Meta-analysis: Science or religion?

Controlled Clinical TrialsPublished 1 December 1989

Curtis L. Meinert

Citations53

TL;DR

Key among the needs are improved means of identifying trials prior to publication via prospective registration of them and vocabulary and nomenclature for identifying reports of meta-analyses in the published literature.

Abstract

Meta-analysis of clinical trials has assumed increasing importance in recent years as a means of reaching conclusions regarding the safety and efficacy of treatments evaluated in individual trials. This article discusses impediments to meta-analyses and enumerates needs that should be satisfied to enhance their usefulness. Key among the needs are improved means of identifying trials prior to publication via prospective registration of them and vocabulary and nomenclature for identifying reports of meta-analyses in the published literature.

Keywords

Decision SciencesMedicineNeuroscience

New England Journal of MedicineMeta-Analyses of Randomized Controlled Trials

1,268 Citations1987Henry S. Sacks, Jayne Berrier +3 more

Journal of Clinical OncologyPublication bias: the case for an international registry of clinical trials.

758 Citations1986R. J. Simes

A model is proposed for reviewing clinical trial results which is free from publication bias based on the selection of trials registered in advance in a registry, and the value and importance of an international registry of all clinical trials are illustrated.

New England Journal of MedicinePreliminary Report: Findings from the Aspirin Component of the Ongoing Physicians' Health Study

519 Citations1988The Steering Committee of the Physicians' Health Study Research Group

Controlled Clinical TrialsThe Oxford database of perinatal trials: Developing a register of published reports of controlled trials

137 Citations1986Iain Chalmers, Jini Hetherington +6 more

The development of the first of these four elements of a database of perinatal trials is described, which will ultimately comprise four main elements: a register of published reports of trials; aregister of unpublished trials; an ongoing and planned trials; and data derived from pooled overviews (meta-analyses) of trials.

Controlled Clinical TrialsReport from the panel on the case for registers of clinical trials at the eighth annual meeting of the society for clinical trials

59 Citations1988Kay Dickersin

The experience gleaned by those involved with two existing trial registers, the International Committee on Thrombosis and Haemostasis Registry and the Oxford Database of Perinatal Trials, can be used to provide insight into the issues generic to trial registration.

New England Journal of MedicineAspirin for the Primary Prevention of Myocardial Infarction

40 Citations1988Arnold S. Relman

Under the somewhat ill-defined rubric "Special Report," a preliminary report from the Physicians' Health Study, a double-blinded, controlled trial of aspirin in the Physicians’ Health Study is published.