DEFINING AND REDEFINING WORK
Gender & SocietyPublished 1 June 1997
DeAnne K. Hilfinger Messias, Eun‐Ok Im, Aroha Evelyn Page, Hanna Regev, Judith A. Spiers, Laurie M. Yoder
Citations67
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score2.27
SNIP3.02
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
In this article the authors examine the ways in which the definition of work as paid employment has affected women's health research, the knowledge and understanding of the relationships between women's work and health, and health and social policies. The authors argue for research and public policy based on an expanded definition of women's work, a redefinition that goes beyond employment to reflect the multiple contexts and dimensions of women's work as well as the diversity and differences among women.
Keywords
Social SciencesHealth Professions
Work and motivation
9,064 Citations1964Victor H. Vroom
Medical Entomology and ZoologyThe Second Shift
2,454 Citations1989Arlie Russell Hochschild, Anne Machung
American Sociological ReviewA Theory of Role Strain
2,319 Citations1960William J. Goode
I believe, however, that the theory of action in its present state provides methods for successfully carrying out this specification, and conversely, generalization as well from lower-level uniformities to higher levels.
Industrial and Labor Relations ReviewFeeding the Family: The Social Organization of Caring as Gendered Work.
1,269 Citations1993Michelle Ciurea, Marjorie L. DeVault
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsParadoxes of Gender
1,169 Citations1995Eleanor M. Miller, Judith Lorber
Social ForcesEthnography Unbound: Power and Resistance in the Modern Metropolis.
919 Citations1992Joe R. Feagin, Michael Burawoy
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsHome and Work: Negotiating Boundaries through Everyday Life
656 Citations1998Patricia Voydanoff, Christena Nippert‐Eng
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsWoman, Culture, and Society.
508 Citations1976M. Kay Martin, Michelle Zimbalist Rosaldo +1 more
Nursing Administration QuarterlyAnnual Review of Nursing Research
505 Citations1997Joyce J. Fitzpatrick, Jane S. Norbeck
Volume 17 focuses on focus on complementary health and pain management and includes chapters by Mariah Snyder, Susan E. Auvil-Novak, Donna L. Algase, Beverly J. McElmurry, and Merle H. Mishel.
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyRole quality, multiple role involvement, and psychological well-being in midlife women.
465 Citations1986Grace K. Baruch, Rosalind C. Barnett
Maid in the USA
371 Citations2016Mary Romero
American PsychologistEmployment and women's health: Effects of paid employment on women's mental and physical health.
311 Citations1989Rena L. Repetti, Karen A. Matthews +1 more
It is concluded that women's employment does not have a negative effect on their health, on the average, and current evidence suggests that increased social support from co-workers and super- visors may be one important mediator of the beneficial health effects of employment.
Women & HealthSex Differentials in Health and Mortality
276 Citations1987Lois M. Verbrugge, Deborah L. Wingard +1 more
Possible explanations for these sex differentials are discussed, and the apparent contradiction--why there is excess female morbidity but excess male mortality--is considered.
Psychology of Women QuarterlyMaternity Leave And Women's Mental Health
253 Citations1995Janet Shibley Hyde, Marjorie H. Klein +2 more
In multiple regression analyses, length of leave interacted significantly with marital concerns when predicting depression; women who took a short leave and were high on marital concerns had the highest depression scores.
Choice Reviews OnlineDomesticity and dirt: housewives and domestic servants in the United States, 1920-1945
238 Citations1990Phyllis M. Palmer
Women & HealthRole Burdens and Physical Health of Women and Men
168 Citations1986Lois M. Verbrugge
Results show that dissatisfaction with roles/life and feelings of very great or very little time pressure are associated with poor health, and role burdens may lie more in subjective feelings about one's activities than in their objective characteristics.
International Journal of Health ServicesGender, Work Control, and Stress: A Theoretical Discussion and an Empirical Test
160 Citations1989Ellen M. Hall
The threats that single-sex studies pose to the valid assessment of the health effects of working life are discussed and the implications are discussed in terms of future directions in the psychosocial work environment field.
AnthropologicaWomen's Work: Development and the Division of Labor by Gender
155 Citations1988Christine Ward Gailey, Eleanor Leacock +1 more
PubMedThe relationship of women's postpartum mental health to employment, childbirth, and social support.
144 Citations1994Dwenda K. Gjerdingen, Kathryn Chaloner
In this select group of women, postpartum mental health was found to be least favorable 1 month after delivery and related to factors associated with employment, recent delivery, and level of social support.
Social Science & MedicineWomen's employment, marriage, motherhood and mortality: A test of the multiple role and role accumulation hypotheses
138 Citations1995Pekka Martikainen
It is concluded that neither of the hypotheses on multiple roles are very relevant for the analysis of female mortality and that more attention should be devoted to understanding the contribution of possible selection effects leading to marriage and motherhood and the contributions of the 'healthy worker effect' in creating low mortality for the employed.
Women & HealthWorker and Mother Roles, Spillover Effects, and Psychological Distress
135 Citations1992Rosalind C. Barnett, Nancy L. Marshall
Mechanisms by which employed mothers reap a mental-health advantage from multiple roles, even when some of those roles are stressful, are suggested.
Sociology of Health & IllnessDomestic conditions, paid employment and women's experience of ill‐health
135 Citations1992Mel Hartley, Jennie Popay +1 more
The findings suggest that the association between paid work and better health is rather less apparent for physical than psychological health, and in women working full time in professional or managerial occupations, and the role of health related selection into different social roles is questioned.
Social ProblemsRegulating the Unregulated?: Domestic Workers' Social Networks
130 Citations1994Pierrette Hondagneu‐Sotelo
Choice Reviews OnlineWomen's paid and unpaid labor: the work transfer in health care and retailing
103 Citations1994
Gender & SocietyTHE HOME AS WORKSHOP:
84 Citations1990Nona Glazer
Women's unpaid work knits together “public” and “private,” demonstrating how capitalism reorganizes the labor process to make use of free service labor.
Women & HealthShe Ate Not the Bread of Idleness
78 Citations1990Daniel Tierney, Patrizia Romito +1 more
The first North American study to show the combined effects of domestic work and paid work on physical health symptoms among women and among couples with children is shown.
Journal of Occupational and Environmental MedicineWomen at Work:Agriculture and Pesticides
74 Citations1994Helen H. McDuffie
Cancer risks related to agriculture, agricultural practices, and agricultural exposures have been conducted among male farmers and farmworkers and agents that contribute to ill health in exposed men may also affect exposed women.
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorWomen's Health Research: Public Policy and Sociology
74 Citations1995Judith D. Auerbach, Anne E. Figert
This work encourages sociologists to participate more directly in the policy debates and advance both science and practice in women's health--by ensuring the inclusion of the sociological perspective.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyBrazilian Women Speak: Contemporary Life Stories
74 Citations1988Daphne Patai
Reframing Women's Health: Multidisciplinary Research and Practice
55 Citations1994Alice J. Dan
The Groundwork for Specialization in Women's Health, a Progressive Feminist Agenda Institutionalizing Women's Oppression, and the Politics of Research and Intervention Towards a Feminist Methodology in Research on Battered Women are discussed.
Women & HealthEmployment Status, Employment Characteristics, and Women's Health
51 Citations1985Judith H. Hibbard, Clyde R. Pope
The findings suggest that the social support and integration gained through work is a salient aspect of employment which contributes to health status differences between employed women and those not participating in the labor force.
Women & HealthTheoretical Underpinnings for Women's Health
50 Citations1982Angela Barron McBride, William L. McBride
A theoretical framework for considerations of women's health is proposed, the central premise of which is that "women's health" at the core means taking women's lived experience as the starting point for all health efforts.
Research in Nursing & HealthRole integration and health among female clerical workers
48 Citations1989Afaf Ibrahim Meleis, Jane S. Norbeck +1 more
The effects of role identity (occupancy and involvement), sex-role orientation, and role integration on perceived health status and psychological symptoms of women in multiple roles were examined.
Women & HealthA Causal Analysis of Employment and Health in Midlife Women
42 Citations1990Pamela K. Adelmann, Toni C. Antonucci +2 more
A model hypothesizing a nonrecursive (reciprocal) causal relationship between employment (hours employed) and health was presented and supported the hypothesis that employment and health have a positive reciprocal relationship for women at midlife.
Image the Journal of Nursing ScholarshipLeave and Employment in Families of Preterm Low Birthweight Infants
40 Citations1996Susan Gennaro
Study findings support the need for longer leave for mothers who have small infants and having a low birthweight infant results in unexpected changes in employment and in increased and unexpected out-of-pocket expenses.
The Forms of Women’s Work
40 Citations1991Robert L. Kahn
Women & HealthHealth and Health Care of Employed Women and Homemakers
40 Citations1986Charlotte Müller
Comparisons of employed women with homemakers using multiple regression analysis and also on direct comparisons of the three work-sex groups suggest that better health is associated with desired, positive roles such as marriage and married parenthood and worse health isassociated with unwelcome role expansions such as single parenthood.
Women & HealthWomen's Roles and Health
39 Citations1995Susan Bullers
Logistic regression techniques are used on data from the 1987 General Social Survey to explore the effects of roles and role quality on women's health, as well as the mediating effects of perceived control in the relationship between role factors and health.
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsAmerica's Working Women: A Documentary History, 1600 to the Present.
39 Citations1978Roslyn L. Feldberg, Rosalyn Baxandall +2 more
Women & HealthJob Stress, Psychosocial Strain, and Physical Health Problems in Women Employed Full-Time Outside the Home and Homemakers
38 Citations1992B. Kent Houston, D. Cates +1 more
Social support from supervisors and coworkers were found to moderate some of the relations between job stress and measures of psychosocial strain, however, social support for homemakers evidenced no moderating effects for relations involving job stress.
International Journal of Nursing StudiesThe work of auxiliary nurses in Mexico: stressors, satisfiers and coping strategies
35 Citations1996Marilyn K. Douglas, Afaf Ibrahim Meleis +2 more
A convenience sample of 59 Mexican nursing assistants and technical nurses, categorized as auxiliary nurses, were asked to complete a questionnaire designed to elicit their perceived work-related stresses and satisfactions, as well as the coping strategies they utilized to diminish work-associated stress.
Women & HealthWomen in Clerical Jobs: Spousal Role Satisfaction, Stress, and Coping
33 Citations1992Afaf Ibrahim Meleis, Patricia E. Stevens
The data about spousal role satisfactions, stress and coping strategies, as perceived and articulated by women in clerical jobs indicates there are almost an equal number of satisfying and stressful aspects of theSpousal relationship.
Journal of Occupational and Environmental MedicineUtility of a Surveillance System to Detect Associations Between Work and Cancer Among Women in Canada, 1965-1991
32 Citations1994Kristan J. Aronson, Geoffrey R. Howe
Data on the occupation and industry in which 242,196 females worked in Canada between 1965 and 1971 are available from a national survey of employers by Statistics Canada, providing up to 25 years of follow-up and over 8,500 cancer deaths anticipated among females.
Health Care For Women InternationalStress, satisfaction, and coping: A study of women clerical workers
31 Citations1989Afaf Ibrahim Meleis, Jane S. Norbeck +3 more
The quality of the work role as perceived by women who hold clerical jobs is examined, with a focus on mothers with one or more children living at home.
Women, Work, and Menopause
30 Citations1991Philip M. Sarrel
Health Care For Women InternationalRole overload and health: The married mother in the waged labor force
30 Citations1994Noreen C. Facione
Research studies paint colorful images of today's working, married mother but have only begun to identify risks to women's health that might be associated with the increased demands associated with multiple roles.
Journal of women's healthWomen's Lives and Women's Health: Using Social Science Research to Promote Better Health for Women
29 Citations1992Joanne Leslie
The policy discussion emphasizes the potential benefits of integrated services for women and the implications of this combined approach for several health programming areas including breastfeeding promotion, screening and treatment of sexually transmitted diseases, and reduction of domestic violence against women.
Research in Nursing & HealthDeveloping the construct of role integration: A narrative analysis of women clerical workers' daily lives
27 Citations1992Joanne M. Hall, Patricia E. Stevens +1 more
A theoretical framework was derived to identify and relate aspects, processes, and patterns of role integration as they are experienced in women's everyday lives in a triangulated study of work, maternal, and spousal role experiences of 87 women clerical workers.
International Journal of Health ServicesWork and Health in Mothers of Young Children
26 Citations1994Patrizia Romito
The aim of this article is to review and discuss some of the findings on this subject, in order to understand whether paid and unpaid work are associated with mothers' health.
Health Care For Women InternationalWork and family roles of women: Sources of stress and coping strategies
22 Citations1987Marcia Killien, Marie Annette Brown
PubMedWomen's employment and the Social Security system.
21 Citations1993Marianne A. Ferber
The changes in women's roles in the home and in the labor market are examined, then possible reforms in the Social Security system are considered that might help it to better meet the requirements of this profoundly altered society.
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsGender and Development in the Arab World--Women's Economic Participation: Patterns and Policies.
20 Citations1997Sally K. Gallagher, Nabil F. Khoury +1 more
American Journal of Occupational TherapyA Woman’s Place: Unpaid Work in the Home
20 Citations1992Loree A. Primeau
Feminist analysis of household work may sensitize occupational therapists to the complex interactions of these meanings and lead them to the realization that women's responsibility for unpaid work in the home may have repercussions in the daily lives of both women and men.
Gender & Society“I NEVER DID ANY FIELD WORK, BUT I MILKED AN AWFUL LOT OF COWS!”
19 Citations1995MAREENA McKINLEY WRIGHT
PubMedWomen's paid/unpaid work and health: exploring the social context of everyday life.
18 Citations1994Jan Angus
It is suggested here that an "ideology of separate spheres" operates in the designation of paid activity in the public sphere as work, whereas activities pursued in the private sphere of the home are overlooked.
Advances in Nursing ScienceVeiled, voluminous, and devalued
16 Citations1994Afaf Ibrahim Meleis, Eloíta Neves Arruda +2 more
The lived experiences of three women from Brazil, Egypt, and Colombia who are in low-income, devalued, but important jobs are presented through their voices and highlight nursing's mission in dealing with the marginalized client as a human being whose context is historical and sociocultural.
Women & HealthThe Health of Women in Paid Employment
16 Citations1993Jacquie Aston, J. John Lavery
Findings with regard to the beneficial effects of social support in the workplace were not specific, however a cynical attitude can influence the value of the work role, with effects being particularly marked in the clerical group.
Western Journal of Nursing ResearchThe United States Women's Health Research Agenda Analysis and Critique
16 Citations1994Nancy Fúgate Woods
The process used to develop a United States women's health research agenda and the published critiques of that agenda are described.
International Journal of Intercultural RelationsRural women in development: Veil of invisibility, world of work
15 Citations1979Rae Lesser Blumberg
Journal of American HistoryThe Servant Problem: Domestic Workers in North America
14 Citations1985Susan Strasser, Linda Martin +1 more
PubMedWomen and work in rural Taiwan: building a contextual model linking employment and health.
13 Citations1989Rita S. Gallin
Work and OccupationsThe Horizontal Distribution of Female Managers within Organizations
13 Citations1994Dana L. Stover
ACCESS OF FEMALE PLANTATION WORKERS IN SRI LANKA TO BASIC-NEEDS PROVISION
12 Citations2002Vidyamali Samarasinghe
PubMedSex, gender, biology, and work.
12 Citations1994D Headapohl
This chapter explores the biologic differences between men and women and how these differences may affect job capacity and compatibility and the controversy over gender roles and resulting occupational segregation and pay disparity.
Women & HealthVoices of Impoverished Brazilian Women
11 Citations1996DeAnne K. Hilfinger Messias, Joanne M. Hall +1 more
Women's unrelenting work in the face of harsh social and economic environments was a broad theme woven throughout the women's descriptions of their lives, and the confluence of role constraints affecting participants' lives included poverty, marginalization, abuse, and lack of support and recognition by partners and society.
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION AND WOMEN’S TIME BUDGETS IN UGANDA
10 Citations2002Victoria M. Mwaka
PubMedTreatment of women in the U.S. Social Security system, 1970-88.
9 Citations1993Jane L. Ross, Melinda M. Upp
It is argued that apparently insoluble, inherent conflicts among the objectives underlying earnings sharing ultimately doomed its enactment and cost considerations, the realization of unintended side effects, and issues relating to transition to a very different Social Security system also helped remove earnings sharing from the legislative agenda.
Women & HealthSelf Care Actions of Colombian Por Dia Domes tic Workers
8 Citations1995Pilar Bernal, Afaf Ibrahim Meleis
Research in Nursing & HealthWomen's work environment and health: Clerical workers in Brazil
8 Citations1996Afaf Ibrahim Meleis, DeAnne K. Hilfinger Messias +1 more
As part of an international study, 60 female Brazilian clerical workers responded to a self-administered questionnaire describing what they liked, disliked, and found stressful about the structural, physical, and social aspects of their work environment.
Journal of women's healthWomen's Health Scholarship: From Critique to Assertion
7 Citations1993Angela Barron McBride, William L. McBride
The movement in women's health scholarship is described as moving away from a mere critique of patriarchal practices to a forward-looking statement of new ideas.
WOMEN AND AGRICULTURE IN WESTERN SAMOA
7 Citations2002Peggy Fairbairn‐Dunlop
BirthRedefining Women's Work During Pregnancy: Toward a More Comprehensive Approach
7 Citations1993Jeanne F. Deloseph
This commentary expands the description of women's work during pregnancy, and proposes the addition of some activities not currently considered in most prenatal assessments, including home care responsibilities, the maintenance and development of intimate relationships, and the tasks identified with becoming a mother.
Western Journal of Nursing ResearchBeing a Mother and a Por Dia Domestic Worker Companionship and Deprivation
7 Citations1995Pilar Bernal, Afaf Ibrahim Meleis
Qualitative findings concerning women's maternal roles, based on interviews conducted in a study on role integration and health, in a Colombian sample of 60 women who are "por dia " domestic workers are presented.
Holistic Nursing PracticeDomestic workers in Colombia as spouses
6 Citations1994Afaf lbrahim Meleis, Pilar Bernal
The results suggest that the women find many aspects of their spousal roles satisfying, including their feelings that the spouses' role provides them with cariño (being loved and cared for).
Health characteristics by occupation and industry: United States, 1983-85
5 Citations1989John Gary Collins
National estimates for selected health characteristics of the civilian noninstitutionalized population in the labor force are presented in this report by the current occupation and by the industry of employment of the person for the US.
Human OrganizationThe Paradoxical World of Daily Domestic Workers in Cali, Colombia
5 Citations1995Afaf Ibrahim Meleis, Pilar Bernal
ASSESSING RURAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMMES IN INDIA FROM A GENDER PERSPECTIVE
4 Citations2002Roli Varma
PubMedSocial and psychological aspects of illness--past and present.
2 Citations1994Willms Jl, Pfeiffer Ca
This chapter reviews the historical events in the saga of women in the workplace and analyzes the contemporary status of those who are striving toward better work environments and greater occupational health for women workers.
…