Information Gathering and Integration as Sources of Error in Diagnostic Decision Making
Medical Decision MakingPublished 1 December 1991
Larry D. Gruppen, Fredric M. Wolf, John E. Billi
Citations57
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.48
SNIP1.35
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Physicians appear to have difficulties recognizing the diagnosticity of information, which often results in decisions that are pseudodiagnostic or based on diagnostically worthless information.
Abstract
This research examined the relative importance of information gathering versus information utilization in accounting for errors in diagnostic decision making. Two experiments compared physicians' performances under two conditions: one in which they gathered a limited amount of diagnostic information and then integrated it before making a decision, and the other in which they were given all the diagnostic information and needed only to integrate it. The physicians: 1) frequently failed to select normatively optimal information in both experimental conditions; 2) were more confident about the correctness of their information selection when their task was limited to information integration than when it also included information gathering; and 3) made diagnoses in substantial agreement with those indicated by applying normative procedures to the same data. Physicians appear to have difficulties recognizing the diagnosticity of information, which often results in decisions that are pseudodiagnostic or based on diagnostically worthless information.
Keywords
Decision SciencesMedicine
ScienceThe Framing of Decisions and the Psychology of Choice
17,311 Citations1981Amos Tversky, Daniel Kahneman
The psychological principles that govern the perception of decision problems and the evaluation of probabilities and outcomes produce predictable shifts of preference when the same problem is framed in different ways.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Threshold Approach to Clinical Decision Making
1,319 Citations1980Stephen G. Pauker, Jerome P. Kassirer
Using the concepts of decision analysis, expressions for two threshold probabilities involved in the choice of whether to withhold treatment, obtain more data by testing, or treat without subjecting the patient to the risks of further diagnostic tests are derived.
New England Journal of MedicineInterpretation by Physicians of Clinical Laboratory Results
740 Citations1978Ward Casscells, Arno Schoenberger +1 more
A small survey was conducted to obtain some idea of how physicians do, in fact, interpret a laboratory result, and asked if a test to detect a disease whose prevalence is 1/1000 has a false positive rate of .
Cognitive ScienceKnowledge Based Solution Strategies in Medical Reasoning
429 Citations1986Vimla L. Patel, Guy J. Groen
The techniques of propositionol analysis are used to examine the protocols of seven cardiologists in a task involving the diagnosis of a case of acute bacterial endocarditis and an explanation of its underlying pathophysiology.
Organizational Behavior and Human Decision ProcessesTwo methods of reducing overconfidence
277 Citations1987Hal R. Arkes, Caryn Christensen +2 more
Journal of the American Statistical AssociationCognitive Processes and the Assessment of Subjective Probability Distributions
268 Citations1975Robin M. Hogarth
It is argued that since man is a selective, sequential information processing system with limited capacity, he is ill-suited for assessing probability distributions, and the importance of task characteristics on judgmental performance is also emphasized.
Organizational Behavior and Human PerformanceExperience and the base-rate fallacy
239 Citations1982Jay Christensen-Szalanski, Lee Roy Beach
It is shown that decision makers can use the base rate to assess posterior probabilities when they have experienced the relationship between the base Rate and the diagnostic information, but when they experience only the base rates, they do not use it.
Journal of General Internal MedicineSystematic errors in medical decision making:
212 Citations1987Neal V. Dawson, Hal R. Arkes
Five factors that can detract from accurate probability estimation and three that impair accurate information synthesis are discussed, and ways to minimize the negative influences of these factors are suggested.
Organizational Behavior and Human Decision ProcessesHeuristics and biases in diagnostic reasoning
124 Citations1988Jonathan Baron, Jane Beattie +1 more
Academic MedicinePremature conclusions in diagnostic reasoning
119 Citations1985Anthony E. Voytovich, Robert M. Rippey +1 more
When the subjects were asked to construct complete, precise problem lists from three case abstracts, premature closure occurred frequently, it could be recognized with good interrater reliability, and it seemed to appear with equal frequency regardless of the level of training.
JAMADifferential Diagnosis and the Competing-Hypotheses Heuristic
80 Citations1985Fredric M. Wolf
The competing-hypotheses heuristic is discussed within the context of diagnostic problem-solving models derived from the literature on medical decision making and clinicopathological conference case records and suggested that the heuristic may be useful as a complement to clinical judgment.
JAMAPhysician Tolerance for Uncertainty
44 Citations1985Richard M. Allman
Greater attention to decision thresholds may improve physicians' understanding of their tolerance for diagnostic uncertainty and the ability of diagnostic tests to reduce it.
Organizational Behavior and Human Decision ProcessesHeuristics and biases in diagnostic reasoning: I. Priors, error costs, and test accuracy
35 Citations1988Jonathan Baron, John C. Hershey
The overweighing of costs seems to result from the use of a heuristic in which the subject tends to minimize the probability of the worst kind of error, regardless of Other parameters.
Medical Decision MakingPhysicians' Misunderstanding of Normal Findings
29 Citations1983Jay Christensen-Szalanski, James B. Bushyhead
This extension of the principle of the normal finding to include signs and symptoms proved to be clinically valuable for the present population of patients with acute cough, because the identified normal findings provided significant information predictive of radiographic pneumonia and unrelated to that provided by the abnormal findings.
Academic MedicineUse of the competing-hypotheses heuristic to reduce ‘pseudodiagnosticity’
21 Citations1988F M Wolf, Larry D. Gruppen +1 more
The results suggest that some problem-solving skills, such as learning to use the competing-hypotheses heuristic, can be enhanced or learned independent of the acquisition of content knowledge.
Journal of Applied Social PsychologyProbability Distortions and Outcome Desirability: Experimental Verification of Medical Folklore<sup>1</sup>
2 Citations1984Russell Jones, Patricia H. Howard +1 more