Mandatory Seat Belt Laws in the States
Evaluation ReviewPublished 1 April 1996
David J. Houston, Lilliard E. Richardson, Grant W. Neeley
Citations28
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score0.45
SNIP0.95
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The general conclusion that emerges from this analysis is that seat belt laws significantly impact state fatal injury rates and primary enforcement and all-seat coverage provisions appear to be particularly effective in reducing fatality rates.
Abstract
This study examines the impact of mandatory seat belt laws on fatal and incapacitating injury rates in the states. Annual data for all 50 states for the period 1975-1991 are used. Pooled time series analysis is employed. The general conclusion that emerges from this analysis is that seat belt laws significantly impact state fatal injury rates. Primary enforcement and all-seat coverage provisions appear to be particularly effective in reducing fatality rates.
Keywords
Social SciencesMedicineEngineering
Journal of the Operational Research SocietyTraffic Safety and the Driver
911 Citations1992Andrew Shea, Leonard Evans
This book is concerned with fatalities, injuries, and property damage from traffic crashes--their origin and nature, and ways to prevent their occurrence and reduce their severity.
Pooled Time Series Analysis
473 Citations1989Lois W. Sayrs
Accident Analysis & PreventionThe effectiveness of safety belts in preventing fatalities
312 Citations1986Leonard Evans
If all presently unbelted drivers and right front passengers were to use the provided three point lap/shoulder belt, but not otherwise change their behavior, fatalities to this group would decline by (43 +/- 3), which agrees with the 40%-50% range reported in a recent major review and synthesis by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
Journal of Studies on AlcoholEffects of minimum drinking age laws on alcohol use, related behaviors and traffic crash involvement among American youth: 1976-1987.
283 Citations1991Patrick M. O’Malley, Alexander C. Wagenaar
Higher minimum drinking ages were associated with lower levels of alcohol use among high school seniors and recent high school graduates, even after multivariate controls; and lowered involvement in alcohol-related fatal crashes among drivers under 21 appeared due to lower alcohol consumption rates--in particular, less drinking in bars or taverns.
Journal of Safety ResearchMandatory seat belt laws in eight states: a time-series evaluation
100 Citations1988Alexander C. Wagenaar, Richard G. Maybee +1 more
Accident Analysis & PreventionEffects of the 65 mph speed limit on injury morbidity and mortality
85 Citations1990Alexander C. Wagenaar, Frederic M. Streff +1 more
Significant increases in casualties were revealed on roads where the speed limit was raised, including a 19.2% increase in fatalities, a 39.8%" increase in serious injuries, and a 25.4% increaseInjury morbidity and mortality in Michigan increased with the maximum speed limit raised from 55 mph to 65 mph.
Accident Analysis & PreventionDeterminants of motor vehicle deaths in the united states: A cross-sectional analysis
75 Citations1991Thomas J. Zlatoper
The estimates suggest that income, the ratio of urban to rural driving, expenditures on highway police and safety, motor vehicle inspection laws, and adult seat belt use laws with secondary enforcement provisions are inversely related to motor vehicle death rates.
Journal of Policy Analysis and ManagementBuckle up or Slow down? New Estimates of Offsetting Behavior and Their Implications for Automobile Safety Regulation
74 Citations1993Robert S. Chirinko, Edward P. Harper
Journal of Policy Analysis and ManagementDoes the Minimum Drinking Age Affect Traffic Fatalities?
70 Citations1987Peter Asch, David T. Levy
Examination of determinants of a variety of traffic fatality rates at the state level for 1978 suggests that the effectiveness of higher drinking ages as a safety policy tool probably has been overstated.
Journal of Safety ResearchThe fatality consequences of the 65 mph speed limits, 1989
60 Citations1991Herbert M. Baum, JoAnn K. Wells +1 more
Policy SciencesRisk compensation and the effectiveness of safety belt use laws: a case study of New Jersey
46 Citations1991Peter Asch, David T. Levy +2 more
JAMAEfficacy of Mandatory Seat-Belt Use Legislation
46 Citations1988Terence Chorba
This study supports the hypothesis that the societal burden of crash-associated injury can be reduced by mandating seat-belt use and predicts that a reduction of approximately 1100 severe or fatal injuries per year can be attributed to the seat- belt law in North Carolina.
Applied EconomicsBreath testing and highway fatality rates
45 Citations1989Henry Saffer, Frank J. Chaloupka
Accident Analysis & PreventionEvaluating the North Carolina safety belt wearing law
39 Citations1990D W Reinfurt, Barry J. Campbell +2 more
Time series analysis showed that statistically significant reductions in percentages of moderate and serious injuries occurred at the beginning of both the warning ticket and the enforcement phases, representing an estimated annual savings of 131 lives and over 2,300 serious injuries in North Carolina during the 18 months following onset of enforcement.
Journal of Safety ResearchThe association between enforcement and seat belt use
34 Citations1988Barry J. Campbell
Accident Analysis & PreventionThe effectiveness of seat belt legislation in reducing various driver-involved injury rates in California∗
33 Citations1993Peter D. Loeb
Robust results are obtained for the efficacy of seat belt legislation on reducing (moderate to fatal) injury rates in California.
1985-1986 EXPERIENCE WITH BELT LAWS IN THE UNITED STATES
26 Citations1987Barry J. Campbell, Jill R. Stewart +1 more
Accident Analysis & PreventionCost savings associated with increased safety belt use in Iowa, 1987–1988
22 Citations1993David E. Nelson, Timothy D. Peterson +3 more
It was found that injuries were more serious and that more deaths and cases of permanent disability occurred among persons who did not wear safety belts, and failure to use safety belts was independently associated with higher payments to hospitals by health care insurers and individuals.
Journal of Safety ResearchReductions in police-reported injuries associated with Michigan's safety belt law
16 Citations1990Fredrick M. Streff, Alexander C. Wagenaar +1 more
Michigan's adult safety belt law has prevented 31,710 injuries from July 1985 through December 1988 and is likely to have prevented further injuries from January 1978 through December 1987.
Accident Analysis & PreventionSeat belt law experience in four foreign countries compared to the United States
15 Citations1988
Evaluation ReviewPolicy Implications From an Evaluation of Seat Belt Use Regulation
12 Citations1992Anand Desai, Min-Bong You
Evaluation ReviewImpact of the Illinois Seat Belt Use Law on Accidents, Deaths, and Injuries
11 Citations1992Steven M. Rock
CHANGES IN DEATH AND INJURY ASSOCIATED WITH SAFETY BELT LAWS 1985-1987
8 Citations1988Barry J. Campbell, Jill R. Stewart +1 more
Journal of Safety ResearchA quantification of the impact of restraining systems on passenger safety
7 Citations1989Saeed Maghsoodloo, David B. Brown +1 more
Journal of Safety ResearchEffectiveness of safety-belt use: A study using hospital-based data for nonfatal motor-vehicle crashes
7 Citations1993Judith M. Conn, Terence Chorba +3 more
It is concluded that the use of safety belts reduces the number and seriousness of injuries for cars of all sizes; however, car size may influence the effectiveness of safety-belt use in preventing a serious injury.
Transportation Research Record Journal of the Transportation Research BoardSAFETY BELT USE AND HIGHWAY SAFETY IN MARYLAND
3 Citations1991Everett C Carter, Paul Schonfeld