers a first step in the eventual identification of the role of territorial behavior in the habitat distribution of a common species.
ScienceResource Partitioning in Ecological Communities
4,088 Citations1974Thomas W. Schoener
To conclude with a list of questions appropriate for studies of resource partitioning, questions this article has related to the theory in a preliminary way.
Journal of Educational StatisticsObserving Interaction: An Introduction to Sequential Analysis
2,312 Citations1988Victor L. Willson, Roger Bakeman +1 more
Journal of Animal EcologyHabitat, the Templet for Ecological Strategies?
2,268 Citations1977T. R. E. Southwood
In this Address, the author will attempt some quantification, but will not be able to emulate those former Presidents who have been able to provide a definitative synthesis of a field or of their own studies, and his offering can be but a small beginning, an indication of the type of characteristics the authors should quantify.
OikosMultiple Scales of Patchiness and Patch Structure: A Hierarchical Framework for the Study of Heterogeneity
1,188 Citations1990Natasha B. Kotliar, John A. Wiens
A hierarchical model of heterogeneity that provides a framework for classifying patch structure across a range of scales and has wider applications as in the study of habitat selection, population dynamics, and habitat fragmentation is developed.
OikosEcological Mechanisms and Landscape Ecology
1,089 Citations1993John A. Wiens, Nils Chr. Stenseth +2 more
This work presents an approach to research that focuses on how individual-level mechanisms operating in a heterogeneous mosaic produce ecological patterns that are spatially dependent.
EcologyA Theory of Habitat Selection
1,077 Citations1981Michael L. Rosenzweig
It is shown that at the equilibrium point of this coexistence, there may be no overt competition remaining, and a modified definition of interspecific competition is suggested.
Annual Review of Ecology and SystematicsPopulation Responses to Patchy Environments
1,052 Citations1976John A. Wiens
An environmental patchwork which exerts powerful influences on the distri butions of organisms, their interactions, and their adaptations is considered.
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesDisturbance, Patch Formation, and Community Structure
996 Citations1974Simon A. Levin, Robert T. Paine
A model is developed to relate community structure to level of environmental disturbance in systems in which the effects of disturbance are localized in space and time, and allows one to relate overall system pattern to the local biology within these areas.
Ecological MonographsHabitat Associations and Community Structure of Birds in Shrubsteppe Environments
537 Citations1981John A. Wiens, John T. Rotenberry
The relations between bird distribution and abundance and habitat characteristics at a regional scale of investigation, using surveys conducted over three consecutive years on 14 plots at nine locations in the shrubsteppe of the northwestern Great Basin of North America, suggest that bird populations in this system vary largely independently of one another.
BioScienceHabitat Selection in Birds: The Roles of Vegetation Structure, Competitors, and Productivity
386 Citations1981Martin L. Cody
The 18th century Gilbert White discovered that there are three sibling species of Phylloscopus warblers in England; he used differences in their breeding habitats as well as Differences in their songs to distinguish them.
OikosHabitat Occupancy Patterns of North American Shrubsteppe Birds: The Effects of Spatial Scale
367 Citations1987John A. Wiens, John T. Rotenberry +1 more
Several factors that complicate bird-habitat analyses at different spatial scales are explored, and it is concluded that these problems of scale are most likely to be circumvented by conducting studies at several hierarchically nested scales arranged on clearly defined environmental gradients over a reasonably long period of time.
Ornithological ApplicationsHabitat Selection in Birds
336 Citations1987Nathaniel T. Wheelwright, Martin L. Cody
This work presents a variety of Approaches to Habitat Selection in Birds and concludes with a call for further investigation into the role of enrichment in the selection process.
Zeitschrift für TierpsychologieThe Pooling Fallacy: Problems Arising when Individuals Contribute More than One Observation to the Data Set
331 Citations1985Lee E. Machlis, Peter W. D. Dodd +1 more
OecologiaMaximizing feeding efficiency and minimizing time exposed to predators: a trade-off in the black-capped chickadee
318 Citations1985Steven L. Lima
Free-ranging chickadees foraging at an artificial patch at various distances from cover can distinguish between these two foraging situations, and their behavior in the conflict situation indicates that they are tradingoff foraging considerations against the risk of predation.
Evolutionary EcologyProcesses organizing open-nesting bird assemblages: competition or nest predation?
308 Citations1988Thomas E. Martin
A series of predicted patterns are established to test whether predation is operating to influence partitioning of space and coexistence of species, to distinguish effects of nestpredation from competition, and to determine the mechanism by which nest predation acts to organize assemblages.
EcologyThermal Effects of Radiation and Wind on a Small Bird and Implications for Microsite Selection
207 Citations1996Blair O. Wolf, Glenn E. Walsberg
Analysis of the effects of solar radiation, wind speed, and their interaction on metabolic rates in the Verdin, Auriparus flaviceps shows the potential importance of daytime microclimate selection to balancing water and energy budgets in small birds.
EcologyThe Use of Space by Wintering Sparrows
164 Citations1977H. Ronald Pulliam, Gus Mills
Differences in microhabitat utilization by sparrows wintering in southeastern Arizona, USA may be sufficient to explain their coexistence.
OecologiaDiet niche relationships among North American grassland and shrubsteppe birds
156 Citations1979John A. Wiens, John T. Rotenberry
The findings seem generally most consistent with the suggestion that food is not normally limiting to bird populations in these systems, and individuals and populations are exploiting the food resources in an opportunistic fashion, which leads to considerable individual, between-year, and between-location variation in diet compositions and interspecific overlaps.
EcologyA Lesson in the Limitations of Field Experiments: Shrubsteppe Birds and Habitat Alteration
156 Citations1986John A. Wiens, John T. Rotenberry +1 more
This experimental manipulation of habitat composition and structure within territories of birds breed- ing in the Artemisia-dominated shrubsteppe of central Oregon is complicated by influences of time lags on individual and pop- ulation responses that may stem from site tenacity by breeding adults, leading them to return to previous breeding locations in years following the manipulation despite the habitat changes.
Journal of Arid EnvironmentsFirst approximation of the effects of rainfall on the ecology and energetics of a Namib Desert dune ecosystem
153 Citations1980Mary Seely, G. N. Louw
A Brief History of Optimal Foraging Ecology
140 Citations1987Thomas W. Schoener
Optimal foraging ecology began in 1966 with the back-to-back publication in American Naturalist of two papers, one by MacArthur and Pianka, the other by Emlen, and the temporal coincidence of the two papers suggests that the ecological world was as ready to receive this proposal as to invent it.
Ecological MonographsDietary Relationships among Shrubsteppe Passerine Birds: Competition or Opportunism in a Variable Environment
139 Citations1980John T. Rotenberry
Several aspects of this study indicate that shrubsteppe passerines are largely opportunistic in their foraging and diet selection, and that the apparent absence of fine tuning to their competitive milieu is most likely a function of the variable environment in which they coexist.
Canadian Journal of ZoologyOvenbird (Aves: Parulidae) hunting behavior in a patchy environment: an experimental study
126 Citations1976Reto Zach, J. Bruce Falls
Since less search path was required per prey found in denser patches, the search effort was concentrated in areas of high profitability and the birds took a higher percentage of prey available in these patches.
EcologyWeather and Reproductive Variation in Shrubsteppe Sparrows: A Hierarchical Analysis
123 Citations1991John T. Rotenberry, John A. Wiens
The observed patterns suggested that clutch—size variation in Brewer's Sparrows may represent adaptive flexibility, the ability to assess potentially favorable environmental conditions and adjust reproductive investment accordingly.
EcologyPlant Demographic Studies in Sagebrush‐Grass Communities of Southeastern Idaho
114 Citations1979Neil E. West, Kenneth Rea +1 more
The overall survivorship curves for most species closely fit a log-log regression for the 1st 11 yr of life, indicating that the chance of survival improved with age, up to the physiological maxi- mum.
Ornithological ApplicationsReproductive Biology of Shrubsteppe Passerine Birds: Geographical and Temporal Variation in Clutch Size, Brood Size, and Fledging Success
111 Citations1989John T. Rotenberry, John A. Wiens
The relationship between avian reproductive success and precipitation in arid regions is more complex than the traditional view of desert birds responding directly to increased primary and secondary productivity; such relationships are indirectly influenced by the effects of rainfall on predator populations, and are further complicated by time lags in predator response.
Ornithological ApplicationsInfluence of Sample Size and Sampling Design on Analysis of Avian Foraging Behavior
108 Citations1984Michael L. Morrison
Analyse de l'influence du plan d'echantillonnage and of the taille of l'echanillon sur les resultats du comportement d'approvisionnement chez Dendroica occidentalis and D. nigrescens.
OecologiaTemporal variation in habitat structure and shrubsteppe bird dynamics
97 Citations1980John T. Rotenberry, John A. Wiens
Journal of Applied EcologyResponse of Breeding Passerine Birds to Rangeland Alteration in a North American Shrubsteppe Locality
97 Citations1985J. A. Wiens, John T. Rotenberry
The failure of such bird populations to respond rapidly to major habitat changes may relate to time lags produced by site tenacity of breeding individuals, and attempts to formulate management policies on the basis of short-term before and after surveys are complicated.
Ecological MonographsArthropod Dynamics on Sagebrush (Artemisia Tridentata): Effects of Plant Chemistry and Avian Predation
77 Citations1991John A. Wiens, Rex G. Cates +4 more
It is suggested that the shrubs responded to the removal of herbivorous, leaf-chewing arthropods by altering chemical allocation patterns; the changes in chemistry persisted for over a year because recolonization of the defaunated plants by these herbivores was slow.
Journal of Wildlife ManagementEffects of Two Sagebrush Control Methods on Nongame Birds
58 Citations1982John S. Castrale
Determination of breeding-bird densities 3-4 years after sagebrush control in central Utah revealed varied responses by bird species, with Brewer's sparrow territories contained 50-86% fewer than the chained and 17-year-old plowed sites.
Journal of Arid EnvironmentsPest outbreaks and rainfall in the semi-arid region of Chile
55 Citations1985Eduardo R. Fuentes, Claudio Moscoso Campusano
EcologyEffects of Needle Architecture on Warbler Habitat Selection in a Coastal Spruce Forest
54 Citations1995Jeffrey Parrish
The relationships found in this study between individual habitat selection and fine-scale features of habitat structure are consistent with the larger-scale patterns of habitat occupancy seen in this system, and have important implications in understanding habitat requirements for declining forest passerine populations.
The AukTerritory Size Variations in Shrubsteppe Birds
53 Citations1985John A. Wiens, John T. Rotenberry +1 more
Analysis of territory size and its variations in two common species of shrubsteppe birds and its relationship to population densities and features of breeding habitats casts doubt on the meaning or value of "average" territory-size measures for a species as a whole.
Ornithological ApplicationsNest-Site Selection by Sage Sparrows
40 Citations1985Kenneth L. Petersen, Louis B. Best
Nest-site selection by Sage Sparrows (Amphispiza belli) in a sagebrush community in Idaho is studied to provide a more complete description of nest-site characteristics of this species and to identify nest- site preferences.
Ornithological ApplicationsRegional Correspondence among Shrubsteppe Bird Habitats
36 Citations1990Fritz L. Knopf, James A. Sedgwick +1 more
Habitats of Brewer’s Sparrows and Green-tailed Towhees were compared in Colorado, Nevada, and Utah to identify regional commonalities in vegetation species, structure, and vigor among habitats of shrubsteppe passerines, suggesting an hierarchical approach for viewing habitat selection by shrubssteppe birds.
Digital Commons - University of South Florida (University of South Florida)Nest Placement in Sage Thrashers, Sage Sparrows and Brewer's Sparrows
34 Citations1980Terrell D. Rich
Preliminary information is presented on nest placement in the Sage Thrasher, Sage Sparrow and Brewer's Sparrow, all of which are reported to require sagebrush habitat for successful breeding.
OecologiaTemporal and spatial variations in the behavior of shrubsteppe birds
33 Citations1987J. A. Wiens, Beatrice Van Horne +1 more
Journal of Range ManagementThe Effect on the Brewer's Sparrow of Spraying Big Sagebrush
33 Citations1975Max Schroeder, David L. Sturges
Ornithological ApplicationsScales of Habitat Selection by Foraging 'Elepaio in Undisturbed and Human-Altered Forests in Hawaii
30 Citations1993Eric A. VanderWerf
Behavioral Ecology and SociobiologyTerritory dynamics in a sage sparrow population: are shifts in site use adaptive?
26 Citations1987Kenneth L. Petersen, Louis B. Best
The magnitude of territory shifts was negatively correlated with preshift fledging success, and after shifts, males experienced greater average reproductive success than before, and successive territory shifts by individual males became progressively smaller.
Annual variation in foraging ecology of prothonotary warblers during the breeding season
23 Citations1990Lisa J. Petit, Daniel R. Petit +2 more
Based on nearly 3,000 foraging maneuvers, most variables showed significant interyear variation during the four prenestling and three nestling periods the authors studied, which may not provide an accurate concept of the foraging ecology in insectivorous birds.
OecologiaBioenergetics and diet in a simple community of shrubsteppe birds
22 Citations1980John T. Rotenberry
The bioenergetic estimates imply that these birds are unlikely to be important in ecosystem processes and, reciprocally, are likely to be limited by food resources even during peak energy demands, and suggest that biological interactions such as competition play a relatively minor role in structuring the bird community in this variable environment.
Digital Commons - University of South Florida (University of South Florida)Selection of Song Perches by Sagebrush-grassland Birds
13 Citations1983John S. Castrale
EcologyHabitat Distributions of Wintering Sparrows: Foraging Success in a Transplant Experiment
8 Citations1996Richard R. Repasky, Dolph Schluter
It is concluded that immediate foraging gains do not explain habitat distributions of these birds, and that interference competition, predation, or other unknown factors are responsible.
Ornithological ApplicationsComparisons of the Behavior of Sage and Brewer's Sparrows in Shrubsteppe Habitats
5 Citations1990John A. Wiens, Beatrice Van Horne +1 more
This comparison of Sage Sparrows and Brewer's Sparrows using observations gathered over several years on two plots at a single location shows how they do or do not differ in their behavior and habitat use.
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)Territorial Behavior of the Sage Sparrow: Spatial and Random Aspects
3 Citations1980Rich, Terrell