Moving towards solutions to some enduring controversies in visual search
Trends in Cognitive SciencesPublished 1 February 2003
Jeremy M. Wolfe
Citations276
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score4.51
SNIP5.51
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Recent work has shed new light on a two-stage solution to the problem of visual search: a preattentive stage that could process a limited number of basic features in parallel and an attentive stage that can perform more complex acts of recognition, one object at a time.
Abstract
How do we find a target item in a visual world filled with distractors? A quarter of a century ago, in her influential 'Feature Integration Theory (FIT)', Treisman proposed a two-stage solution to the problem of visual search: a preattentive stage that could process a limited number of basic features in parallel and an attentive stage that could perform more complex acts of recognition, one object at a time. The theory posed a series of problems. What is the nature of that preattentive stage? How do serial and parallel processes interact? How does a search unfold over time? Recent work has shed new light on these issues.
Keywords
Computer ScienceNeuroscience
Cognitive PsychologyA feature-integration theory of attention
12,207 Citations1980Anne Treisman, Garry A. Gelade
A new hypothesis about the role of focused attention is proposed, which offers a new set of criteria for distinguishing separable from integral features and a new rationale for predicting which tasks will show attention limits and which will not.
International Journal of Computer VisionModeling the Shape of the Scene: A Holistic Representation of the Spatial Envelope
6,410 Citations2001Aude Oliva, Antonio Torralba
The performance of the spatial envelope model shows that specific information about object shape or identity is not a requirement for scene categorization and that modeling a holistic representation of the scene informs about its probable semantic category.
NatureSpeed of processing in the human visual system
3,540 Citations1996Simon J. Thorpe, Denis Fize +1 more
Psychonomic Bulletin & ReviewGuided Search 2.0 A revised model of visual search
3,522 Citations1994Jeremy M. Wolfe
This paper reviews the visual search literature and presents a model of human search behavior, a revision of the guided search 2.0 model in which virtually all aspects of the model have been made more explicit and/or revised in light of new data.
Vision ResearchA saliency-based search mechanism for overt and covert shifts of visual attention
3,193 Citations2000L. Itti, Christof Koch
A detailed computer implementation of a saliency map scheme is described, focusing on the problem of combining information across modalities, here orientation, intensity and color information, in a purely stimulus-driven manner, which is applied to common psychophysical stimuli as well as to a very demanding visual search task.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceTemporary suppression of visual processing in an RSVP task: An attentional blink?
2,281 Citations1992Jane E. Raymond, Kimron L. Shapiro +1 more
Cognitive PsychologyContextual Cueing: Implicit Learning and Memory of Visual Context Guides Spatial Attention
1,998 Citations1998Marvin M. Chun, Yuhong Jiang
The results show how implicit learning and memory of visual context can guide spatial attention towards task-relevant aspects of a scene.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceGuided search: An alternative to the feature integration model for visual search.
1,864 Citations1989Jeremy M. Wolfe, Kyle R. Cave +1 more
Searches for triple conjunctions (Color X Size X Form) are easier than searches for standard conjunctions and can be independent of set size, and three parallel processes can guide attention more effectively than two.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceGuided search: An alternative to the feature integration model for visual search.
1,388 Citations1989Jeremy M. Wolfe, Kyle R. Cave +1 more
Cognitive PsychologyIllusory conjunctions in the perception of objects
1,356 Citations1982Anne Treisman, Hilary J. Schmidt
It is confirmed that illusory conjunctions are frequently experienced among unattended stimuli varying in color and shape, and that they occur also with size and solidity (outlined versus filled-in shapes).
Annual Review of PsychologyVISUAL ATTENTION: Control, Representation, and Time Course
1,312 Citations1997Howard E. Egeth, Steven Yantis
The time course of attention as it is directed to one stimulus after another is considered, including how much attention can be said to be location- or object-based.
The attentive brain.
893 Citations1998Raja Parasuraman
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformancePerceptual grouping and attention in visual search for features and for objects.
876 Citations1982Anne Treisman
The effects of perceptual grouping on search for targets defined by separate features or by conjunction of features is explored, suggesting that preattentive grouping creates separate feature maps within each separable dimension rather than one global configuration.
NatureSerial and parallel processing of visual feature conjunctions
873 Citations1986Ken Nakayama, Gerald Silverman
It seems that the visual system is incapable of conducting a parallel search over two stimulus dimensions simultaneously, but this conclusion is extended for the conjunction of motion and colour, showing that it requires a serial search.
NatureTask difficulty and the specificity of perceptual learning
836 Citations1997Merav Ahissar, Shaul Hochstein
It is shown here that the degree of specificity depends on the difficulty of the training conditions, and it is found that the pattern of specificities maps onto the patterns of receptive field selectivities along the visual pathway.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B Biological SciencesFeature binding, attention and object perception
750 Citations1998Anne Treisman
Experiments suggest that attention plays a central role in solving the 'binding problem', which concerns the way in which the authors select and integrate the separate features of objects in the correct combinations.
Psychological ScienceWhat Can 1 Million Trials Tell Us About Visual Search?
716 Citations1998Jeremy M. Wolfe
Trends in Cognitive SciencesA saliency map in primary visual cortex
668 Citations2002Li Zhaoping
A model is used to show that this saliency map accounts for the way that the relative difficulties of visual search tasks depend on the features and spatial configurations of targets and distractors.
Journal of Experimental Psychology GeneralCompetition for consciousness among visual events: The psychophysics of reentrant visual processes.
657 Citations2000Vincent Di Lollo, James T. Enns +1 more
NatureDirect measurement of attentional dwell time in human vision
635 Citations1994John S. Duncan, Robert Ward +1 more
It is suggested that visual attention is not a high-speed switching mecha-nism, but a sustained state during which relevant objects become available to influence behaviour, consistent with recent physiological results in the monkey.
NatureInhibitory tagging system facilitates visual search
624 Citations1988Raymond M. Klein
The following study of human performance supports assumptions that inhibition of return operates in serial search, presumably to improve search efficiency, and provides a functional link between these two phenomena.
Journal of Experimental Psychology GeneralCompetition for consciousness among visual events: The psychophysics of reentrant visual processes.
574 Citations2000Vincent Di Lollo, James T. Enns +1 more
Psychological ScienceInhibition of Return is a Foraging Facilitator in Visual Search
564 Citations1999Raymond M. Klein, W. Joseph MacInnes
Data from this study strongly support the proposal that inhibition of return functions to facilitate visual search by inhibiting orienting to previously examined locations.
NatureVisual search has no memory
562 Citations1998Todd S. Horowitz, Jeremy M. Wolfe
Human observers are asked to search for a letter ‘T’ among letters ‘L’ and it is shown that efficiency is not impaired, and the standard theories of visual search must be revised.
Vision ResearchExternal noise distinguishes attention mechanisms
534 Citations1998Zhong‐Lin Lu, Barbara Anne Dosher
A powerful method for identifying and characterizing the effect of attention on performance in visual tasks as due to signal enhancement, distractor exclusion, or internal noise suppression is developed and tested.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceThe structure of attentional control: Contingent attentional capture by apparent motion, abrupt onset, and color.
497 Citations1994Charles L. Folk, Roger W. Remington +1 more
The results of five spatial cuing experiments suggest that stimulus salience may also play a role in attentional capture and support the hypotheses of Folk et al. (1992) and support asymmetric capture effects between abrupt onset and apparent motion related to stimulus Salience.
Vision ResearchThe psychophysics of visual search
465 Citations2000John Palmer, Preeti Verghese +1 more
It is concluded that low threshold theories can account for simple visual search without invoking mechanisms such as limited capacity or serial processing.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceOn the distinction between visual salience and stimulus-driven attentional capture.
451 Citations1999Steven Yantis, Howard E. Egeth
It is concluded that efficient selection of an element in visual search does not constitute evidence that the element captures attention in a purely stimulus-driven fashion.
Journal of the Optical Society of America APostadaptation orientation discrimination
413 Citations1985D. Regan, K. I. Beverley
It was found that adapting to a high-contrast grating degraded discrimination for test gratings inclined at about 10-20 deg to the adapting grating while having little effect on the detection of these inclined gratings.
NeuronVisual Search and Attention
350 Citations2001Preeti Verghese
A framework based on signal detection theory shows how visual attention influences tasks that require searching for a target among distractors and improves performance by increasing the discriminability of the attended signal.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceMeasuring the effect of attention on simple visual search.
337 Citations1993John Palmer, Cynthia T. Ames +1 more
Psychonomic Bulletin & ReviewVisuospatial attention: Beyond a spotlight model
318 Citations1999Kyle R. Cave, Narcisse P. Bichot
In this review, the general question “Is visual attention like a spotlight?” is broken down into seven specific questions concerning the nature of visual attention, and the evidence relevant to each is examined.
PerceptionIs it a Bird? Is it a Plane? Ultra-Rapid Visual Categorisation of Natural and Artifactual Objects
317 Citations2001Rufin VanRullen, Simon J. Thorpe
It is concluded that, at least for these two superordinate categories, the speed of ultra-rapid visual categorisation of natural scenes does not depend on the target category, and that this processing could rely primarily on feed-forward, automatic mechanisms.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceThe role of categorization in visual search for orientation.
295 Citations1992Jeremy M. Wolfe, Stacia R. Friedman‐Hill +2 more
Psychological ScienceVisual Search has Memory
294 Citations2001Matthew S. Peterson, Arthur F. Kramer +3 more
Journal of the Optical Society of America ACritical color differences determined with a visual search task
254 Citations1990Allen L. Nagy, Robert Sanchez
Response times were measured for a visual search task in which the observer was required to find a target that differed from distracting stimuli only in color.
Vision ResearchSalience from feature contrast: additivity across dimensions
244 Citations2000Hans‐Christoph Nothdurft
Test targets that displayed orientation, motion, luminance, or color contrast, or pairwise combinations of these, were presented in line texture arrays, and their saliences were quantified in comparison to reference targets at defined luminance levels, indicating a higher degree of independence between the underlying saliency mechanisms than for other stimulus dimensions.
NeuronThe Psychophysical Evidence for a Binding Problem in Human Vision
197 Citations1999Jeremy M. Wolfe, Kyle R. Cave
In conclusion, it is concluded that when attention is not available to United Kingdom features correctly, they can be put together to form a coherent picture.
CognitionThe role of priming in conjunctive visual search
196 Citations2002Árni Kristjánsson, DeLiang Wang +1 more
It is concluded that the role of priming in visual search is underestimated in current theories of visual search and that differences in search times often attributed to top-down guidance may instead reflect the benefits ofpriming.
Psychological ScienceSpatial Attention in Visual Search for Features and Feature Conjunctions
191 Citations1995Min-Shik Kim, Kyle R. Cave
NatureAttention is fast but volition is slow
174 Citations2000Jeremy M. Wolfe, George A. Alvarez +1 more
A visual search task is used to show that deliberate movement of attention is significantly slower because of an internal limit on the speed of volitional commands.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceThe temporal dynamics of visual search: Evidence for parallel processing in feature and conjunction searches.
172 Citations1999Brian McElree, Marisa Carrasco
It is concluded that both features and conjunctions are detected in parallel, and implications for the role of attention in visual processing are discussed.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceProbing distractor inhibition in visual search: Inhibition of return.
154 Citations2000Hermann J. Müller, Adrian von Mühlenen
The results support the operation of object-based IOR in serial visual search, with IOR demonstrable only when rechecking is prevented (facilitating task switching) and monitoring for probes is not biased toward search objects.
Perception & PsychophysicsInhibitory tagging in visual search can be found if search stimuli remain visible
151 Citations2000Yuji Takeda, Akihiro Yagi
Evidence of inhibitory tagging could be observed only when the items of the search tasks were maintained until the responses for the small probes were made, and this appeared to be an object-based effect.
Psychological ScienceIn Search of Remembrance: Evidence for Memory in Visual Search
127 Citations2000Árni Kristjánsson
Search was slower when the target was always relocated to a position previously occupied by a distractor than when the items remained in place, showing the importance of memory for locations in a visual search task.
Perception & PsychophysicsSearch for multiple targets: Remember the targets, forget the search
126 Citations2001Todd S. Horowitz, Jeremy M. Wolfe
This work tested the assumption that memorydriven search proceeds by sampling without replacement using a multiple-target search paradigm, and found that this assumption was consistent with the memory-free search hypothesis but would also be consistent with memory for a small number of previously attended locations.
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceEffect of surface medium on visual search for orientation and size features.
119 Citations1990Patrick Cavanagh, Martin Arguin +1 more
Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception & PerformanceInhibition of return to successively stimulated locations in a sequential visual search paradigm.
105 Citations1998Sheldon Danziger, Alan Kingstone +1 more
Visual CognitionMemory for rejected distractors in visual search?
101 Citations2003Todd S. Horowitz, Jeremy M. Wolfe
Perception & PsychophysicsInhibition of return and visual search: How many separate loci are inhibited?
99 Citations2000Janice J. Snyder, Alan Kingstone
The study revealed that IOR can be measured at a minimum of five locations and the magnitude of the IOR effect was largest at the most recently searched location and declined from there in an approximately linear fashion.
Vision ResearchParallel search for a conjunction of contrast polarity and shape
91 Citations1994Jan Theeuwes, Frank L. Kooi
The present results suggest another exception: search for a conjunction of contrast polarity and shape can be conducted in parallel while the same conjunction consisting of color and shape requires some serial search.
Perception & PsychophysicsDriving attention with the top down: The relative contribution of target templates to the linear separability effect in the size dimension
79 Citations2001John Hodsoll, G. W. Humphreys
The linear separability effect can be determined in part by use of top-down knowledge to facilitate the detection of targets at the ends of a continuum defining the stimuli.
Journal of Experimental Psychology GeneralThe preattentive emperor has no clothes: A dynamic redressing.
79 Citations2001Vincent Di Lollo, Jun‐ichiro Kawahara +2 more
An input filtering system, which is dynamically reconfigured so as to optimize performance on the task at hand, is proposed, which contradicts Sagi and Julesz's (1985a) claim that detection tasks are processed preattentively and efficiently, whereas discrimination tasks require focal attention and yield inefficient steep slopes.
Perception & PsychophysicsInhibitory tagging in visual search: A failure to replicate
78 Citations1990Jeremy M. Wolfe, Charles W. Pokorny
This study found that probe reaction times were elevated atall distractor locations, relative to empty locations, following both parallel and serial search tasks, and this appears to be a forward masking effect.
PerceptionPreattentive Vision and Perceptual Groups
78 Citations1990Mary J. Bravo, Randolph Blake
A visual search task was used to test whether the shapes of several perceptual groups can be processed in parallel and suggests an expanded role for preattentive processing in vision.
Components of attention
76 Citations1984Michael I. Posner
Human Factors The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics SocietyA Variable-Memory Model of Visual Search
75 Citations1984Taghi Arani, Mark H. Karwan +1 more
A new model is proposed in which search is intended to be systematic but suffers from imperfect memory, and is derived for single and multiple occurrences of a single fault (or target) type.
Psychological ScienceSearching for One Versus Two Identical Targets: When Visual Search Has a Memory
64 Citations2000Bradley S. Gibson, Libo Li +3 more
The present study sought to clarify the amnesic-search hypothesis by investigating whether memory processes can guide search in other contexts in which targets also have the potential to be tagged.
Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological SciencesHorizontal—vertical filters in early vision predict anomalous line-orientation identification frequencies
44 Citations1991David Foster, Patrick Ward
A comparison of predicted and observed frequency distributions showed that the hypothesized orientation signal was formed as an opponent combination and horizontal and vertical filter responses, which contrasts with the classical oblique effect in vision when scrutiny of the image is allowed.
Vision ResearchOrientation contrast vs orientation in line-target detection
35 Citations1995David Foster, Stephen Westland
Target detectability was found to depend both on absolute orientation, represented by background-field orientation, and on orientation contrast, which is difficult to explain by general models of orientation discrimination based on simple orientation opponency between local line-sensitive filter units.
Acta PsychologicaPerceptual processing modes in the functional visual field
34 Citations1985A.F. Sanders, M.J.M. Houtmans
The results show that the total fixation times between presentation and response were only shorter in the 10° than in the 45° condition when the signal pair consisted of two dot columns, which argues against the generality of Sanders' (1963) stationary field-eye-field distinction.
Munich Personal RePEc Archive (Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich)Parallel Search for a Conjunction of Shape and Contrast Polarity
32 Citations1994Jan Theeuwes, Frank L. Kooi
Perception & PsychophysicsVisual search in multicharacter arrays with and without gaps
25 Citations1979Judith Rich Harris, Marilyn L. Shaw +1 more
Although this model is primarily designed for RT, with some additional assumptions it can be extended to accuracy results, and generates U-shaped serial-position curves and produces RT predictions in good accord with data from arrays with and without gaps.
Visual Search and Attention: Review A Signal Detection Theory Approach
12 Citations2001Preeti Verghese
Vision ResearchOrientation-selective summing mechanisms revealed in visual search
2 Citations2002Kevin A Laack, Lynn A. Olzak
Property of the neural mechanisms that mediate detection of complex grating targets in an orientation-based visual search task are investigated and it is argued that mid-level mechanisms such as these may be the neural substrate for conceptual orientation feature maps.