The Newfound Credibility of Qualitative Research? Tales of Technical Essentialism and Co-Option
Qualitative Health ResearchPublished 1 September 2003
Rosaline S. Barbour
Citations110
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.04
SNIP1.25
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is suggested that the author's own everyday research practice, involving teaching and supervision, provides an opportunity to advance debates about rigor by allowing us to formulate a considered response that respects both the complexities and the unique contribution that qualitative research can make.
Abstract
Qualitative research is no longer the "poor relation" to quantitative research that it has been in the past. However, it is important to monitor the manner in which it is becoming incorporated into the mainstream. In this article, the author examines current dangers and challenges by critically reviewing current developments affecting our own research practice. It is argued that technical essentialism (including the co-option of grounded theory) characterizes many responses to qualitative research. The author concludes by suggesting that our own everyday research practice, involving teaching and supervision, provides an opportunity to advance debates about rigor by allowing us to formulate a considered response that respects both the complexities and the unique contribution that qualitative research can make.
Keywords
Social Sciences
BMJChecklists for improving rigour in qualitative research: a case of the tail wagging the dog?
2,557 Citations2001Rosaline S. Barbour
It is argued that there is no substitute for systematic and thorough application of the principles of qualitative research and technical fixes will achieve little unless they are embedded in a broader understanding of the rationale and assumptions behind qualitative research.
The Quality of Qualitative Research
1,999 Citations1999Clive Seale
Qualitative researching
1,061 Citations2006Julie K. Mason
Qualitative Health ResearchRationale and Standards for the Systematic Review of Qualitative Literature in Health Services Research
998 Citations1998Jennie Popay, Anne Rogers +1 more
It is argued that three interrelated criteria can be identified as the foundation of good qualitative health research: interpretation of subjective meaning, description of social context, and attention to lay knowledge.
SociologyThe Place of Inter-Rater Reliability in Qualitative Research: An Empirical Study
996 Citations1997David Armstrong, Ann Gosling +2 more
Qualitative Health ResearchUsing Reflexivity to Optimize Teamwork in Qualitative Research
767 Citations1999Christine A. Barry, Nicky Britten +3 more
It is proposed that reflexivity employed as a team activity, through the sharing of reflexive writing and group discussions about arising issues, can improve the productivity and functioning of qualitative teams and the rigor and quality of the research.
European Journal of Public HealthEnsuring rigour in qualitative research
587 Citations1997C Seale
A general review is followed by a detailed illustration of selected techniques, including the use of counting in qualitative research, the development of systematic coding schemes with the aid of computer programmes, searching for deviant cases and the useof the transcription techniques of conversation analysis.
Qualitative Health ResearchEnhancing the Rigor of Grounded Theory: Incorporating Reflexivity and Relationality
434 Citations2001Wendy A. Hall, Peter Callery
It is argued that reflexivity and relationality, which are defined as attending to the effects of researcher-participant interactions on the construction of data and to power and trust relationships between researchers and participants, should be incorporated into grounded theory.
Journal of Health Services Research & PolicyThe Case for Combining Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches in Health Services Research
294 Citations1999Rosaline S. Barbour
The potential for qualitative approaches to contribute to quantitative work — by providing insights into the process of data construction, identifying relevant variables to be studied, furnishing explanations for unexpected or anomalous findings, and generating hypotheses or research questions for further investigation is examined.
SociologyThe Data are Out there, or are They? Implications for Archiving and Revisiting Qualitative Data
293 Citations1998Natasha S. Mauthner, Odette Parry +1 more
Qualitative Health ResearchMixing Qualitative Methods: Quality Assurance or Qualitative Quagmire?
212 Citations1998Rosaline S. Barbour
The existence of several qualitative traditions is highlighted, each with its own distinctive set of assumptions about what constitutes appropriate research questions; theoretical frameworks; research settings; relationships with those whom the authors study; techniques for eliciting data; form and content of data; and approaches to analyzing, presenting, and disseminating data.
Sociological Research OnlineNegotiating Selves: Reflections on ‘Unstructured’ Interviewing
134 Citations1998Peter Collins
Family PracticeExplicit guidelines for qualitative research: a step in the right direction, a defence of the 'soft' option, or a form of sociological imperialism?
106 Citations1998Alison Chapple
Within the context of health service research, qualitative research has sometimes been seen as a 'soft' approach, lacking scientific rigour, and numerous social scientists have produced checklists, guidelines or manuals for researchers to follow when conducting and writing up qualitative work.
Family PracticeQualitative methods: beyond the cookbook
87 Citations1998G Harding
It is argued that qualitative HSR benefits from recognizing and drawing upon theoretical principles underlying qualitative data collection and analysis.
Family PracticeA review of recently published qualitative research in general practice. More methodological questions than answers?
59 Citations1997Pat Hoddinott
Qualitative Health ResearchThe Development of Qualitative Health Research: Taking Stock
29 Citations2001Sally A. Hutchinson
A discussion of the stages of stopping, waiting, transition, and entry is followed by speculation about the key characteristics necessary for qualitative research to be valued and valuable in the future.
Applying the qualitative method to clinical care
5 Citations2020David J. Silverman