Pump and Circumstance: Robert Boyle's Literary Technology

This paper analyzes the resources used to produce matters of fact in Robert Boyle's experimental programme, and argues that the notion of a `public' for experimental science is essential to the authors' understanding of how facts are generated and validated.

Abstract

Robert Boyle's experimental programme had as its end-product the generation of indisputable matters of fact. In this paper I analyze the resources used to produce these matters of fact, paying particular attention to linguistic practices. Experimental reports rich in circumstantial detail were designed to enable readers of the text to create a mental image of an experimental scene they did not directly witness. I call this `virtual witnessing', and its importance was as a means of enlarging the witnessing public. The notion of a `public' for experimental science is, I argue, essential to our understanding of how facts are generated and validated. In these episodes, circumstantial reporting was a technique for creating a public and for constituting authentic knowledge.