Effectiveness in professional organizations: the impact of surgeons and surgical staff organizations on the quality of care in hospitals.

PubMedPublished 1 January 1982Open access

Ann Barry Flood, W. Richard Scott, W Ewy, William H. Forrest

Citations50

TL;DR

This research examines the relative importance of different structural units in a professional organization, the hospital, as they affect organizational effectiveness, indicating that hospital features have more impact on surgical outcomes than do surgeon characteristics.

Abstract

In this research, we examine the relative importance of different structural units in a professional organization, the hospital, as they affect organizational effectiveness. The difficulties of measuring effectiveness in a complex professional organization are discussed, and an adjusted measure of surgical outcome is developed. Data are drawn from a prospective study of over 8,000 surgical patients treated by more than 500 surgeons in 15 hospitals throughout the nation. Two different types of analyses are presented, both indicating that hospital features have more impact on surgical outcomes than do surgeon characteristics. The second analysis assesses the relative importance of specific attributes of the hospital, surgical staff organization, and surgeon characteristics on surgical outcomes.

Keywords

Economics, Econometrics and FinanceHealth Professions

New England Journal of MedicineQuality-of-Care Assessment: Choosing a Method for Peer Review

281 Citations1973Robert H. Brook, Francis A. Appel

Medical CareStudies of Process-Outcome Correlations in Medical Care Evaluations

73 Citations1978William McAuliffe

Since the validity of outcome measures has never been determined, there is little reason at present for believing that outcome measures are more valid than process measures.

New England Journal of MedicineEffectiveness of Inpatient Follow-up Care

66 Citations1971Robert H. Brook, Francis A. Appel +3 more

The course of 403 patients discharged consecutively from the medical service of a teaching hospital was studied to determine their medical care after hospitalization and to evaluate its quality.

Journal of Health and Social BehaviorProfessional Power and Professional Effectiveness: The Power of the Surgical Staff and the Quality of Surgical Care in Hospitals

63 Citations1978Ann Barry Flood, W. Richard Scott

Regression analyses revealed that the extent of control exercised by the surgical staff over individual surgeons did relate to the quality of care as predicted, and higher power by the hospital administration was the factor most strongly associated with quality of surgical care.

Journal of Chronic DiseasesPredictability of coronary heart disease

54 Citations1979Tavia Gordon, William B. Kannel +1 more

The Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly Health and SocietyOrganizational Determinants of Services, Quality and Cost of Care in Hospitals

33 Citations1979W. Richard Scott, Ann Barry Flood +1 more

A promising new research approach is explored as a source of information on that most elusive of all measures in service organizations--the outcome experienced by clients.

Medical CareThe Relationship Between Intensity and Duration of Medical Services and Outcomes for Hospitalized Patients

28 Citations1979Ann Barry Flood, Wayne Ewy +3 more

Using a composite measure of the intensity of specific medical services reflecting the mix, amount, and relative costliness of the services provided, out data clearly supported the expectation that hospitals providing higher than expected levels of specific services to patients also had better outcomes than expected.

Journal of Health and Social BehaviorOrganizational Goals and Quality of Medical Care: Evidence from Comparative Research on Hospitals

15 Citations1970Mary E. W. Goss

The evidence suggests that some systematic relationships do exist between hospitals and certain goals-teaching, research, profit, and service, particularly with regard to teaching goals.