A preliminary investigation of balint and non-balint behavioral medicine training.

PubMedPublished 1 February 2004

Andrew L. Turner, Ronald L Malm

Citations95

TL;DR

Only Balint-trained residents showed gains in self-reported psychological medicine skills, abilities, and confidence beyond levels developed in year 1, when compared to standard behavioral medicine curriculum for first- and second-year family medicine residents.

Abstract

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Despite inclusion of Balint training in US family medicine residency programs, little research exists about the effectiveness of this training in improving residents' behavioral medicine skills. This study compared the outcomes for residents who did and did not undergo Balint training to increase residents' psychological medicine skills in two rural training programs. METHODS: Fourteen residents from two rural community-based training programs were assessed using the Psychological Medicine Inventory, following standard first-year behavioral medicine training. At one residency program, residents then participated in 9 months of Balint training during the second year of residency training, while at the other program they did not. Both groups were reassessed at the end of the second year of residency. RESULTS: Only Balint-trained residents showed gains in self-reported psychological medicine skills, abilities, and confidence beyond levels developed in year 1. CONCLUSIONS: Balint training enhances the levels of residents' self-reported psychological medicine skills, when compared to standard behavioral medicine curriculum for first- and second-year family medicine residents.

Keywords

MedicineHealth Professions

JAMAThe Patient-Physician Relationship

80 Citations1996Richard M. Glass

There is an intensification of the tension between the science and the art of medicine, and there are severe strains related to the rapid changes in the economics of medical practice.

JAMADoctors Have Feelings Too

73 Citations1988William M. Zinn

Self-awareness is the key to utilizing emotions in the clinician-patient relationship to improve the patient-physician relationship.

PubMedThe current status of Balint groups in US family practice residencies: A 10-year follow-up study, 1990-2000.

47 Citations2001Alan H. Johnson, Clive D. Brock +2 more

About half of US family practice residencies operate groups described as Balint groups, but they meet less frequently then 10 years ago and are less likely to have a physician involved in group leadership.

PubMedBalint work in England: lessons for American family medicine.

43 Citations1988L Scheingold

The work of Michael and Enid Balint in developing case discussion seminars for general practitioners in England has important implications for the teaching of family medicine in the United States.

PubMedThe Balint movement in America.

30 Citations2001Alan H. Johnson

The Balint Society, is presently working to standardize credentialing of Balint group leaders to assure continued quality growth in the American Balint movement.

PubMedBalint seminar leaders: what do they do?

22 Citations1999Joel H. Merenstein, Kata Chillag

Balint leaders and their groups in the program studied did not function as traditionally described by Balint, and these residency groups functioned partially as support groups, attempted to relieve or dampen anxiety, and had a hierarchical system with the leader as the teacher/controller.

PubMedReframing Balint: thoughts on family medicine departmental Balint groups.

14 Citations2003Howard F. Stein

The frequent group "deviation" from the central Balint task of understanding difficult physician-patient relationships is reframed as less "resistance" or "obstacle" to work, as it is an expression of unmet developmental needs and organizational realities.

PubMedBalint group observations: the white knight and other heroic physician roles.

12 Citations1999Clive D. Brock, Alan H. Johnson

A typology of five roles that resident family physicians on occasion assume when relating to troubling patients presented in Balint group seminars is reported, which intend to perform a heroic function in rescuing or protecting the patient, the family, or the physician from a distressing medical situation.