Action Anticipation Through Attribution of False Belief by 2-Year-Olds
Psychological SciencePublished 1 July 2007
Victoria Southgate, Atsushi Senju, Gergely Csibra
Citations1,071
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score2.50
SNIP2.29
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The data demonstrate that 25-month-old infants correctly anticipate an actor's actions when these actions can be predicted only by attributing a false belief to the actor.
Abstract
Two-year-olds engage in many behaviors that ostensibly require the attribution of mental states to other individuals. Yet the overwhelming consensus has been that children of this age are unable to attribute false beliefs. In the current study, we used an eyetracker to record infants' looking behavior while they watched actions on a computer monitor. Our data demonstrate that 25-month-old infants correctly anticipate an actor's actions when these actions can be predicted only by attributing a false belief to the actor.
Keywords
PsychologyNeuroscience
CognitionDoes the autistic child have a “theory of mind” ?
8,438 Citations1985Simon Baron‐Cohen, Alan M. Leslie +1 more
A new model of metarepresentational development is used to predict a cognitive deficit which could explain a crucial component of the social impairment in childhood autism.
CognitionBeliefs about beliefs: Representation and constraining function of wrong beliefs in young children's understanding of deception
6,320 Citations1983Heinz Wimmer
A travelling salesman found himself spending the night at home with his wife when one of his trips was unexpectedly cancelled, and he leapt out from the bed, ran across the room and jumped out the window.
Child DevelopmentMeta-Analysis of Theory-of-Mind Development: The Truth about False Belief
4,465 Citations2001Henry M. Wellman, David Cross +1 more
A meta-analysis found that when organized into a systematic set of factors that vary across studies, false-belief results cluster systematically with the exception of only a few outliers, and is consistent with theoretical accounts that propose that understanding of belief, and, relatedly, understanding of mind, exhibit genuine conceptual change in the preschool years.
ScienceDo 15-Month-Old Infants Understand False Beliefs?
2,355 Citations2005Kristine H. Onishi, Renée Baillargeon
A novel nonverbal task is used to examine 15-month-old infants' ability to predict an actor's behavior on the basis of her true or false belief about a toy's hiding place, supporting the view that, from a young age, children appeal to mental states—goals, perceptions, and beliefs—to explain the behavior of others.
Developmental PsychologyUnderstanding the intentions of others: Re-enactment of intended acts by 18-month-old children.
2,025 Citations1995Andrew N. Meltzoff
Eighteen-month-olds situate people within a psychological framework that differentiates between the surface behavior of people and a deeper level involving goals and intentions and showed that children could infer the adult's intended act by watching the failed attempts.
The MIT Press eBooksThe Child's Theory of Mind
1,781 Citations1990Henry M. Wellman, Susan Carey +3 more
CognitionThe relationship between cognition and action: performance of children 312–7 years old on a stroop- like day-night test
1,546 Citations1994Cherie L. Gerstadt, Yoon Joo Hong +1 more
It is concluded that the requirement to learn and remember two rules is not in itself sufficient to account for the poor performance of the younger children in the experimental condition.
Mind & LanguageWhy the Child's Theory of Mind Really Is a Theory
1,127 Citations1992Alison Gopnik, Henry M. Wellman
ManNatural Theories of Mind: Evolution, Development and Simulation of Everyday Mindreading.
1,093 Citations1992Andrew Lock, Andrew Whiten
(from the chapter) in the initial survey of tactical deception in primates (Whiten and Byrne, 1988a), the implications for primate psychology of obtaining good evidence which implied an understanding of others' intentions by the animal were emphasized.
CognitionObject permanence in five-month-old infants
964 Citations1985Renée Baillargeon, Elizabeth S. Spelke +1 more
The results of these experiments indicate that, contrary to Piaget's (1954) claims, infants as young as 5 months of age understand that objects continue to exist when occluded and 5-month-old infants realize that solid objects do not move through the space occupied by other solid objects.
Psychological ScienceAttribution of Beliefs by 13-Month-Old Infants
817 Citations2007Luca Surian, Stefania Caldi +1 more
Cognitive DevelopmentImplicit understanding of belief
767 Citations1994Wendy A. Clements, Josef Perner
CognitionTwo reasons to abandon the false belief task as a test of theory of mind
736 Citations2000Paul Bloom, Tim P. German
An alternative conception of the role of the false belief task is presented and it is shown that theory of mind need not entail the ability to reason about false beliefs.
Annual Review of PsychologyUnderstanding Other Minds: Linking Developmental Psychology and Functional Neuroimaging
726 Citations2004Rebecca Saxe, Susan Carey +1 more
Neuroimaging reinforces and elaborates upon this view by providing evidence that domain-specific brain regions exist for representing belief contents, and these regions are apparently distinct from other regions engaged in reasoning about goals and actions.
Cognitive DevelopmentAn age-related dissociation between knowing rules and using them
725 Citations1996Philip David Zelazo, Douglas Frye +1 more
CognitionPretending and believing: issues in the theory of ToMM
721 Citations1994Alan M. Leslie
Two early attitude concepts, pretends and believes, are discussed in the light of some current findings.
Infant Behavior and DevelopmentFourteen- through 18-month-old infants differentially imitate intentional and accidental actions
720 Citations1998Malinda Carpenter, Nameera Akhtar +1 more
Infants before age 18 months thus may understand something about the intentions of other persons, which represents infants' first step toward adult-like social cognition and underlies their acquisition of language and other cultural skills.
Child DevelopmentIgnorance versus False Belief: A Developmental Lag in Attribution of Epistemic States
642 Citations1986G.-Juergen Hogrefe, Heinz Wimmer +1 more
Trends in Cognitive SciencesChimpanzee minds: suspiciously human?
531 Citations2003Daniel J. Povinelli, Jennifer Vonk
It is suggested that additional experiments will be unhelpful as long as they continue to rely upon determining whether subjects interpret behavioral invariances in terms of mental states, and a paradigm shift is proposed to overcome this limitation.
Child DevelopmentSmall-Scale Deceit: Deception as a Marker of Two-, Three-, and Four-Year-Olds' Early Theories of Mind
469 Citations1989Michael J. Chandler, Anna Fritz +1 more
Child DevelopmentSmall-Scale Deceit: Deception as a Marker of Two-, Three-, and Four-Year-Olds' Early Theories of Mind
448 Citations1989Michael J. Chandler, Anna Fritz +1 more
The results of this study show that even 2 1/2-year-olds are capable of already successfully employing a range of deceptive strategies that both trade upon an awareness of the possibility of false beliefs and presuppose some already operative theory of mind.
CognitionWhere to look first for children's knowledge of false beliefs
444 Citations1991Michael Siegal, Karen Beattie
In this investigation, even 3-year-olds often responded correctly when asked to predict the initial behavior of a story character with a false belief, and this results are discussed in terms of the conversational worlds of children and adults.
Child DevelopmentTwo-Year-Old Children's Sensitivity to a Parent's Knowledge State When Making Requests
440 Citations1996Daniela K. O’Neill
Infant Behavior and DevelopmentWho put the cog in infant cognition? Is rich interpretation too costly?
412 Citations1998Marshall M. Haith
Child DevelopmentThe Role of Inhibitory Processes in Young Children's Difficulties with Deception and False Belief
410 Citations1998Stephanie M. Carlson, Louis J. Moses +1 more
It is argued that children's performance on false belief tasks is also likely to be affected by inhibition deficits, and that the source of their difficulty on deceptive pointing tasks lies in a failure of inhibitory control.
CognitionChildren's early understanding of false belief
328 Citations1991Peter Mitchell, Hazel Lacohée
3-year-olds' understanding of the representational capability of the mind is investigated by examining whether they would acknowledge that they had entertained a wrong belief, and the posting task made it possible for children simultaneously to focus on physical reality and acknowledge false belief.
Cognitive PsychologyBelief-desire reasoning as a process of selection
321 Citations2004Alan M. Leslie, Tim P. German +1 more
Here, it is shown how toMM-SP can account both for competence and for successful and unsuccessful performance on a wide range of belief-desire tasks across the preschool period, and two processing models differ in the way that belief and desire inhibitory processes combine to achieve successful action prediction.
British Journal of Developmental PsychologyChildren's everyday deception and performance on false‐belief tasks
300 Citations2000Paul E. Newton, Vasudevi Reddy +1 more
Psychological ScienceChildren Are Cursed
230 Citations2003Susan Birch, Paul Bloom
It is found that young children exhibited a curse-of-knowledge bias to a greater extent than older children, a finding that is consistent with their greater difficulty with false-belief tasks and that children's misattributions were asymmetric.
Current Directions in Psychological ScienceRepresentation of Objects and Events
168 Citations2003Rachel Keen
Trends in Cognitive SciencesDevelopmental parallels in understanding minds and bodies
147 Citations2005Alan M. Leslie
Evidence that 15-month-old infants attribute false beliefs (FBs) to other people lends dramatic new support to the idea that mental state concepts ("theory of mind") emerge from a specialized neurocognitive mechanism that matures during the second year of life.
British Journal of Developmental PsychologyCompetence and performance in false belief understanding: A comparison of autistic and normal 3‐year‐old children
144 Citations1999Luca Surian, Alan M. Leslie
Trends in Cognitive SciencesDo infants really understand false belief?
140 Citations2005Ted Ruffman, Josef Perner
It is argued that current data can be explained equally well by means of an interaction between genetic endowment and the environment, and that exploration of this interaction should not be curtailed by a priori restrictions due to genetic over-specification.
Mind & LanguageDo Children Understand the Mind by Means of Simulation or a Theory? Evidence From Their Understanding of Inference
125 Citations1996Ted Ruffman
Developmental ScienceDoesn’t see, doesn’t know: is anticipatory looking really related to understanding or belief?
117 Citations2001Wendy Garnham, Ted Ruffman
Choice Reviews OnlineApes, monkeys, children, and the growth of mind
111 Citations2004
It is argued that primate minds are best understood not as fixed collections of specialized cognitive capacities, but more dynamically, as a range of abilities that can surpass their original adaptations.
Developmental PsychologyLooking and search measures of object knowledge in preschool children.
95 Citations2003Bruce Hood, Victoria Cole‐Davies +1 more
It is indicated that children visually discriminate violations of solidity but that this sensitivity is not associated with successful search performance, and an unexpected sex difference was found, with boys outperforming girls.
Infancy12-Month-Old Infants' Perception of Attention Direction in Static Video Images
79 Citations2005Claes von Hofsten, Emma H. Dahlström +1 more
Trends in Cognitive SciencesEvidence for infants' understanding of false beliefs should not be dismissed
35 Citations2005Gergely Csibra, Victoria Southgate
Three reasons are put forward why there is no need to explain Onishi and Baillargeon's recent findings with 15-month-olds in terms of attributing false beliefs (FB) and why they do not explain the infants' performance.
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseApes, Monkeys, Children, and the Growth of Mind
31 Citations2005John D. Newman