The Impact of Brief Alcohol Interventions in Primary Healthcare: A Systematic Review of Reviews
Alcohol and AlcoholismPublished 13 November 2013Open access
Amy O’Donnell, Peter Anderson, Dorothy Newbury‐Birch, Bernd Schulte, Christiane Sybille Schmidt, Jens Reimer
Citations608
SJR quartileQ2
SJR score0.75
SNIP0.79
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
This overview highlights the large volume of primarily positive evidence supporting brief alcohol intervention effects as well as some unanswered questions with regards to the effectiveness of brief alcohol intervention across different cultural settings and in specific population groups, and in respect of the optimum content of brief interventions that might benefit from further research.
Keywords
Medicine
BMJPreferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement
83,276 Citations2009David Moher, A. Liberati +3 more
PubMedPreferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA Statement.
45,120 Citations2009David Moher, Alessandro Liberati +2 more
Annals of Internal MedicinePreferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses: The PRISMA Statement
37,262 Citations2009David Moher, Alessandro Liberati +3 more
Cochrane Database of Systematic ReviewsEffectiveness of brief alcohol interventions in primary care populations
1,650 Citations2018Eileen Kaner, Fiona Beyer +7 more
Moderate-quality evidence is found that brief alcohol interventions have little impact on frequency of binges per week and there is substantial heterogeneity among studies, which demonstrated that both men and women reduced alcohol consumption after receiving a brief intervention.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyA pragmatic–explanatory continuum indicator summary (PRECIS): a tool to help trial designers
1,398 Citations2009Kevin E. Thorpe, Merrick Zwarenstein +9 more
A tool to assist trialists in making design decisions that are consistent with their trial's stated purpose is proposed, with 10 key domains and which identifies criteria to help researchers determine how pragmatic or explanatory their trial is.
Prevention ScienceStandards of Evidence: Criteria for Efficacy, Effectiveness and Dissemination
1,341 Citations2005Brian R. Flay, Anthony Biglan +8 more
These Standards will inform efforts in the field to find prevention Programs and policies that are of proven efficacy, effectiveness, or readiness for adoption and will guide prevention scientists as they seek to discover, research, and bring to the field new prevention programs and policies.
BMC Medical Research MethodologyMethodology in conducting a systematic review of systematic reviews of healthcare interventions
1,210 Citations2011Valerie Smith, Declan Devane +2 more
Conducting a systematic review of reviews highlights the usefulness of bringing together a summary of reviews in one place, where there is more than one review on an important topic.
AddictionBrief interventions for alcohol problems: a meta‐analytic review of controlled investigations in treatment‐seeking and non‐treatment‐seeking populations
1,100 Citations2002Anne Moyer, John W. Finney +2 more
The LancetEffectiveness and cost-effectiveness of policies and programmes to reduce the harm caused by alcohol
1,097 Citations2009Peter Anderson, Dan Chisholm +1 more
School-based education does not reduce alcohol-related harm, although public information and education-type programmes have a role in providing information and in increasing attention and acceptance of alcohol on political and public agendas.
The LancetLanguage bias in randomised controlled trials published in English and German
1,026 Citations1997Matthias Egger, Tanja Zellweger-Zähner +4 more
English language bias may be introduced in reviews and meta-analyses if they include only trials reported in English if authors are more likely to report trials with statistically significant results in English than in German.
Annals of Internal MedicineBehavioral Counseling Interventions in Primary Care To Reduce Risky/Harmful Alcohol Use by Adults: A Summary of the Evidence for the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force
728 Citations2004Evelyn P Whitlock, Michael R Polen +3 more
The assumption underlying brief behavioral counseling interventions in primary care is that, for identified risky or harmful drinkers, reducing overall alcohol consumption or adopting safer drinking patterns will reduce the risk for medical, social, and psychological problems, and little experimental evidence supports this assumption.
Preventive MedicineEfficacy and effectiveness trials (and other phases of research) in the development of health promotion programs
718 Citations1986Brian R. Flay
The concepts of efficacy and effectiveness are examined from the viewpoints of the traditions and philosophies of health-care research and social program evaluation, and eight phases of research are suggested for the development of health promotion programs.
Archives of Internal MedicineReduction of Alcohol Consumption by Brief Alcohol Intervention in Primary Care
701 Citations2005Nicolas Bertholet
Focusing on patients in primary care, a systematic review and meta-analysis indicated that brief alcohol intervention is effective in reducing alcohol consumption at 6 and 12 months.
Cost Effectiveness and Resource AllocationGeneralized cost-effectiveness analysis for national-level priority-setting in the health sector
547 Citations2003Raymond Hutubessy, Dan Chisholm +2 more
Acta Psychiatrica ScandinavicaUse of mental health services in Europe: results from the European Study of the Epidemiology of Mental Disorders (ESEMeD) project
527 Citations2004The ESEMeD/MHEDEA 2000 investigators, Jordi Alonso +36 more
The first results of the use of health services for mental disorders in six European countries as part of the ESEMeD project are presented.
Drug and Alcohol ReviewThe effectiveness of brief alcohol interventions in primary care settings: A systematic review
441 Citations2009Eileen Kaner, Heather O Dickinson +7 more
Brief interventions can reduce alcohol consumption in men, with benefit at a year after intervention, but they are unproven in women for whom there is insufficient research data.
Journal of Public HealthBarriers and facilitators to implementing screening and brief intervention for alcohol misuse: a systematic review of qualitative evidence
367 Citations2010Maxine Johnson, R Jackson +3 more
Brief screening and brief intervention for alcohol misuse in adults and children over 10 years has been shown to be effective in some settings, but a number of barriers and facilitators to implementation are identified.
AddictionAlcohol screening and brief intervention: dissemination strategies for medical practice and public health
317 Citations2000Thomas F. Babor, John Higgins-Biddle
The concept of risky drinking is introduced and the potential of alcohol screening and brief intervention (SBI) to reduce alcohol-related problems in medical practice and in organized systems of health care is considered.
AddictionIdentification of behaviour change techniques to reduce excessive alcohol consumption
312 Citations2012Susan Michie, Craig Whittington +4 more
It is possible to identify specific behaviour change techniques reliably in manuals and guidelines for interventions to reduce excessive alcohol consumption and, in brief interventions, promoting self-monitoring is associated with improved outcomes.
The Open Dentistry JournalFrom Systematic Reviews to Clinical Recommendations for Evidence- Based Health Care: Validation of Revised Assessment of Multiple Systematic Reviews (R-AMSTAR) for Grading of Clinical Relevance~!2009-10-24~!2009-10-03~!2010-07-16~!
311 Citations2010Jason Kung
The AMSTAR instrument is revised, detracting nothing from its content and construct validity, and utilizing the very criteria employed in the development of the original tool, with the aim of yielding an instrument that can quantify the quality of systematic reviews.
BMC Medical Research MethodologyEvaluation of exposure-specific risks from two independent samples: A simulation study
308 Citations2011William M. Reichmann, David Gagnon +2 more
The currently accepted simple product-based method for calculating exposure-specific risks (ESR) was only a reasonable approach when the exposure probability is small and the RR is ≤ 3.0, and the revised product- based estimator provides much improved accuracy.
American Journal of Preventive MedicinePrimary Care Intervention to Reduce Alcohol Misuse
287 Citations2008Leif I. Solberg, Michael V. Maciosek +1 more
Screening and brief counseling was cost-saving from the societal perspective and had a cost-effectiveness ratio of $1755/QALY saved from the health-system perspective, making it one of the highest-ranking preventive services among the 25 effective services evaluated using standardized methods.
BMJEffectiveness of screening and brief alcohol intervention in primary care (SIPS trial): pragmatic cluster randomised controlled trial
274 Citations2013Eileen Kaner, Martin Bland +15 more
No significant differences in AUDIT negative status were found between the three interventions, and evidence that brief advice or brief lifestyle counselling provided important additional benefit in reducing hazardous or harmful drinking compared with the patient information leaflet was lacking.
Review of the effectiveness of treatment for alcohol problems.
264 Citations2006Duncan Raistrick, Nick Heather +1 more
Alcoholism Clinical and Experimental ResearchEfficacy of Brief Interventions for Hazardous Drinkers in Primary Care: Systematic Review and Meta‐Analyses
259 Citations2004Javier Ballesteros, John C. Duffy +3 more
The results, although indicating smaller effect sizes than previous meta-analyses, do support the moderate efficacy of BIs, as applied in the primary care setting.
BMJScreening in brief intervention trials targeting excessive drinkers in general practice: systematic review and meta-analysis
246 Citations2003Anders Beich, Thorkil Thorsen +1 more
Although even brief advice can reduce excessive drinking, screening in general practice does not seem to be an effective precursor to brief interventions targeting excessive alcohol use.
Drug and Alcohol ReviewAlcohol screening and brief intervention in primary care: Absence of evidence for efficacy in people with dependence or very heavy drinking
244 Citations2010Richard Saitz
The absence of evidence for the efficacy of BI among primary-care patients with screening-identified alcohol dependence raises questions regarding the efficiency of screening and BI, particularly in settings where dependence is common.
PLoS ONECan Simply Answering Research Questions Change Behaviour? Systematic Review and Meta Analyses of Brief Alcohol Intervention Trials
244 Citations2011Jim McCambridge, Kypros Kypri
Answering questions on drinking in brief intervention trials appears to alter subsequent self-reported behaviour, and the effects of brief alcohol interventions may have been consistently under-estimated.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyA simple and valid tool distinguished efficacy from effectiveness studies
211 Citations2006Gerald Gartlehner, Richard A. Hansen +3 more
When applied in a standardized manner, the proposed criteria can provide a valid and simple tool to distinguish effectiveness from efficacy studies and can also be used to determine the external validity of individual studies, given an appropriate population of interest.
Alcohol and AlcoholismINTERVENTION FOR EXCESSIVE ALCOHOL CONSUMPTION IN PRIMARY HEALTH CARE: ATTITUDES AND PRACTICES OF ENGLISH GENERAL PRACTITIONERS
200 Citations1999Eileen Kaner
Over the past 10 years, there appears to have been an increase in numbers of GPs who feel that they should be working with alcohol issues, but fewer GPs perceive themselves as being effective in this work.
Annals of Internal MedicineEffect of Telmisartan on Renal Outcomes
193 Citations2009Johannes F.E. Mann, Roland E. Schmieder +17 more
The effects of telmisartan on renal function in a large sample that was intolerant of ACE inhibitors and had vascular disease but not macroalbuminuria are examined, and the composite renal outcome was dialysis or doubling of serum creatinine.
Family PracticeFactors influencing inquiry about patients’ alcohol consumption by primary health care physicians: qualitative semi-structured interview study
168 Citations2003Marja Aira, Jussi Kauhanen +2 more
There still exist many barriers to initiating discussions about alcohol in the consultation room and changing the frame of reference of the concept of alcohol drinking from an addictive disease to a general lifestyle risk factor could overcome many of these barriers.
AddictionThe effects on mortality of brief interventions for problem drinking: a meta‐analysis
161 Citations2004Pim Cuijpers, Heleen Riper +1 more
Although the overall death rate was low in the population of problem drinkers, brief interventions do appear to reduce mortality.
Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health CareEffectiveness of strategies to implement brief alcohol intervention in primary healthcare
152 Citations2006Per Nilsén, Mauri Aalto +2 more
Intervention effectiveness generally increased with the intensity of the intervention effort, i.e. the amount of training and/or support provided, and the overall effectiveness was rather modest.
AddictionEpidemiology and alcohol policy in Europe
151 Citations2011Jürgen Rehm, Witold Zatonksi +2 more
Any reduction in the dose of alcohol consumed, at least down to 10 g/day, will reduce the annual and lifetime risk of an alcohol-related death and there is a need for alcohol policy to focus on measures in reducing alcohol consumption, throughout middle age, with immediacy of impact.
Alcoholism Clinical and Experimental ResearchTreatment of Alcohol Abuse: An Evidence‐Based Review
150 Citations2003Mats Berglund, Sten Thelander +4 more
This article represents the proceedings of a symposium at the 2002 annual meeting of the Research Society on Alcoholism in San Francisco, CA, organized and cochaired by Mats Berglund and Sten Thelander.
BMJDrug-grapefruit juice interactions
136 Citations2013Munir Pirmohamed
Two mechanisms are clear but individual responses vary in the response of the immune system to foreign substance abuse.
Journal of Studies on AlcoholEngaging general practitioners in the management of hazardous and harmful alcohol consumption: results of a meta-analysis.
127 Citations2004Peter Anderson, Miranda Laurant +3 more
It seems it is possible to increase the engagement of general practitioners in screening and giving advice for hazardous and harmful alcohol consumption, and promising programs are those that have a specific focus on alcohol and those that are multicomponent.
Drug and Alcohol ReviewObstacles to carrying out brief intervention for heavy drinkers in primary health care: a focus group study
123 Citations2003Mauri Aalto, Petteri Pekuri +1 more
The main actions to be taken to promote brief intervention are to educate professionals about the content of early-phase heavy drinking and to produce directing, but not excessively demanding guidelines for carrying out EIBI.
Alcohol and AlcoholismReduction of Drinking in Problem Drinkers and All-Cause Mortality
122 Citations2013Jürgen Rehm, Michael Roerecke
A model for reduction of drinking in heavy drinkers and its consequences for all-cause mortality risk was estimated and it was shown that the higher the level of drinking, the stronger the effects of a given reduction.
Alcohol and AlcoholismIntervention against Excessive Alcohol Consumption in Primary Health Care: A Survey of GPs' Attitudes and Practices in England 10 Years On
118 Citations2011Graeme Wilson, Catherine A. Lock +4 more
There still appears to be a gap between actual practice and potential for preventive work relating to alcohol problems, and translational work on understanding the evidence-base supporting screening and brief intervention could incentivize intervention against excessive drinking and embedding it into everyday primary care practice.
Drug and Alcohol DependenceChange over time in alcohol consumption in control groups in brief intervention studies: systematic review and meta-regression study
105 Citations2008Richard J. Jenkins, John McAlaney +1 more
This systematic review sought to examine the nature of change in alcohol consumption over time in control groups in brief intervention studies and found heterogeneity was reduced but was still substantial in a sub-set of 15 general population studies undertaken in English language countries.
AddictionBrief interventions for hazardous drinkers delivered in primary care are equally effective in men and women
103 Citations2003Javier Ballesteros, Asunción González‐Pinto +2 more
The results support the equality of outcomes among men and women achieved by brief interventions for hazardous alcohol consumption in primary care settings as well as the odds ratios for the frequency of individuals who drank below harmful levels.
Europe PMC (PubMed Central)Screening, Behavioral Counseling, and Referral in Primary Care To Reduce Alcohol Misuse
103 Citations2012Jonas De, Garbutt Jc +11 more
Alcohol misuse, which includes the full spectrum from drinking above recommended limits (i.e., risky/hazardous drinking) to alcohol dependence, 1-3 is associated with numerous health and social problems and more than 85,000 deaths per year in the United States.
Treating Alcohol and Drug Abuse – An Evidence Based Review
89 Citations2003Prof. Dr. Mats Berglund, Sten Thelander +1 more
The most comprehensive scientific review of its kind, it presents the findings from more than 1,600 studies on the effectiveness of different treatments, allowing them to save major resources by identifying ineffective treatments and being aware of cost-effective alternatives.
American Journal on AddictionsA Meta-analysis of the Efficacy of Nonphysician Brief Interventions for Unhealthy Alcohol Use: Implications for the Patient-Centered Medical Home
79 Citations2011Lynn E. Sullivan, Jeanette M. Tetrault +3 more
Nonphysician brief interventions are modestly effective at reducing drinking in primary care patients with unhealthy alcohol use, and the effect was smaller but reached statistical significance.
Addictive BehaviorsThe public health and brief interventions for excessive alcohol consumption: The british experience
79 Citations1996Nick Heather
The British experience of research and implementation of community-based brief interventions, which is longer than that of other countries, is focused on as a means of discussing problems in this area and recognizing and solving such problems.
Alcohol and AlcoholismModelling the Cost-Effectiveness of Alcohol Screening and Brief Interventions in Primary Care in England
78 Citations2012Robin C. Purshouse, Alan Brennan +6 more
A universal programme of alcohol SBI in primary care is estimated to be cost-effective, under all but the most pessimistic assumptions for programme costs and effectiveness.
Cochrane Database of Systematic ReviewsPsychosocial interventions delivered by general practitioners
73 Citations2003MJH Huibers, AJHM Beurskens +2 more
Of the psychosocial interventions reviewed, problem-solving treatment for depression seems the most promising tool for GPs, although a stronger evidence-base is required and the effectiveness in routine practice remains to be demonstrated.
Academic Emergency MedicineA Preliminary Report of Knowledge Translation: Lessons From Taking Screening and Brief Intervention Techniques From the Research Setting Into Regional Systems of Care
72 Citations2009Edward Bernstein, Deric Topp +5 more
This report tracks services provided during dissemination of the ED-SBIRT extender model to seven EDs across a northeastern state, in urban, suburban, and rural community settings, and provides a number of important lessons for a large rollout.
Drug and Alcohol ReviewMechanisms of change in control group drinking in clinical trials of brief alcohol intervention: Implications for bias toward the null
70 Citations2010Judith Bernstein, Edward Bernstein +1 more
This review identifies problems with retrospective analysis of predictors of control group change, and underscores the need to design prospective studies to permit identification, quantification and adjustment for potential sources of bias in BAI trials.
Medical CareA Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Health Care Utilization Outcomes in Alcohol Screening and Brief Intervention Trials
67 Citations2011Jeremy W. Bray, Alexander J. Cowell +1 more
Systematic review results suggest that SBI has little to no effect on inpatient or outpatient health care utilization, but it may have a small, negative effect on ED utilization.
Addiction Research & TheoryInterventions delivered during antenatal care to reduce alcohol consumption during pregnancy: A systematic review
50 Citations2010Alyssa Gilinsky, Vivien Swanson +1 more
There was some evidence from a small number of studies that single-session face-to-face brief interventions resulted in positive effects on the maintenance of alcohol abstinence during pregnancy, and more intensive interventions may be required to encourage women who continue to drink during pregnancy to reduce their consumption.
Alcohol and AlcoholismDOES SOCIO-ECONOMIC STATUS INFLUENCE THE ACCEPTABILITY OF, ATTENDANCE FOR, AND OUTCOME OF, SCREENING AND BRIEF INTERVENTIONS FOR ALCOHOL MISUSE: A REVIEW
40 Citations2006Christopher Littlejohn
There is evidence that once recruited, and following attendance for intervention, participants' SES does not influence treatment outcome, and fidelity to research design is suggested to allow for any participation effects to occur.
Family PracticeChallenges to alcohol and other drug discussions in the general practice consultation
37 Citations2011Helen Moriarty, Maria Stubbe +5 more
Mindful prioritization of competing demands, time pressures, topic delicacy and the acuteness of the presenting complaint can impede use of AOD discussion opportunities.
Preventive MedicinePsychosocial factors and blood pressure
36 Citations1985Michael Marmot
The evidence linking psychosocial factors to sustained blood pressure elevation is highly suggestive and comes from a variety of sources, but in humans the evidence linking psychological traits to hypertension is inconsistent.
Drug and Alcohol ReviewNICE work if you can get it: Development of national guidance incorporating screening and brief intervention to prevent hazardous and harmful drinking in England
35 Citations2010Eileen Kaner
Evidence from the alcohol field and other clinical areas indicates that national prioritisation of brief alcohol intervention activity, by a body, such as NICE, is likely to be a key driver of implementation by practitioners.
Journal of Substance Abuse TreatmentBrief interventions for problem drinking and women
31 Citations2002Grace Chang
Examination of the efficacy of brief interventions for the population of women in need of some alcohol treatment suggests brief interventions are not consistently helpful to women drinkers.
Journal of Substance UseScreening and brief alcohol interventions: What, why, who, where and when? A review of the literature
29 Citations2004Catherine A. Lock
The review will provide a working definition of screening and brief intervention and explain why it is considered to be an important element of preventive care and the settings in which screening and Brief intervention can and does take place.
Drug and Alcohol ReviewBrief intervention content matters
29 Citations2013Jim McCambridge
The PRE-EMPT authors conclude that ‘enduring behaviour change and improvements on biochemical and biometric measures are unlikely after a single routine consultation with a clinician trained in behaviour change counselling, without additional intervention’.
Sociology of Health & IllnessThe (non) use of prioritisation protocols by surgeons
20 Citations2010Kevin Dew, Maria Stubbe +3 more
It is suggested that the interactional work required in the delivery of such news challenges the ability of clinicians to use protocols such as CPAC, and sheds light on important consultation processes that need to be more carefully considered when designing interventions to influence clinician behaviour.
Current Opinion in PsychiatryImplementing alcohol disorders treatment throughout the community
11 Citations2011Antoni Gual, Michaela B do Amaral Sabadini
Alcohol is a major public health problem and brief interventions are one of the cost-effective measures that can be taken at a community level, Nevertheless, implementation of those measures is difficult and further research is needed to identify the best implementation strategies.
Journal of Psychology in AfricaBrief Intervention of Alcohol Problems in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Review
11 Citations2009Karl Peltzer
Brief intervention of alcohol problems in health care settings showed positive results but were difficult to integrate into routine practice, and brief interventions combined with HIV risk reduction counselling showed promising short term results.
BMJWhat is the appropriate MHRA regulatory response to calcium's increased cardiovascular risk?
7 Citations2013Mark J Bolland, Alison Avenell +2 more
The MHRA recommended restricting the prescription of strontium ranelate for osteoporosis because it increased the risk of myocardial infarction, although it did not increase mortality, in a pooled …