Camera-Related Behaviors during Video Recorded Medical Interactions
Journal of Nonverbal BehaviorPublished 14 March 2007
Louis A. Penner, Heather Orom, Terrance L. Albrecht, Melissa M. Franks, Tanina Foster, John C. Ruckdeschel
Citations82
SJR quartileQ3
SJR score0.55
SNIP1.01
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Results suggest video recording can provide nonreactive means of studying medical interactions and suggest cameras may be reactive measurement devices that alter what normally transpires during interactions.
Abstract
Video recording provides an objective record of the content of medical interactions. However, there is concern that cameras may be reactive measurement devices that alter what normally transpires during interactions. This study addressed potential reactivity of cameras in medical interactions. Interactions between 45 patients and 14 medical oncologists were video recorded and coded for camera-related behaviors. Eleven of 45 patients performed none of the behaviors. Among the other patients, camera-related behaviors were infrequent and, on average, constituted about 0.1% (one-tenth of one percent) of total interaction time. Behaviors occurred most often in very early stages of interactions, and when physicians were absent from the room. Seven physicians showed camera-related behaviors, comprising less than 0.1% of the time they were in the interaction. Results suggest video recording can provide nonreactive means of studying medical interactions.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyA comparison of coping assessed by ecological momentary assessment and retrospective recall.
374 Citations1998Arthur A. Stone, Joseph E. Schwartz +7 more
Journal of Language and Social PsychologyVisible Acts of Meaning
247 Citations2000Janet Beavin Bavelas, Nicole Chovil
Medical CareProblems and Prospects for Health Services Research on Provider-Patient Communication
207 Citations1985Thomas S. Inui, William B. Carter
Quality of Life ResearchCognitive psychology and self-reports: Models and methods
200 Citations2003Jared B. Jobe
The models and methods that cognitive psychologists and survey researchers use to evaluate and experimentally test cognitive issues in questionnaire design and subsequently improve self-report instruments are described.
PubMedDoes awareness of being video recorded affect doctors' consultation behaviour?
188 Citations1990M Pringle, C Stewart-Evans
Four general practitioners, two of whom had no previous experience of video recording in the consultation, took part in a study to assess the effect of awareness ofVideo recording on their consultation behaviour, finding no significant difference in consultation length, the number of problems dealt with, or previous inexperience of video recordings.
Medical EducationAssessment of general practitioners by video observation of communicative and medical performance in daily practice: issues of validity, reliability and feasibility
171 Citations1999R. Ram, Grol +4 more
To develop a video assessment method for General Practitioners by analysing issues of validity, reliability and feasibility of observation of videotaped regular consultations.
Family PracticeUsing video-recorded consultations for research in primary care: advantages and limitations
168 Citations2000Tim Coleman
Using video-recorded consultations for research purposes may cause bias in the characteristics of doctors and patients who agree to participate in research, according to researchers considering using this technique in their research.
Journal of Clinical OncologyStrategic Physician Communication and Oncology Clinical Trials
159 Citations1999Terrance L. Albrecht, Christina G. Blanchard +3 more
Patients were more likely to accrue to the trial when their physician verbally presented items normally included in an informed consent document and when they behaved in a reflective, patient-centered, supportive, and responsive manner.
Social Science & MedicineThe Medical Interaction Process System (MIPS): an instrument for analysing interviews of oncologists and patients with cancer
117 Citations2000Sarah Ford, Angela Hall +2 more
The development of a new instrument, the Medical Interaction Process System (MIPS), for use in teaching communication skills and empirical research in medical encounters, particularly, between doctors and patients with cancer is described.
Patient Education and CounselingObservations on methodological and measurement challenges in the assessment of communication during medical exchanges
58 Citations2003Debra Roter
This essay explores methodological and design challenges related to broadening the study of medical communication through more creative and thoughtful study designs.
Brain and CognitionNeural correlates of dual task interference in rapid visual streams: An fMRI study
57 Citations2003Walter S. Marcantoni, Martín Lepage +3 more
Journal of PersonalityDay‐to‐day Relationships Between Self‐awareness, Daily Events, and Anxiety
56 Citations2002John B. Nezlek
The strength of the relationship between public SA and positive social events was stronger for people who were less anxious, less depressed, and for those with greater self-esteem.
American Journal of Public HealthDo Men Know That They Have Had a Prostate-Specific Antigen Test? Accuracy of Self-Reports of Testing at 2 Sites
52 Citations2004Evelyn Chan, Sally W. Vernon +2 more
The accuracy of self-reports of PSA testing should be interpreted with caution, and Concordance, sensitivity, and false-negative values were 65%, 67%, and 33%, respectively, at 1 clinic site and 88%, 64%, and 36% at the other.
PubMedThe reactions of patients to a video camera in the consulting room.
48 Citations1984Edwin Martin, Patrick Martin
Patients with anxiety, depression, or problems relating to the breasts or reproductive system were more likely to withhold consent and were less likely to refuse video recording of their consultation if they were asked by the doctor for their verbal permission as they entered the consulting room.
BMJVideotaping of general practice consultations: effect on patient satisfaction
40 Citations1995Louisa Campbell, Frank Sullivan +1 more
This work compared patient satisfaction scores after videotaped consultations and after consultations that were not videotaped, on the basis that if patiens felt uncomfortable during consultations that was being videotaping, then the scores would be lower.
Journal of Advanced NursingContinuous video recording: a new clinical research tool for studying the nursing care of cancer patients
37 Citations2001Christina Andersen, Lis Adamsen
Continuous video recording, as a research tool can document accurately interaction and behaviour between cancer patients and nursing staff between stressful irradiation treatments and nursing performance in these situations, can be a useful tool for instruction and for future research.
BMJReactions of patients to video recording of consultations in general practice.
37 Citations1985Guy A. Herzmark
Examination of doctors' responses to being filmed would usefully complement the emphasis on the views of patients and show that the more opportunity patients are given to decline the more likely they are to take it.
Behavior Research MethodsA portable, unobtrusive device for videorecording clinical interactions
36 Citations2005Terrance L. Albrecht, John C. Ruckdeschel +8 more
This article describes a system designed to videotape clinical interactions in a manner that can be moved in and out of different clinical rooms to preserve flexibility in its use and demonstrate that the system is unobtrusive during the interaction, yet fully compatible with institutional review board guidelines to protect human participants’ privacy and freedom to control the recording process.
Journal of Nonverbal BehaviorDifferences in Audiotaped Versus Videotaped Physician-Patient Interactions
22 Citations2002Dawn L. Riddle, Terrance L. Albrecht +6 more
ManOVA analyses show that ratings of audiotaped physician-patient interactions are not equivalent to ratings of videotaped encounters, and exploratory factor analyses show differences in the underlying structures of the data derived from the audio-only versus the video information.
Journal of Cancer EducationUnderstanding Patient Decisions about Clinical Trials and the Associated Communication Process: A Preliminary Report
18 Citations2003Terrance L. Albrecht, Louis A. Penner +1 more
Data is presented that suggest using the system to test the conceptual model can improve the understanding of patient decisions about clinical trials and hold out the potential for improving provider training.
BMJVideotaping general practice consultations.
18 Citations1993Jacqueline Bain, Neil S D Mackay
The consent rate for videotaped consultations in their study was 91%, which shows the vulnerability of patients to coercion, and when coercion and bias are removed, consent rates in the order of 4-10% are to be expected.
Communication QuarterlyReduction in public speaking state anxiety during performance as a function of sensitization processes
18 Citations2002Chris R. Sawyer, Ralph R. Behnke
BMJOzaena and iron deficiency.
16 Citations1968Iván Bernát
The question arises why these patients received iron if no deficiency was present, further, whether iron deficiency could be expected after prolonged iron treatment, and whether objective changes did occur in these cases.
Journal of Experimental Social PsychologyTV cameras, public self-consciousness, and mock juror performance
16 Citations1984Saul M. Kassin
BMJNew deal shifts may increase house officers' stress
14 Citations1995C. Grainger, E. Harries +1 more
Palliative MedicineIs videotaping of consultations acceptable to patients attending a hospice day centre?
13 Citations2001Peter Hargreaves, Roger Peppiatt
If videotaping of consultations in the hospice setting is to be undertaken, more advanced notice than that usually given in general practice is required and strict safeguards should be in place to protect vulnerable patients.
Family PracticeConsent rates for video-recording general practice consultations: effect of ethnicity and other factors
11 Citations2004Richard D Neal
No significant differences in consent rates were found between white and south Asian patients, even after controlling for age, gender and self-reported understanding of English.
Academic MedicineInformed Consent and Patient Videotaping
10 Citations2002Dennis J. Butler
Most of the videotaping consent forms analyzed in this study did not provide adequate information to assist patients in making a voluntary, informed choice to be videotaped, raising the potential for violations of patient privacy and confidentiality.
BMJVideotaping of general practice consultations
5 Citations1995J. E Bain, N. S D Mackay
It is difficult to imagine a more wrong headed approach to osteoporosis than that proposed by E M Tayler, where a bone density scan rarely influences a decision to start or continue hormone replacement therapy.